Attacco frontale del New York Times a Shen Yun, la risposta degli artisti

NTD Italia
259 iscritti
American Thought Leaders con Jan Jekielek
Nell'agosto del 2024, il New York Times ha pubblicato una serie di articoli che denunciano diversi abusi all'interno della compagnia di danza classica cinese Shen Yun.
Sia gli attuali artisti di Shen Yun che quelli che hanno lasciato la compagnia affermano che gli articoli del Times non sono veritieri.
Noi, abbiamo deciso di dar voce ai diretti interessati.
link originale: https://www.theepochtimes.com/epochtv/shen-yun-artists-respond-to-new-york-times-articles-5716994
Visita il sito di NTD Italia:
https://www.ntditalia.tv/
#ShenYun #ShindyCai #SunniZhou
In August 2024, the New York Times
published a series of articles
denouncing various abuses
within the Chinese classical dance company Shen Yun.
Both the current artists of Shen Yun
and those who left the company
claim that the articles in the Times are not true.
We have decided to give voice to those directly interested.
I've interviewed intellectuals of all walks of life,
including artists.
Sometimes when they are misrepresented in other media,
I give them space so that my audience
can have the full picture.
The Epoch Times has been a sponsor of Shen Yun for years.
I was shocked to see how Shen Yun's artists
were portrayed in these New York Times articles.
And now it's up to the artists themselves
to give their version of the facts.
I did read the articles and my initial reaction
is the same as a lot of the other dancers to Shen Yun.
We're really surprised and sad by what we saw on the article.
I performed with Shen Yun for seven years.
From my experience in Shen Yun,
I really do feel like it was very, very valuable for me.
She asked me like,
are you okay? Are you happy there?
And I was like,
I've never been happier in my life by being there.
My name is Cindy Kai.
I'm a dancer with Shen Yun Performing Arts.
Even though we went through the same experiences,
I'm getting a completely different picture
of what it's really like.
So, what was your reaction?
Sadness and disappointment towards this article.
I feel like this article dehumanizes us in a way
that we're a wonderful group of people.
Everyone with their own personality, interests,
hobbies and activities.
And then you're talking about
how we're all under this oppressive atmosphere.
And I feel like it's very, very wrong to be out there.
And then my very first reaction was
like, how could this happen?
Like, an environment that has helped us so much
and helped us grow so much,
like, why is it growing so much?
Why is it getting so much in this way?
Which is our story.
We just decided to talk about that.
To share our stories,
not to lie about that.
I remember that evening,
we all sat down
and we started writing our experiences
until midnight.
We had so much to say.
We really want to like,
Honestly, when I read this article,
I felt like I was reading some kind of like,
horror novel, a work of fiction basically.
I'm not invalidating anyone's experiences,
but I do feel like they do miss
a really big part of things.
And it's like the good part,
the positive parts about
the experiences you gain here.
Because the Shen Yun that they describe
is not the Shen Yun that I go to every day.
They wanted to showcase
traditional Chinese culture,
a culture that the Communist
takeover in China
wanted to erase.
Today, Shen Yun tour companies,
dancers, singers, and orchestras
perform in front of
nearly a million people
worldwide each year.
In a scenic and remote campus
in the north of the state of New York,
Shen Yun also nurtures
the artistic talent
of two religiously affiliated private organizations
affiliated to religion.
One of the main claims
in the New York Times articles
is that Shen Yun would have
neglected medical care
and created a climate
in which dancers were afraid
to take care of themselves
when they got hurt.
But the dancers, we tell them,
it's not true.
You want to take care of
a world-class artist
if you do that level on stage.
It doesn't make sense
to take care of yourself.
It doesn't exist.
It's like saying to Simone Biles,
go fix your ankle,
while she's the one
who's zipping around.
It would be impossible
to get certain results.
For decades,
the Chinese regime
has been conducting
fierce propaganda
against Shen Yun
and Falun Gong.
It falsely claims
that Falun Gong practitioners
do harmful things,
including systematically
refusing medical care
and being extremists.
Now these same lies
are being repeated
by the New York Times.
There's this claim
that we dance
despite our injuries,
but if you think about it logically,
if that was the case,
we would have a very high
abandonment rate
and we would lose
various dancers
every season.
We have to maintain
a high-level standard
and it would be impossible
with people
zipping around on stage.
Obviously,
it's in our interest
to take care of ourselves.
I'm just trying to speak
on, you know,
a psychological level
because if you don't
tell anyone
about your injury,
no one knows.
Every time I let
others know
that I was hurt,
I was moved
from certain positions.
Or the instructors
or the manager
would do everything
to make sure
that I was really well.
But if I don't
tell anyone,
no one helps me,
no?
Maybe they see you
zipping around,
but they don't know
if you're zipping
because your foot
hurts a little bit
at that moment
or if you got
a little sprain
or if you really
ripped something.
Every time
that I got hurt,
someone else
raised their hand
and said,
I'll do that part,
don't worry.
I'll leave the stage
on the left
and I'll come back
on the right.
I think there's
like this misconception
that we made
this wrong idea
so that when we get
hurt,
we don't take care
of ourselves
and we don't
clench our teeth.
That's not true
I have a lot
of classmates
that because of
injuries
were taken
to the hospital
Like last year
when I was an
apprentice,
while I was
training,
I did a jump
and when I landed
I missed the time
and I fell
and I dislocated
my ankle
and my teacher
came to me
and said,
are you okay?
Do you think
you can do it?
We can change
the formation
and replace you.
I kind of have
a similar experience
because,
I remember
one of the years
before the show
I was doing a flip
and I landed
and I did
a weird turn
and my knee
hurt me
and then
my teacher
came to me
and said
you can
actually
We are Cerotti and Garze, and I think we all know how to use it.
We are very good at talking about the problems between us.
It is always a team game, in which everyone works only to help each other
and to make sure that the audience receives the best we can offer.
Fear, emotional abuse, threats, these are words repeated in the articles of the New York Times.
But the artists who have spoken to us have told us quite the opposite.
From my experience, it is quite the opposite.
Before I moved to Fei Tian and Shen Yun, I was a victim of bullying
at a level that I did not imagine possible at school, and I had to overcome it on my own.
Here, the community and the environment make me feel much safer.
My personality has changed so much that I have opened up much more.
I have become more sociable, because everyone around me is so open and tolerant,
and everyone supports me, to the point that I have lowered my guard.
I think this community in Shen Yun is very precious,
because when I see younger people coming, I feel obliged to help them,
as others have helped me when I first came.
And I know that in a lot of artistic companies there is always a very intense sense of competition.
It is almost your life, Mea.
And even if you are at the top, you always live in the fear of falling and being eliminated.
In Shen Yun, on the other hand, we really try to help each other.
Since I got to Shen Yun, I have hope for myself.
I used to suffer from depression, but I have had moments of good luck in my life.
But now I have overcome it for a very long time, because our mutual commitment is to support each other.
Between us there is no competition, we push each other to improve.
Our climate is very healthy.
Passing to the teachers, in this piece it is said that some are very hard.
Is there room for severity?
The word very hard is used in a non-truthful way, in my experience.
I have been in Shen Yun for more than 10 years and I have never felt coercion.
Indeed, I have felt guided.
I have been guided beyond my limits, never forced beyond my limits.
My instructor criticizes me, sometimes it is difficult to accept.
Of course, criticisms are difficult to accept.
But it is never a thing like, you are worthless as a person.
You can do this to improve.
Speaking of teachers, if for a week the teacher is very kind and patient
and explains things to the student in a very kind way,
and maybe one day he is nervous on his own and the words are a little bit harder,
if that student accepts it, then he remembers only that day and says to you,
that teacher has always mistreated me.
Exactly.
But in reality it is often not true.
And many times, in a dance class, if the piano teacher is playing
and, for example, everyone is raising their right arm,
but you are raising your left arm, the teacher tells you loudly,
you are raising the wrong arm.
It has to be heard, right?
It is not that you can't hear it, if not, you don't even hear it.
In class it is like this.
And many times the teacher then comes to explain himself.
Maybe I was a little bit harder before.
It was first of all to make me feel, and then because you were wrong
and I want to make you improve.
So there is a lot of communication between teacher and student.
It's not a unilateral thing like,
here they treat me like a fish in the water and that's it.
It's not like that at all.
And I'm pretty sure that if you ask any Olympic athlete
or any successful person,
at the end of the day it's not that they look back and think,
I wish my teacher would have been more permissive with me,
so I would have done less good.
On the contrary, they look back at all those times
and they thank their teachers for pushing them there.
You need someone to tell you, you can do more.
I see more potential in you than you see yourself.
This is a true teacher.
One might think it's just about being a dancer,
but then you think about all the lessons you've learned along the way.
When my teacher told me I could do more than I thought I could,
it was true.
And then you apply this to life.
If you look at the facts,
since Shen Yun was founded,
it's grown from a company to eight companies.
We go all over the world.
We only perform in the best theaters.
If we really were this institution painted by the New York Times,
how could we do this?
If you accuse us of forcing people to stay in this environment
that causes fear.
Shen Yun is growing.
It's not just flowing.
We're constantly improving to become the best in the world.
So, if it really was forcing people to stay and improve
and make the company better,
if it were, like for me personally,
I would have stayed in a company that made me feel threatened
and like intimidated and had all these ridiculous rules.
I would have really just stayed in a place like that
for over a decade.
The articles in the New York Times
have also talked about dancers under pressure to lose weight
and humiliated if they can't.
Is there something that for you has been taken out of context?
Is there something true?
To be honest, I feel everything was taken out of context.
I think a lot of people have chosen to see only certain things
because me and other male dancers,
reading the article, we burst out laughing.
We? Will we be malnourished?
This is just a joke.
If you see me eating, malnourished,
it's the last thing that comes to mind.
You should see us at the buffet, that's all.
But yes, we brush our teeth.
Obviously, afterwards we burn.
We do a lot of exercise.
Yes, sorry, I'll finish here.
There would be a lot to say about this.
I'm going to show you what Shenzhen dancers eat on tour.
Check out the spread.
So we got some pasta here.
It's like spaghetti.
There's pork chops.
We're going to walk so we can show you a little bit of that food.
All right guys, let's go.
Where's that cinnamon thing?
It's got a little bit of everything.
It's also a matter of nutrition.
You don't want to stuff yourself with sweets.
Even the gymnasts know that.
When you have a lot of excess weight on your body,
it affects your bones, your knees, your cartilages.
It hurts you if you're not aware of how you're eating.
Do you want to ruin your knees right away
or eat healthy and maybe be able to dance without problems
for another two or three years?
Yeah, I remember our teacher saying like, you know,
our teacher was telling us that an adequate diet
is not for nothing to eat more or eat less.
She suggested that we have proper meals a day
but to limit snacks and snacks.
You might think that dancers don't eat anything
or that they just don't want to be scared to eat.
Actually, it's actually not true.
We eat pretty normal, but we eat healthy.
It's enough just to have a healthy diet.
It's not like that extreme.
So there are a couple of other things in this article.
One is Shen Yun treats many of his artists as objects to be used.
And then most of the time he says he was used by a religious movement
that was interested in the spread of his vision.
What do you think about this?
I think it's the opposite.
Because I've often seen the direction of talking to dancers
about their future, you know,
and to help them understand what to do next.
They're already thinking about what the dancers will do next.
And it's been true for me as well.
They talked to me about various possibilities for the future.
This or that.
Maybe the theatrical production.
The life of a dancer is very short.
You can't go on for 50 years like a singer.
At 70, 80, you can sing.
But a 30-year-old dancer starts thinking later.
So it's the exact opposite.
There's no use and throw.
I took a digital design course at Fei Tian College.
And then I took courses in digital design,
Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere, InDesign.
Everything that had to do with dancing.
It was sort of what he was asking, you know,
what are the future possibilities?
There's the stereotype about athletic schools
that, you know, you don't really need to focus on the academic side.
You're telling me that's not the case.
I think in Fei Tian...
The artists told me that every student at Fei Tian
has a complete scholarship that covers
university fees, textbooks, rent and accommodation.
Additionally, students are allowed to apply
for a tour of Shen Yun
to earn scholastic credits.
The company covers all expenses.
Also, I feel like in the whole course of study,
you don't just learn to dance,
but there are so many lessons,
such as serious, you know,
you learn things like perseverance,
or humility, that you then use in any area of life.
So, say in the future I do have to choose
what other career I'm going to be doing,
I will be using everything I learned in this course.
And I'm pretty sure that in whatever area
I choose to develop in,
these skills will lead me to success.
The article in the New York Times
says that you have severe restrictions
on the use of the internet,
meaning that you're not allowed to communicate
with the outside world, that you're kept isolated.
I think the article is a little bit confusing.
Actually, there's Fei Tian, the school,
and then there's Shen Yun.
So, in Fei Tian, there are students who are minors,
and the school is responsible for them.
But one of my colleagues told me that
Fei Tian gives a lot more freedom
than the Catholic school where he used to go,
where he wasn't even allowed the down phone,
the old type of cell phone.
At that time, you know,
there's a school district in Los Angeles,
it's like one of the main districts
that they're doing a home camp.
It's becoming a thing where, you know,
people use so much information,
it's almost scandalous.
And this is the school.
Obviously, I'm a professional member of Shen Yun,
so, yeah, I have the freedom to,
I have the phone, I have the computer,
it's whatever I want to do.
Yeah, if you're a school,
you're more interested to focus on studies,
Yeah, that's a misconception,
because as a member of Shen Yun,
we are allowed to use our phones and computers
and have our own families and our own lives.
So, I feel like that is a very extreme image
that I read in the article,
and I definitely don't recognize it.
This is a boarding school,
and the teacher,
people in charge of this school,
we need to take care of our kids,
because their parents are not there.
Shen Yun, of course,
I have a phone,
and I can go on the internet,
even now, no problem.
We don't know anything about the world.
You could read the New York Times,
if you wanted to.
Exactly, so it's like,
we have access to it,
but we need to protect the students,
especially the minors.
You know, it's an interesting moment.
A lot of schools are,
you know, banning phones.
There's been a lot of awareness,
especially with Jonathan Hyde's new book,
about how destructive the use of smartphones
and social media is.
It's almost as if Shen Yun
was at the forefront of this.
The people who created Facebook and Google
don't let their kids use the internet.
Steve Jobs didn't let his kids use the iPad.
We're following their example here.
To put things in perspective,
once I heard this funny thing,
who at the end of their life
lies on the bed of death,
looks back and says,
what a shame,
I wish I had spent more time on the smartphone.
You know, in life,
you just have to move on
and do the things that matter,
with the people that matter,
real people.
This article also says that
when you decide to stop,
you're almost stopped,
as if you weren't allowed to leave.
How do you respond?
I left.
I know so many people,
friends and ex-colleagues,
who thought that this career
wasn't for them,
and the company didn't oppose anything.
What usually happens is,
you know,
the management talks to you.
Is there anything we can do
to make things better?
And some of these people
didn't feel good,
maybe for a while,
and the management talked to them
a couple of times,
you know, making steps back,
making concessions,
trying to improve their situation.
But in the end,
they decided that
it wasn't for them.
And they left without any problems,
as it's fair to do
in a responsible management team.
A dear friend of mine
was a very talented dancer.
One time, we were chatting,
he was talking about his future.
Maybe he wanted to change fields
because he was interested in science.
A couple of days later,
he left the company,
he said what he thought,
and the next day,
he was gone.
Fast and in pain.
The artists who work with Shen Yun
practice Falun Gong,
and even the Falun Gong principles
have this freedom
to come in and out.
There are no records,
no signatures,
no contracts,
nothing.
You take a book,
you read it,
and if you share the teachings,
you start practicing.
That's it.
Maybe in the future,
my perspective will change,
and I won't want to study anymore.
Also, this is your free choice.
There is never anything forced,
in any way,
both in the teachings of Falun Gong
and in the way Shen Yun is managed.
Falun Gong,
a Buddhist spiritual practice
was introduced in 1992
and quickly gained popularity in China
for its health benefits
and teachings based on truth,
compassion, and tolerance.
However, a 1999 survey revealed
that in China,
there were from 70 to 100 million practitioners.
Then the Chinese Communist Party
began to persecute them.
Millions of practitioners
were sent to labor camps,
many were tortured,
and others were even killed
for their organs.
The PCC denies everything,
but these are established facts
without a shadow of a doubt
by numerous organizations
for human rights,
independent investigators,
and anti-government organizations.
Shen Yun,
at one point in the show,
represents on stage
this persecution.
So there is a kind of message
of Falun Gong in the show.
In this article,
there is the idea
that there is some
subdued and evil message.
We do have scenes
that reflect the persecution of Falun Gong,
and this is just telling
how things are.
The facts.
We don't invent anything.
We tell things
that don't come out of China.
The mainstream media
doesn't talk about it,
and the PCC
certainly won't tell you about it.
But this is something
that happened to my family.
My uncle and my aunt
were homeless for 10 years
in China
just because of their faith.
They didn't do anything wrong.
They were normal peasants in China,
very simple people,
but they were practitioners.
The police found out
and came to arrest them.
They were able to escape
before the police
arrested them.
And for 10 years,
they wandered around China.
Why isn't it okay
to talk about something like that?
And what's so strange
about a faith
that unites people
or makes them stronger?
Without this,
maybe I'm just
dancing for myself
and for my fame,
for the success
of a company for sure.
But there is also
another level
that is much deeper.
I don't understand
why there are so many
negative connotations.
We have personally
experienced the miracles,
the goodness,
the harmony
that Falun Gong
has brought to our community.
Just look at our class.
When students
are together with sincerity,
compassion, tolerance,
everyone works together
so well.
If there is a conflict,
you think that
the other person
is wrong.
But we,
in our community,
take a step back
and think,
maybe I'm too harsh,
maybe I'm not
comprehensive enough.
And naturally,
conflicts resolve
very quickly.
This kind of environment
is really difficult
to find.
Falun Gong
has always been non-violent
and Shen Yun
has always been non-violent as well.
We're not trying
to hide anything.
If you go to Beijing
and you open a sign
that says truth,
compassion, tolerance,
and then you get arrested
and jailed.
If you just look
at this,
you understand
what kind of people
are the people
who want to
erase these three words.
Like,
look at these
beautiful words
and they are the
principles
that we try
to hold on to.
And now
we are accused
of wanting
to spread
something dark
and mysterious.
We are dark
and we are
very transparent
We say on our
website that
we practice
truth,
compassion,
tolerance.
I'm not ashamed
to say that.
I have nothing
to hide.
All the teachings
are online.
You can go online
and download everything
for free.
And if everyone
around you
followed truth,
compassion,
and tolerance
you can imagine
how different
the world would be.
We are united
by these principles
but not in a
forced way
but in a
philosophical way
in the way
a faith
unites people.
We are trying
to share
a message.
Yes,
maybe if all
the newspapers
talked about
persecution
and real facts
maybe we wouldn't
feel so forced
to put it
in our show
because we are
the only voice
that exists.
For us
spirituality
is a very
big part
of Chinese
culture
and of our
history.
For thousands
of years
like Buddhism,
Taoism
has been
a part of
Chinese culture.
I feel that
Falun Gong
is a continuation
it's the modern
equivalent
of our spirituality.
So naturally
that will be
in our show
because it's
a part of who we are
but for people
to take that
and use it
against us
I think it's
very unfair
because we are
not forcing
the audience
to think
like us
or something
like that.
We are talking
about it
we are talking
about our
history.
Mingye Liu
a former dancer
in Shengyun
now a dance teacher
in a private school
says that
the Chinese regime
has tried to
prevent
the representation
of persecution.
I left the company
many years ago
but a few years ago
my uncle
in China
contacted me
and said
the police
came here
and asked me
if I have
a nephew
in America
who is associated
with Shengyun
and they did it
in a threatening tone
like
it's better
for you
if you tell him
to stop
otherwise
something
could happen
to you.
So apparently
here too
I was followed
and I grew up
here in the United States
I'm an American
and I'm being
spied on
by the Americans
and yet
these American
newspapers
basically
line up
on their side.
From day one
we've been met
with a lot
of problems.
Last year
the tires
of our bus
were cut
a hole
on the side
so that
the tires
didn't explode
but collapsed
on the highway
and it happened
often.
Last year
we received
a phone call
that said
they had
planted a bomb
they created
a fake
X account
to defame us
the Communist
doesn't like
what we do
so these
kind of articles
need to be
taken seriously.
Shen Yun's art
guided by the principles
of truth
compassion
and tolerance
is deeply rooted
in the traditional
Chinese culture.
The traditional
Chinese culture
includes the belief
that the great art
the art that
really inspires
and elevates
can only be produced
by individuals
with a strong
moral character.
The Chinese culture
is intrinsically
and has always been
for thousands of years
spiritual
in its Buddhist
and Taoist
and the Confucian
is only a part
of what it is
if you separate
spirituality
from culture
there is nothing
left.
This was the
innate soul
of Chinese culture
before communism
took power.
There is nothing
in the show
that forces
or insists
in promoting
a faith or religion
in our audience
there are Christians
Buddhists
Atheists
we have people
who are here
telling something
that is actually
happening
there is this
gross
injustice
there is this
human rights
nobody talks
about it
so we do it
the Falun Gong
is in line
with the direction
of the show
because it is
a spiritual practice
it is bringing
up many
spiritual elements
that have
disappeared
in society
we are talking
about Buddha
we are talking
about Tao
and Dei
and the Falun Gong
connects to this
through tradition.
To conclude
what do you
hope will
happen next?
Media companies
have a great
responsibility
I hope
they can be
responsible
for the American
and this
means
giving serious
voice to both
parties
and doing
serious research
because a
simple article
can do
a lot of
and I encourage
people to
really think
with their
own heads
and look at
the context
of how
things are
presented.
I wish for
the world
to hear
the other
bell
our
personal
experiences
and I
wish
that they
could see
it with
their own
eyes
that they
could
understand
and
have
a
conversation
with
them.
We have
also
published
several
investigative
reports
that
talk
about
the
new
York
Times
and
how many
times
that
article
reflects
those of the Chinese regime.
Thank you for watching this special episode
of American Thought Leaders by Jan Jekielek.
