A common criticism of both presidential nominees heard in the aftermath of Tuesday night’s debate was that viewers didn’t learn anything new from them in terms of policy.
Joining us now to discuss this and the nominee's policy proposals is political strategist
Gerard Felitti. He's also a geopolitical analyst and attorney specializing in international law.
Why do you think both Harris and former President Trump avoided stipulating specific policy
positions during the debate, Gerard? Well, it's really hard to tell. I think that both
found it more convenient to debate one another on non-issues, on personality, trying to goad
one another, making it about style, making it about the persona of the candidate rather than
about substance. With Kamala Harris, the issue is that we don't really know how she's planning
to pay for some of her policy ideas. And the second part of the problem is she has held
contradictory positions for years. With Donald Trump, he has been very strong on a number of
issues like the economy and immigration, but he too doesn't have a firm commitment to how he's
going to implement some of these ideas. Do you think that this is something moderators
should have pressed them harder on or do you think the moderators pressed them enough?
I don't think the moderators were doing the best job that they could. They did certainly
press Donald Trump a lot, not as much or not at all for Kamala Harris. But we also saw this in
the CNN interview that Kamala Harris did. These candidates are not always answering the questions.
And when prompted again and again by the moderators, they still don't answer the questions.
I think really that's important for the American people to see that the candidates aren't answering.
It's very difficult to get moderators to do that when the candidates themselves are unwilling.
That just seems to be a general trend in debates these days from what we've seen in the primary
elections. Things were a little bit different in the debate between Joe Biden and Trump,
but that really stood out as an oddity to me personally. From the campaign's perspectives,
do you think there's been a change in strategic approach when it comes to debates
from their point of view? Do you think it could be
no longer advantageous to outline policy or commit to any presidential actions?
I think from what we have seen in the last eight years of presidential politics is that it has
become a race more of personality than substance. It's become a more an emotional appeal to people,
to voters than a pragmatic one with specific policy ideas. Don't get me wrong, the policies
are important and they are outlined often by the candidates in policy papers. We see this
both from the Trump and Harris camps. But when it comes to actual debates, it's about putting
on a show. It's about showing the public that they should trust you to be president for the
next four years. And that oftentimes is not about talking about specific agenda,
but making themselves good and competent and more so than the other person.
We don't see the debates on specific policy proposals. We haven't seen that for a while
and we will not see that for the rest of this election cycle.
Now, the debate aside, there's still much we don't know in terms of detailed policy from
former President Trump or Harris. I want to focus on foreign policy here in particular with us.
Tell us, what do we actually know so far about their foreign policy positions?
The policy position of Donald Trump is easier to understand because he actually has been president.
We expect that he will continue doing now as president what he did before,
which is looking at our allies to bear a bigger burden, a bigger share of the burden for military
defense, whether it's NATO or other treaties, looking to our partners to step up economically
when there are international issues that require multi-country assistance, looking for our partners
to take the lead in Europe, not always the United States. This is consistent with what he's done
before. Also, a very strong support for Israel, standing against Iran, making sure that Iran does
not develop a nuclear weapon. With Harris, we assume it will be much a continuation of the
Biden policies, but we don't know with certainty. And when it comes to Israel, there's certainly
been equivocation because on the one hand, she says she is supportive of Israel and will provide
them with weapons. But on the other hand, she surrounds herself with staff that does not like
Israel and is fairly anti-Semitic. So there's a lot that we have left to see about how Harris
will address global issues and whether she will go back to the negotiating table with Iran.
And especially China, we don't know what her history is or what her stance is,
other than that she wants to rein them in to some extent.
Foreign policy in particular, there's always a place for some level of strategic ambiguity
in terms of policy. Do you think this is playing into Trump and Harris's hesitancy to release
specifics? Well, I think the American public understands that when it comes to international
affairs, you can't really be too specific because a lot of the things that the president deals with
are reactive, are responses to a crisis. And you can give the world a good indication of what
your principles are, what you're thinking, what you're guided by, but you can't always say you
will deploy the following troops or you will respond with the following sanctions. So that's
not realistic. But both candidates, what they're doing is essentially laying out their vision for
what guides their decisions when it comes to foreign affairs. Yeah, I would imagine they'd
be thinking about that kind of risk. What do we still need to know from both Harris and Trump
when it comes to their approach to, say, the Middle East, the Russian-Ukraine war?
When it comes to the Middle East, there needs to be a pressure, especially on Harris,
to provide specifics on how she intends to deal with Iran. That is the biggest threat in the
region by far. Its proxies have been aggressive and creating wars and terrorism for decades.
Yet the Biden-Harris administration has been very lenient towards Iran, giving them billions of
dollars in exchange for hostages and seemingly wanting to restart nuclear talks that were not
favorable to the West. So those are things that Harris has to answer. On China, both candidates
need to answer to the extent that political and economic pressure will be brought to bear
to stop not just the expansion of China across the world, their military and social influence,
but also to deal with things like the fentanyl crisis, which is very much
fomented by China and affecting the US. Donald Trump has outlined sanctions, has outlined tariffs.
We don't know how Kamala Harris will address China. These are important issues that need
to be further refined. Finally, Gerard, there's only 53 days until the election. Is there anything
voters can do to get these campaigns to release more detailed policy or commitments before then?
Keep asking the questions, keep demanding answers. I think that the more that you have
these candidates out there facing questions from the people and the more that's video,
the more we see the reluctance of either candidate to address the public and sit for
press interviews, the more likely people are to think that these are not serious players.
Donald Trump, to his credit, has had a lot of press conferences. He answers questions.
Kamala Harris has not. So really, we need to see, especially Harris, sit down for interviews in
which she actually answers questions. And the public can certainly demand that reporters and
the media do a better job in holding them accountable to actually providing answers.
Yeah, there is indeed a significant contrast between these two candidates in terms of the
number of press conferences. Political strategist Gerard Felitti, thank you again for your time.
My pleasure. Thank you.