Are Functional Capacity Exams (FCE) in Long Term Disability Claims Good or Bad?

Disability Insurance
6 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 22, 2024
Hi, I'm Greg Dell and I'm here with attorney Steven Jessup and today I want to talk about
functional capacity exams also known as FCE exams which is the abbreviation. So throughout this
video if we use the words FCE we're referring to functional capacity exam. Now Steve we've seen
thousands of these exams both utilized by the insurance company and also utilized by claimants
that we represent and there's a lot of pros and cons to them and I guess it depends on
different types of cases. So let's talk about them for a little bit. First of all like what they are
and what someone should expect if they're asked to go to one and then we'll cover
some scenarios where they could be good and where they could be detrimental to a claim.
Well I mean an FCE is essentially a formalized test that's going to determine what someone's
physical capacity is for work in the context of how the Department of Labor quantifies work
whether it be sedentary, light, medium, heavy, extra heavy. Typically the test can last anywhere
two four hours sometimes they're very very involved can go over a course of two days
so they can get an idea of how someone is on the day after if the testing affected them it's going
to impact their ability almost in measuring a good day bad day scenario and they're often used
especially within the context of the disability claims to try to draw a nexus between a person's
physical complaints usually some type of pain related condition and actual restrictions and
limitations for this idea of actual full-time you know workability. And they're usually administered
by either a physical therapist or a physician could be a physiatrist and most of these are done
by a protocol that they follow that goes into a standard computer program that will then generate
a report based upon the way in which a person performs. So let's talk about the aspect of what
to expect in one of these functional capacity exams if you go to one. I mean you're going to expect
that you're actually going to have to do some work they're going to lift, carry, push, pull, there's
grip testing, sustained walking ability, up and down stairs, there's a whole gamut of physical
activities so it is something that isn't just so much as if you go to a doctor and there's just a
generalized examination of your physical being you're actually going to do various different
tests to assess you know any restrictions. What are your thoughts of the objective nature of the
testing results versus subjective meaning how much feedback or complaints come from the potential
examinee versus you know the actual do they prick you with something and it says yes this is you
can't fake it basically. No well you know unfortunately you will see in test results and
you know you can get sometimes you get those reports back and they show that people self-limited
there is built-in standardized validity testing throughout various of the tests to be performed
and they will have adjustments for people's subjective complaints they don't want to
continue with something because it hurts that's a subjective so that gets pulled into the test as
well so it can be manipulated however the testing will show that so that there it it's an objective
test but it can still be manipulated just like neuropsychological examinations can be manipulated
by the person or attempt to taking it so it's a way to get strong objective evidence especially
if the validity testing all the indications are a person put forth proper effort but on the flip
side of that it can also come back that it's you know person may be over embellishing their
symptoms and things like that then it makes the test kind of useless in a lot of ways. Okay now
there is controversy over these particular tests because you take a person who has what they call a
sedentary job which is a job where you're supposed to be able to sit for basically six hours out of
an eight-hour workday with maybe a 15-minute break every hour or two hours and then how is this
testing this functional capacity test going to accurately show that someone can't sit for at
least six hours a day five days a week? Well I don't know if there's any way to 100% accurately
show that in general this type of testing by no means is you know perfect science it's not the
way it's not going to directly relate to someone's actual job duties it's more of a generalized sense
they do do evaluations and we'll see reports that you know someone may have for instance the ability
at the sedentary level to lift up and carry 10 pounds but they may not be able to meet the
sitting requirements because if they have a lower back problem that's causing issues with the legs
it's not going to affect their upper body ability to lift so it does have it is built in for that
but unfortunately it is not exact science. Yeah but I mean like when you go for this test I know
they don't tell you you know they say Mr. Jessup please go sit in this chair for six hours we want
to see how many times you maneuver around in the chair how often you get up what your level of pain
is they do a sitting exercise that might be five or ten minutes maybe 15 and then that's supposed to
replicate what goes on you know week in week out for an employer so I think that's a problem
potentially with these tests but I guess there's a protocol that they follow where so many thousands
of people have done the test and if you can do x amount of activity for so many minutes then you
should be able to translate it to work so when do you I know a lot of times the insurance companies
like to ask for these tests and we always have when it comes down to it based upon how the testing
was administered or what was asked of the person there's ways that we can punch holes in it to
maybe say it's not reliable but at the same token there's many clients that we've asked to go to a
functional capacity exam because we know that the insurance companies as one-sided as they are
they love these exams so if they love these exams then kind of play the game and give them the
functional capacity exam so what types of cases do you like to recommend that a client has their
doctor send them to a functional capacity exam I mean I think any time it's someone it's their
basis of the disability is physical inability even in situations where there are serious fatigue
issues you know even if it's not directed towards pain or limitations restrictions of movement so
I would say the vast majority are going to be related to any of the chronic pain conditions
and that whole umbrella is the fatigue conditions and you know even in situations in certain
conditions like multiple sclerosis Parkinson's even some of that stuff too that's not traditional
pain but does have physical limitations and restrictions for a person so I think that's
always going to be one of the things you look at because an insurance company regardless of what
someone's MRIs say and you know any objective you know medical evidence in there the actual
symptoms of pain is still subjective so they're always going to try to argue back this idea of
you know subjection subjective so this is a way to try to take those subjective complaints
extrapolate it over testing that's standardized in hopes of finding the information that you know
supports the restrictions I think one of the things about it being subjective in nature because the
person who's administering the exam has to properly document everything that's going on so when I have
a client in the insurance company says we want to send your client to an FCE I almost always ask to
have that functional capacity exam videotaped and if they deny the videotape which they're often not
allowed to then I want to have an independent witness there to take notes as to what was going
on because again the results are only as good as what the examiner writes down and I've had many
cases where you know the person says well the claimant wasn't trying or the claimant was able to
do something for 10 minutes when in fact they actually went for 15 minutes and it was maybe it
was a mistake by the person who reported it and that report is the only thing that the disability
company is going to consider so the client's at a huge disadvantage if they don't have anything to
rebut the evidence on the FCE so that's something to really be important now you find a lot of the
FCE examiners won't allow the video it's true so that's kind of like then you get into this issue
and say our client will go but they're not going to allow the video and then you put it back on
the company to find someone who's going to allow the video because I think it's real important to
have that video and there's also the possibility to it especially if someone's on claim or even
it's during a review of an appeal or something where they want to send out to a functional
capacity evaluation and you're not in a position where you're prevented for sending your client to
your own so if the you know the tests vary you're at least creating you know some type of difference
of opinions that still need to be rectified and so overall you know what are you saying you know
if your opinion is our FCE is good are they bad I think that there's many aspects of them that can
be proven unreliable I think they're a tool that the disability insurance companies like and if you
know how to utilize them in the right manner they can be very helpful for a disability claimant if
you're the one trying to obtain your own testing but the disability companies on the other side
try to manipulate the results often against you so if you've been asked to attend one of
these exams or you're considering one of these exams for a long-term disability claim
please give any of our lawyers a call we always offer a free consultation
we can help you anywhere in the country and we look forward to the opportunity to speak with you
