The Modern Astrology Obsession, Explained

Astrology in the old and present civilization
47 followers
What's up guys? Helen here with a confession. I'm an Aquarius, meaning I'm idealistic and
chronically late. You're probably thinking, why the hell would I care? Well, you don't have to
be inundated with hundreds of Scorpio memes on social media to know that astrology has gotten
big. In 2018, Americans spent $2.2 billion on mystical services, i.e. astrology, tarot,
and psychic readings. Meanwhile, astrology apps raked in a chill $40 million the following year.
Skeptics of astrology, like astronomer Carl Sagan, have fairly pointed out the lack of
scientific evidence supporting the practice. But that, to us, is probably the least interesting
thing about this phenomenon. Whether astrology works isn't the question. The question is,
in our science and tech-happy era, what makes the spiritual craft of astrology so endlessly
compelling to so many people? Let's dip a toe into the mystical in this Wisecrack Edition
on how astrology captivated the modern world. But first, I want to tell you about our sponsor
for today's video, Selfdecode. Unlike letting the stars tell you who you are, Selfdecode is a
service that uses actual science to help you get insights about your genes, and thus, your health.
Through a combination of AI and machine learning, Selfdecode analyzes your genome to make health
recommendations that are tailored to your unique needs. The process was really straightforward. I
spit in a tube and mailed them to them in a prepaid envelope. Gross, I know, but simple.
After about six weeks, my wellness reports arrived. And while they confirmed a lot of
things I already expected, I was surprised at just how much my genes could tell me about my health
and my personality. Case in point, apparently I have so many genes associated with anxiety
that of all the people Selfdecode tested, I'm at the top 97th percentile. That's a solid A.
This will come as no surprise to anyone who knows me in real life, but I didn't expect my high-key
fear of basically everything to show up in my genes as strongly as it did. I was also really
intrigued to find out that I have a lot of genes that are associated with high coffee consumption
and a gene that is associated with drinking less water, which might explain this. What I liked
about Selfdecode is that along with your health reports, the company gives you actionable insights
on how to improve your health based on what works for your genes. So, for example, apparently people
with my variant of the BDNF gene see a lot of improvement in anxiety symptoms with exercise,
so maybe I'll start going for a run or hit the gym the morning before I have to get on a podcast.
Selfdecode's wellness reports are full of useful recommendations for diet and lifestyle changes,
and even on potentially helpful supplements that can help you optimize your personal health.
That said, Selfdecode is not a diagnostic tool, but it does give you some genuinely useful insights
that can help you make wiser decisions when it comes to taking care of yourself. If you're ready
to learn more about your genome and how to make the most of it, check out the link in the description.
At checkout, use the code Wisecrack to get 25% off your Selfdecode order. And now, back to the show.
Now, the human impulse to find meaning in the stars is nothing new. Ancient Babylonians were
reading the night sky back in the second century BCE. In ancient Greece, astrology developed in
tandem with astronomy and was treated with respect by the likes of Ptolemy and Plato.
Throughout history, kings would use court astrologers to help them make important decisions,
like who to invade or what flavor ice cream to eat. In the 12th century,
astrology became heavily tied to medicine, and the job title physician-astrologer was a real thing.
Astrology was even taught at universities across Europe until the late 17th century. But around
then, the Age of Enlightenment, coupled with propaganda and political pressure, put a dent
in astrology's credibility. For a couple hundred years, it was relegated to a fringe interest of
freaky weirdos. For a long time, in many places, it was even illegal to predict futures. The
spiritualist movement of the mid-to-late 19th century would revive the ancient craft somewhat,
but it would never be as well-respected. Fast forward to the swinging 60s,
and baby boomers zealously embraced astrology. And to this day, it's remained a huge,
if hugely mocked, part of our culture. But how did we get here? What accounts
for astrology's enduring popularity? Well, you can largely thank occult enthusiast Alan Leo,
a late 19th century New Ager who super liked reading the stars. But he had a big problem.
It was still illegal in England to predict the future for money. So after going to court and
being fined for his little hobby, he took his lawyer's advice and stopped making predictions.
But what good was astrology without predictions of death, thunderstorms,
or unsightly pimples on your wedding day? Leo was about to figure it out.
See, he also believed that the Age of Aquarius was fast approaching. This was going to be a
blissful era of raised consciousness and humanity reaching its true potential. He wanted to help
everyone get ready for this dope galactic spectacle, specifically by achieving better
self-understanding. Importantly, Leo believed that character is destiny. That meant astrology
should help people better understand their character and temperament, rather than predicting
external happenings like car crashes. And here's a major plus, describing someone's personality is
not technically telling the future. Thus, it was not illegal. Now, quick sidebar. You know your
sun sign? That's not your whole astrological picture. Professional astrologers take into
account the position of every single planet in the solar system when crafting a star chart.
But that is very complicated and requires a lot of math and training. Thus, it was super expensive
and pretty much exclusive to the upper class. This made astrology kind of hard to popularize.
So, Leo came up with the ultimate shortcut. Teach people their sun sign and draw conclusions about
their character based solely on that. This bite-sized approach to the craft proved massively
popular. Soon, newspapers would start publishing horoscopes and life would never be the same for
any of you two-faced gemini's. Just kidding. But yeah, he basically made abbreviated horoscopes a
thing, though he couldn't have possibly predicted the 21st century meme explosion he was effectively
setting in motion. Leo's sun sign only approach would largely define modern astrology, standardizing
zodiac signs also, helpfully, made astrology marketable on a massive level via cheap almanacs.
Conveniently, this was happening just as the consumer capitalist economy was entering full
swing. At the same time, Leo would inspire astrologer Dame Rudhyar to take this character
stuff a step further in the 1930s by invoking a sparkly new type of science, psychology.
Specifically, by borrowing from one Carl Jung. Side note, turns out Jung was a big old weirdo
who liked alchemy and astrology. In fact, Jung liked astrology so much that it's speculated that
his zeal for the craft was at least partially responsible for his famous breakup with mentor
Sigmund Freud. This makes sense, because as writers Kieran LaGrace and Saffron Rossi explain in their
book Jung on Astrology, at root, both astrology and Jungian psychology might be seen as being
engaged with the critical task of developing greater self-knowledge, of bringing to awareness
the unconscious factors underlying our life experience. Rudhyar formally merged astrology
with Jungian psychology, especially his notions about the collective unconscious and archetypes.
Thus, he created psychological astrology and popularized the idea of reading your horoscope
as a cheaper version of seeing a shrink. Rest assured, not everybody was happy about the
mainstreaming of astrology. In 1952, cultural critic and notorious grump Theodore Adorno wrote
a semi-aggressive 78-page screed critiquing sun sign columns. He declared that fans of astrology
were persons who do not any longer feel that they are the self-determining subjects of their fate.
He studied Los Angeles Times horoscopes and noted certain themes, specifically that they
seemed to promote bourgeois values like tact, hard work, and success, while flattering people
about how intuitive they supposedly were. He wondered how, in the age of astrophysics,
anyone could possibly believe that their personality was affected by their date of birth.
That same question continues to be posed today. For her part, scholar Christine Monk argues that
two world wars, nuclear weapons, and the environmental crisis have all made science
seem a lot less sexy. This then leads people to seek out decidedly unscientific things
like astrology. But what if the popularity of astrology in modern times isn't just explainable,
but was actually pretty inevitable? Back in 1966, sociologist Jacques Matreux argued that astrology
is actually a perfect fit for modernity, and many have since agreed. See, as scholar Marshall
Berman explained, rapid change is one of the central tenets of modernity. Whether it's the
decreased power of religious and other social institutions, or rapidly increasing globalization,
our world is in a constant state of flux. As Monk explains, the world today seems more enchanted
than ever, but is also, in certain ways, more dangerous and demanding. We are constantly faced
with the challenge to make decisions and to act in the world without full knowledge and without
a privileged point of view. Frequent job changes, cross-country moves, divorces, and so on add far
more variables to everyday life than our ancestors ever had. Meanwhile, a decaying social fabric
leaves us all as lone agents, trying to figure out how to behave. This creates fraught situations
where we worry about making the wrong choices, about being the wrong kind of person. As scholar
Olav Hammer writes, in late modernity, we construct who we really are by engaging in self-reflexive
speculation and considering a variety of options. That's where astrology comes in for a lot of
people, as a mediating force to help them make sure they're not f***ing up. As Monk puts it,
to use astrology is a way to claim a home in the cosmos. That's during a time when a lot of us
don't have that psychic home anywhere else. That's why astrology is particularly attractive to people
in liminal situations, like a breakup or job loss. In a world full of choices, the guidance of the
stars, no matter how unproven, can feel centering for some. Monk notes that astrology both lets us
feel acted upon by forces larger than ourselves, while also helping folks to make a shift of
perspective and to reconstruct their worlds in slightly different ways. Reading your horoscope
on the internet, she explains, can magically create a foreground and background for the
In this way, she believes its appeal is largely about agency and empowerment.
Perhaps it's no wonder, then, that astrology has, in America, traditionally attracted marginalized
groups, like women and people of color, who are all too often denied power in daily life.
Some scholars think astrology even functions as a powerful coping mechanism. This all makes it
somewhat ironic that astrology has become an important spiritual outlet for so many people,
precisely because it's so aptly adjusted to modern capitalism and mass production.
But the popularity of astrology is also reflective of the way society now sees
individuals. Remember how old school astrology was all about big events, like wars and royal
coronations, rather than about little old you and your inexplicable romantic affinity for mouth
breathers? That's in large part because, before the early modern era, individualism wasn't all
that important. It was thought that every person had a few basic core characteristics in common,
but the concept of the unique individual eventually caught on, with a little help from
Renaissance philosopher Michel de Montaigne, among others. In our late modern times, the pursuit of
that authentic, unique self has become paramount, and astrology is one way of sussing out and
understanding your own quirks and idiosyncrasies. In the process, Hammer explains, we've seen
decreasing concern with cosmogonic myths or social charters and an increasing insistence
on personalized legends, self-centered rituals, and the spiritual transformation of each individual.
The individualization of religion, of finding salvation in your own self, is distinctly modern
and perfectly suited to astrology, and this understandably coincides with the overall
reduction in power of organized religions in our age. Hammer writes that these days,
not only is truth to be found within each of us, the very locus of spirituality is our own self.
But what if your own self is kind of discombobulated? How can you make sense of your
life? Well, astrology can help with that too, apparently. As Hammer explains, astrology
facilitates something called narrativism, which conveys the idea that we tell the stories of our
lives, stories that construct a temporal unity for our identities and that link our specific
life histories with purported grand, overarching themes. In this way, Hammer writes, it offers a
conceptual framework for constructing a narrative unity of life and furnishes a narrative form
within which one's life history can be understood. Hammer even says these narratives can function as
therapeutic interventions, though please don't break up with your therapist just because you
blame all your problems on Mercury being a retrograde. Linguist Charlotte Lin argues that
narrative is one of the most powerful ways of creating and maintaining one's personal identity.
Narrativizing can also help you establish causality and coherency in your life story.
Didn't get asked to prom? Blame pesky Venus. Didn't get that promotion? F*** you, Mars.
Essentially, astrology can help us explain away the apparent randomness of human life,
and according to Lin, it can do that regardless of if we fully believe in it or not.
As Monk summarized, in such a disorderly world, astrology offers a symbolic and metaphorical
system of imagining within a frame of order, even if that order is, you know, not at all
scientifically proven and pretty randomly concocted by a few savvy 20th century spiritual entrepreneurs.
But what do you guys think? Is astrology distinctly modern or a lingering remnant
of ancient spirituality? Let us know what you think in the comments.
Big thanks to our patrons for their support and be sure to check out our podcast.
Hit that subscribe button with the fury of a vengeful Capricorn,
and don't forget to ring that bell. And as always, thanks for watching. Peace.
