“Project 2025” would be a health disaster. Here are 5 reasons why
1 Video View·Sep 17, 2024
Project 2025, more like Project 1905.
Hey, friends, Dr.
Abdul El-Sayed here.
Before I go on, make sure to like and subscribe.
Tell your friends, because we're trying to have some important
conversations here about, say, I don't know, the fall of democracy
and why it is that we really, really need to protect it.
Now, here's the thing.
If you haven't heard about Project 2025, I don't even know where you've been.
This is the Heritage Foundation, a super conservative think tank.
It's their plan to try and fundamentally remake American government.
What their proponents are calling it is the idea of a silent
new American revolution.
Yeah, that's the language they're using.
They're saying it's going to be a bloodless revolution.
Now, I don't know about you, but I kind of think that,
I don't know, a bloodless revolution led by people
who fundamentally don't believe in democracy a la January 6th
is not really what I signed up for.
And in 2024, I think all of us need to do all we can to protect ourselves.
Now, in this video, I wanted to talk about five reasons
why Project 2025 really would take us back to 1905
when it comes to health and health care in this country.
Now, here's the thing about it.
The idea really starts with a remaking of the nature
of the federal government system.
Now, this is going to sound super arcane, but I do need you to follow along with me
because it'll help you to understand exactly why I call this going back to 1905.
One of the biggest fights in American politics in 1905
was about civil service reform.
Now, that may sound esoteric, but let me explain what that means.
In American government, you elect a new president
and that new president gets to appoint leaders of federal agencies.
Those leaders then appoint a couple of people below them
and they lead those agencies.
But the civil service, they're the folks who work inside those federal agencies.
They're the experts on you name the thing, whether it's NOAA
and expertise on the nature of our climate,
or it's the FDA and expertise on epidemiology and clinical study design.
Now, all of this, all of it requires protection for these people
because they're supposed to be able to have independent expertise
that informs the way our government ought to work.
Just because Republicans or Democrats get elected
doesn't change the nature of climate science or epidemiology.
However, what Project 2025 wants to do at its base
is fundamentally eliminate the civil service as we know it.
It would usher in huge swaths of new appointees who are, well,
functionary lackeys of the president and the party
rather than competent experts in their space.
Now, you can imagine how that's essentially a small government idea.
If you replace expert civil servants with a bunch of political lackeys,
those agencies will fundamentally cease to function in the same way.
And that's a really dangerous thing for all of us, because, well,
like we talked about in previous videos when we were talking about,
for example, the elimination of Chevron doctrine,
those people are responsible for promulgating everything
from regulations to rules to fundamental guidelines
that keep us safe in ways that we can't even imagine.
I personally think it's a great thing that epidemiologists are involved in,
I don't know, assessing the value of studies when they're approving
drugs that people are going to take in their bodies.
I also think it's great that I can rely on NOAA to tell me
what's happening in the weather.
And the idea of replacing those people with folks whose main credibility
is that, I don't know, they are part of the party of the president.
That to me is a bit dangerous.
I like the idea that there are appointees and then there's a civil service.
And the thing about it is that this does really take us back to 1905
when there were huge pushes for civil service reform,
making sure that rather than appointing lackeys to the president in their party,
we were appointing competent civil servants who could pass a test
and had expertise in the area of the government they were supposed to run
because, well, government should be there to serve all of us,
not just people of a particular party or ideological persuasion.
So that's the main gist of Project 2025.
But if you just Google Project 2025 and look at what they want to do
with each of the federal agencies, you're going to learn a lot.
I want to talk a bit more about what this would mean for health
after this message from our sponsors, the Marguerite Casey Foundation.
Let's be honest.
While some folks worry about the threat of fascism in the United States,
many are already living it.
Across the country, organizers are being labeled terrorists
for fighting for the sanctity of life in Palestine,
the health of our planet at Standing Rock and fighting against expansion
of the prison industrial complex at Cop City.
The stakes could not be higher.
And those who care about freedom, especially funders,
need to understand the history of how we got here and the role we can play
in helping fuel multiracial coalitions that can fight the forces of fascism.
Be part of the solution.
Register now to join Marguerite Casey Foundation Summer School,
building a people and planet centered future.
Together, summer school participants will hear from visionary organizers,
activist scholars and experts and get political education
that has the power to spark the solidarity essential for creating a future
focus on the well-being of people and the planet.
Sign up today to join Marguerite Casey Foundation
Summer School at Caseygrants.org slash summer school.
That's C-A-S-E-Y-G-R-A-N-T-S dot org slash summer school.
All right. So terrible idea.
Number one is to place a cap on Medicaid services.
In case you don't know what Medicaid is, consider yourself lucky.
Medicaid is the federal government funded state government operated
health insurance program for low income people.
That's as opposed to Medicare, which is the federal government run,
federal government funded program for seniors and people with certain
disabilities. One way to remember that is we care for our elders and we aid our
poor. Okay.
So Medicaid is a program that largely serves low income people across this
country.
And well what Project 2025 would do with Medicaid is it would cap a lifetime
benefit. Meaning once you've had Medicaid for a certain amount of time,
you're off Medicaid. That's it. You don't get it back.
Regardless of what happens with your income,
regardless of whether or not you can actually afford health insurance on the
market. Nope, you're done. You're gone. No health care for you.
Now this is in keeping unfortunately with what conservatives have made of the
ACA, the Affordable Care Act, of course, otherwise known as Obamacare.
One of the things about Obamacare is it expanded Medicaid,
but it required states to have to choose to expand too.
They put a little bit of money and they get a huge amount of federal money back
in terms of the ability to provide healthcare for folks who meet a certain
eligibility criteria and expanding Medicaid means that you increase the roof on
who got access to Medicaid. So who gets hurt the most? I don't know.
Low-income people in a, I don't know, predominantly Republican States.
It makes no sense. Literally taking healthcare away from their own voters.
I can't explain it,
but the worst part about this is that those people go without healthcare and
that would be a travesty because we know having access to healthcare saves lives.
That's why you go and see a doctor. Number two,
it would split the CDC into two agencies.
Now the best analogy for this I have is cutting the corpus callosum.
Now the corpus callosum is what connects the two sides of your brains together.
When you cut it,
there's some really weird interesting psychological findings because the two
sides of the brain can't communicate.
Now what project 2025 proposes to do to the CDC is to clip its corpus callosum
to turn it into two different agencies.
One is the country's chief epidemiology agency,
publishing health statistics and data.
The other is a public health agency offering guidance, nothing more,
just guidance to the American public about how to keep them safe. Now,
don't you think it would be kind of important to, uh,
use health statistics to, I don't know, educate public health guidance. Don't,
don't you think those two things go together?
Apparently not according to the geniuses who wrote the project 2025 manifesto.
What this would mean is that we would be flying blind,
basically public health officials making guidance, nothing more,
according to project 2025,
devoid of the same agency being able to actually take those statistics, uh,
and use it to make those guys.
So it doesn't really quite make sense and I don't really understand why except
for the people that wrote this report have beef with the entire public health
institution because of a made up spot with folks like Anthony Fauci.
They literally call him out in the project 2025 manifesto.
You got to see it to believe it. Number three,
they advocate openly discriminating against all sorts of Americans when it comes
to healthcare, particularly LGBTQ folks.
And one of their main goals is to use the health agencies of this country to
push and drive a certain kind of lifestyle.
Now given that this is a conservative document and you can imagine who they
include, but one of the most important things that was done under president
Obama done again under president Biden,
because Trump reversed it was to protect healthcare for LGBTQ individuals.
This would do away with that protection. Now, I don't know about you,
I want to live in an America where no matter who you are,
you get access to the healthcare you need when you need it and that you're not
going to be discriminated, denied healthcare because of who you are. And this,
well, this would openly outwardly do away with that. Number four,
and this one's a doozy.
They want to eliminate abortion medications.
They want to reverse the FDA's ruling that uses science to demonstrate
that Mifepristone is both safe and effective. They want to reverse that. Now,
if you don't believe me about the importance of the civil service,
this is one of those places.
Scientists made those decisions by looking at data and interpreting it. Instead,
they want to use their ideology to deny people medication that they can use to
end an unwanted pregnancy. Now, the irony, you can't even make this up,
is that one of their key goals of project 2025 is to protect bodily sanctity.
Now who's, I don't know,
but certainly not women and people who can get pregnant. I'll tell you that much.
And here's the thing.
Whereas these terrible abortion bans that we've seen crop up in too many States
since the fall of Roe v. Wade only affect folks in those States in effect,
banning abortion medication would affect everybody.
And the majority of abortions are medication abortions. And then number five,
and this one hits me really hard in the gut is that they want to eliminate the
pathway to state-based single payer health care.
Now when I ran for governor of Michigan in 2018,
I ran on single payer health care.
I literally wrote the book on Medicare for all.
And one way by which you would pursue state level single payer health care is to
use what's called a Medicaid waiver.
You can ask the federal government to take the Medicaid dollars that they give
you and deliver it to you in different ways.
And you could leverage this to be able to create on top of it,
a single payer Medicare for all style system across States.
A number of States have considered this. Some have come close,
New York and California in particular, and Oregon's also thought about it.
And what they want to do is eliminate the state-based waivers.
And if you did that,
that would mean is that you would be ending a pathway to Medicare for all at the
state level.
Here's the irony of that is that conservatives used to be the state's rights
people. Remember they,
they claimed that the whole war that they fought over racism and slavery was
about state's rights. Yeah.
Except for when it comes to a state giving all its people health care,
how do you explain it? You can't, but there is one hilarious irony in all of this.
You know, the ACA, Obamacare, the affordable care act,
you know where that originated? It originated as a conservative idea hatched where
the heritage foundation. So there's that.

