Lecture 39

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 14, 2024
Welcome to the last lecture of this week where we are discussing the material testing.
We have discussed about tensile test, compression test, bending test
and impact test in the last lectures. I will focus on testing for hardness
in this lecture and I will also talk about testing for fracture.
In the course basics of mechanical engineering one, we are discussing the solid mechanics,
we are discussing the theory of machines where linkage mechanisms and other things
have also been discussed by Professor Ram Kumar. So, this would be the last part that we will
discuss in the mechanics, we were discussing the testing. Further, I will take you to the
theory of machines part in the coming lectures in the next week.
Now, when we talk about hardness, what is hardness testing? First, let us see what is hardness.
Hardness is the resistance of a body to indentation by another harder body. Only harder body can
indent into a softer body. For instance, you use knife to cut cheese, cheese is softer,
knife is harder. You use a saw made of mild steel or saw blades to cut the wood, wood is softer
and you use the saw blades made up of high speed steel to cut mild steel, high speed steel is
harder. So, it is always the harder material that indents into the softer material. In other words,
hardness is the mechanical resistance of a material specimen to mechanical indentation
by another harder body that is indenter. So, specimen is one term, indenter is another term,
indenter is harder body, specimen is a softer body. The hardest natural material is diamond
which is used for indenter that is for industrial applications as well, industrial diamond is there
which is used for indentation and diamond is not very commonly used for indentation.
I will show you the indenter materials in this lecture and also we will see where diamond is
used generally. So, hardness and strength are two different entities, hardness, strength.
Hardness definition differs from definition of strength which is resistance of material
to deformation and separation. This is resistance to deformation and hardness is
resistance to indentation. Hardness testing is one of the most widely used methods in
mechanical material testing especially for metals. This method can be used to find
qualitative relations to other material properties for example, strength,
stiffness, density or to the material behavior under certain stresses for example, abrasion
resistance even. Hardness testing is a comparatively easy and fast method to perform.
It causes relatively little destruction because it is only indentation, we are not doing any
destructive testing. It is only indentation and the specimen can be used time and again to check
for the indentation for the hardness at the different intervals whenever the requirements
are there. Only minor superficial damage remains on the specimen's surface because it is only
indentation that is also of the order of a few millimeters. It provides a quality control option
that is incoming and outgoing goods inspection like hardness is used for the incoming and outgoing
goods inspection whether the material is having adequate hardness to be used as a raw material
or whether as a finished good is it hard enough to go to the use in realistic environments.
So incoming and outgoing inspection hardness is used because this is not a destructive testing,
we do not break the material. Here a wide range of specimen geometries can also be tested using
hardness testing method. A wide range of specimen geometries are used or can be used.
What is the objectives of hardness testing? Hardness testing is an essential aid in the
differentiation of materials as well as for the analysis, development and improvement of materials
and technologies within the framework of fundamental research that is material science,
materials engineering, material diagnostics. It is used to determine characteristics values
that is hardness values which are critical for use of the material in industrial applications
that is suitability of material for a technically relevant component. Their acceptance in control
processes within the scope of the quality assurance that is again incoming and outgoing
goods inspection as I mentioned. So there could be differentiation of materials that is mix up
of materials for the clarification of damage situations that is damage analysis. So I would
put it here mix up of materials could be one area or for the damage analysis in the case of the
damage situations. Methods with static force application are predominant for hardness test
on metals. Measurements are either taken on the indentation depth or indentation size left behind
by the indenter. For static methods in hardness testing a differentiation is made between depth
measurement methods and optical measurement methods. These are two methods depth measurement
method and optical measurement method. Hardness measurement, hardness test is
measured by following ways depth measurement method optical measurement method. Depth
measurement methods measure the residual indentation depth of the indenter. The
Rockwell method is the only standardized depth measurement method, which is built against
the standards ISO 6508 and ASTM E18.
Besides these, there are non-standardized depth measurement methods such as Brillouin
and Vickers for the depth.
Optical measurement methods are there.
Optical measurement methods measure the residual indentation size of the indenter.
Standardized optical hardness testing methods include Brillouin hardness test, which is
ISO 6506 and ASTM E10.
Knoop hardness test, which is ISO 4545, ASTM E92, ASTM E384.
And Vickers hardness test, ISO 6507, ASTM E92, ASTM E384.
Methods with dynamic force application can also be used within the scope of hardness
test.
These include, for example, the Lieb rebound hardness test method.
Lieb hardness test is against ISO 16589 and ASTM A965, which measures the rebound height
of a ball indenter.
This is a typical hardness testing system or equipment, where we have a complete system
that has a frame here.
We have hand wheel and we have a platen or we call it anvil, where the specimen is kept,
the specimen here.
An indenter is there that indents inside the body.
Then elevating screw, to elevate the anvil up, hand wheel is to rotate and to elevate
using the elevating screw.
We have a microscope that measures the indentation diameter.
That is measured by indentation.
I will show you a video.
Lever is to apply the load.
There are hangers with load.
We can change the load physically here.
These are loads here.
Now, I will just show you the standards for hardness measurement.
There are, for instance, for sure it is ISO 76191, ASTM D240, for ball indentation hardness
it is ISO 20391, Rock Valley's ISO 20392, ASTM D785, instrumented hardness testing is
against the standard ISO 19278, their test methods, different test methods and ISO standards
against them.
For Brinell, it is ISO 6506, ASTM E10.
I have already mentioned these tests, these ISO standards in the previous slides.
You can go through them.
Next is hardness measurement procedure.
First step is to press a specifically dimensioned and loaded object, that is indenter, into
the surface of the material you are testing.
Then we measure the depth of the indenter penetration or size of the impression left
by the indenter to determine the hardness.
This is measured using microscope.
Then we apply the force in consistent manner without shock and measure the hardness, that
is depth of indentation.
Then we apply force for the required time, if a timed hardness is desired.
We ensure that the material under the test is minimum of 6 millimetres, that is 0.25
inches thick.
I will go through the videos for Brinell hardness and Rockwell hardness and I will also walk
you through the virtual laboratory simulation for them.
Let us watch the video for Brinell hardness, that is also developed by Centre of System
Design, NADK, Suratkal, under the virtual laboratory project.
This is optical Brinell hardness tester.
This is the experimental setup for Brinell hardness testing.
The objective is to determine the indentation hardness of mild steel or whether we could
use mild steel, cast iron, brass, any of the material that we wish to test.
The indenter diameter is 10 millimetres.
We select the load P for the testing.
So here P is 1000 kg.
So we turn the handwheel below, we put the specimen up and turn the handwheel below.
The motor is switched on so that the load is applied.
The hand lever when it goes to the load position, the load is getting applied for 10 to 15 seconds
the load is applied and then we pull the hand lever to the read position and through microscope
we understand the reading or note the reading.
Then we unload it and try to put the readings in the observation and try to calculate the
HPW, that is Brinell hardness number.
So Brinell hardness number is HPW, that is H is for hardness, B is for Brinell and W
is for tungsten material.
Tungsten is the material of the indenter.
So let me go through the virtual setup or the virtual laboratory experiment now.
So this is the aim of the experiment in virtual laboratory for Brinell hardness test that
is to determine the indentation hardness of mild steel specimen, cast iron specimen, brass
specimen, aluminium specimen.
Theory part is also given here where the machine which I showed you is here and we also watch
the video that how does the indentation go and what are the steps here.
The indenter diameter here is 10 mm when we talk about the Brinell hardness and HPW number
that is hardness Brinell tungsten HPW number, this is just a number that is dimensionless
number.
This is a relationship for this that is 2P by pi D into D minus square root of the difference
of the diameters that is capital D square minus small d square, where P is load in kg,
HPW is Brinell hardness number which is in kg per millimetre square, capital D is diameter
of the ball, small d is diameter of the indentation.
So these relationships are there, so you can all read about them.
I will just go through the procedure, we will go step by step.
Let me first go through the self-evaluation questions that is the pre-test evaluation.
The first question here is the ability of the material to resist stress without failure
is called, when we are talking about resisting stress without failure it is strength.
Second question, during hardness test the indenter is usually a ball indenter, pyramid
indenter, cone indenter, all of these, all of these shapes are there when we talk about
the indenter shape.
In Brinell hardness test the diameter of the ball used to test copper specimen is, there
are different diameters for different specimens depending upon the known hardness or known
hardness range of the material, the diameter is different.
For copper this diameter is 5 millimetre.
Property of hardness of material is resistance to, as we have discussed already, it is resistance
to indentation and indentation, we talk about the indentation in the Pyrenex inspection,
scratching is also there, wear is also there, so all of the above are the answers.
So property of hardness of material is resistance to scratching, wear, indentation, all of the
three.
The ratio of test load to surface area of indentation in this test is, this ratio is
directly the Brinell hardness number.
The value of distance between successive indentation is always lesser than distance of centre of
indentation from edge of specimen, this we have to determine whether true or false, the
value of distance between successive indentation is always lesser than the distance of centre
of indentation from, no, this is not correct, this is false.
Diameter of impression is found by the microscopic observation that is there, mounted in the
testing machine itself.
Select the correct statement from the following, a brittle material has no plastic zone, a
ductile material has large plastic zone, both of them are correct, a rigid material has
no plastic zone, all of these are correct.
This was my pre-test assignment, I got 8 out of 8, so this is correct.
Let us now go through the simulation, here the objective is to determine the indentation
hardness of mild steel, cast iron, brass, aluminium etc. using Brinell hardness testing
machine.
Operators use this Brinell hardness testing machine, the first step is, diameter of the
indenter is 10 millimetre, we select load P based upon the type of the material selected
that is mild steel, cast iron, brass, aluminium etc., so we select brass from here, once brass
is selected, then we have now gotten the P by D square ratios here, where P is load
in kilograms, D is diameter of the indenter, so P by D square is equal to 30, that is load
is 3000 kg, P by D square is equal to 10, that is load is 1000 kg, P by D square is
equal to 5, that is load is 500 kg, each weight equivalent to 250 kg supporting hanging rod
and base plate is 250 kg, so this is each weight here is corresponding to 250 kgs, so
what we use the load value here is 1000 kg and selected material is brass.
Step 2, the specimen is placed on the supporting table, then the hand wheel below the table
is turned in clockwise direction until the gap between the surface of the specimen and
indenter is 5 millimetre, so I will just click here, so that this is rotated and this
there is a gap between the indenter and the specimen, it is not contacted.
Next step, we switch on the machine and then load and unload positions are there of the
lever, I will turn the lever to the load position and then for 10 to 15 seconds this load is
supplied, I can stop at any point, it is time going on, so maybe just at around 30
seconds I stop, so this is trial 1, I go forward to the step 4, when hand lever is pulled back
to unload position and diameter of impression is measured through a microscope that is attached
to the apparatus.
I will just click on the microscope screw here and note the reading, the measured diameter
of indentation is 3.48, this was trial 1, for trial 1 the diameter of indenter is 10
millimetre, load is 1000, P by D square is 10, diameter of indentation is 3.48 and 3.48
average is 3.48, D by D that is the diameter of indentation by the diameter of the ball
that is the indenter is 0.348, from this I calculate the Brinell-Hurwitz number that
is HPW, that is calculated using the formula which I just mentioned and the average diameter
is calculated by D Ix plus D Iy by 2, so we calculate the hardness number that is 101.9,
this was trial 1, then we go for trial 2 where again we rotate the wheel, bring it close
to the indenter, so that the distance between the indenter and the specimen is 5 millimetres,
we go to the next step, we switch on the machine, we load the machine by turning the lever,
then after around 15 seconds I stop, then go to the next step to measure the diameter,
diameter is 3.46, this is diameter of the indentation on the brass workpiece.
Then I again measure my hardness that is 103.12, so 2 trials were taken for the diameter of
indenter 10 and the load of 1000 kg, these 2 hardness numbers that is Brinell-Hurwitz numbers
are averaged out to 102.51, so this was Brinell-Hurwitz test. Now let us watch a video for
Rockwell-Hurwitz test as well, Rockwell-Hurwitz test is little different from Brinell, it is a
calculation, direct number that comes, it is on 2 scales C and B, let us see that.
So, this is Rockwell-Hurwitz tester, so this is experimental setup, objective is to find the
Rockwell-Hurwitz test of hardness number for mild steel, cast iron, brass, aluminium,
spring steel etc., we select the specimen of our choice, we pick the brass as the specimen,
so indenter is ball indenter, we fix the indenter into the position,
we lock the indenter here, once a specimen is selected, we place the specimen on the
anvil and we rotate the wheel so that specimen is in contact with indenter here,
so then this smaller dial gauge pointer should reach to 10 kg of the load.
So, based upon the material used, we select the major load, so there are 2 loads here,
minor and major, so then we put the lever to the lower position, so 10 to 15 seconds is load is
there, now reading is noted down here, so here the reading is for C scale because brass is the
specimen, so here Rockwell hardness number is 91, then we unload the specimen, then we take
off the specimen, we can put the other specimen there and try to again take reading for different
specimen, we can take readings and Rockwell hardness number is a direct number, we do not
have any calculations, it will just give you direct number based upon the scale that you have
selected, B and C scales are there for the harder and softer materials. So, let me go through the
virtual laboratory setup for this, this is the virtual setup for Rockwell hardness test,
the objective is to find the Rockwell hardness number of mild steel, cast iron, brass, aluminium
and spring steel etc., just to cast a glance over the theory, this is the machine setup that is
there, we have a dial indicator here, we have load device, we have indenter, anvil, elevating screw,
hand wheel, most of the systems are just like what was there in Brillouin hardness number,
but only separate thing that we have is the loads here are there, the part of the machine itself,
there is a screw where you can select the load depending upon the material and also it is a dial
indicator that gives you the number directly. Another difference is we apply load in two steps
that is one is the initial load of 10 kg, then the final load, final load we can select for the
specific material, initial load is always 10 kg, so that the surface whatever the impurities if
those are there, those are taken care of. Now, hardness test can be conducted using
different indenter dimensions that is cone, degree, 120, ball for 1.58 millimetre, then cone
for 120 degrees, initial load is all given, the major load is 50 kg, 100 kg, 150 kg for
these sets of materials respectively, the harder the material is, the more will be the load and
the scale would be different, these are scales A, B, C, the dial gauge which I showed you had
two scales B and C and the reading that we have gotten for the brass workpiece was in a B scale
that is Rockwell hardness number 91 that came in the video. Now, this is indentation, how is the
shape of indentation as all these things you can read, I will just walk you through the
self-evaluation questions and then we will finally go to the simulation.
The first question is what is the diameter of the Rockwell ball indenter? Rockwell ball
indenter diameter is 1 by 2 soot that is 1 by 2 into 1 by 8th of inch, so this is 1 by 16th of
inch, load applied for Rockwell C test is more than Rockwell B test, yes it is true, C is for the
harder materials, what is the unit of Rockwell hardness number? Rockwell hardness number has
no unit, answer should be dimensionless number, match the following for Rockwell hardness test,
so first point is minimum thickness of span, minimum thickness of span should be 10 times
the permanent increase of the depth of indentation, so 1 matches with B, so 1 with B,
I have two options A and C here, so out of A and C let me see another option, second point here is
distance between center of two adjacent impressions should be at least, this distance
should be 3 times the diameter of the indentation, so this makes me select this option A3, B1, C2,
that is 2.5 times diameter of indentation is the distance between center of an impression
and edge of specimen should be at least this value 2 times of the diameter, then for B
it is minimum thickness of span and C is 3 times the diameter of the indentation,
that is distance between two adjacent impression, the minimum distance.
Next question is what is the value of minor load applied in the experiment? This is 10 kg we have
discussed, why minor load is initially applied? Wonderful question, minor load is initially
applied so that the surface roughness or surface impurities are taken care of
and the penetrator is firmly seat into the position for major load, Rockwell hardness
number is obtained by Rockwell hardness formula, deactivating from the gauge, yes it is deactivating
from the gauge, there is no formula for it, diamond indenter can be used for metals having hardness,
diamond indenter because diamond is the hardest material, so any hardness value more than 20 HRC
diamond indenter can be used. In C scale of Rockwell hardness testing the shape of indenter
used is in C scale because it is the hardest diamond cone indenter is used, so we can submit
the quiz here and we can go for the simulation part next. So this is the simulation environment
objective is to find the Rockwell hardness number of mild steel, cast iron, brass, aluminium,
spring steel etc. Apparatus used is the Rockwell hardness testing machine, step one is to select
the specimen, we will select brass as the specimen and type of indenter that we will use is ball
indenter, the hand wheel is turned until the specimen is in contact with the indenter and
the pointer of the smaller dial gauge reaches to the red dot, so we rotating the pointer so that
the pointer reaches the red dot, it has reached the red dot and then we go to the next step,
this is trial one going on and we set the load, we set the load to 100 kg,
major load applies 100 kg, then we switch on or we turn the lever to apply the load,
so now load is being applied, now the load is applied for around 15 seconds, we can again
turn off the load by pressing the hand lever and it is showing the reading here,
that is the leader, the larger leader is showing the Rockwell hardness number that is 79,
this was trial one where B scale is used, load is 100 kg and Rockwell hardness number is 79,
let us go trial two, in trial two again I will rotate the wheel so that here the minor load is
set to the red point, so minor load of 10 kg is applied, then go to the next step and adjust
the load, that is the major load to 100 kg, once it is adjusted to 100 kg, we turn the lever on
to apply the load, after around 15 seconds we turn off the lever and Rockwell hardness number
would come, that has come as 80, in the first trial it was 79, second trial is 80, so average
of these to be taken and the average is 79.50, this is directly we have gotten Rockwell hardness
number, so this was a demonstration on the hardness test, hardness is resistance to indentation,
resistance to scratch, resistance to wear. Now I will take you to the fracture test,
a quick demonstration on that, I will just walk you through the small theory part and walk you
through a video only, we do not have the simulation available for the fracture test, so we only walk
you through the video, so what is fracture test? Fracture testing involves subjecting a material
specimen to control loading conditions to understand its behavior under stress and strain,
so this is strength, hardness is different that is resistance to indentation, strength is resistance
to deformation, so fracture testing is for strength, this testing method is essential for
evaluating a material's toughness, resistance to fracture and ability to withstand loading
without catastrophic failure. To provide critical data for engineers to assess the reliability and
safety of materials using structural and industrial applications, fracture test is
conducted, it is a specimen that is fractured, there are various ways to conduct this test,
so there is a extensometer that is COD extensometer, this helps us to understand
what is the extension that is going on, where COD is crack opening displacement gauge.
Why is fracture testing important? First point is safety assessment, it helps to ensure that
materials used in critical applications such as in aerospace, in construction can withstand
loading conditions without sudden failure, enhancing overall safety, material reliability,
it provides insights into materials ability to resist crack initiation or crack propagation
and catastrophic fracture, crucial for predicting its reliability and lifespan that is generally
the correct fracture is not there but if it is propagated slowly or some catastrophic
failure could happen, so this is tested using the fracture test. Quality control,
it allows manufacturers to verify material consistency and adherence to specifications
that is material strength or fracture strength is determined here which ensures that the products
meet required standards and perform reliably in service. So procedure, we prepare the specimen
according to the standard dimensions ASTM or ISO standards are there which are typically
rectangular or cylindrical in shape, this is a cylindrical specimen that you can see
in the previous slide we had the rectangular specimen for fracture testing, surface condition
is only to make sure that surface defects should not be there that affect the test results, I will
show you this video. Testing apparatus include fracture testing machine, we utilize a specialized
testing machine designed for fracture testing such as a tensile testing machine we use for UTM
and for Charpy impact test we use a specific testing machine, so there is a fracture testing
machine that is utilized here, specimen is securely mounted over the machine so that it remains stable
during the testing. Loading and testing, application of load, we apply controlled
loading conditions to the specimen which may include tension, compression, bending, impact
depending on the type of fracture test being conducted. Tick acquisition, sensors and
transducers are used to measure the load, displacement and other relevant parameters
during tick test. Monitoring crack propagation, we record and monitor the progression of cracks
within the specimen to analyze crack growth behavior. The crack growth behavior means in the
beginning the crack would be very small, the crack would be keep growing and when the crack
completely happens the load will just be released in a way so that propagation and the flow of the
crack growth is studied here. Analysis of results, first thing that we try to understand from the
fracture testing is fracture toughness, we calculate the fracture toughness parameters such as
critical stress intensity factor that is KIC which indicates a material resistance to crack
propagation. Energy absorption, we evaluate the energy absorbed during fracture to understand
the material's ability to dissipate energy under loading. Fracture surface examination, we inspect
and analyze the fracture surface of the specimen using microscopy or other techniques to determine
fracture mechanism and identify any contributing factors. So that is fracture mechanism could
help us understand whether it was brittle, whether it was ductile, whether it was
slow or whether it was rapid. These properties are taken from the fracture surface.
Equipment includes the testing machines such as tensile testing machine used for conducting
tension test to determine the fracture toughness parameters. We have impact testing machine that
is Char-Pure Iso-Impact testers for assessing impact resistance and fracture behavior.
So this is peeling off, so this is our tensile testing machine for fracture.
Then notch toughness tester is there, it is specifically designed to evaluate material
resistance to crack initiation at the notched areas. So different setups are there. Measurement
instruments includes load cell, displacement sensors, data acquisition system. Load cells
measure the applied load with high accuracy. Displacement sensors monitor specimen deformation
and crack propagation. Data acquisition system collects and analyze data to generate fracture
test results and curves. Safety precautions, safety enclosures that is to protect the operators from
potential hazards. Safety enclosures are there which include the PPE which ensures the operators
wear the appropriate equipment that is a protective equipment so as to mitigate risk associated with
testing apparatus. Procedure fracture toughness evaluation that assesses material resistance to
crack propagation in aircraft components. Then impact resistance testing that evaluates
material's ability to withstand impact loads like bird strikes or so. Then failure analysis that
analyzes the material failures to enhance design and maintenance practices for safer aircraft
operations. So I will walk you through the video, the past two which is given in this slide. Let us
go through this video and try to understand how fracture testing is conducted. This video is from
Zurich Oil TV who are the manufacturers of the mechanical testing machines. In this video you
can see a fracture toughness test on ASTM 399 material is used using the HA 250 machine. HA 250
means 250 kilo newton of load is applied in this machine with 100 millimeters of the stroke. So it
is a hydraulic setup machine in which different grips are there. It is a CODX sensor meter that
is there and compact tensile specimen is there. So this is the interface that is the user interface
of the machine where we can input the dimensions of the specimen. Specimen dimensions are measured
and put it here it is 25.57 of thickness then width is put 63.75. Then we mount the specimen
into the CT grips here. We put the pins here and pins are locked. Now the CODX sensor meter on the
blades is attached here to the CT specimen so that we measure what is the extension value.
And here testing frequency is set first. We put the force value that is
one kilo newton. Now fracture testing is started here. You can see the way the loading is happening
pre-cracking this is how the machine behaves and it is also plotting the live fracture here.
So crack opening is also there running the fracture toughness. So this is the fracture
crack has happened now. Now you can see suddenly fall of the load is there. So this is how the
fracture test is conducted. We are measuring the crack length directly from the specimen
and this surface of the specimen also tells you about the properties or the behavior what the
specimen is. We put the values of the different dimensions here that is what is ligament or so
then we generate the report that this is the result taken from the fracture toughness.
So this is what the modern machines helps us to understand the toughness that is fracture
toughness in different forms. So there are certain features always for machines which are
different by the different manufacturers. Here they have also given that is simple integration
of accessories, high temperature furnace is also there in this CT setup. So there are multiple
ways fracture testing is conducted using the sharp impact test systems, using the tensile systems
or using the systems where the fracture at the notch is to be tested that is a
notch toughness test are there. So this was about the hardness test and fracture test in this
lecture. We will meet in the next week where we will talk about the cam, the belts, the chains,
the gears and we will continue the lecture series on basics of mechanical engineering one. Thank you.
