Some see him as a visionary, a powerful leader who united China. Others label him a tyrant, most famously known for the "burning of books and burying of scholars". But did he really do that?
#gjwpluswatchparty Good news! Gan Jing World recently launched GJW+ streaming, a platform dedicated to presenting a wide array of clean, uplifting, traditional, and educational film and television works. Subscribe to GJW+ now for only $6.99 per month, the price of just two cups of coffee, and enjoy a top-notch viewing experience with your family. Click the link below and by using the exclusive discount code SARA, you can enjoy a 15% discount.
Unveiling the Forgotten, the Forbidden, and the Divine — a journey through China’s lost wisdom and a return to timeless tradition.
Follow me, and rediscover the China that time tried to forget. And consider supporting my research through a donation to help keep these forgotten voices alive. (Donation link: https://paypal.me/KSJBG)
When it comes to Qin Shi Huang, the first emperor of China, opinions about him have always been
mixed. Some see him as a visionary, a powerful leader who united China. Others label him a
tyrant, most famously known for the burning of books and burying of scholars. But did he really
do that? Hey everyone, I'm Sarah. Today, I want to talk about the truth behind this historical event,
and why Qin Shi Huang may have been wrongfully accused.
Many people think that burning books and burying scholars happened at the same time and were part
of the same event. But actually, these were two separate incidents that occurred under different
circumstances. Let's start with the burning of books. According to the records of the Grand
Historian, the event took place in 212 BC during a grand celebration for Qin Shi Huang's birthday.
He held a lavish banquet at Xianyang Palace, where 70 scholars, who were high-ranking officials
responsible for preserving important texts and teaching, gathered to offer their respects and
congratulate the emperor. At the banquet, one of the officials Zhou Qingchen praised Qin Shi Huang's
achievements, saying, In the past, the Qin territory was only about a thousand miles wide,
but after uniting the land and driving away foreign invaders, you turned the former feudal
states into commanderies and counties. Now, everyone lives in peace, without the threat of
war. Even the rulers of ancient times cannot compare to your virtue, your majesty. Naturally,
Qin Shi Huang was pleased. But another scholar, Chunyu Yu, the tutor of Qin Shi Huang's eldest son,
Fusu, boldly criticized Zhou. He argued that Zhou was flattering the emperor, and that the old feudal
was better for maintaining stability. After Qin Shi Huang unified China, he replaced the feudal
system with a centralized government, known as the commandery-county system. This reform faced
opposition, especially from Chunyu Yu and other officials who preferred the old ways. However,
Qin Shi Huang's prime minister, Li Si, defended the new system, stating that the feudal system
led to constant warfare between regional rulers, weakening the emperor's control.
After hearing both sides, Qin Shi Huang decided to stick with the commandery-county system.
Eight years had passed since the reforms, yet Chunyu Yu still advocated for the feudal system.
During Qin Shi Huang's birthday celebration, he boldly spoke out, praising the past and
criticizing the present system. His words, especially on such an important occasion,
were seen as disrespectful to the emperor. What's surprising, though, is Qin Shi Huang's reaction.
The records of the Grand Historian note that the emperor simply said,
let's discuss this further. Chunyu Yu openly criticized the commandery-county
system at the emperor's birthday banquet, yet he faced no punishment afterward.
If this had happened today, such defiance might have led to severe consequences.
But back then, it seemed scholars were free to speak their minds without fear,
regardless of the setting. A few days later, Li Si suggested something drastic.
He proposed that private schools be banned and that all non-Qin books be burned,
except those related to medicine, agriculture, and divination. This would ensure that people
wouldn't cling to old ideas, slowing down progress. Qin Shi Huang's response to Li Si's proposal was
a simple decree, it is permitted. Typically, a decree like this was meant to communicate with
officials and wasn't directed at the general public. This neutral phrasing showed that Qin
approved of Li Si's loyalty, but also indicated limits on the extent of the book burning.
Li Si understood the emperor's intent, he only announced to the public that private collections
of the poetry, documents, and the works of various philosophers were to be destroyed,
but the official archives kept a copy of everything. Evidence from Qin bamboo
slips unearthed in Hubei suggests that no large-scale book burning actually took place.
According to the Cambridge History of China, the real damage to literature was caused by warfare,
not by the burning of books under Qin Shi Huang. The burying of scholars incident supposedly
happened a year after the book burning, but the records of the grand historian doesn't
directly mention burying scholars. Instead, it says that during the later years of Qin,
the emperor burned books and punished certain practitioners of mystical arts.
Now, we know that Qin Shi Huang was obsessed with finding the secret to immortality.
From birth, Qin Shi Huang was believed to have signs of greatness. His parents told him that
when he was born, birds gathered on the rooftop, and he was born with unique features like double
pupils, teeth, and even dragon-like scales down his back. His father also shared a legend passed
down through the Qin royal family, which foretold that a great ruler would emerge to unify the land.
This belief was reinforced by the story of Qin Shi Huang's ancestor,
Duke Wen of Qin, who dreamed of a giant yellow dragon, a symbol of the heavenly emperor,
descending upon Qin, predicting that a true emperor would rise from their lineage.
The History of the Qin State also recorded stories about Qin Shi Huang's distant ancestor,
Duke Mu of Qin. His daughter, Nong Yu, and her husband, Xiao Shi, were said to have achieved
immortality. They played the flute to summon phoenixes, and then rode on dragons to ascend
to the heavens. These stories further convinced Qin Shi Huang of the existence of immortals,
and deepened his reverence for the divine and supernatural forces. Following this,
many conmen posing as mystics took advantage of his beliefs, offering to find an elixir of life.
According to the records of the grand historian, two such mystics, Liu Xing and Hou Xing, promised
Qin Shi Huang they could help him become immortal. He rewarded them generously, but as time passed,
they failed to deliver and began making excuses. Eventually, they started criticizing Qin Shi Huang
behind his back and fled in fear. Angered by their betrayal, Qin Shi Huang sent inspectors
to interrogate other alchemists in Xianyang. As a result, the alchemists who had been involved
in creating elixirs began accusing each other. Ultimately, over 460 individuals were found guilty
and were executed. Qin Shi Huang ordered their execution and publicly announced their crimes to
serve as a warning to others about the consequences of deceiving the emperor and violating the
principles of loyalty and trust. However, according to the language used during the
Qiansha, killing and burying, likely refers to executing people and then burying them without
proper rites, rather than the modern understanding of burying alive. As for whether 460 alchemists
were actually executed, this number is also questionable. It seems contradictory for Qin
Shi Huang to publicize such a severe action if he intended to use it as a warning. It's possible
that the figure was exaggerated or distorted over time. It's worth mentioning that despite
Qin Shi Huang's reputation for tyranny, historical records show he wasn't excessively violent.
During his conquests of the six warring states, there are very few accounts of mass executions.
In fact, he treated royal families from defeated states kindly. Even though Crown Prince Dan of
Yan sent Jing Ku to assassinate him, when the Qin army, upon capturing Ji city, Qin Shi Huang did
not set fire to the city or slaughter the royal family and officials of Yan. He only received the
severed head of Crown Prince Dan, which had been sent by the king of Yan. As for Gao Jianli, a
musician and close friend of Jing Ku who had been involved in the assassination attempt, after being
captured, Qin Shi Huang merely blinded him and even allowed him to serve as a court musician,
though Gao later attempted to assassinate the emperor again. During his 37-year reign,
Qin Shi Huang never executed any generals or ministers. Even when the great general Wang Jian
committed a capital offense, Qin Shi Huang allowed him to enjoy wealth and honor for the rest of his
life. Both of Wang Jian's sons were also favored and appointed to important positions by the
emperor. This paints a very different picture of Qin Shi Huang than the one typically associated
with tyranny. Renowned Chinese archaeologist Duan Qingbao believes that Qin Shi Huang has
been unfairly maligned, intentionally demonized. He argues that most of the negative accounts about
Qin Shi Huang come from early Han Confucian scholars, whose aim was to legitimize the
new Han regime while using Qin's downfall as a warning to encourage the current rulers to
govern wisely. Not only was Qin Shi Huang labeled a tyrant, but even his appearance was distorted.
The Records of the Grand Historian describes him as having a hooked nose, long eyes,
a prominent chest, a voice like a wild animal, unkind with the heart of a tiger and wolf.
This description painted him as having a harsh, unattractive appearance and a cruel,
ruthless nature. Apart from the infamous burning of books and burying of scholars,
another major piece of evidence often cited to support claims of his tyranny comes from
Records of the Grand Historian, which states that he used 700,000 prisoners to construct the
Er Pang Palace and his mausoleum at Mount Li. It was commonly interpreted that these prisoners
were slaves or ordinary people. However, hidden palace refers to officials, not ordinary people.
Most of the workers were military personnel, war captives, or criminals. In fact, after Qin Shi
Huang unified China, military conscription and labor service were greatly reduced,
significantly lowering casualties. Moreover, according to Qin law, those serving in labor
duty were provided with wages, food, and clothing, and each household could not be forced to provide
more than one person at a time for service, showing concern for the people's welfare.
It's well known that Qin adopted Xiang Yang's reforms, which were based on legalist principles,
and while the punishments may seem harsh today, they were common among the warring states of that
era. Yet, in Records of the Grand Historian's chapter on Cruel Officials, not a single Qin
official is mentioned. The list is entirely made up of Han Dynasty officials. If Qin was truly
tyrannical, wouldn't there have been many more cruel officials? Qin Shi Huang's philosophy of
governance was made clear in his inscription on Mount Tai, where he emphasized the importance
of legal regulations. The administration of the state must operate smoothly, all industries must
develop harmoniously, and now everything has a legal basis. Similarly, his inscription at Langya
read, Fair laws are the foundation of all things, making human relations harmonious,
fostering filial piety, and familial respect. This shows that his governance was more about
In December 1975, the Yunmeng Shuihudi Qin bamboo slips were unearthed in Hubei,
revealing several Qin laws. For example, if a husband steals 1,000 coins, and the wife hides
300, how should she be punished? The answer is, if the wife knew about the theft and hid the money,
she would be charged for concealing 300 coins. If she didn't know, she would not be held
accountable. If someone kills or injures a person on the street and bystanders within 100 steps do
nothing, they would be heavily fined, up to two suits of armor. These laws show that Qin justice
wasn't as ruthless as often imagined, with careful distinctions in culpability. Compared to some
modern systems, in China, where intervening can sometimes result in punishment, Qin law
emphasized responsibility and moral duty. In the records of the Grand Historian,
there is a passage stating, No matter how large or small the affairs of the empire,
they were all decided by the emperor. The emperor weighed the reports with a stone balance and
worked day and night, with no rest until all matters were addressed. Qin Shi Huang reportedly
reviewed one load of bamboo slips daily, weighing around 60 kilograms, equating to roughly 200,000
characters. This illustrates Qin Shi Huang's dedication to governance, showing he was a
diligent ruler. Claims of his tyranny seem to be untrue. Alright, that's it for today.
Don't forget to like, comment, and share. See you next time.