I Tried Making Homemade Oatmeal Creme Pies | Claire Recreates

History Of Food
342 followers
5 Video Views·Sep 22, 2024
Today's Claire Recreates is an oldie but a goodie.
It's Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pies.
Seeing it makes me feel like I'm in a different time period,
like an earlier bygone era.
There's a lot of nostalgia for the way the box looks,
like red, white, and blue.
You got Little Debbie right here.
I remember thinking they were good.
Seems like Americana, you know?
These, to me, look so much more appealing
than pretty much anything I take out of a package
on this show at all.
It looks like a cookie, which makes me really happy.
It has these like cracks in it.
It's super uniform.
It's really round.
It makes me want to eat it.
It looks really good.
This channels to me more of like a molasses cookie
because there's no visible oats,
unlike an oatmeal, like an oat cookie
that you would make at home, which just has oats in it.
Like there's no visible oats at all.
There's not an oat in sight.
The lightness and the softness are remarkable.
Just this, the weight of the cookie
is starting to kind of break it apart.
That's how soft it is.
Picture in the box also, interestingly,
has the filling scalloped, like in petals.
But here you can see like the cookies have sealed.
Like you're not really getting
a lot of the filling peeking out.
Cookie diameter, seven to seven and a half centimeters.
Filling thickness, 0.5 centimeters.
So the overall thickness is
just about one and a half centimeters.
Total weight is 39 grams.
A single cookie weighs 17 grams.
1734, means it's only five grams of filling.
You know, what I kind of smell is sort of brown sugar.
I'm not getting oats.
Okay, so it's really sweet.
It's really, really sweet.
The cookie has a real chew and then a resistance,
and that's where I get the oat.
That's where I feel like I'm eating
ground up oats in a good way.
I definitely get kind of like molasses.
It doesn't have a lot of, a strong flavor of warm spice.
What I really taste,
because I looked at the ingredients already,
so I know what it is.
It really tastes like the raisin paste,
which is so interesting.
I would never be able to identify the flavor
if I didn't know that that's what's in it,
but tasting it, that's immediately what I get.
It tastes like raisins.
The ingredients in Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pies are
corn syrup, number one, enriched bleached flour,
parentheses, wheat flour, barley malt,
niacin, reduced iron, thiamin, mononitrate,
brackets vitamin B1, riboflavin, brackets vitamin B2,
folic acid, close parentheses,
palm and soybean oils with TBHQ
and citric acid to protect flavor,
whole grain rolled oats, molasses, raisin paste,
sugar, water, dextrose.
Contains 2% or less of each of the following,
leavening, parentheses, baking soda, ammonium bicarbonate,
sodium aluminum phosphate, close parentheses,
whey, salt, soy lecithin, cornstarch,
natural and artificial flavors, mono and diglycerides,
polysorbate 60, sorbitan, monostearate, dried eggs,
modified cornstarch, sorbic acid,
to preserve freshness, soy flour,
for the long list of 2% or less,
dried egg whites, annatto extract,
beta carotene, caramel color, chocolate, cocoa butter,
citric acid, cocoa processed with alkali,
high fructose corn syrup,
modified wheat starch, nonfat dry milk,
palm and palm kernel oil, pectin, polysorbate 80,
propylene glycol, monostearate, red 40,
lake, rice flour, sodium citrate,
sodium stear oil, lactylate, soybean oil,
titanium dioxide, parentheses, color,
and turmeric extract.
Such a long ingredient list.
I'm actually pretty excited.
I love oatmeal cookies, love.
And I'm excited to make them in this style,
which is like an extremely soft,
slightly chewy cookie.
And I'm excited to take some inspiration
from the ingredient list.
Like they mentioned,
like there's a little bit of cocoa in there,
which I think is super interesting.
The raisin paste, I think is really interesting
and might be like the secret flavor in there.
I would like to achieve this kind of like
cracked, fissured look,
but if I don't, I'm not gonna sweat it too hard, I think.
My game plan is start with a cookie,
hopefully nail it, make the cream,
hopefully nail it, put them together.
Three steps.
I'm basically making what I think will be
a good oatmeal cookie,
but I'm making some changes.
I'm gonna grind the oats and flour
so that there's basically no more perceivable bits of oat
because there aren't any in the cookie.
I am also going to take a portion of the oats
that I'm adding and I'm gonna cook them.
And I'm gonna add some raisins
and I'm gonna cook it down and puree it.
What I'm doing is I'm kind of like
fixing water into the recipe
without having to just add it to the batter
and like thin it out.
And I think that's gonna contribute to softness.
I know I'm adding molasses
because it's in the ingredient list
and I can tell from the color
that it's just like I need it for color.
But the molasses is gonna serve a really important purpose.
It is going to prevent that other brown sugar in the cookie
from like recrystallizing and making the cookie hard.
So it's gonna keep it really soft.
And I don't think I'm gonna add any warm spice,
which I was initially thinking that I would.
It doesn't really have that flavor.
It just kind of has the flavors like molasses and oat
and weirdly raisin.
I think I have some in here.
Aha, golden raisins.
Immediately when I thought about
the little Debbie oatmeal cream pies,
I was like, oh, corn syrup.
But molasses has the same purpose.
Molasses is an invert sugar as is corn syrup.
So I don't think I need to add corn syrup
because I'm using molasses.
The first thing I wanna do is get my oats cooking.
I'm gonna also add a quarter cup of golden raisins
and the raisins are definitely adding sweetness.
And I do think we'll also make them softer.
The raisin pulp is going to help
to inhibit gluten formation a little bit.
I'm adding that flour and I think we'll also make them,
you know how like the cookies sort of like fall apart
as you start to bend them?
I think that's what's gonna happen.
So I'm gonna add a half a cup of milk
to just get this cooking.
If it looks like it's getting too dry, I'll add more water.
I'm just gonna let that come up to a gentle simmer.
So now I'm gonna put together my mix of dry ingredients
in my food processor.
A cup of oats, a cup of flour,
a teaspoon of baking soda.
Molasses is very acidic
and baking soda is gonna react with that acid
and it also is gonna be responsible
for the cookie spreading.
And I want these cookies to spread a lot.
They're gonna get really thin.
Half a teaspoon each.
Kosher salt and baking powder
to aerate the cookie itself
and like give a little bit of a crumb
because again, these are so incredibly light.
And then I'm gonna add not a lot of cocoa.
I don't want it to be a discernible flavor.
Maybe seriously just a teaspoon.
Cocoa is a very strong flavor.
And I'm gonna add a little turmeric
because I want that yellowish color in there.
Maybe a half teaspoon of turmeric.
So I'm gonna process this
until the oats basically disappear.
This is simmering.
I'm gonna add a little water to this.
I'm wondering now if,
because I already have the food processor out,
maybe I can just make the entire thing
in the food processor.
Wouldn't that be easy?
I'm just feeling it,
rubbing it between my fingers
to see the size of the oat pieces.
I think it could be a little finer.
And I'm gonna grab a bowl to transfer this into.
I am anticipating that this is gonna be a very soft dough.
I'm gonna leave the oats,
they're not as fine as the flour.
I'm gonna leave some really fine pieces
so I get a little bit of texture in the final cookie.
So my dry mix is done.
Let me get it into this bowl.
It smells like breakfast
because it smells like the oatmeal that's cooking.
Now I need oil and I need molasses.
I'm gonna show you a trick.
So I need a quarter cup of oil.
I'm gonna pour the quarter cup of oil
into one of my little measuring cups.
Then I'm gonna pour it into this other measuring cup.
And now I have a measuring cup that's really well greased
and I'm gonna measure my molasses into this one.
Because molasses is so sticky,
it is basically sugar.
And it's a nightmare to scrape out of containers
so I'm gonna measure two tablespoons molasses.
And when you oil it, it just slips right out.
I do want to check on my cooking oats,
see the pooling milk slash water.
I'm gonna cook until that's gone.
This is just another minute on the stove
at a slightly higher temp.
Now I have this sort of like, you know, porridge,
thick porridge, not a lot of extra liquid.
I guess what I really want to do is cool this down quickly.
I'm like the queen of the ice bath.
I'm gonna make a quick ice bath and get this cold
and then I can go right into assembling the batter.
This is gonna be cold, although it is sort of cold.
My cooled oat mixture is gonna go in.
Definitely gonna save this saucepan
in case I need to do this whole thing over.
So I'm gonna process this until I have something smooth
and I don't mind some texture from the oats
as long as it's like a similar fineness
to the dry mix that I ground.
But I do want the raisins to be completely pureed.
Here's the texture.
It's still relatively coarse,
but from what I can tell just looking at it,
it's oatmeal texture and not really,
I don't see a lot of like discreet pieces of raisin.
Now I'm gonna add my butter.
This is eight tablespoons.
I'm doing a mixture of butter and oil.
Oil is liquid at room temp.
So at room temp, the cookies will be,
I think in my mind, softer.
I'm gonna add my brown sugar, a one cup packed, light brown.
One large egg, two teaspoons of vanilla.
And as I'm processing that, I'm gonna stream in my oil.
I'm doing it this way because with the egg in there,
I'm hoping that the oil will emulsify into the mixture
and won't make it more liquid.
That by emulsifying, it'll actually thicken it.
I'm gonna scrape down the sides
and I'm gonna add the molasses.
And because I greased it, it should fall right out.
Same thing with honey, any really sticky ingredient,
corn syrup, definitely process that.
So now I'm gonna add my dry ingredients.
And hopefully I form something like a dough
that I could easily portion and that's not too liquid.
I'm gonna pulse this in.
It's super liquid.
I'm gonna add more flour.
Oh my God, it's so liquid.
I'm gonna keep adding more flour
until I get something dough-like.
Oats don't have gluten.
Like you don't get the same thickening.
And they have their own starches that thicken,
but it's not going to act
the way flour is going to in a recipe.
Then I'll keep that nearby in case I wanna add more.
All right, so that already seems more dough-like.
It's still really soft.
I'm gonna add another half cup.
I don't need it to be firm enough
for me to roll it in my hands,
but I do need it to be firm enough that if I scoop it,
that it's gonna hold its shape.
The way it was like balling up, that's a good sign.
Let's take a look.
Okay, it's a good idea to bake one as a test.
I'm gonna preheat my oven.
It has like a peanut butter consistency.
It's holding its shape well enough.
The oven's at 350.
I was baking earlier and I did have something spill
on the bottom, so it is a little smoky.
I think it's only gonna help.
I'm gonna put the cookies in.
I don't anticipate they're gonna bake long.
I'm gonna check them like at eight minutes.
So I've kind of been watching them
because the oven light is on.
They're puffy, which I don't like.
Although they do have cracks on the top.
That I do like.
I'm hoping I can deflate them.
Maybe I can give it a nice hard tap on the countertop
and knock some of that air out.
Oh God, the smoke.
Sorry.
The color is very light,
but they're nice and crackly on the top.
Like that, I'm pleased with.
Like, just judging on the surface, it's pretty close.
The color is obviously not dark enough.
Let's see how they cool.
Part of me is just sort of like, can I just flatten it?
But then it's gonna be kind of dense.
And then it's gonna be too dense,
so that's not really a good solution.
What if you use the Silpat instead of the...
If I use the Silpat, they'll spread more.
Interesting, Cal.
Suggestion.
If I added more molasses and more baking soda
to increase spread, that might help.
So just as a side-by-side,
the size coincidentally is very similar,
but of course my cookie is like twice as tall,
if not taller.
So obviously it's too much batter.
I need to make them smaller
and I need to do something
that's really gonna increase spread
and I need to make them darker.
Okay, so see how the inside is cakey?
It's just too cakey.
One thing I keep thinking of
is my own recipe and dessert person,
which is a molasses cookie.
I was like,
why don't you just make that as a comment today?
I'm thinking about it.
So for the next test round,
I'm gonna take the existing batter,
I'm gonna add two more tablespoons of molasses,
doubling the total quantity.
I'm gonna add more cocoa,
a little more salt for flavor,
and importantly, another half teaspoon of baking soda
to try to increase spread of the cookies.
This says soda, right?
Yep.
Okay.
I'm gonna add two more tablespoons of butter.
This is the nice thing about doing this
in a food processor
is that you can very quickly
and thoroughly mix in more ingredients.
Why is it being so weird?
Did this thing come on?
Is it because it's so thick?
Wow, look how much it thickened up.
Do you?
Guys, what's wrong?
I'm gonna burn out the motor.
It's going so slow.
So weird.
It's going so slow,
it's not even incorporating the butter.
All right, I'm gonna give it a good stir.
It has really set up,
which I'm happy to see.
And you know,
the amount that it's set up
makes me think that I don't actually need
as much flour as I have in here.
But if I just waited for it
and kind of rested it,
then it wouldn't be so cakey.
It's just so weird.
Is it on like low voltage?
How do I know?
It's just plugged in.
My thought is that the blade
isn't really fully on there,
but I checked it,
it seems like it is.
All right,
this maybe has incorporated well enough to see.
Just looking for any butter.
All right, I'll have to troubleshoot.
All right,
so it did incorporate the butter.
I'm gonna get my Silpat out.
Smaller scoop.
I don't know how much they're really gonna darken
in the oven because
they're not in there that long.
The color is better.
I'm wondering if I need even more molasses.
Again, the batter really did set up so much.
I'm just sitting,
so good thing to know.
Next time,
I am sort of thinking that the flour is too high.
I'm gonna set it for seven minutes
because I'm making them smaller.
Seven minutes,
I'm gonna pull them out.
Okay, so
importantly,
I lost the cracking actually.
They're not really deflating.
They definitely did spread more.
So comparing a cookie from the previous round,
they're about the same size,
a little smaller,
but I used a smaller scoop,
but they're still pretty puffy.
The color's a little bit deeper,
but it's not quite the darkness that I want.
So I still think actually more molasses.
They feel super soft,
which is good.
They're a lot more sad looking than these.
I think I might wanna increase the turmeric
to give it a little more of a yellow.
These I think didn't crack
because they spread really rapidly at the beginning
before the top had a chance to set.
So what that tells me is maybe I want a cookie
that spreads more on its own
and I don't use a Silpat.
Back to parchment.
I am encouraged by the second test.
I also think that they want a little bit of warm spice.
The original cookie doesn't have it,
but I'm trying to make my version better.
So I might add a little cinnamon
and maybe a tiny bit of clove for spiciness.
I have my cooked oat raisin mixture.
Oh, I didn't mean to do that.
I meant to grind it first.
All right, hold on.
I screwed up.
Went out of order.
I didn't mean to start with the wet.
I meant to start with the dry.
For exactly this reason,
which is now I have to dry the,
rinse and dry this thing off.
Meant to grind the dry ingredients first.
Also, hey, the food processor works now that I cleaned it.
When I took the food processor apart,
the blade was like super gummed up with batter,
like up in the part that connects to the base.
And it was like, couldn't spin.
So I cleaned it, but now it's working.
So I'm gonna start with my dry ingredients.
I have my oats and my flour.
This is a reduced amount of flour compared to version one.
Adding the cocoa, which I increased to a tablespoon.
The salt, which I increased.
The baking soda, which I increased,
but I'm omitting the powder.
And then my spices.
So I have increased amount of turmeric,
and now I'm using a little cinnamon and a pinch of clove.
It's hard to have molasses and oats
without like a little cinnamon.
Smells good.
Smells spicy.
Right now, back to that oat mixture, my oat and raisin.
Now I'm gonna add the butter.
This new quantity is 10 tablespoons.
I think I cut it up into pieces last time.
I did.
I'm too tired.
All right, I'm getting, so impatient.
Just gonna add the sugar.
Oh, I forgot the thing was on.
Crack the egg in.
I'm gonna stream in the oil and the vanilla.
Molasses, dry ingredients, plus the cocoa.
Just gonna pulse this in.
So I'm just gonna let this rest.
This has set up.
I don't know, did we wait like 10 minutes or so, maybe?
It has thickened.
It really does just look like natural peanut butter.
They spread to about the right size,
but they were too tall.
So I know I need less batter overall,
given that they like thin out to the dimensions that I want.
So I'm gonna do like three quarters of a scoop,
but then I want it to be nice and rounded.
So I'll just kind of like smooth it out.
I like the color so far.
Into the oven, I'm gonna bake them for,
I'm gonna check them after six minutes,
because if they flatten out quite a bit,
they'll bake even faster.
Hopefully they flatten out.
Oh God, hold on.
That's six minutes.
They kind of look the same as they did before.
They're a little puffy.
They're not cracked.
Let's take a closer look.
Hopefully they settle down quite a bit.
They're actually already losing volume, which is good.
See how much they've flattened already?
What I'm missing are the cracks.
I have like sort of like holes rather than cracks.
The diameter is basically exactly what I need it to be,
which is between seven and seven and a half centimeters.
So my feeling at the moment is like,
if the flavor is there and the texture is there,
the color is there,
how much do I really care
about them not being cracked on the surface?
Not that much.
Go with a toothpick and just draw a little crack.
I'm not doing that.
Oh God, they're so soft.
I feel confident regarding flavor.
And the color is nice.
The color is a little bit deeper, I think,
than batch number two.
The softness seems really good.
They're so soft that even after they come off
and they're starting to set,
I can still kind of move them around.
There's no cooling and setting,
but at the moment they feel that level of softness
where that the cookies are,
where like if you hold them in your hand,
they would like droop.
Let's do a side by side.
I do think that the original are like a little more pleasing
just in look based on the cracks.
The color is pretty close.
There's a little bit of a sheen to the original
that I think the latest batch has
that the second batch doesn't have.
They did get really thin.
I'm pretty much right at that half centimeter
that I was going for.
Mm, so I just started eating it.
Mm, these are good.
Now I want to bake a bunch of cookies.
My goal is to have 24 really nice circular cookies
so I can make 12 sandwiches.
Are you gonna whack them or does it need it?
I don't think it needs it.
Like they're already settling down.
I mean, give it a little help.
This tool works so well for making nice round cookies.
Cookies are baked.
What I like, the color, the taste, the texture.
I like that they're all very uniform
and that little rounding motion with the cutter
was super effective.
They're, I think, gonna make such nice looking
sandwich cookies when I add the filling.
So we're moving on to the filling.
I'm gonna grab my ingredients.
I can put these off to the side.
I know that the filling, which they call cream,
is marshmallow.
But really, it's more similar to a marshmallow fluff
or like a marshmallow spread than a fluffy marshmallow
that you could cut like into a square.
So to make a marshmallow fluff, I pulled my ingredients.
I have some salt, some sugar, water,
a little bit of egg white.
Then I have corn syrup.
I had to have corn syrup at some point.
A little cream of tartar, a very small amount of gelatin,
a quarter teaspoon, and I just have some vanilla.
By the way, this is a recipe that I am using
based on one that I found on the King Arthur website
for a marshmallow fluff spread recipe
that people said was really good.
The first thing I wanna do is soften the gelatin.
You always want to use cold water
when you're softening gelatin.
So I'm just gonna let that hang out there
and it's gonna soften and that's gonna allow it
to melt into my marshmallow mixture.
Then I'm going to combine my sugar, my water,
my corn syrup in a saucepan.
And I greased this container to help the corn syrup
release and come out, which it's doing very easily.
Now into my bowl, I'm gonna put my egg whites,
my cream of tartar.
It's gonna help to stabilize everything.
And a pinch of salt.
I need to be cooking that sugar corn syrup mixture
at the same time I'm whipping my egg whites.
And so I can't, it's gonna be too hard
to like look back and forth from over here.
So I'm gonna move over here.
I'm gonna get this going over medium high heat.
You don't wanna stir it.
I don't want to crystallize any of the sugar.
I want it to just dissolve and melt and come to a boil.
Now the corn syrup in there is going to like
go a very long way toward preventing crystallization.
This is at a boil.
And as soon as this reaches the 220s,
I'm gonna start to whip my egg whites.
So this is giving me 222.
So I'm gonna start whipping.
So once the egg whites are kind of at soft peaks,
which they are somewhere close to soft peaks at least,
I can just kind of leave them alone for a second.
240.
Remove that from the heat.
Gonna quickly scrape in that softened gelatin.
You can see how it's become solid.
Quick stir in that is going to melt the gelatin.
Then I'm gonna stream this mixture into my egg whites.
I don't regret stopping it,
but I do wanna just scrape in the last amount.
This is gonna take several minutes,
but I wanna whip it until it's nice
and like thick and fluffy and marshmallow fluffy.
I'm whipping this on high.
It's been a few minutes.
And the mixture is getting really thick and fluffy.
The bowl's a little warm.
So I wanna just keep going.
I'm gonna add my vanilla now.
So this will be nice to have like real vanilla.
So I'm just gonna continue to beat this
until it's like really thick and fluffy,
but still has a little bit of elasticity to it.
And it's gonna be mostly cool to room temp.
So another maybe minute or two.
Okay, this is basically done.
How are you gonna know the right?
How am I gonna know the right amount?
I'm gonna eyeball it.
I think that's, I feel really good about that.
I'll kind of eyeball what I think seems right,
the thickness of filling that I want.
I guess I should do one in the middle, right?
I think if I do six, I can do one there.
So I would say that these are kind of marble-sized dollops,
very imprecise.
Put one on top.
So I wanna grab one that seems similar in size.
They are sort of slightly different.
I feel like it looks really good, right?
Not too thick.
You can see the filling kind of peeking out.
It's like the picture.
The petals are sort of disappearing
as the marshmallow is sort of like being squeezed out,
but I think that's okay.
Looks right to me.
I'm gonna keep going.
I think just being mindful that I'm not increasing
the amount of the filling is helping me a lot.
And the filling has already started to set up a little bit
where it's not giving like long pulls.
And so I think the texture is gonna be kind of just right.
When I hold one and I balance on my finger,
I can feel it slumping over my finger.
It's just not to the extent of the Little Debbie.
Let's compare side by side.
Right off the bat, I know that mine are not as soft.
The colors are very similar.
The color on mine is even maybe a little bit darker
and the Little Debbie, a little bit more of that yellow.
I'm really glad I put the turmeric in.
I think it kind of warmed it up
and made it a little more golden.
Size-wise, I think mine, it's definitely taller.
I think sometimes like you don't think things
are gonna add up as much as they do,
but they definitely did.
So mine's a little bit taller,
but it does have that separation between the cookies
where you can see the filling peeking out.
And I think that looks pretty darn good.
I also like that on mine,
you can actually see little bits of the oat,
which I think is really nice.
Really similar size.
So I feel like I nailed that.
43, it's so close.
Not bad.
I do think that it would be better
if the marshmallow set for a little bit longer,
but let's see what kind of texture I get.
Similar color, very, very white.
Definitely not as aerated and fluffy,
but like, does it look so appealing and delicious?
Okay, I'm gonna try it.
Mm, very soft.
Mm.
Mostly what I get is molasses
and then the texture of those oats.
The marshmallow helps to keep everything together,
gives you some vanilla flavor, so much less sweet.
I'm happy with the warm spice amount.
I feel like it just makes the cookie taste
like what you think it should be.
So soft.
This is what I think it looks like that tastes like.
This is, thanks, this is the Little Debbie.
The only thing I wish is that mine
had cracks on the surface.
That's the Little Debbie.
Yeah, I gotta start somewhere.
The Little Debbie one's delicious,
it's just a little too sweet.
Could be chewier.
Oh, okay, great.
Mm, crispy on, yeah,
because you're making like a proper cookie.
First thing is so many more spices.
Well, yeah.
The Little Debbie doesn't actually have any spices in it.
Yeah, I make a little room to get to the center here.
You could just break it open and bite.
Yours is so much better.
Less sweet and all the spices.
I was gonna say. Really.
We only need that sound bite.
But thanks. Okay, great.
I'm really happy.
I think what I really like about this one, actually,
is I didn't have to do anything weird.
I didn't have to get a drill out or cut up cardboard.
I love it because what I really got to focus on
was like fine-tuning flavor and texture.
And I kinda gotta hand it to Little Debbie.
They make a great treat.
I just prefer mine.
If you have ideas of things you want us to make,
put it in the comments below
and we're gonna bring you more episodes.
Thank you so much for watching
and don't forget to like and subscribe.
