Infinite Banking Is A Scam | Response To Dave Ramsey

Insure Smart
8 followers
6 Video Views·Sep 25, 2024
Take Our FREE quiz that will give you an exact score on how efficient you are with your money and help you understand what areas of your financial life can improve! -https://bttr.ly/quiz
Is life insurance good or bad? I will say this on record that infinite banking and life insurance,
permanent life insurance is probably not for the masses. And we as a company don't even help people
do this if they don't have a certain amount of money because it's just not in their best interest.
So for us, 96 or 97% of people shouldn't do this strategy. So that tells you that I'm not saying,
I'm not endorsing infinite banking. I'm not saying it's the best thing in the world,
but I do think it could be a powerful strategy if set up and used properly for the person that
wants to get the right results. So with that, with you knowing my biases, let's jump into the video.
I had a question for you. I've been working with a financial advisor who's giving me some advice
and I follow the show. I'm on baby step seven currently, but he presented me with an idea that
was a little outside the box and I have term life insurance. I've been anti whole life,
but he presented me with this infinite banking concept. Jesus, you're kidding me. Yeah. I have
excess money in a savings account and looking to rebalance my portfolio to get it to work a little
bit harder, but my risk tolerance is a little bit low and he showed me how you can do this where
you overfund the whole life policy. You could access the money, you break even in year seven
and then the dividend outruns what you put into it. It doesn't seem like a terrible idea in that
regard, but I just wanted your take on why that might not be the best.
Well, all right. So already Dave is very irritated and you could see right from his
body language and from his words that he's like, wow, this guy is ripping you off. Even if you,
Jason, who actually explained overfunded whole life, break even in year seven, which
may or may not be a good fit. I don't know what the design was like. What I find super fascinating
is Dave Ramsey is going to go right into attack mode and he knows nothing about Jason's situation.
What is his investment strategies? Where is he at in life? What is he trying to accomplish?
He knows none of that. So it's very interesting how Dave Ramsey can jump right into an attack.
And of course he can do that because in his book, he really sees one answer here.
The problem is that where it gets confusing is that, God, he's selling a dividend.
A financial advisor? This is an insurance guy.
Well, he's both. It's one of the bigger companies.
Northwestern Mutual or Prudential.
Exactly.
Yeah. Okay. He's an insurance guy. He's not a financial advisor.
Okay. Because those are both mutual companies. Now, there are two types of
life insurance companies, mutual and stock. Okay?
Likely you bought your term unless you bought it from him, from a stock company.
A stock company, stockholders own the insurance company.
A mutual company, which is Prudential and Northwestern State Farm is mutual,
is the policyholders are actually the stockholders. Okay?
Okay.
So when the company makes a profit, the policyholders receive a dividend
as if they were a stockholder and received a dividend. Does that make sense?
All right. So up until this point, Dave Ramsey is pretty accurate in everything that he's saying.
He's talking about the difference between a stock company and a mutual company.
The biggest difference is stock companies, the profits go to stockholders.
And so when you look at like Warren Buffett and other people that have made a lot of money,
they're owning a big chunk of stock companies because as we'll see later,
insurance companies can be very profitable.
And then mutual companies, the profits go back to their policyholders.
So it's kind of the difference between a bank and a credit union.
And that's really the biggest difference.
The other thing that I'll just find fascinating is
Dave Ramsey, who knows a ton about life insurance, apparently
is saying that Prudential is a mutual carrier.
Prudential is not a mutual carrier.
They were at some point, but they, I think in 1915, switched over to a stock company
and are traded on the New York Stock Exchange.
Yep, yep.
Now, follow the math here.
If you are the owner of the company and you're also the customer of the company,
and the only place the company gets money is from the customers that are owners,
and they give you money from a profit, by definition, that means it's because
they took too much from you as a customer.
There wouldn't have been a profit otherwise.
Okay.
So the IRS has deemed, consequently, that mutual life insurance company dividends
are not dividends in the true sense of a dividend, that instead they are,
and this is the IRS's language, they are instead a refund of a deliberate overcharge.
So they overcharge you in order to give you some money later
to make you feel like you're making money off of them.
And it's absolute hogwash.
It's a pass-through.
Mathematically, it's a pass-through.
It's the way it has to be.
It's the legal definition of the freaking company, and the IRS says so.
All right.
Again, Dave Ramsey is having a half-truth here as it relates to the dividend.
So the dividend is a return of premium.
That's actually beneficial because it's not taxable.
It's one of the only setups that a dividend, you don't have to pay any taxes on.
So it's actually tax-free.
Now, a dividend is made up of the profits of the company.
Now, the profits of a company could be from over, quote-unquote,
overcharging on a life insurance premium.
But you also have to look at a lot of these mutual companies have other divisions,
like disability, term insurance.
Some people have a whole stock portfolio, and they can manage people's money,
and all those profits go to the company, which get passed down to who?
That's right, the policyholder.
Also, one of the biggest, largest owners of capital is insurance companies.
If you look at any skyscrapers, they're either owned by two people,
banks or insurance companies.
So what are insurance companies doing with the billions of dollars that they have?
They're investing it.
What are they doing with the money that they've invested?
They're, number one, making sure that they can cover all the claims and make their promises.
But number two, they're passing that down to the policyholders.
And so we just say, Dave Ramsey makes it sound like the dividend is just a return of premium,
and it's some Ponzi scheme here.
And that couldn't be farther from the truth.
And it's shocking because if you look at banks and a lot of the wealthy own life insurance,
and they're not doing it because they're dumb.
They're doing it for a reason.
They're trying to accomplish a result.
And so again, just because it's quote, unquote, a return of premium doesn't mean
they're just take overcharging you and paying that back.
The other thing is when you start doing this for a while,
you will see that the dividend is larger than your premium altogether.
Like that's very common.
And so how does that work?
You pay in X, you get X, Y, and Z.
Well, again, it's one of those things where it's just a form of the insurance company
continuing to pay you and you not having to pay tax.
So yeah, the thing I didn't love, you know, when you take the money back,
you basically are paying an interest rate on it.
Exactly.
And whose money is this?
Right.
That you're borrowing your own money and you're paying them interest?
Yeah.
This is infinite banking for them.
Again, Dave Ramsey is absolutely wrong here.
He made the comment, you're borrowing your own money.
Who is this?
This infinite banking for them.
You're not borrowing your own money.
Maybe Dave Ramsey should read my book, The And Asset.
You're borrowing against your money while your money is continuing to grow tax-free
without losses, fees, and without interruptions.
So you get an asset that's going to continue to grow for the rest of your life.
And not just the growth, but show up in a powerful way in the future
while still having access to capital, in some cases, less than 5%.
So you're not borrowing your money.
This would not make any sense.
It wouldn't mathematically make sense if you were borrowing your own money and paying yourself back.
You're borrowing against your money.
You need tax-free access to money while your money grows tax-free.
And you'll ultimately get to pass on that money to the next generation tax-free as well.
It's actually an amazing thing.
And this is probably one of the most misunderstood concepts as it relates to infinite banking.
Yeah.
The infinite banking concept is old school, whole life, done poorly.
You need a real financial advisor, not an insurance broker that's trying to sell you
a load of manure.
And so, yeah.
The other thing is, is that your cash values that are sitting there all die with you.
So whatever cash you put into this is equal zero at your death because they only pay the face value.
Pru does not have a policy.
Northwestern Mutual does not have a policy that pays more than the face value,
except Universal Life Bees, which are not in infinite banking products.
And Universal Product B is where they charge more than they usually charge,
which basically buys the insurance so they can still keep your money,
is the way the math actually works on this.
All right.
Again, Dave Ramsey is wrong on this.
He talks a lot in other videos about the insurance companies stealing your money.
They're stealing your cash value.
And this is something that a lot of people have questions about because
they watch Dave Ramsey's videos and say, Caleb, the companies steal my money.
In typical old-fashioned whole life,
where you have a base premium and you have a base death benefit,
there's some truth to that.
So you put in your base premium and you could be chugging along and
there's really no cash value in the first couple years.
And then year 20, you have your cash value.
And if you pass away, the death benefit, let's say it's a million when you start,
could very well stay a million.
So in that case scenario, Dave Ramsey is correct.
Majority of policies are like, I've never sold a straight up base contract like that.
Majority of policies, especially used for infinite banking, are overfunded.
They're overfunded either using two things, a term rider and a paid up additions.
Paid up additions, essentially you're buying individual portions of life insurance at one time.
And think of it as Lego blocks, like adding to the death benefit.
And so if you look at an illustration each year,
your death benefit is increasing more than the cash value.
So is it true that you don't get to keep your cash value when you pass away?
Absolutely.
But is it also true that your death benefit is greater than when you started?
Yes.
And in most cases, it's higher than the amount of money that has been in the cash value.
So is Dave Ramsey very misleading here?
I would say so.
And if he looked at a properly designed banking policy,
he would notice that the death benefit in some cases could be double, triple
than when you first started because of the paid up additions riders.
So you're dealing with one of the most expensive insurance products in the marketplace.
If you're dealing with either one of those two companies,
I would stay completely away from both of them.
Everyone in the financial field except people that work for them, we all think they're a joke.
All of us.
Anyone who's academically trained or has any kind of CFP or anything else,
when someone says they work for Northwestern Mutual, we just kind of laugh and go,
yeah, right, you screw people every day.
So, dude, you need to get away from them and you need to go get a real financial advisor
that can help you do some real investing that takes into consideration your low risk tolerance.
Low risk tolerance does not lead you to losing your money 100% of the cash invested at death.
Dave Ramsey makes pretty much the statement that if you are a CFP,
if you're doing the right thing for your clients, if you're a fiduciary,
if you're a smart person in general, you won't touch life insurance with a 10-foot pole.
And again, that couldn't be more further from the truth.
One of the people that I had on my podcast recently was Dr. Wade Fowle,
who's written many books on retirement planning.
He's not an insurance person.
He's a researcher and is one of the leading researchers when it comes to
retirement income distribution, trains a lot of financial planners.
In fact, a lot of people that have a CFP have taken Wade's courses
and he's a big fan of using life insurance in a proper way.
Not necessarily in an infinite banking way, but he uses it in an income retirement planning way.
I've also learned from people like Jason Sanger, who's designed
a software called Wealth Building Cornerstones that talks about
how one could use life insurance and actuarial science for income planning.
And he has academic backing and resources to back that up.
I've had him on my podcast.
I've had Todd Langford on my podcast, who's had the calculator system called Truth Concepts,
which is just a mathematical breakdown of money.
I've had Dave Anderson, who's one of the smartest guys I know as it relates to money.
And all these people don't just have opinions,
but they have models, calculators, software to back up what's actually going on.
And you'll find that people that are well-researched can take a step back and say,
are we looking for a result or are we taking what a pundit is going to say about my money?
That's a bad risk tolerance thing.
So you need to move on, dude.
You need to move on.
And the whole thing of the dividends are paying for it
is such a joke because the dividends are the refund of a deliberate overcharge.
So who's paying for it?
If you own Home Depot stock and you got dividends from that,
then Home Depot is making a profit, but they're making a profit off of their customers.
And I'm the owner of the investment.
I get that dividend.
That's different than if I am the customer and I'm the stockholder,
thereby the only way I made a profit was off of me.
Myself.
So I pay you an extra $100 and then you give me $70 of it,
and I'm supposed to feel great about that.
Right.
So that's what this amounts to.
And so you guys working with State Farm,
when you get your little dividend check, that's what it is.
It's the refund of a deliberate overcharge.
IRS verbatim says that.
Yeah.
And that's why you don't get taxed on it.
If you get a dividend on Home Depot stock,
you get taxed on it as income because it's real income.
You really made an investment and then you really made an income.
So that's what's going on with that stuff.
So do not buy anything in the life insurance world based on dividends.
Again, I think Dave Ramsey forgets that these are massive companies
that are invested in real estate, in long-term investments,
and are the backbone of what this economy is built on.
I think sometimes we can forget that.
And so that's all I want to say.
And I also think if you look at where banks are putting their tier one assets,
where a lot of corporations are putting their money,
where the ultra wealthy are doing,
why would they be touching life insurance if it was such a terrible thing?
And then why is insurance companies actually investing?
So he makes the difference between Home Depot,
a dividend is they're actually making a profit.
Well, insurance companies can make a profit too.
The difference between a stock company is those profits go to the stockholders
and the mutual companies, the profits go back to the policyholders.
Well, if insurance companies were such a bad investment,
why would people buy their stock on the stock exchange?
Just a thought to think about.
You look at the price, look at the structure of the policy,
and you'll usually find that mutual companies, by the way, are the higher priced.
So when you go to a quote service, like a Zander Insurance,
and you get quoted on term life insurance,
you're going to find no mutual companies
in the 42 different companies that they give you a quote from
because they're not competitive.
Why?
Because they charge more so they can give some of it to you back later
and make you feel like that you got something.
Okay.
Again, Dave Ramsey is misleading here.
He's pretty much saying that no mutual companies can be competitive
with term insurance quotes because of how they do pricings and dividends.
So number one, if you do term insurance, you don't get a dividend.
And number two, there are a couple of mutual companies that are very competitive
and in some cases are a better option
because they give you more options
when it comes to a potential conversion in the future.
That's really what it amounts to.
And that's why you won't find them.
They're not competitive.
Yeah. Dave, you're fired up about this one.
Man, I'll tell you what pisses me off.
Infinite banking my butt.
Infinite banking is for them.
Listen, the only thing that that agent has for his whole life
is a need for your commission to be paid to him.
Absolutely.
That's the only whole life thing that is involved here.
These products are horrendous.
And you know, it's bad enough when they feed on the middle class.
But that guy's a baby step seven, man.
He's probably a millionaire.
And they create such a jumbled word picture that you can't cut through the BS.
I also just want to point out, he mentions this guy's probably a millionaire.
It's ironic because he doesn't know anything about the gentleman that called in.
The other thing that I want to say is he's right.
Majority of middle class people that are just scraping by,
infinite banking may or may not be a good strategy for them.
It really depends on how you're going to invest.
And if controlling money throughout your life is an advantage or disadvantage,
because there's some that it's actually a disadvantage to control capital.
The other thing that I want to say is the difference between a commission and a fee.
Think about it.
A fee, a 1% fee over a lifetime can be far greater than a commission up front.
What's ironic is when you design policies like the end asset or infinite banking the correct way,
a lot of times you're cutting your commission by 1 4th or 1 5th to set it up properly.
And so again, it's like, yes, there's a commission,
but it's significantly different.
And if you look at it over the next 30 years,
fraction of what people are making when they're investing your money
and getting a 1% for asset center management.
I smell a rat.
Something's not right.
Something be wrong with these people.
I ran.
This deal is there.
I can't put my finger on it, but this deal is bad.
Yes.
And you ended up in another deal.
There's a much better deal because you listened.
Even though you couldn't logically explain it, you could listen to your heart.
Absolutely.
Listen to the bell when the bell rings.
It's called the Holy Spirit.
Yeah.
This is the Dave Ramsey show.
Again, I'm a big fan of Dave Ramsey.
I think he's doing a lot of things good for our country and for people.
When he takes such a strong approach and doesn't know anything about infinite banking,
and yet he knows enough to just really make you look like a scumbag.
If you're in the business and you mentioned life insurance,
I just wanted to be put on record for having a video that kind of goes through this.
If you want to learn more about this concept,
if you want to learn more about the end asset, a couple of things.
I have a book.
It's called The End Asset.
I would highly recommend you get it.
I also have a lot of content on my podcast on YouTube that breaks down different strategies.
I'm not saying that this is for majority of people.
In fact, we as a company have taken a stand and said,
majority of people probably shouldn't do this.
Just like Dave Ramsey speaking to the majority of people that
should be cutting up their credit card.
This is not a get rich quick scheme.
This is not a this will make you rich.
It comes down to efficiency and it can be a very efficient tool,
especially if you think taxes and control are something that you want.
Like if you want to pay less in taxes and if you want more control,
it could be a phenomenal thing to have as a foundation of where your wealth is at.
