John Singer Sargent (Full Length): Madame X and Dr. Pozzi

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
John Singer Sargent was the most successful society portrait painter of the Belle Epoque, and having one’s portrait painted by him was seen as an indication of impeccable good taste. In this episode, I look at two paintings created by Sargent. #Artexhibitions
John Singer Sargent was the most successful society portrait painter of the Belle Époque
and having one's portrait painted by him was seen as an indication of impeccable good taste
and was a social achievement in and of itself. In this episode I look at two paintings created
by Sargent, two paintings united by a scandal. One of them is of Dr Pottsy, a celebrated
gynaecologist and infamous ladies' man who was referred to by many of his clients as l'amour
médecin or Dr Love. At the time Sargent's painting of Pottsy was criticised for the doctor's overtly
sexual swagger and gossips picked up on the painting's possible homoeroticism. The other,
Madame X, shows Virginie Gautreau who like Dr Pottsy had a colourful love life and is also
shown in a provocative pose. Sargent embedded both portraits with a salaciousness unseen in polite
society. But was the public outcry because of the paintings or because of the gossip that connected
the sitters? The paintings have been written about and discussed as separate works of art
but instead of looking at them as two separate paintings maybe it's time we talked about them
as a pair. John Singer Sargent was born in Florence in 1856 to unconventional American
parents who had left their hometown of Boston, Massachusetts and lived their life as wealthy
cultural nomads in Europe. Sargent's mother, an amateur artist, was a classic eccentric heiress
dragging her semi-reluctant husband and children across Europe on an endless grand tour. They
lived in Florence, Venice, Rome, Sorrento, Naples, Lake Como, Lucerne, St Moritz, Munich, Berlin,
Paris, Biarritz, Nice, Madrid, Seville and Cadiz. She made sure she captured every landscape and
monument around them and hauled her children into every museum as soon as they were old enough to
hold a pencil or brush. She hosted gatherings wherever they went inviting everyone from
poverty-stricken artists to American expat millionaires. She exposed Sargent to Velazquez,
Goya, Rembrandt and many other artists who would later influence his own work. Madame Sargent was
a powerful self-assured and rather theatrical woman and Sargent would make a career out of
painting iconic women just like her. He showed an early aptitude for watercolours and his mother
encouraged his precocious but astounding artistic talents by enrolling him in art classes. Madame
Sargent was determined to see her talented son rise through the ranks of the great artists
so she moved the entire family to the centre of the art world, Paris. They arrived in Paris in 1874
when Sargent was 18, just as the Impressionists were making their mark on the fussy French salon
system. He would be influenced by their loose gestural brushwork and later he would become
friends with Monet and even paint him. His mother arranged for him to study with the artist
Carolus Duran. The young Sargent was impressed by this painting by his tutor which had scandalised
Parisian society with its sexually suggestive dropped glove. A scandal that 10 years later
would be mirrored by the public reaction to Madame X. Sargent's virtuosity of technique was recognised
immediately by Carolus Duran who became the subject of Sargent's first major portrait he
created at the age of just 23. In this painting we already see the Sargent-esque touches we will
see throughout his career. The skin tones are so hyper-realistic and yet elsewhere his brushwork
is very loose and abstract. It is an extraordinary painting that he showed at the Paris Salon of 1879
to almost universal acclaim. But Sargent would always have an ambiguous relationship with critics.
The Paris Salon was the most prestigious art exhibition in Europe. It was an annual event
organised by the French Academy of Fine Arts and was known for its strict and conservative jury
selection process. It was crucially important to a young artist and was a place where Sargent could
showcase his works to a wide audience of art critics, collectors and the general public.
The problem was its size. In 1884 the Salon was attended by 300,000 visitors and showed 5,000 works
stacked one on top of the other with only the best artists getting eye-level placements.
They were also arranged together by genre so visitors saw hundreds of landscapes and then
hundreds of still lives, then history paintings, then portraits one after the other. It was
overwhelming and extremely difficult for any painting to stand out. Sargent understood this
and knew that he needed to produce something sensational for the Salon to get their attention.
He knew that getting people talking about your paintings was good for business. The very first
time he entered a painting to the Salon was in 1878 when he was just 22. It was his first major
success, singled out for its use of impressionistic brushstrokes. By the time he entered this group
portrait in 1883 he was a celebrity artist and this life-size painting established him as a
Carolus Duran encouraged his students to study the work of Diego Velasquez and with this painting
Sargent produced a modern re-imagining of Las Meninas that was the talk of the Salon.
Around this time he met Henry James who was already an established writer while Sargent
was a rising star in the art world. James was a great champion of Sargent whom he described in
Their relationship would be one of the most important and enduring of Sargent's life.
In 1884 he showed Madame X and this painting would create an even bigger sensation than previous
entries as well as a tabloid frenzy. Being a portrait painter is so much more than being a
skilled draftsman. Sargent's exposure to a broad cultural education via an eccentric route meant
that in a stiff buttoned-up Victorian society the artist was a breath of fresh air. He was dashing,
fashionable, charming and witty. He spoke several languages, played the piano and was well read.
He could hold conversations with English kings and American presidents. He was close friends with
composers and writers across the globe and he could gossip with flamenco dancers and gondoliers
in their native language. It was his personality that gave him the ability to capture the essence
of his subjects, to extract their innermost secrets. Regardless of their social status
or background he would seduce them with his knowledge and wit. Previously artists with a
classical training would carefully plot their paintings. They'd sometimes grid the canvas then
draw outlines directly onto it and paint section by section, sky, sea, mountains etc. Sargent's
teacher Carolus Duran changed all this and taught his students to paint what they saw quickly,
looking at the subject in terms of tonal values, lights and darks, rather than using outlines.
Using half tones as a base and adding highlights and accents loosened up Sargent's style.
Carolus Duran encouraged his pupil to use a heavily loaded brush wet on wet in a technique
known as a la prima or direct painting that encouraged a broad painterly style. None of this
was new. The baroque painter Franz Hals was famous for using the a la prima technique.
The traditional method of painting a face onto a canvas was in three separate stages, in charcoal,
in thin color wash and then in paint. Sargent however went against the grain, used very little
if any underdrawing and created his portraits through a single application of paint in one
sitting applied in thick impasto. By concentrating on the subject's tonal values a solid shape grows
out of and into his half tone background. Sargent simplified everything and just focused on the
After establishing the larger shapes and masses in his composition he started working on the
details in light and dark tones. By establishing the middle tonal values first he could judge how
light or dark the final accent should be. It was a way of working not dissimilar to sculpting.
Larger values first, finer points last. The result was a finished painting that looked
fresh and spontaneous with fluent and easy brushwork. Getting to this seemingly spontaneous
point required a lot of preparation. He would paint many studies and sketch everything. When
he knew his subject well he was ready to start working on the actual canvas. Sargent would place
his canvas right next to the sitter rather than a few feet away as was standard. He would then
jump back and forth as he painted, jab the canvas and jump back again. Continually viewing from a
distance both the sitter and his painting of them at the same time, at the same angle and in the
same light. Cartoonists even made fun of his frenetic swordsman-like approach to attacking
the canvas. His brush and his grip were equally important to his loose style. He held his brush
almost like a conductor's baton as we can see here which gives the brush a certain spring.
He believed you must draw with your brush as readily as unconsciously as you draw with your
pencil and how you hold your brush affects how the paint is applied. Close up we see the jabbing
and slashing of paint from both his dance-like movements and the loose way of holding his brush.
The important things to Sargent were that once all the preparation was done he was familiar with
the physicality and the personality of the sitter and all the structure and tones were in place
then he was ready to attack the canvas a la prima in one sitting as if the painting
magically sprang fresh from his brush. When you study Sargent's paintings up close his thick
visible brushstrokes are quickly applied and appear abstract or haphazard but seen from a
distance everything comes together perfectly in a realistic representation. This is the key to
Sargent's work and what differentiates him from the Impressionists. While Sargent certainly used
loose brushwork and was interested in the effects of light he did not always use these techniques
in the same way. The artist limited himself to using a palette of mostly neutral colours
and had no interest in the Impressionists obsession with colour theory. Plus of course
Sargent used the colour black unlike the Impressionists. He was just more interested
in tonal values and in the end accurate representation. He may have used abstract
brushstrokes but he combined it with a hyper realism that the Impressionists rejected.
It's hard to look at this painting without the feeling one is being seduced. Samuel Jean Pozzi
was one of the most fascinating and notorious men in Paris. He was a 35 year old gynaecologist to
the stars, good-looking, dynamic and charismatic in the extreme. He was a married man with a family
but he was also a womanizer infamous for his numerous affairs including with the legendary
actress Sarah Bernhard, Bizet's widow, the poet Judith Gautier and several actresses and dancers.
He was described by the Princess of Monaco as disgustingly handsome and by a contemporary as
a beautiful work of art himself. It is as a prodigious lover we know him now thanks to the
notoriety of Sargent's portrait. But we mustn't forget that Dr Pozzi was actually a brilliant
19th century renaissance man. He was catapulted from provincial bourgeois beginnings to the upper
echelons of Parisian society and rose quickly through the ranks by his intelligence and charm.
He was a surgeon and a pioneering gynaecologist, a writer, an author and a translator. He was an
anthropologist who travelled widely in North Africa and South America and most importantly
he was also an art collector and patron of the arts. Sargent met Pozzi in 1881 and started work
on the painting. There were plenty of portraitists in Paris at the time and Sargent knew he needed an
edge to stand out. The risk-taking and unmasculine poses and attire made sure Sargent was noticed
early on and Dr Pozzi liked to risk. The composition departs significantly from the usual
formal academic portraits of medical doctors and is certainly different from the way Pozzi
presented himself to the public. The portrait with its strange clothing and seductive quality
comes across as more of a boudoir portrait. Sargent's mainstream sensuousness has always
been recognised and scholars have said that the image flirts between heterosexual and homosexual
desire. The artist's private life is not necessarily the key to his work but as with all artists it
is important to look at the world he inhabited. Little is known about Sargent's personal life as
he destroyed many of his private papers but in 1981, a full century after he created them,
a portfolio of intimate nude males in sensual or erotic poses was discovered. He had given it to
his friend Isabella Stewart Gardner for safekeeping. He knew they would be seen after his death.
What those daring images tell us is that Sargent had a need to push the boundaries of what was
considered acceptable in art and that is precisely what makes him so interesting. In the portrait of
Dr Pozzi, his swagger is unmistakably sexual. He is oozing sex appeal. His bedroom eyes look dreamily
into the distance and his neatly trimmed beard and pomaded hair suggest a familiarity with his
own reflection. Portrait painting at the time dictated that formal dress was worn but Sargent
had already broken this unwritten rule with an earlier portrait where the sitter is rather
saucily dressed in an unbuttoned shirt and is posing in a Velázquez swagger. In Dr Pozzi at home
the outfit and the colour are quite shocking. He is in a dressing gown of the brightest crimson,
suggestive of passion. His left hand sits limply on his hip and he fingers a red cord with a
dangling tassel hanging heavily between his legs as if he may open the robe to the viewer at any
point. The other hand languidly caresses his chest. It is a provocative pose even for the 21st century.
Beneath the gown his nightshirt is dazzlingly white and romantically Byron-esque. The red robe
gives him a renaissance magnificence and references images of popes and cardinals by the old masters.
The pose is utterly self-assured and commanding and could have been modelled after El Greco's
portrait of a man which Sargent knew well. It is the gynaecologist's hands which are the focal
point of the composition. Sargent's depiction of hands in his paintings are considered some of the
most skilful and expressive portrayal of hands in the history of western art. He tended to bend,
twist or contort fingers and hands into unusual and sometimes impossible positions. Using hands
to suggest the character and temperament of his subjects. Using subtle variations in posture,
gesture and expression to create a sense of psychological depth and complexity.
In his wonderful portrait of Robert Louis Stevenson for example, Sargent portrays the
in a way that suggests both creativity and fragility. With the fingers delicately posed
as if in the act of creating. This painting of the French artist Paul Allure records the precise
and delicate pose of the artist's hand as he applies paint to his canvas with intense concentration.
Dr Pozzi's hands are tapering and sensitive with long busy fingers that suggest his surgical
prowess as a gynaecologist. But also hint at the more sensual side of Dr Pozzi. Sargent aware that
the painting of Dr Pozzi was perhaps too salacious decided against showing it in Paris where he lived
and instead decided to show it in London. The painting got mostly hostile reviews. British
critics found it objectionably Parisian, too decadent, too en vogue. One critic even hinted
it was effeminate. The portrait ranks amongst Sargent's most experimental works rivaled only by
his infamous Madame X. Madame X would be Sargent's most ambitious work to date. It would change the
course of both his life and his subject and yet it almost didn't happen. His sitter the 23 year old
Virginie Gautreau was a figure of fashionable high society. The it girl of her day and she was famous
for being infamous. Sargent was determined to produce something for the 1884 salon just as
unconventional as his Dr Pozzi who would even be a factor in choosing her. This was not going to be
one of his usual empathetic renderings of a woman but something much more stagey. He would portray
her as a diva and he would capitalize on her notoriety. Like Sargent Gautreau was an American
expatriate from a wealthy family. Her father was killed during the American Civil War and she and
her mother moved to Paris where Virginie's strange beauty and natural grace made sure she married well
to a prosperous but boring banker. She wasn't conventionally beautiful even for the time but
with her alabaster skin, red upswept hair and shapely figure she was undeniably striking.
She skirted the fringes of bohemian Paris and was constantly featured in gossip magazines like
L'Illustration thanks to her many extramarital love affairs. Sargent met her in 1880 when he
painted Dr Pozzi who was one of her lovers. In Parisian society it was perfectly acceptable
for married women to have affairs as long as one was discreet about it. The first thing to
understand is that she didn't commission the painting, it was Sargent who pursued her. Initially
Madame Gautreau was not interested at all and it took months of persuasion with several of her
friends approached by Sargent and a word in her ear from Dr Pozzi. Everyone wanted to paint her
and everyone wanted to meet her. The artist and the subject must have recognized in each other
a like-minded hunger for fame and she eventually agreed in early 1883 but insisted Sargent came to
her estate in Brittany to paint her. As it wasn't a commissioned work and she had done the artist a
favor he had no choice. The whole process was difficult. She sat for a few drawings but it took
over 30 sessions to find an effective pose. Settling on one that captured her famous profile.
As always Sargent's palette and brushwork were inspired by Velázquez and his chiaroscuro by
artists like Titian. In fact Sargent had originally emphasized the light dark contrast even more with a
much darker background. Unhappy with it he painted over with the more neutral color that we see today.
If you look carefully though you can see traces of the darker background along the frame's edge
because he repainted while the portrait was still framed. Another inspiration was Japanese prints
which were becoming increasingly fashionable in Europe during the late 19th century.
Madame X incorporates elements that are similar to Japanese aesthetics such as the use of asymmetry
and the emphasis on negative space, her stark black clothes and the minimalistic background.
Sargent's depiction of her skin tone was criticized at the time for its powder blue
and some said she looked like she was decomposing. Gautreau was actually a Louisianan Creole of mixed
European heritage and was often mistaken for a South American then considered exotic. According
to the artist it was her use of chlorate of potash powder and arsenic that gave her skin a lavender
tinge. Her ears have been touched with rouge to denote blushing a fashion in those days but one
that would lead to more accusations of her being a painted lady. One member of the tabloid press
even suggested it was a post-coital flush. It's hard to make out but she is wearing the tiniest
of tiaras barely there in the shape of a crescent moon. The symbol of Diana the goddess of the hunt
perhaps referencing her supposedly predatory nature as a huntress seductress. Another detail
is the table legs which taper upwards into winged sirens or femme fatales from Greek mythology who
plunge sailors to their doom. And while we are here let's look at how Sargent depicts the light
hitting the edge of the table so realistically. But up close it is just a single slash of his brush
and her wedding ring which added to the scandal is really just one tiny dab of paint but from a
distance reads perfectly as a wedding ring. Our eyes do the rest. In this photo of the painting
taken at the time of the Paris opening we see that he originally painted her with the strap
of her gown falling off her shoulder. It was this detail that caused such an outcry. The loose strap
was seen as a signifier of loose morals suggesting either the beginning or the end of a sexual liaison.
Only later when the exhibition closed and after much pleading from Madame Gautreau's mother
did Sargent repaint that section but by then the damage was done. It is worth looking at
what women were wearing at the time in two portraits painted by Sargent in the same year
he painted Madame X. The scandal started on the opening night. Sargent had always been the darling
of the salon fated by everybody but not this time. Crowds gathered around the painting and jeered.
They shouted that it was detestable, monstrous. It is genuinely hard to see what the fuss was about.
20 years before in 1865 Manet had shown Olympia at the salon to a scandalized Paris. So why the
shock now? The difference was that Manet's Olympia was a prostitute. Like the women in
Toulouse-Lautrec's painting also on display in 1884 but Madame X was part of French high society.
At the time Sargent had named the painting Madame XXX but Parisians knew exactly who this woman was.
Despite Paris's reputation as a decadent bohemian city Madame Gautreau's sexual confidence and
shame-free adultery struck a nerve. Even though her infidelities were known thanks to the scandal
sheets they were not considered a fit subject for polite society. Parisians were forced to
confront their own decadence which they preferred not to acknowledge and this was where Sargent went
wrong. The salons were a sacrosanct part of French culture and he a foreigner was flaunting immorality
in their faces with a painting of another foreigner an exotic one at that. Reviewers
objected to Madame Gautreau's appearance the low-cut dress and her plentiful cleavage but
most of the scathing reviews were reserved for the shockingly wanton shoulder strap.
If we do look at them as a possible pair the first thing to notice is that the dimensions
of the works are similar. That's not to say that he hadn't used large thin canvases before
but looking at other paintings from this period it was a rarity. Sargent was attracted to theatricality
and glamour and Dr Pottsy and Madame X are male female versions of the same type. They are both
flamboyant peacock figures with a streak of vanity and a knack for seduction. There is something in
the way they are posed which is unconventional. They have an indirect gaze and they both have
Seen together there is a certain amount of flirtatious energy between the paintings
a sexual frisson. Is it possible that Sargent dared to create a pair of companion portraits
almost identical in scale and of a similar audaciousness which alludes to the sitter's affair
in a way that upper-class Parisians would have understood and that once it was out in the open
so to speak it would have made the scandalous portraits just that little bit more scandalous
and grab more attention for Sargent. The artist may never have intended for them to be displayed
together not physically anyway but I think there is a possibility he saw them as a pair and even
foresaw the ruckus they would cause. Sargent had created a scandal with these two paintings that
Dr Pottsy was never socially ostracized. Unlike his female counterpart his infidelities were seen
as par for the course. If anything he became even more accepted and would go on to become one of the
most eminent doctors and research professors of his generation. Later he became a French senator
and then served in two wars. First as a medic in the Franco-Prussian war of 1870 and then in the
First World War as a military surgeon. He was by this time in his late 60s stouter and grayer but
still handsome in his lieutenant colonel's uniform. On the 13th of June 1918 a former patient came to
see Pottsy in his consulting room. The doctor had operated on him three years before and the man
believed he had become impotent as a result. He shot Dr Pottsy three times and then shot himself
in the head. Pottsy's emergency surgery was unsuccessful and he died shortly afterwards.
After Madame X was shown in Paris Sargent himself was socially ostracized and commissions dried up.
His old friend Henry James persuaded the artist to join him in England and make a fresh start.
Sargent took Madame X with him which he said was the best painting he ever did and he kept it on
display in his new London studio as his scandalous calling card. It is a myth that Sargent was an
overnight success in London. The British aristocracy was initially wary of such a scandalous painter
and it took a while but the talented are always forgiven and Sargent knew how to create a buzz.
Two years after his arrival in London he produced this incredible painting of his friend's daughters
and the commissions came flooding in. Eventually Sargent became the pre-eminent portrait painter
of British society averaging 14 portrait commissions per year each costing the equivalent
of $130,000 in today's money. Madame X was not so lucky she was banished by Parisian high society
and her family would be obliged to leave Paris. I think however her social exclusion has been
exaggerated. Before the salon she told Sargent how much she loved the portrait and even though
Sargent picked it out it was her choice to wear that recklessly low-cut dress and it was she who
approved the pose including the fallen strap. She must have known how she would be perceived by the
public yet we know that within a year of the scandal she was back in Paris and back in the
As an American in Paris she was never going to be totally accepted in French high society
and it's quite possible that she just didn't care what they thought.
The experience didn't stop her vanity and after Sargent she commissioned two of her own portraits
and her choice of outfits was hardly demure. They both seemed to capitalise on the notoriety
of Sargent's painting. She went on to live a happy effacuous life with her husband.
A beauty until the end she died in Cannes in 1915. Shortly after her death Sargent
sold the painting to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York 30 years after he created it.
On the proviso it would be renamed Madame X and the museum would never use her real name.
John Singer Sargent died at the age of 69 in his sleep for a while he was seen as anachronistic
and facile. A society painter and a careerist happy to pander to aristocratic privilege
which is ironic as his contemporaries saw the gestural abstraction in his paintings
as a radical departure. Sargent occupies that crucial moment in art history just before things
began to change so quickly and he was criticised by some for his reluctance to participate in the
Now we know that he was one of the greatest painters of the late 19th and early 20th century
who wasn't merely creating flattering theatrical images of the idle and the ostentatious.
Sargent captured the very essence of his times with depth and truthfulness even in his most
flamboyant paintings. Even though the artist was on the inside he was also an outsider
and this is what gives Sargent an edge and a different perspective on the world.
This is what drove him to create some of the most memorable and innovative art of his generation.
