(S2 E1) Florence: Aesthetics and Politics, 1420-1450 | A Narrative Art History of the Renaissance

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
This is the story of how the Renaissance was born, how, in the 15th century, it grew from a network
of seeds and bloomed, how it twisted and turned like a searching tendril, crossing geographies
and reaching varied cultures, uniting some and dividing others, how it matured decade by decade
before reaching the apogee that is the High Renaissance, where season one began.
Watching the previous season is by no means required to understand this one. This series,
two years in the making, uses art history to trace the birth of modern western civilization.
This is season two of A Narrative Art History of the Renaissance.
We'll begin in the Tuscan countryside, about an hour west of Florence, in a town called San Romano.
600 years ago, in 1432, it was the site of a famous battle that influenced how Florentine
politics played out for the remainder of the 15th century, or Quattrocento in Italy.
That battle was immortalized in three grand paintings by Paolo Uccello, a born and bred
Tuscan who trained and worked across various media, from mosaic to sculpture to metalwork to painting.
And there is a monumental sculpturality to these battle scenes, these frozen snapshots of chaotic
motion. This first panel brings us onto the battlefield at dawn as the fighting begins.
We see an equestrian charging at the enemy with a look of resolve. This is Niccolò da Tolentino,
our protagonist, a mercenary or condottiere, fighting for Florence. 15th century melee
fighting relied on hired mercenary soldiers, as Florence didn't have a standing army until
Machiavelli introduced one in 1506. In Niccolò's hand is the commander's baton, and crowning his
head is not a helmet, but an extravagant headdress called a mezzocchio. Uccello portrays him as
reckless but ambitious, destined for victory. So destined, in fact, he doesn't need protection.
The only two unprotected faces we see are in the foreground, Niccolò and his strangely calm
page boy behind him. The rest of the picture is a maze of diagonals composed of lances and swords
and trumpets. We see armor adorned with silver leaf now tarnished but once gleaming, rendered
with incredible precision. And the density of soldiers is so much higher on the left,
on the Florentine side, it appears as if the Sienese are completely outnumbered. The direction
of motion is strictly rightward, against the Sienese, and blood is nowhere to be seen.
My favorite details are on the ground. It's littered with broken lances arranged in this
uncanny perfect grid. Uccello here is experimenting with a system of representing spatial recession
called linear perspective. He's even attempted to portray this fallen soldier in perspective by
foreshortening, making his body recede in space. Except here, Uccello doesn't quite get it right,
and the soldier ends up looking somewhat distorted. The quest to convincingly
reconstruct 3D space would go on to define Florentine Renaissance art.
The contrast between foreground and background is stark. The distant pastoral landscape,
framed by oranges emblematic of the summer season, is completely removed from the mayhem of battle.
Uccello has a profound sensitivity to natural detail. In fact, Uccello is a nickname,
meaning bird, and honors his interest in portraying the natural world.
But the sense of perspectival space suddenly ends with the flowering hedge. It gives the battle an
almost hallucinatory quality. These warriors become a ghostly blur of metal and weaponry.
In the second panel, the action continues, and so does the conceit of spatial depth.
It's now afternoon, and Niccolò de Tolentino is finally helmeted. With his lance, he pushes the
Sienese commander off his horse. We can almost hear the frantic neighing, but again, this chaotic
motion is confined to the Sienese side. Their horses are either recoiling or fallen. The two
Florentine horses on our left are completely civil, echoing each other's poses, lending a
sense of order and organization. And in the third and final scene, it's now nighttime, after a full
day of fighting. We see a new figure, another Condottiere, who's arrived as backup for the
Florentine side, giving orders for a final, decisive counterattack that will take out the
Sienese, who in this scene are nowhere to be seen. This implied victory concludes Uccello's trilogy.
There's one issue. The assured Florentine victory Uccello shows us is not supported by other
sources. They report that in reality, Niccolò de Tolentino was overambitious and had to be saved
by his allies, barely achieving victory if at all. In fact, Siena also considered itself to have won
at San Romano, but Florentine patrons nonetheless jumped at the opportunity to celebrate their
supposed victory. Uccello's battle trilogy is then a commemoration of what was considered a
brilliant military success, a source of civic pride. Now, San Romano itself was but one clash
in a much bigger conflict. In the 15th century, the Italian peninsula comprised a number of
city-states. The Republic of Florence was constantly fighting over territory with neighboring
city-states, fighting for ownership of port cities like Genoa and Pisa that offered access to
Mediterranean commerce. Smaller city-states, trying to optimize their interests, were absorbed into
either side of this conflict. These included Siena, Florence's southern neighbor, which was
still trying to recover internal stability after being ravaged by the 14th century plague.
After years of being threatened by Florentine territorial expansion, Siena submitted itself
to Milan, which was viciously anti-Florence. The resulting tension boiled to a head at San Romano.
When Uccello began work on these panels in the 1430s, Florence itself was undergoing political
upheaval. Florence was a republican name, but true political power rested in the hands
of wealthy noble families who earned their fortunes in various trades before dabbling
in politics. At the dawn of the 15th century, the prominent Florentine family name was Albizzi.
But another family was on the rise, led by successful bankers who improved systems of
accounting, the Medici. As the Medici gained prominence and moved into government,
the Albizzi rightly perceived them as a threat, and in 1433, they exiled the heir of the Medici
banking dynasty, Cosimo. Unfortunately, this didn't sit well with Florentine citizens,
because the Medici bank was key to the city's economic stability. So by popular support,
Cosimo's exile was ended prematurely, and when he returns to Florence in 1434,
he turns the tables and exiles the Albizzi from the city, becoming the most powerful man in
Florence. A matter of months before the Albizzi fell from grace, they commissioned a curious work
in the Florence Cathedral, or Duomo. And today, it's so busy inside, it can be really easy to miss.
But it's done in fresco, so it's painted on wet plaster, and the paint's dried to become an
integral part of the wall. And it honors a famous dead condottiere, John Hawkwood,
whose coat of arms we can see on the pedestal. Hawkwood had once suppressed a major peasant
revolt that enabled the Albizzi to gain power, so it's reasonable for them to memorialize him,
even though Hawkwood had also actually fought against Florence several times. And after rising
to power, Cosimo de' Medici now faced a choice. He could keep this old Albizzi commission,
or he could scrap it. Well, he chose to keep it. Why? Well, let's consider the implications of
seeing this monument as a Florentine citizen in the Duomo. John Hawkwood was an English condottiere,
so in a way, he symbolizes Florence's ability to attract the best foreign mercenary talent
to fight in its favor. That's a proclamation of Florentine power, and it advertised Florence
to other condottieri, fight for us and we'll immortalize your legacy. This would have been
beneficial rhetoric regardless of who was in power. The artist Cosimo hired for the job was
none other than Paolo Uccello, probably for his experience with bronze sculpture. Indeed,
he paints this equestrian portrait in grisaille, or monochrome shades of gray, reminiscent of real
bronze. This monument heralds the fact that in Renaissance Florence, art was a propagandistic
weapon wielded by the powerful to assert their status and to foster civic pride. To understand
the development of Florentine culture within this political context, let's take a tour around the
city. The Hawkwood Monument is frescoed in the Duomo, which is formally named the Cathedral of
Santa Maria del Fiore, Saint Mary of the Flower. This cathedral is situated at the heart of the
city, and dominating the Florence skyline is its dome, a landmark of Renaissance architecture.
Construction on the Duomo itself started in the late 13th century, but the dome had been a
challenge nobody dared to conquer. It would be the largest ever constructed to date, spanning more
than 45 meters at its widest, and the true feat of engineering would be to construct a freestanding
dome, which has no structural support apart from the sides. So it wasn't until 1418 that a dome
design competition was announced. One architect, Brunelleschi, was in Rome at the time of the
announcement, studying ancient Roman architecture, and he hurried back to Florence, believing his
background in mathematics and his knowledge of classical design prepared him well to tackle this
challenge. So he sends in a proposal for a freestanding dome, and the key to his idea was
He had an inner skeleton layer with bricks and a crisscross herringbone pattern to direct weight
to the edges, to the support of the walls underneath. This inner core was many-sided,
however not round. On top, he put a wooden frame to support an exterior layer of brick, a shell
that made the dome appear smooth and round. This was Brunelleschi's original model, which he
intentionally left incomplete, lest others copy it. Well, the judges initially scoffed at
Brunelleschi's design, and the legend goes that Brunelleschi responded by challenging the judges
to make an egg stand upright. How would you approach this task? Well, the judges failed,
and Brunelleschi smugly smashed the egg in half, whereupon the upper half of the shell stood up
all by itself. His performance demonstrated the value of thinking outside the box,
and that however much of a fantasy his idea seemed, it was worth considering. His proposal
ultimately won. Construction on Brunelleschi's dome started two years thereafter, and took 16
years to complete, but it would be the crowning achievement of early Renaissance architecture,
symbolizing the new heights to which Florence had risen. Architects like other artists received
commissions not only from churches and private patrons, but also from merchant guilds. Certain
guilds held immense power in city government, and they also had philanthropic responsibilities.
The wealthy Silk Merchants Guild posed the following commission to Brunelleschi a year
after his dome proposal, to design a building in which orphaned children could receive care
and education, the Ospedale degli Innocenti, Hospital of the Innocents, only a few blocks
away from the dome. Brunelleschi's design proved, once again, groundbreaking. I mentioned he had
been studying Roman ruins. Indeed, the word Renaissance, French for rebirth, refers to this
very kind of renewed interest in Greco-Roman heritage, classical antiquity. And revolutionarily,
Brunelleschi applied geometric principles of classical architecture in his own practice,
a style called allantica, the manner of antiquity. It gave him an arsenal of circles,
squares, and perfect proportions, a geometry he molded into the early Renaissance aesthetic.
There's no better example than the loggia, or covered corridor, lining the exterior of
the Ospedale. We see Roman-style composite order columns, but also Romanesque-style rounded arches
drawn from medieval architecture. So Brunelleschi synthesizes the Roman and the Romanesque,
effectively reviving classical architecture. And he did this at a time when academics were
immensely interested in Roman culture, at a time when ancient Greek and Latin texts
were also being rediscovered and translated. Increasingly, 15th century scholars would
emphasize the classics, with the mentality that change and renewal was needed in European society.
From this philosophy, the notion of Renaissance humanism was born, a system of thought that
reconciled classical paganism with Christian faith, viewing humans as likenesses of God
who held immense individual potential. This humanist worldview would guide the cultural
blossoming of Renaissance Italy. But aside from mathematics and architecture,
Brunelleschi was also intensely interested in optics. He sought a method to project three-dimensional
imagery onto two-dimensional planes, something crucial in architectural design, but also in
By conducting experiments, he devised a mathematical basis for the perspective we
saw in Uccello's work. The principles are simple. In order to create the illusion of 3D space,
we need a horizon line, then a collection of diagonals in the foreground that all convert
to a single vanishing point on the horizon in the background. This system of geometric
constructions is called linear perspective, and it offered a new methodical approach to space.
To see linear perspective in action, let's visit the Basilica of Santa Maria Novella,
again not far from the Duomo. And as you walk into the nave of the church,
it's hard to miss the fresco on the left-hand wall, Masaccio's Holy Trinity.
Like Uccello, Masaccio developed an immediate interest in linear perspective, and his
compositions reflect an astute awareness of geometry and symmetry. The figures at the foot
of the cross are arranged in a pyramid, Mary and Saint John the Baptist, with two donors on the
step below, the patrons of the work. Note how the alternating red and blue of these four cloaked
figures provide balance and coloration across the vertical divide of the crucifix, which is
itself framed by two sets of classical columns. The ceiling is coffered, though square indentations
are another hallmark of Greco-Roman architecture. Indeed, the entire structure evokes a Roman arch.
Masaccio here pioneers the classical revival so central to the nascent Renaissance.
I can't help but be drawn to the nuanced modeling and anatomical accuracy of Christ's ribs.
The morbid realism is astounding. Christian theology holds that God coexists in three
separate forms, three persons in unity, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. We see in the
of Masaccio's composition the crucified Christ, the Son of God. Above him is a dove,
symbolizing the Holy Spirit, and still above is God the Father. The bottom of the fresco
cuts underground to a crypt holding a cadaver monument. Above the sarcophagus
is an ominous inscription, seemingly the skeleton's message to us.
I once was what you are, and what I am you also will be. It's a memento mori,
a reminder of the transience of life and the inevitability of death. Viewed in juxtaposition
with Christ's crucifixion and the Trinity above, the implication is clear. The only hope for
salvation after death lies in faith and in devotion to God. And while we're at Santa Maria
novella, I want to pay tribute to the architect of its facade, Leon Battista Alberti. A humanist,
intellectual, mathematician, cryptographer, a real polymath. His treatise De Pictura,
or On Painting, codified Brunelleschi's system of linear perspective and formally related it
to optical science. In it, he counsels artists to learn and perfect the skill of perspective,
and in this way it's a work of art theory, establishing perspective
and ideal proportion as a standard for evaluating artistic merit.
To see Masaccio going further and using space as a narrative device, we'll cross the river Arno to
the church of Santa Maria del Carmine. In the San Romano panels, we saw how Uccello foregrounds the
message. Here, Masaccio's task is similar, to convey a multi-part narrative in one continuous
fresco, this time the biblical story of the tribute money. Although the patrons,
the Brancacci family of silk merchants, would have understood the narrative,
remember that early Renaissance artists were responsible for making biblical episodes
comprehensible for illiterate audiences. They're trained to be master storytellers.
We see the central group of figures arranged in a semicircle, recalling the semicircular
apse of a church. This is Christ and his disciples. Indeed, Christ is the vanishing
point of the picture. All the diagonals converge on him, leading our eyes instinctively to him.
The man in orange, however, is removed from that sacred space. He is a tax collector,
demanding that they pay tribute. Christ responds to his demand by pointing toward the water
on our left. A disciple on his right echoes his pose. This is Saint Peter, whose life story is
shown in this chapel because Peter or Piero was the namesake of one of the Brancacci family members.
Their fingers advance the narrative by directing our eyes to the shore,
where Peter procures the money, the so-called tribute penny, by extracting it from the mouth
of a fish, as per Christ's instructions. Logically, it follows that the third and
rightmost scene must be the resolution, where Peter pays the tax official with the tribute penny.
So Masaccio, through this clever usage of space, directs us through a story that's non-linear and
yet visually clear. Unfortunately, he would die just three years after painting this, at 28 years
old. Let's return to the Duomo at the heart of Florence, where we'll look at another structure
in that piazza, too often overshadowed, quite literally, by the cathedral. It's an octagonal
building called the Florence Baptistry. The eight sides represent the sum of the seven days in a
week and the eighth day of resurrection. Now, this is a 12th century building, older than the Duomo
itself, and it's significant because it's home to the only baptismal font in Florence. The ritual
of baptism marks one's admission to the Christian church, and the appearance of this baptistry is
certainly commensurate with its religious significance. It's built in a medieval Romanesque
idiom. We see the iconic white Carrara marble, green serpentine stone, and rounded Romanesque
arches. But there's an even more remarkable element of this building, its doors. There are three sets,
each facing a cardinal direction, except for west, which is occupied by the apse.
Walking around the baptistry, we see the evolution of Florentine art from the 14th century, when the
first set of doors were made, to 1452, when the final set were commissioned. From the plain
backgrounds and distinctly medieval quatrefoil shapes, emerged a new spatial and narrative
clarity, literally thrown into relief, gold-studded and grounded in linear perspective.
The second and third sets of doors are the work of Ghiberti and his workshop, and there's an
intriguing bit of rivalry involved. Back in 1401, Ghiberti and Brunelleschi were competing for this
commission. Ghiberti won, and Brunelleschi, envious and disillusioned, left Florence for Rome, where he
began studying classical ruins. That's why he was in Rome when the dome competition was announced,
so that the development of linear perspective would have taken on a very different trajectory
if Brunelleschi had won and hadn't made his fateful journey. And it comes full circle with
Brunelleschi's perspective now animating Ghiberti's panels. These scenes derive from the Old Testament,
with narratives spanning the creation of the world to Christ's teachings. Ghiberti uses varying heights
of low relief to demonstrate spatial recession. Notice how elements in the panels project outward
to different degrees. Each panel is a window into a distinct and convincing pictorial space,
bringing this Romanesque baptistry into the Renaissance age. These doors took 27 years
to complete. Ghiberti retired soon after, and I love this quotation from his autobiography,
reflecting on these gates as the zenith of his career.
I strove to imitate nature as clearly as I could, and with all the perspective I could produce,
I carried out this work with the greatest diligence and the greatest love. It's the
manifesto of Renaissance artistry. Later, Michelangelo would be so impressed by Ghiberti's
golden doors, he deemed them the gates of paradise. A similar technique of conveying a sense of space
was developing simultaneously in sculpture, called sciacciato. In marble, it was pioneered
by Donatello, an associate of both Brunelleschi and Ghiberti, and honored as a ninja turtle.
What Brunelleschi was to architecture, and what Masaccio and Uccello were to painting,
Donatello was to sculpture. Both Ghiberti and his bronze panels, and Donatello and this marble
Madonna, managed to achieve spatial recession in low or bas relief, while giving volume to their
figures. Objects like this were commissioned as private devotional aids, and this one is
particularly tender. The face of the Christ child rests gently behind the nurturing virgin,
who leans forward in maternal affection. There's a bond between mother and son.
We can feel the texture of the Christ child's robes as the virgin holds him softly,
her foreshortened fingers pressing into the drapery. Lush hair is suggested by just a few
marks of the chisel. The ear is sculpted with a virtuosic sensitivity to anatomical structure.
This is an exquisite image of motherly love. Throughout his illustrious six-decade-long
career, Donatello worked in marble, bronze, wood, wax, clay, producing bas reliefs and
sculptures in the round, and monumental tombs and architectural ornamentation,
a versatile master of all three-dimensional media. This tour de force of Renaissance sculpture
stands out in Donatello's oeuvre for its emotional intensity and raw realism.
It's a freestanding section of wood made from a single trunk of poplar, and from it,
he brings to life Mary Magdalene, her hands suspended in prayer, not quite touching.
Long hair draping over her shoulders, mirroring the form of her tattered robes like cross-currents,
fixed, haunting gaze. Donatello has imbued this figure with a psychology so complex,
so raw, so realistically human, it's overwhelming, leaving us unsettled, haunted.
We see Mary Magdalene in her old age, which she spent alone in southern France,
repenting for her sins, as she had once been a prostitute before becoming a devoted disciple.
Donatello captures that introspective repentance. There's no idealization here,
we can feel her emotional weight, perhaps exhaustion, but not weakness, this is an image
of strength. Look at her muscular arms, look at her eyes, determined, unyielding.
Mary Magdalene was seen as the paragon of the repentant, a testament to the possibility of
salvation, through devotion, even after committing sin. This sculpture sent shockwaves across
contemporary Renaissance audiences, it still does in audiences today. The sheer visual and
psychological impact of the penitent Magdalene's raw emotion is timeless.
But Donatello had immense range. I'm showing you here a very different figure, a young boy,
standing in a dynamic contrapposto. Contrapposto, or counterpoise, is a balanced position where you
put your body weight on the engaged right leg, while the left leg is bent and relaxed.
We do it all the time. We see this pose often in ancient Roman statuary, and neuroimaging shows
that the brain is possibly naturally inclined to find contrapposto aesthetically pleasing.
Now this boy is nude, aside from broken trousers and a gilded belt. His hands raised high would
have once held some kind of attribute. Now that it's lost, there's no consensus on who he really
is. He might be Cupid, with a lost bow and arrow, because if we walk around the sculpture,
we can see Cupid's wings. This erotic association gives amore, or love, as the statue's name.
But his trousers belong to Attis, a Greek vegetation god. His winged sandals are those
of Mercury. This eclectic mix of iconography isn't consistent with any particular mythological
figure. It's a composite product of Donatello's own imagination, of his own study of classical
myth. That's what makes this youngster so compelling. He's a playful enigma,
made certainly for an erudite humanist patron learned in the classics.
To bring him to life in bronze, Donatello would have first sculpted him out of clay,
then made a three-dimensional hollow mold with all the statue's features finely imprinted onto
the interior. Then he would have poured hot bronze into the mold, an alloy of copper and tin,
before breaking the mold to reveal the statue inside.
But Donatello's most celebrated sculpture is his bronze David.
This is the first freestanding sculpture of a sexually mature male nude since ancient Roman
times, a reflection of Donatello's abiding interest in classical statuary. Now, male
Roman gods and athletes would also commonly be portrayed in the nude. This is a classical
convention called heroic nudity. For a young boy who's just single-handedly vanquished a six-foot
nine giant Goliath, David stands in a strikingly calm contrapposto. Indeed, he stands on Goliath's
decapitated head with a satisfied expression. The laurel wreath crowning his head symbolizes
military victory, but his expression doesn't convey the rigidity and intimidation of a triumphant
military leader. Instead, Donatello opts for a gentle, sensuous, subtly erotic approach to
depicting David. Some interpret this effeminate approach as being reflective of Donatello's
homosexuality. This David once stood in the courtyard of the Palazzo Medici in Florence.
There, the image of David's victory over Goliath would have served a powerful political function.
Florence identified closely with David. His triumph mirrored the Florentine victory over
Milan as part of the wars in Lombardy. Indeed, a politically charged inscription
once accompanied David. The victor is whoever defends the fatherland.
God crushes the wrath of an enormous foe. Behold, a boy overcame a great tyrant. Conquer,
oh citizens! Let's take this opportunity to look around the Medici Palace.
Cosimo de' Medici is not a ruler by law. He ruled in practice, de facto. Florence was supposed to
be a republic. But in fact, Cosimo used his wealth to manipulate election outcomes in favor
of his own supporters. Medici associates dominated the Florentine government as puppets when Cosimo
was pulling all the strings from backstage. But Cosimo's faithful followers included more than
just politicians. They included artists too, attracted by his social and financial standing.
And remember that artists are inherently competing with each other for commissions.
So being close with wealthy patrons got them work and money.
Michelozzo, an architect, cleverly fostered a close relationship with Cosimo very early on.
They had traveled together to Venice during Cosimo's exile, and upon their return,
Michelozzo was tapped to design the Medici Palazzo. Now, looking at this facade, it's hard
to tell that this residence belonged to the most powerful man in Florence because Cosimo
maintained a pretense of modesty. Nevertheless, the facade is strategically designed so that when
viewed at street level, it seems taller than it really is. As your eye travels up the building,
there's a transformation from the jagged stone walls at ground level to the smooth masonry at
top. This flat stonework lightens the top of the structure, triggering an illusion
that amplifies the palazzo's height. So the exterior is really remarkably modest.
The interior, however, is a different world. A world of grand ostentation and boundless luxury.
It's a dazzling suite of classicizing interiors, and the most magnificent room
might be the Medici's private chapel. Inside, on three walls, are narrative frescoes of pomp
figures, equestrians in extravagant garb, laypeople, kings and courtiers from abroad,
even contemporary Florentines. This is the entourage of the three magi, the three kings,
who are following the North Star to the stable at Bethlehem, where the Christ Child had just
been born. Notice the diversity of personages here, red-capped Florentines but also Ottomans
and a black man holding a bow, reflecting the extent of multiculturalism in Renaissance Europe,
and we'll discuss this topic in detail in episode 4. The naturalism of these trees,
mountains, and numerous animals, and the rich costume of the procession, calls to mind an
adoration of the magi by Gentile da Fabriano from four decades earlier in the altarpiece,
whose decorative transitional style between late Gothic and early Renaissance deeply affected
Quattrocento painters. That certainly includes Benozzo Gozzoli, who painted the monumental
frescoes in the Magi Chapel, but unlike in Gentile's altarpiece, we actually don't see
the magi arriving at Bethlehem adoring the Christ Child at all. Rather, we see them en route,
which is unusual. Each wall spotlights the journey of one particular magus. I'm showing
here the most celebrated scene featuring the magus Caspar. But keep in mind the intended function
of this space. Medici family members would have been praying at the altar beneath these frescoes,
where there was once an altarpiece showing the Virgin and Child. In this setting,
the Medici themselves would become the magi, bringing the narrative to life from painted
procession to physical prayer. The Medici identified with the magi at once luxurious royalty
and devout men of faith. Indeed, we see family members featured as members of the Grand
Procession. The 1450s and 60s were a time of dynastic change in Florence. Cosimo would die,
his son Piero would rule for five years, and then Piero's son Lorenzo would rise to power.
Benozzo's frescoes immortalize their legacies in paint.
We also see Benozzo Gozzoli himself. And we know it's him because he's written Opus Benotti,
work of Benozzo, on his hat. He's proclaiming his close association with the Medici for the
sake of his own reputation and legacy. Now, large fresco cycles like this weren't
one-man jobs. They were team projects involving specialized artists hired ad hoc,
painters of animals, plants, landscapes. They would have all contributed, but Benozzo,
a supervising painter and head of the workshop, got all the credit. So we've now witnessed the
development of classical revival and linear perspective alongside Medici patronage,
but these weren't limited to the forms of buildings or the content of paintings.
They influenced the very shape and form of paintings, too. Prior to the mid-15th century,
Italian altarpieces generally looked like this. Ornate groups of panels, collectively called a
polyptych, a gothic format with gold ground and often inseparable frames. But Brunelleschi
declared polyptychs obsolete. Instead, he promoted the pala, a rectangular style of altarpiece
fit for classical style frames, and starting mid-century, altarpieces increasingly adhered
to the pala form. Domenico Veneziano's altarpiece for the Church of Santa Lucia de Emanuele is among
the first. The single central panel shows the Virgin and Child flanked by full-length saints,
a type of subject known as a sacra conversazione, sacred conversation. Below it, there's a predella,
or base, with smaller scenes, each featuring an episode from the life of the saint directly above
it. In a sacra conversazione like this, the patron would choose which saints they would like included,
so each of the four are featured here for a reason. And every saint has attributes
derived from their life experiences that allow us to identify them. Starting with the leftmost saint,
we see a ring of hair called a tonsure, indicating that he's a monk. This is Saint Francis of Assisi,
a former resident of the church for which this was painted. Beside him stands an unkempt saint
who wears a cloth of camel skin with a slender long cross. This is John the Baptist, a patron
saint or protective saint of the city of Florence. On the other side is another Florentine patron
saint, Zenobius, in his bishop's robes. And then we have Saint Lucy, Santa Lucia, the namesake of
the church. Her palm branch symbolizes spiritual victory and, by extension, her torture and
martyrdom during the Roman persecution of Christians. So each saint serves a symbolic
function, and here they collectively represent the church of Santa Lucia, emphasizing its Florentine
identity. We also see linear perspective applied here on the steps of Mary's throne, and this
iconic green, black, white, and pink architectural setting evokes the polychrome facade of the
baptistry. It's a uniquely Florentine palette. So we've now visited several Florentine churches,
the baptistry, and the Medici palace, but I want to highlight an often overlooked aspect
of Renaissance Florence, its monastic communities and mendicant orders, the friars, monks, and nuns
who dedicated their lives to faithful devotion. Monks and nuns lived in cloistered monasteries
and convents, isolated from city life. Friars, on the other hand, led similar frugal lifestyles,
but actively preached in urban cities. One particular Dominican friar also worked as a
painter, Fra or Brother Angelico. It's a nickname that honors the angelic beauty of his work.
This picture is attributed to the earliest years of his career. It's called a Thebaid. The term
comes from Thebes, an Egyptian city where early Christians retreated to practice simple lives of
desert asceticism, rejecting worldly pleasure to live in solitude as hermit monks. Among their
ranks were Saints Jerome and Francis. They became the sort of model for monastic life.
Fra Angelico portrays their stories here in this panoramic landscape full of jagged,
stylized mountains, seeking to evoke the wilderness of the Egyptian desert. But having
never traveled to Thebes himself, Fra Angelico took inspiration from his native Tustin countryside
instead. The buildings here are clearly out of proportion with the figures, but it's the
spiritual message that matters here. These devoted monks are renouncing material wealth
to commune with nature and with God. There's Saint Francis in prayer on the peak of a mountain,
experiencing a divine vision and receiving the stigmata, the wounds of Christ. There are monks
fetching water, reading, traveling through the wilderness in a symbolic pursuit of redemption
and enlightenment. I love the details Fra Angelico includes of monks interacting with nature and
with exotic animals and some fantastical ones. Here, a man is introduced to a beast that's
probably supposed to be a Nile crocodile. Another is fishing in this river that flows into a harbor.
One sits reading in a chariot drawn by lions. In fact, I encourage you to pull up this painting
in Wikimedia and just see how many different animal species you can spot.
Here's another delightful bit. What's happening? An unhappy elder being carried on a stretcher
and he's glaring at the sorry-looking monk while the monk in the back throws him an angry look.
The Thebaid is not a continuous narrative, but rather a collection of snapshots of monastic life.
Fra Angelico himself belonged to a community of Dominican friars that lived at San Marco,
a monastery just two blocks away from the Duomo. In the 1440s, the old structure was redesigned
and renovated under the supervision of Micheluzzo and the sponsorship of Cosimo de' Medici,
who actually owned a private prayer cell within it. So the interior, the corridors, and monastic
cells as intimate spaces for contemplative devotion were to be redecorated with new frescoes.
And who was more appropriate for the job than Fra Angelico himself? The product was truly angelic.
This annunciation greets us in the dormitory of San Marco on the way to the monastic chambers.
It captures the moment when the archangel Gabriel announces to the virgin that she'll bear Jesus
Christ, the Son of God. These modest muted tones, gentle and serene, are most conducive to tranquil
devotion. What's innovative about this composition is its outdoor setting in a loggia,
and a fenced garden alluding to Mary's virginity and the nature of the Immaculate Conception.
Imagine you're being confronted with it upon ascending the stairway leading to the monastic
prayer cells. There's just barely light in the monastery. This is an encounter with the divine.
Equally magical are the biblical scenes adorning the prayer cells,
smaller in scale but delicate, graceful, and moving. Fra Angelico imbues these frescoes
with spiritual power, channeling his own faith and piety to inspire it in others.
The final stop on our tour of Renaissance Florence is another monastic site just across
from San Marco, the convent of Santa Polonia, once home to a community of Benedictine nuns.
The Last Supper is a scene I think we know well from Leonardo da Vinci's mural,
but this fresco was done by Andrea del Castagno five decades earlier. It decorates the dining
room or refectory of Santa Polonia, and that makes sense given the refectory's function
as a space for supper, but consider too the role of women in Renaissance Florence.
Their locus of concern was restricted by patriarchal Florence to the domestic sphere.
Food preparation was naturally a key part of their socially assigned duty, and it was linked
religiously to the Eucharist, the consecration and consumption of bread and wine, and the
particular prevalence of Last Supper scenes in 15th century nunneries points us to deeper layers
of meaning that this fresco would have held to its uniquely female audience. This work,
although really much overlooked, constitutes a kind of summation of the innovations in Florentine
art from the first half of the Quattrocento. The classical columns framing the picture,
the intense interest in experimenting with geometric patterning, the accurate foreshortening
and spatial recession of the tiles on the roof, the figural realism, the perspectively convincing
three-dimensional space housing Christ and his disciples. Judas, who went on to betray Christ,
sits alone on our side. Notice too these peculiar marble tiles lining the back wall, an homage
to Roman wall painting and an innovative example of the trompe-l'oeil conceit, the technique of
tricking the eye into thinking it's real stone. They help to balance the composition's colors
while orienting us toward Christ and Judas, the focal figures in the story, and they possess
a certain mesmerizing quality so important for facilitating a spiritual experience.
So function and audience, as we've seen, inform iconography. From frescoes made for monastic
contemplation to propagandistic sculpture made for the Medici courtyard. And overarching this
new blossoming of the arts was a methodical system of depicting 3D space, linear perspective,
formulated by Bernoullesti and codified by Alberti, alongside the spirit of classical revival,
ushering in an age of Atlantica, geometric perfection, and unprecedented realism. Together,
these patterns define Florence's artistic renaissance. Next time, we'll travel across
the Alps to visit the Burgundian court in Bruges and Brussels in modern Belgium. We'll compare
stylistic developments between northern and southern Europe by following key developments
in early Netherlandish painting, including the advent of oil paint. I hope to see you then,
and thank you for watching A Narrative Art History of the Renaissance.
