6 MINS AGO! Jim Rickards Shared Terrifying Predictions

Coin Crunch
8 followers
Sep 10, 2024
So 90% is the critical threshold.
The U.S. is at 131%, highest in history, which means we are well past the point where you
can borrow your way to growth, where you can borrow your way out of a debt crisis.
And we were heading for a debt crisis.
So the way it works is raise interest rates, tighten money, reduce the balance sheet, etc.
Get unemployment up.
Doesn't sound like a desirable goal, but that's what it takes, and that's what happened in
1982.
Get unemployment high enough so people are buying hamburgers instead of steak.
They're buying, you know, whatever is the least expensive thing on the shelf, day-old
bread instead of new bread, or they're not buying gasoline because they're not going
to work, etc.
That will bring prices down, but at a very high cost, which we just talked about, which
is high unemployment and lower productivity.
Meanwhile, the U.S. debt keeps going up.
We haven't really talked about the debt.
That part of it looks like 1981.
But if you throw in a global financial crisis, then it starts to look more like 2008.
Yeah, well, that's like a glacier.
Glaciers are extremely powerful, but they move extremely slowly.
Some exceptions, but they kind of like, you know, an inch a year, a couple inches a year,
but they move mountains.
I mean, they just, they create rivers, they create canyons, they move mountains.
They're extremely powerful, but slow.
That's a good metaphor for the impact of debt.
And when I talk about debt, particularly with the United States, but you can apply this
to any country, I focus on the debt to GDP ratio, because you can't really talk about
debt in isolation without thinking about the capacity to pay the debt.
In a simple example, if you have a $50,000 balance on your credit card, and you're making
$30,000 a year and trying to pay rent in New York, etc., good luck.
You're probably going to go bankrupt or at least to fall on that card.
But if you owe $50,000 on your credit card, but you're making $5 million a year, you just
write a check.
It's no big deal.
My point is, you can't look at a $50,000 debt and decide if it's a problem or not unless
you compare it to the income.
And if it's too low, it's a problem.
And if the income is high, not a problem.
So that's why you use the debt to GDP ratio.
The US just hit $31 trillion in national debt.
That is national debt, almost all of it in the form of US Treasury securities.
Not all of it, there are other obligations, but mostly US Treasury securities.
Well, is that a problem or not?
Well, one way to answer the question is compare it to GDP, do the ratio.
The answer is that ratio is now a little over 130%.
What was it in 1980?
When Ronald Reagan was elected, the answer is 30%.
30% is completely comfortable.
That's like the person with the $50,000 debt is making millions, no big deal.
30% is comfortable.
50%, yeah, getting up there.
Angela Merkel in all her years in Germany, and there's a lot of research to back this
up, says that 60% was the limit.
And that's what the Masters Treaty that created the European Union and the European Central
Bank, that was their goal.
They said, don't go over 60%.
If you do, you're expected to take measures, raise taxes, or reduce debt, or reduce spending,
do something to get that back down under 60%.
If you say, what's the critical threshold where water turns to steam, or water turns
to ice, or something changes in such a way that's not the same, it's radically different,
but it happens very quickly.
The best research says the answer is 90%.
And this comes out of Ken Rogoff at Harvard, also Carmen Reinhart, who's now the chief
economist at the World Bank.
But they've looked at hundreds of cases over hundreds of years.
And I like that because it's not just cherry picking data.
Developed economies, developing economies, economies that issue debt in their own currencies,
ones that issue debt in other currencies, principal US dollars, et cetera.
A wide variety of case studies.
And they show that when your debt-to-GDP ratio goes over 90%, your multiplier of an
additional debt goes below one.
So just to put that in context, at 30%, if I borrow $1 and spend $1, I might get $1.30
of growth, assuming you spend it wisely.
That's a big condition.
But you borrow $1 and spend $1 and get $1.30 of growth.
OK, the debt was productive if you put it to good use.
But that $1.30 gets smaller and smaller.
As you get closer to 90%, it goes to $1.20, $1.10, $1.05.
Past 90%, roughly, you borrow $1 and you spend $1, and you only get $0.95 of growth.
You don't get your dollar back in terms of GDP.
And then 90% and 85%, et cetera.
So 90% is the critical threshold.
The US is at 131%, highest in history, which means we are well past the point where you
can borrow your way to growth, where you can borrow your way out of a debt crisis.
And we were heading for a debt crisis.
Now, Stephanie Kelton, she's the big brain of modern monetary theory.
She's a professor at State University of New York.
She says it doesn't matter.
That they always point to Japan.
Japan is at 280%, way past any member of the peer group.
China is probably higher.
China is a little more opaque because they are.
But also, they don't have as much national debt.
If you look at the national debt to GDP, it's modest.
But they have an enormous amount of provincial debt.
And the banking system is owned by the government or controlled by the government.
So when you're throwing the bank debt, the state-owned enterprises, the provincial debt,
and the government.
So that's the real national debt.
Stephanie Kelton says it doesn't matter because you're borrowing in your own currency.
So if you're Argentine and you're borrowing dollars and you print pesos, how are you going
to pay the dollars back unless you have huge trade surpluses, which they don't?
So they just default.
Argentina is a serial defaulter and everyone expects that.
If you borrow in dollars and you print dollars, which the United States does, they're like,
what's the problem?
Just print the dollars and pay the money back.
Well, that's true.
If you print dollars, there's no reason to default on dollar debt because you actually
can print the money and buy the bonds.
But it doesn't mean nothing else bad happens.
What about inflation or hyperinflation?
What about the foreign exchange rate?
The exchange rate can collapse.
And these modern monetary theorists show very little understanding of the international
aspects.
They treat the US like a closed economy, which it's not.
I mean, if it were a closed economy and we didn't have to worry about trade deficits,
trade surpluses, capital flows, exchange rates, foreign credit, China owning $1 trillion of
US Treasury securities, which they do.
If you didn't have to worry about any of that, I think they'd probably still be wrong, but
they'd have a better case.
But you do.
And they're just not very knowledgeable about any of those things.
But you can think of exchange rates as a conveyor belt.
Exchange rates are one way the problems go from one country to another, or good things
can go from one country to another, depending on whether your exchange rate is going up
or down, the impact on terms of trade, et cetera.
But they completely ignore all that.
They also ignore the role of commercial banks.
They just look at the Treasury and the Fed and look at money supply, like M0, but don't
understand how commercial banks create M1 and they do their own thing.
They're not on as short a leash as they seem to think.
But if you read Stephanie Kelton's book, The Deficit Myth, she says, well, we don't really
need a bond market, the US bond market.
We only have a bond market as a favor to investors because it gives them a place to put their
money.
But why have government spending, so the Treasury borrows money by issuing bonds, and then the
Fed monetizes the bonds by buying the bonds.
And that gives the Treasury the money to pay the bills, et cetera.
She says, do away with all that.
Just give the Fed wire instructions for Lockheed.
And if you need five F-35 fighter jets, order them and just send the money right to Lockheed.
Why do you need a bond market?
She actually says that.
I mean, legally, that might be possible, but to suggest that you can do that without
consequences is nonsense.
And they say, what about inflation?
Well, their view is as long as there's excess capacity and unmet needs, et cetera, you're
not going to have inflation because there's a lot of slack in the economy.
That's a legitimate debate.
But they say when inflation happens, raise taxes.
And by the way, they also say you don't need a tax system because if you can just print
the money, why do you have to collect taxes?
And their answer is, we collect taxes to redistribute income.
OK, well, at least they're honest.
I mean, it's kind of a socialist model, but they're honest about it.
But it's important to bear in mind that Stephanie was the principal economic advisor to Bernie
Sanders in 2016 and 2020.
And Bernie Sanders today is the chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, controls the
purse strings.
So coming out of Congress, and Biden's kind of a cypher.
He's barely aware of his own existence.
So Sanders is in a powerful position, and she's the Bernie whisperer, so to speak, who's
behind all this.
So if you ask the typical member of Congress, can you define modern monetary theory, they'll
look at you funny.
They've either never heard of it, or they certainly don't know what it means, MMT.
But they're acting in accordance with modern monetary theory.
Whether they know it or not doesn't matter.
The actual behavior of the Congress, and again, just go back to COVID 2020, because we talked
about the debt to GDP ratio.
So in around May or June 2020, Trump put through a $2 trillion COVID relief package.
And that was when the Paycheck Protection Plan, that was $800 billion, and everyone
got the $1,200 check, et cetera, et cetera.
And then at the end of December, at the very end of the Trump administration, they did
another trillion dollars, almost.
And that's when everyone got the $600 checks, and now you're up to $1,800.
By the way, those checks, that is helicopter money.
What the Fed does is kind of nonsense.
But when it's fiscal policy, not monetary policy, and you're handing out checks, that
is helicopter money.
And credit to Larry Summers for saying, you're going to get inflation out of this.
Well, Biden comes into office in January 2021, and he's like, not to be outdone.
He did his own COVID relief package.
That was another $2 trillion, and that's when we all got the $1,400 checks.
They just handed them out.
And then later that year, they did the trillion dollar infrastructure package.
And then, just to top it off, what we got recently was the just under a trillion dollar
Green New Deal, or I call it the Green New Scam.
Well, and the baseline budget deficit, before everything I just described, the baseline
budget deficit was about a trillion dollars a year.
So take a trillion dollars for 2020, 2021, and 2022, add on $2 trillion for Trump's first
package, $1 trillion for a second one, $2 trillion for Biden's first package, $1 trillion
for the Green New Scam, and I think a trillion for infrastructure.
That's $7 trillion on top of the $2 trillion baseline budget deficit.
So that's $9 trillion piled on top of what was at the time about a $21 trillion national
deficit.
That's how we got to $30 trillion.
That's how the ratio went from 106 to 131.
These numbers are mind boggling.
And MMT says it doesn't matter.
But it does matter.
And it shows up the way I described earlier, which is it slows growth.
You don't get growth.
So best case for the US is very slow weak growth, which we saw from 2009 to 2019.
Worst case is you throw a recession on top of that, which we're heading for, and the
US will be in fiscal distress.
