Prelievo forzato di organi in Cina, intervista all’avvocato dei diritti umani David Matas

NTD Italia
259 iscritti
American Thought Leaders con Jan Jekielek
Il primo sopravvissuto al prelievo forzato di organi in Cina ha recentemente reso pubblica la sua storia a Washington.
Da oltre vent’anni i praticanti del Falun Gong e di altre religioni ed etnie vengono barbaramente perseguitati, torturati e uccisi dalla dittatura comunista cinese.
Il commento dell’avvocato dei diritti umani David Matas.
Intervista modificata per motivi di chiarezza e brevità.
link originale: https://www.theepochtimes.com/epochtv/what-the-first-known-survivor-of-chinas-forced-organ-harvesting-reveals-david-matas-5719889?ea_src=frontpage&ea_cnt=a&ea_med=us-politics-right-1
Visita il sito di NTD Italia:
https://www.ntditalia.tv/
#PrelievoForzatoOrgani #FalunGong # PemingCheng
David Matas, it's a pleasure to have you back at American Thought Leaders.
Pleasure is mine.
David, I never would have expected to meet a survivor of forced organ extraction.
This barbaric practice perpetrated by the Chinese regime.
Tell us about Mr. Cheng's case.
I could see in terms of what I have, because he is a Falun Gong practitioner.
Obviously, his organs were taken from him.
Medical examinations and X-rays do not lie.
It is really unusual for someone to survive.
One of the problems we have faced is the lack of media attention to the seriousness of the problem.
No one can talk about the victims, because all the victims are dead.
No body is subjected to autopsy.
The conclusions we have come to are the result of a mosaic of many different evidence.
The problem that we have encountered in communicating the issue is not the lack of evidence, but the excess.
We have thousands of pages, hundreds of pages, that together tell a story.
But he was the only one who was able to say, this happened to me.
On September 4, the survivor Peming Cheng publicly responded to the bizarre statement of the Chinese regime,
according to which he would have operated for his own good.
The Chinese regime has recently publicly admitted that its doctors operated on Cheng without his consent,
while he was imprisoned for practicing Falun Gong, but to save his life.
My name is Cheng Peming.
My name is Peming Cheng.
In November 2004, I was taken by force from the prison of Daqing to the major hospital of Daqing, where they operated on me.
This is the scar.
It is 35 centimeters long.
I stand here today.
Today, here, I can appear normal.
I walk and speak normally.
But in reality, I will never be able to return to how I was.
But today, I will never be able to return to how I was.
My left side is causing me pain at every heartbeat.
I struggle to breathe in bed.
It is truly unbearable.
I can't sleep at night.
I can't get up.
Peming Cheng was able to come to America with the help of the former Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, Robert Destro.
What was necessary to bring Mr. Cheng to America?
It seems to me that there was a bounty on his head.
There was a bounty on his head, and he was hiding in Thailand.
When I found out about the case, I had to negotiate with the Thai government, because he was in Thailand illegally.
We brought him here, and the rest is history.
We subjected him to diagnostic tests for images and everything else.
It is quite clear that they took something from him.
Now we are confirming the suspicions we have had for all these years.
Mr. Cheng was the victim of a forced extraction of organs.
Now we know, and the Chinese have confirmed the details.
How did they confirm the details?
They confirmed that the surgery happened, and also where and when it happened.
We were able to bring Mr. Cheng to the United States, and make sure that independent doctors visited him.
At the time, Cheng was serving an eight-year sentence, and he was subjected to extreme torture, and repeated electric shocks.
The regime claims that the surgery was done to help him after Cheng, in protest, had swallowed a small nail and a blade.
But the doctors claim that nothing can explain how an operation that removes a large part of the liver and lung can be used to recover such stoned objects.
As the record shows, there was no need to enter his side for the entire back, and through the chest.
They could have gone down into the esophagus with an endoscope and extracted everything.
Are you referring to their official version?
Yes, exactly.
Is it surprising that they made such a declaration?
Yes, it surprises me that there is an official version.
For me, as a lawyer, this is an admission of guilt.
The International Lawyer for Human Rights, Nina Shi, Director of the Center for Religious Freedom at the Hudson Institute.
It's immensely important that a true survivor publicly declares that she was a victim of forced extraction of organs, with medical verification and testimony.
This is a concrete test and it is a direct test, it is not an indicative test.
Then there is this strange response from the police and the Chinese government,
according to which he was actually a prisoner held in a hospital and subjected to a surgical intervention without his consent.
It is a crushing proof.
How is it possible that he is alive?
Why did they leave evidence?
This man is the living embodiment of evidence that the Chinese regime would never want to leave.
He was hospitalized twice.
The first time his organs were extracted, the second time I really believe his life was in danger.
If he hadn't run away, I don't think he would be alive today.
There are other people who escaped from China and escaped from detention.
What is unusual about him is not so much the fact that he escaped, but that the organs were taken only partially.
People are systematically killed in the extraction of organs.
The Chinese health care system does not kill Falun Gong practitioners to silence them, but to make money with their bodies.
Why was the forced extraction of organs done only partially in this hospital?
Wait for the Chinese government or the hospital to explain it.
I am not in a position to be able to explain it.
I only know for certain that the organs of a Falun Gong practitioner have disappeared.
This is obvious, but hypotheses can be made.
Wendy Rogers, who chairs the advisory committee of this international coalition,
said that perhaps a partial extraction of the liver was done, because it could be used for a child.
Another possibility is that it was just training or research, because this hospital is not a transplant hospital.
But it is an unprecedented fact.
Maybe they were just trying to develop some techniques.
It's shocking.
I mean, this is the problem with dealing with mass atrocities.
In Canada and the United States we are not surrounded by mass atrocities.
They are not part of our daily life.
The problem is that very often people, instead of believing what they see, see what they believe.
People do not believe that this can happen, or find it very difficult.
Communism is not just the ideology of the permanent committee of the Communist Party.
Since childhood, every Chinese has been indoctrinated with communist ideologies.
They see the world in a different way.
What for us is shocking and unusual, in communist China is everyday life.
Yes, this is a mass atrocity, but it is not the first.
There is Tiananmen Square, which was a repression on a national scale.
There was the Great Kharestia.
There is the Cultural Revolution.
China has had a series of mass atrocities, one after the other, with sandblasting, falsity and immunity.
For the generations of people who have lived under communism, it is always the same story.
And as a result, they develop a different mentality.
Give us some information about your work, and how you entered the field of human rights.
I started out worrying about the Holocaust.
I was born in Winnipeg during the Holocaust.
When I grew up enough to realize what had happened,
I understood that neither I nor any other Jew would be alive today if it had not been for the upheavals of the war.
And for the fact that the world war was won by the allied powers and not by those of the axis.
My goal was to deliver justice to the mass murderers of Nazis.
After the war, Nazi leaders spread all over the world to escape the trials.
After the Second World War, it was easier for Nazi war criminals to enter Canada and the United States
than for Jewish refugees.
And even today I am working on this problem.
Those responsible, the few still alive, are now too old to be persecuted.
Most are dead, but it remains the question of obtaining access to the documents.
I am still looking for these documents on Nazi war criminals.
Not only those who have been persecuted, but also those who have never been.
The persecuted people will be a few dozen.
But historians estimate that thousands have arrived in Canada.
What do these documents say about them?
This is a reason that pushed me to do what I did.
Then I did daily practice with the refugees.
I took care of refugees and I was involved in NGOs for human rights such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the International Commission of Lawyers.
You participated in the drafting of the original report, which evaluated whether the forced extraction of organs took place in Communist China.
Tell us about it.
It all started in 2006.
A woman had publicly declared to Washington that her ex-husband had taken horns from Falun Gong practitioners at the Xiujian Hospital in Shenyang, in the province of Liaoning,
and that other doctors had taken other organs, and that the organs were sold to the tourists of the plants, and that the bodies were cremated.
Almost immediately after the woman's statements, the Chinese government denied.
An NGO, the Coalition to Investigate the Persecution of Falun Gong, turned to my colleague David Kilgour.
They had drawn up a list of 20 people who believed they could conduct independent research on this topic.
I was on the list with David Kilgour.
From the beginning we were told that there were no victims to be interviewed,
no bodies to be submitted for autopsy, no witnesses, only culprits and victims,
because of the proximity of prisons and hospitals, and there were no documents, except those governing prisons and hospitals, that could not be consulted.
For me, the problem was not to establish that it had happened, but simply to determine whether it was true or not.
The coalition that asked us to do it did not give us money, did not provide us with data or indications.
They only asked us to do something, as many other communities of victims of human rights have done in the past.
We tried to prove it or deny it, but without leaving it in suspense.
We put together tests and trial procedures, both for and against.
We had 15, 20 of these tests.
In short, the confusion tests did not lead to anything, but the confirmation tests produced some evidence for each.
The answer was therefore quite clear. It was true.
At this point it is assured that it is real.
There was the China Tribunal.
Ethan Goodman wrote The Slaughter.
Your original reports have convinced me from the beginning.
There have been several government resolutions in this regard.
In some countries there is also legislation against this phenomenon.
And there's a lot of peer-reviewed academic articles.
Kirk Ellison, Jay LaVie, Matthew Robertson and Wendy Rogers.
There's been a whole series of academics and researchers.
Organ extraction is the way people are killed.
There is an article in the American Journal of Transplantation on a small sample of Chinese research articles,
in which in 72 cases, unbeknownst to the people who wrote the articles,
it was revealed that they had killed people through the process of organ extraction.
Yes, the processing profession is so used to this that it does not even consider it wrong.
Didi Kirsten Tatlov, ex-reporter of the New York Times,
was interviewing in English a couple of Chinese doctors who dealt with transplants.
Then they started talking to each other in Mandarin,
without knowing that she understood them, because she speaks Chinese.
One doctor says to the other,
we cannot talk about prisoners killed by organs.
The other says,
do you mean only prisoners sentenced to death,
or even prisoners of conscience?
China has invented this justification because there was a huge transplant boom
after the beginning of the persecution of Falun Gong,
claiming that everything came from donations,
even if at the time there was no donation system.
In fact, we interviewed some people who were said to come from the condemned to death.
Sure.
Then they changed the propaganda from donations,
to prisoners of the arm of death.
As far as I know,
there were actually prisoners of the arm of death.
But there was not a boom of the latter in the period when the persecution of Falun Gong began.
Indeed, the numbers were decreasing,
because in China the law provides for the execution seven days after the sentence.
And there were international pressures to reduce the death penalty,
which actually happened.
But the official propaganda was that of the prisoners in the arm of death.
The prisoners of conscience wanted to hide them.
Obviously, everyone knew.
But they wanted to hide the prisoners of conscience.
They could not talk about it.
And then a journalist hears this conversation in which a doctor tells the other not to talk about it,
because the official propaganda of the party forbids it.
Occasionally there are these leaks of news,
which reveal what is happening.
You have described this as an unheard evil on this planet.
Why are people not outraged?
To a certain extent, the problem is the novelty.
The ability to do good and evil is innate in all of us.
But what changes over time is technology.
What made the Holocaust different from the previous anti-Semitism,
which existed for millennia,
was not anti-Semitism itself.
It was the trains, the lethal gases, the tanks, the radio, the microphones.
These are the things that made the Holocaust what it was.
This is a new form of evil caused by the development of the technology of the implants.
At the time, people tended to believe in the Holocaust.
It was not just people on the street, including very well-informed Jews.
There was a judge of the Supreme Court of the United States,
Frankfurter, to whom the evidence of Auschwitz was presented by a Polish spy, Jan Karski.
And Frankfurter said, I don't believe you.
The person who had presented Karski to Frankfurter said,
this man is telling the truth.
And Frankfurter, I didn't say he was lying.
I just said I don't believe him.
At the time, Hannah Arendt didn't believe us.
Raymond Aron didn't believe us.
These were important Jewish philosophers.
Rudolf Wurba escaped from Auschwitz with the Auschwitz projects
and went around telling Jewish communities, look what's happening.
Go away.
Some believed him and left.
Others didn't, stayed and were killed.
It seemed too unreal and inconceivable compared to what people had seen until then.
And I think it happens with every new technology.
Now we have internet, social media and artificial intelligence.
And they're producing a series of completely new problems
because of our old inclination to always do good or bad.
We haven't talked about the scope of this phenomenon.
How long has it been going on and how many are the transplants?
I know the exact numbers are very difficult to determine.
There are no exact numbers, but you can have an idea of the scope of this phenomenon.
Once in China there were four registries of heart, liver, lung and kidney transplants in different cities.
One was in Hong Kong for liver transplants.
The other three did not publicly report the data.
But after the beginning of the persecution of Falun Gong, liver transplants have increased significantly.
The person in charge of the registry of liver transplants at the time was Wang Hai Bo.
After the publication of the report, the registries disappeared.
I personally saw Wang Hai Bo at a conference on transplants.
I know he's in charge of the registry of liver transplants.
And I asked him, why did you cut public access to the archives?
He said, we didn't ban it.
You can have them.
Just ask.
If he tells us why he wants them and how he will use them, if it's okay with us, he can have them.
This is his answer.
The same goes for hospitals.
In 2016 we had all the hospital data.
They are on the websites and are not difficult to obtain.
We didn't go to all the hospitals, because there were 100 hospitals that did transplants.
At that time, there were 167 approved by the state.
So those who weren't, started to operate clandestinely.
But those approved by the state published their data.
We added them up and we reached 100,000 transplants.
Per year?
Yes, per year.
At the beginning there were 60,000 and in the years it rose to 100,000.
Once we mentioned that source, they disappeared.
But after all, organ sales are a commercial activity.
And it's hard to run a business without making people know their product.
They can't hide all the information.
And then they are proud of their technological progress.
They like to boast about their transplants.
They don't even realize how much they self-accuse, until we don't use their data.
So they take everything away.
Over time, it becomes more and more difficult because the information disappears.
Every time we mention something, we know that we will never be able to mention it again.
We will never be able to update that data, because they will make it disappear.
The problem is not to find out what happened, but to find out the evolution, once our results are published.
There was the idea of never again, compared to the Holocaust.
The fact that we weren't worried about the forced extraction of organs since 2006,
has meant that this crime has spread to others.
There is no doubt about it.
The big numbers for the Uyghurs began only in 2017, when their mass arrest began.
It happened to the Uyghurs partly because of the exhaustion of the Falun Gong population,
after the mass killings for their organs.
But the evolution of technology has increased the duration of organs out of the body.
ECMO technology, right?
Yes, exactly.
The Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation.
But not only.
There are new refrigeration techniques and liquid immersion techniques.
In practice, they can send organs all over China from Xinjiang.
We have seen airports in Xinjiang with signs that said,
reserved for the transport of organs, and we have photographed them.
Again, the Chinese have boasted of this technological progress,
the ability to transport organs from Xinjiang all over China,
until we realized it.
Then they stopped talking about it.
This would not have happened if the abuses of the Falun Gong had been stopped.
In Busan, South Korea, a conference was held where it was discussed
to develop in Asia a system of transplants similar to the European one.
Within the European Union it is possible to circulate organs.
The Chinese have tried to do the same in Asia.
This would mean that the organs of the prisoners of conscience
would go to South Korea and Japan,
because now there are many tourists of the transplants from Japan
and South Korea to China.
I have been quite regularly in Asia to talk about these problems.
When I do, there are Falun Gong practitioners,
the Uyghurs, the independent Christians and the Tibetans.
But now I also see the Mongols.
They are persecuted.
I have not seen evidence that they are being killed for their organs,
but they think they are the next.
This machine is devouring the Chinese population,
group after group.
In prison, we made a pact among us detainees.
Whoever survives must tell the world the truth about the persecutions suffered.
Today, I am here not just to speak on my behalf.
Many of the people who were with me in prison are dead
and can no longer speak.
Former Deputy Frank Wolf,
stern defender of human rights in the three decades spent in Parliament,
says evidence of the death of prisoners for their organs
by the Chinese regime has been known since 1997.
But Western leaders have pretended not to see.
Harry Wu, who you may or may not remember,
came to me in 1997 to talk to me,
and he showed me some photos.
The Chinese government was going to take the blood group of the prisoners.
When people arrived by plane from the West,
they were justified and then they did the transplant.
Harry showed me the images of the execution.
Now the situation is worse and no one does anything.
There are indications of involvement of some American institutions.
All this must end.
What do you think can be done right now?
Well, you could get a trial from a legal study
or an association of human rights
to denounce any American institution that participates in this.
You have to tell them to stop.
If they don't stop, they have to be denounced.
You are killing people.
In several countries a law has been passed.
Jacob Lavie mentioned earlier
that it was crucial to pass a law
that prevents Israeli health care from paying for organ transplants in China.
It was in 2008 or 2009, and it was the first.
Recently, something very similar was passed in three American states,
and the Falun Gong Protection Act was passed by the House,
and now it's in the Senate.
It's the first federal law on this topic.
There is also the Stop Organ Harvesting Act,
which has also been approved by the House and the Senate,
even if it seems to have been postponed.
I think Texas has passed a law on specific insurance for China.
The Israeli law now says
that you can't pay for organ transplants abroad.
The destination country is not specified,
but Texas explicitly says
that transplants in China cannot be insured.
I think the U.S. has a similar law.
What is the use of passing a law that provides for these sanctions?
Yeah, the U.S. law is sanctions, immigration, and denunciation.
It's about raising public awareness,
because I would say that the majority of patients
don't know that someone has been killed for their organs.
Maybe it's a voluntary stupidity,
but some, perhaps most,
really believe in any story invented by Chinese communists.
So this law will not stop the system in China,
but it will discourage people from going to China for transplants.
What is your hope for the visibility of this news
and for the legislation now at the Parliament?
The wheels of justice and human rights
are moving slowly, but inexorably.
In the end, the system will reach the party,
because the persecution will reach the party.
And it's not just for the Chinese communists,
it's for the persecution in general.
In every repressive system there are oppressors and oppressors,
but no one resists forever.
In the end, the parties are reversed,
but the oppressors do not become oppressors,
because they have suffered the evil.
It will simply collapse under the weight of its own evil.
What do I hope will happen?
My opinion is that there is no need to hope,
or make predictions, or think about the future.
The future must be created.
Attorney Matas, it was a pleasure.
My pleasure. Thank you very much.
