On the Whistle: Man City 2-2 Arsenal - "Pride, punishment and pain"

gunnerblog
3 followers
5 Video Views·Sep 23, 2024
Hi guys, I don't know how you feel. I feel pretty exhausted after that one.
I feel a bit like I've played for that 10-men Arsenal team
clinging on in that match. Full-time at the Etihad,
Manchester City 2, Arsenal 2. Football is a funny sport isn't it? I mean if I told
you before the game we'll get a draw, we'll get a point,
we'll have 10 men, I think you would have absolutely
snapped my hand off but at the same time not winning.
This one feels like a real body blow, a sucker punch given the fact that we led
for so long, given the way we competed and defended
in that second half and given the cruelty of that late winner.
Hey, I still think there's a lot of positives to be taken from the
performance. I think we showed that we are the team who
can really compete with City. I don't think there's another side in
the Premier League who could defend that well with 10 men
against this Manchester City side. Arsenal made them look quite ordinary
for much of that and were it not for a lucky break
on a corner that I think was outside of the allotted period of stoppage time and
where Arsenal had a few tired legs and a few tired minds,
we would have won this game. Huge credit to the players for the effort
they put in in the second half and huge credit to
them in the first half as well. How many times have we seen Arsenal go
to the Etihad, concede the first goal as they did in this occasion to
Erling Haaland and collapse? You know, it's all very well
when you're defending a lead but to go behind
and then turn things round to lead the game before half-time,
I think that tells you about the enormous reserves of belief that are
present in this squad at this point in time.
It was an interesting team. Ben White didn't start. We had Calafiore and
Timber at full-back, Havertz in midfield with Rice and Partey,
Trossard leading the line and Saka and Martinelli as the wide men.
And I think Calafiore took a bit of time to really get into the game.
He was beaten by Savino quite easily on the first goal.
Arsenal's defensive line, for a rare moment,
wasn't particularly well set. I think Gabriel was
playing Haaland on the side. In fairness to him, he was kind of pulled
out of position by a run from Bernardo Silva as well.
City's movement off the ball is what makes playing against them so difficult
at times. You know, they've always got two or three runners pulling the
defenders in different directions. Haaland loves that. He exploits the space
and a really nonchalant finish inside David Reyes near post.
But there was to be a turnaround and I think
there are two big incidents in this game that have been kind of defining.
One is obviously the sending off of Trossard
and that had a huge impact on the match. But I also think the injury of Roderick
had a huge impact on the game. An innocuous challenge with Thomas Partey at
a corner. He goes down with a knee injury.
You obviously don't wish injury on any player but
I think Arsenal fans will have breathed a sigh of relief when he went
off the pitch because he is such an important player for City
and has been such an important player in these fixtures over the years.
He's an important player for City full stop. I mean if they're going to be
without him for a number of weeks that could be a huge boost to Arsenal and to
their title challenge. And it swung the game. I really do think
that swung the game in the first half. Arsenal came back into it. Calafiore
grew into the game well just a bit. Bent home a beautiful
shot from a Martinelli cutback. I mean it was a really inch perfect finish into
the far top corner. It was kind of the only shot
that he could pull off on his left foot from that angle and he managed it.
That's the level of technical ability we're dealing with here. Reminded me of
Saliba's goal against Bournemouth towards the start of last season.
Celebrated with Mikel Arteta on the touchline. And then there was the set
piece threat right. Gabriel threatened once and probably should have scored.
Hedda was very close just over the bar. Didn't get it down. Well
no mistake the second time. Sacker lofting another ball towards the far
post. Karl Walker left stranded and Gabriel
powers it in. And at that point Arsenal looked really good. Really comfortable.
I actually think that with Rodri off the pitch
and with... Rejected a phone call that's coming in.
With Rodri off the pitch and with Arsenal having 11 men
on. I think we would have won this game. I mean obviously we'll never know and
maybe you know we would have been more
ambitious going forward and would have left space for the likes of
Haaland and then later you know Grealish and Foden off the bench. Who knows right.
But we were in a very strong position and that is why the loss of Leandro
so painful. I mean I've got really mixed
feelings on this one okay. So I want
delaying a restart to be dealt with. I always think about that home game
against Newcastle. Do you remember like a year or two ago
and what a nightmare it was and how there weren't enough bookings and
we will have home games at the Emirates Stadium where we are crying out
for those delays to be punished and punished
sharply early. Arsenal are a team who probably more often than not will
actually benefit from this new directive if it's
applied fairly okay. So I sort of want it
at the same time sending a player off and putting a team
down to 10 men. It's unduly harsh. It really does seem like an absurd
level of punishment for a relatively minor infraction. I
wonder if a better solution would be something like
if you delay the restart a minute is added on in stoppage time.
I mean that would be quite an interesting one.
You know maybe even not a minute but automatically 30 seconds the same way as
a substitution is an auto 30 seconds. Maybe that could be a way of
dealing with it. Rather than yellow card you're going to
face a guaranteed 30 seconds more in stoppage time.
I don't know. You know Simbins is another argument
but taking off a player in a game that had been quite a sort of enthralling
end-to-end contest a lot more needle in the game in the rivalry in general I
would say than there ever has been. Lots of confrontations between
players and staff. Kai Havertz laid a marker
in the first 14 seconds didn't he barging into Rodri and it continued kind
of in that vein right up until the last kick of the game.
Miles Lewis Skellig hit face to face with Erling Haaland on his Premier League
debut in that little scrap. I just think it's so harsh.
It's a really interesting one though isn't it. I mean I just think it destroyed
the game as a spectacle. It led to the second half being a
training exercise. Quite a gripping training exercise
but not really what we want from a kind of showpiece fixture like this.
It seems absurd. Like if the idea of punishing
the guy who's delaying the restart is to sort of protect the integrity of the
spectacle. Well arguably taking a man off the
pitch is doing a lot more damage to the spectacle.
It's something they really need to think long and hard about. Is it something
Arsenal are being particularly discriminated against
for? I don't know. It does feel like that after the João Pedro one
in the Brighton game went unpunished. The Doku one I need to see again
I think it might have been a bit different because if you look the
referee sort of points where he wants the free kick taken from
and Doku knocks the ball back in that direction. But
you know I need to watch that again and frankly I don't think I can face it.
But here's where I'm at with it. Really harsh. It's kind of an absurd
application of the rule. I think Trossard is kind of being
instinctive. He's just doing what footballers do and what he's done his
whole career. You know he's 28-29. His whole career
when a free kick's been given he's probably booted the ball away
and he's just acting on instinct. He also might suspect he's about to blow
for half time because again I think we were past the allotted stoppage time
and he might think oh he's blown. But I do think in the cold light of day
tomorrow we might say look we know the parameters. We've had the
warning of Rice being sent off for this. We've had before that you know PGMOL
coming in and telling us it's going to be an important initiative this season.
Arsenal have got a lot better, a lot cuter around gamesmanship and small
margins but this is a margin that matters. We need to stop losing players
to this. It needs to end now and if referees are going to continue to
look to send our players off for it then our players have to be
smarter and more cute. That's my take on it. We know we can't change
what referees do but we can change what we can do.
So off he goes and the second half is what it is. I think I was a bit
worried that we didn't play with any kind of outlet but to be fair to
Arteta and to be fair to the players they nearly got it right and I think
they had enormous confidence in their ability to see it out. I remember
seeing Gabriel on camera after 81 minutes and he was smiling. He was
like I love this. I think there are players in this team who enjoy that.
I think Gabriel and Saliba are obviously among them. David Reier
who was good again. Declan Rice I think relishes some of that aspect of
the game and Kai Havertz. When we signed Kai Havertz did anyone think
we'd be talking about him as a guy who relishes a backs to the wall
defensive effort? I didn't hear much of that in the reports I heard from
various Chelsea fans I spoke to but there you go. It's the player he's
become. I'm going to pick out two players who have been criticised a
lot recently. It's not that I think they were the best but I think they've
had a lot of stick and when players do good things they deserve
commendation. I'm going to pick out Gabriel Martinelli who I thought
worked incredibly hard and did carry the threat particularly in the first
half. In the second half he spent much of the game defending as a kind of
sixth man in defence, an extra left back but I thought he stayed on the
field and Saka didn't. Maybe there was an injury there but I think that
tells you the degree of trust that Arteta has in him to apply himself to
work hard to track back. I thought he was outstanding in that respect and
I'm going to mention Thomas Partey as well because basically for most of
2024 I've not been that impressed with his performances. I think today he
quietly did a lot of very good work on the edge of our box. Gabriel and
Saliba obviously defend that box brilliantly but against City you've got
to win the knockdowns, you've got to win the second balls and it looked to
me like he got there very often and he had a bit of composure on the ball when
we needed it just to give us a few seconds of spike here and there. So
shout out to those two guys. Arsenal will be angry, Arsenal will be annoyed. I
expect Michel Arteta to come out fighting, I'm sure we'll be talking about
the referees. I think they'll be using this as motivation and I mentioned that
needle, I mentioned that spikiness between the two teams. Could that fuel
Arsenal in what remains of the season? There is a long way to go but we are
very very well positioned. I'm gonna leave it there for now. Oh knackered
after that, absolutely knackered and a load of podcasts, different podcasts to
do about it over the next few days. So I've got a handbrake off in a minute, I've
got to ask our section tomorrow, I've got the athletic football podcast tomorrow
lunchtime. They will be available all the usual places. Thanks for putting up
with my wallpaper which plenty of you got in touch to let me know you don't
like and same with my shaved face. A lot of you don't like that either but I had
to shave it for work, that's the way it goes. Yeah, mixed feelings tonight but I
think in context, in time, we'll come to see it as a good point, a point gained
and City at home to a tight rival playing a full half against ten men
maybe they will look at it as two points dropped, we shall see. I'll leave it there
guys, take care, all the best, speak to you soon, bye bye.
