M61 - Barred Spiral Galaxy - Deep Sky Videos

Space and Time
211 followers
2 Video ViewsยทSep 25, 2024
Messier 61. Gorgeous. Isn't that a pretty one? We've saved up some of the good ones.
It's a barred spiral galaxy. It's in the Virgo cluster, so it's about however far the Virgo
cluster is away. 50 million light years, that kind of distance away. It's a bit unusual because the
Virgo cluster, because it's a relatively rich cluster of galaxies, that's quite good at stripping
the gas out of a lot of its galaxies. But as you can just actually see from the image here, this is
a galaxy which has got a lot of gas, because there's lots of star formation going on in it,
and you only really get star formation where, you know, if you've got a gas rich galaxy.
There's all sorts of features that you can see, like for example these dust lanes
are associated with the orbits of the material in the bar here, where the orbits get distorted
in such a way that you end up bringing lots of gas together in these kind of weird spirally
features, which is where you see this dust obscuration, where a whole load of gas has
all been chopped together. There are two clear indicators of star formation in this picture.
One are the blue bits, and the blue bits are just where there are bright young stars that form,
because the blue stars are the massive stars, and the massive stars have very short lifetimes,
which means wherever you see blue light, that's telling you stars have formed very recently,
which almost certainly means stars are still forming there. And then the other indication
of star formation are a lot of these kind of pink bits, and these are these things called
H2 regions, where there is a very, very bright star which is actually ionising the gas around it,
so it's very much exciting the gas around it and causing the hydrogen gas around it to glow
with this kind of characteristic reddish colour. A couple of features here. One is,
if you look at the bar itself, it actually looks slightly redder in colour, and there
aren't any of these big pink regions in it. So there's not a huge amount of star formation going
on in the bar, and that's a common feature of bar galaxies. In the bars themselves, they tend not to
actually have that much star formation. And the other feature is at the very ends of the bar,
you can see this kind of collection of pinky red bits, which are these indications of very strong
star formation going on there. It's less clear at the other end. Maybe out here you can see
something, but you tend to see star formation sometimes enhanced at the ends of the bar.
And so one of the questions has been in astronomy is, why is that the case? Why is it that within
the bar you tend not to see very much star formation, outside the bar lots of star formation,
and sometimes there's this enhancement right at the ends of the bar as well. And there's kind of
two possibilities. One is that maybe whatever the process is that drives star formation just doesn't
work so well within a bar. So maybe you need to have a particular kind of orbit or a particular
set of things going on, and for whatever reason, you don't find that in the bar regions of galaxies.
The second possibility is maybe there just isn't the raw material, that maybe there's just loads
of gas outside the bar and not very much gas inside the bar. Can't make stars if you haven't
got the gas to make the stars out of in the first place. And so I have a paper from a couple of years
ago, called CO Multiline Imaging of Nearby Galaxies, blah blah blah blah blah. Star formation in the
bar spiral galaxy NGC 4303, which is actually just another name for Messier 61. So they're looking at
Messier 61 and they're observing molecular gas, so carbon monoxide in this case, to study how much
material there is, to see whether or not the reason that stars are or aren't forming in these
different regions is because of the amount of raw material or whether there's something else going on.
Professor, why wouldn't they be looking at hydrogen? I thought hydrogen was the key gas
for star formation. So if you want to form stars, you need cold gas, right, because hot gas doesn't
kind of collapse down. So you need cold gas, which probably means you need molecular gas. So the
molecule you'd really like to look at is molecular hydrogen, because that's what most of the universe
is made of, that's what most of the stars are made of. Molecular hydrogen has this irritating feature
that it doesn't actually have any features, or at least none that we can actually observe very
easily. It's to do with, you have to talk to a chemist about this, not me, but it's to do with the
fact that it's a symmetric molecule, because you've got two hydrogen atoms, and that means that there
are modes of excitement that don't happen in hydrogen because it has this symmetry about it.
Whereas carbon monoxide, because it's got a carbon and an oxygen, it's nicely asymmetric, which means
you get a whole load more features, which means it's much easier to observe. The hope is that if
you observe carbon monoxide, that's telling you about molecules, and if there's carbon monoxide
molecules, there's probably hydrogen molecules as well. It's a slightly dodgy thing to do,
but nonetheless, CO is often used as kind of a tracer for hydrogen, for molecular hydrogen,
because we can actually observe it where we can't observe the molecular hydrogen. So they observed,
they made maps of this thing in CO, in carbon monoxide, and again it turns out life is quite
complicated in that if you look at normal CO, which is like normal carbon and normal oxygen,
there's so much of it that actually it becomes what's known as optically thick.
It's like looking at a star, right, when you look at a star you only see the surface layers,
you don't see right through down to the middle. It's the same with this, if you're observing normal
carbon monoxide, you kind of only see the outer layers, and that's not helpful if you're trying
to figure out how much of it there is, because you don't know whether it's that much or that much,
right, because you only see the front bit. So actually because it's optically thick, you can't
see through it, so it's not terribly easy to translate from the observations to the amount
of actual carbon monoxide and then hence how much molecular material is. Fortunately there's another
isotope of carbon, carbon-13, instead of carbon-12, which is much rarer, and because it's a different
isotope, that means that the carbon atom weighs a slightly different amount, that means that the
lines, the things that get excited as it jiggles around, are at different wavelengths. So you can
see the carbon-13 differently from the carbon-12, so you can see carbon monoxide, which is made of
carbon-13 and oxygen, as well as carbon-12 and oxygen. Because it's so much rarer, there's much
less emission from it, and you don't run into this problem of it being optically thick, you can
actually see right through. So in principle, carbon-13 and oxygen gives you a nice measure
of how much actual molecular material there is. There's one final complication, as if we didn't
have enough of it already, which is what you actually observe, of course, is the intensity
of emission, not the total mass of stuff. So if, for example, supposing that the transition that
you're seeing wasn't being excited at all, you wouldn't see anything. So there could be a whole
load of carbon monoxide there, but you wouldn't see a thing. And so you need to know, okay, so
how much is this stuff being excited? If the thing were in thermodynamic equilibrium,
in other words, if it had a kind of a well-defined temperature, it turns out you can do that
calculation. We don't think these things are in thermodynamic equilibrium, so it's kind of hard
to figure out what kind of temperature it is, how excited it will be. So what the guys did in this
paper is they did this stuff called non-LTE, non-local thermodynamic equilibrium calculations,
where they used both those 12 CO observations, so the normal carbon monoxide and the 13 CO
observations, combined them together, and it turns out that if you make a few assumptions about
what's going on in terms of how far you are from thermodynamic equilibrium, that's enough
to translate it into the mass. Basically, what they've been able to do by making these molecular
observations of carbon monoxide are figuring out how much molecular material there is in this
galaxy. And what they found, when they look at the different regions of the galaxy, is in the
middle region here, where star formation is suppressed by about 30 percent relative to a bit
further out, there's 30 percent less molecular material. At the ends of the bar, where star
formation is a bit enhanced by 20 or so percent, there's about 20 percent more molecular hydrogen.
So it looks like the thing that's really driving whether or not you see star formation isn't
anything fancy about the star formation process, it's actually whether you've got the raw material
there in the first place. You just haven't got the gas. Yeah, you can't. If you haven't got the gas, you can't
make the stars. Well, you know what my next question is? What's that then? Why is there not much gas in the bar?
So, the other piece of information you get out of these observations, because you're looking at an
emission line, not only does that tell you how bright it is, and so by this very convoluted
argument, how much there is of the material, but because there's a Doppler shift in it, depending
on whether that material is coming towards you or going away from you, you can actually figure out
the motions of this gas. And so they were able to see whether the motions of gas were systematically
different in the regions where there's less molecular gas or whether there's more molecular gas.
And the quantity they measure is some measure of how much random motion there is in this gas.
What you find is where there's little random motion, there's not much molecular material.
Then as you start going up in random motions, you get more molecular material. Then when you
go up a bit further in random motions, you get less again. We're doing the Goldilocks thing again,
right? You need it just right. If there's too little random motion, then actually you don't
squeeze things together, you don't make molecular gas, so you're not going to make stars.
If there's too much random motion, it turns out then probably the collisions are too energetic,
so that things don't merge together. They just kind of bounce off each other. And so actually
you don't end up making the kind of big molecular clouds you need to make stars there either. You
need things just right somewhere in the middle. So what's going on in the bar? So there's probably
quite a lot of gas in the bar, but because the orbits are very distorted in a bar, you have
very some kind of shear, so you have big differences between one bit of gas and the
next bit of gas. And that means that they're actually moving at high speeds relative to each
other. And that generally means that actually that they're moving too fast to smash together
to create these molecular clouds. So the gas isn't even getting to the molecule phase, right?
Almost certainly too turbulent. And sometimes it could be just not turbulent enough, but I think
in the bar it's probably because it's too turbulent because there's just so much of this kind of
shearing motion. 1,200 light years from the galactic centre in comparison to our
solar system, which is like 25,000 light years away.
