The Secret meanings of Swan Lake - a short documentary

Ballet Tales
13 followers
2 Video ViewsยทSep 9, 2024
This is my personal take on Swan Lake, exploring some of the hidden meanings within the ballet.
Hello, I'm Julie Cronshaw. I've been teaching Cicchetti Method classical ballet in London for more than 25 years.
I graduated from the Royal Ballet School Teachers' Training Course in 1986 and danced professionally before setting up my own school.
I'm a Fellow of the ISTD in the Cicchetti Method and hold the Enrico Cicchetti Diploma.
Most recently, I've made a film called Ballet's Secret Code, which is available on this channel.
And for more information, content and even more videos, you can go to the website BalletSecretCode.com.
I hope you enjoy this video.
Why are the acts broken up into essentially the ethereal plane and the material plane?
The colourful first act of Swan Lake represents the earthly plane where we see a scene full of merriment, a mixture of people and characters and the setting up of the story.
Then in act two, a complete change of colour and mood as the scene opens with a night time view onto a lake.
The scene plays out in monochrome. The swan maidens are in white, Rothbart is in black.
The tabs at the side of the stage indicate a forest with looming shadows.
It is well known that along with words, colours also arouse different emotions.
We say like a red rag to a bull, green eyed jealousy, yellow bellied coward, black and blue and so on.
In the practice of yoga, there is a word which means disinterestedness or detachment.
This means that one be well advised to live one's life without getting caught up in the drama of one's thoughts and actions.
And the word itself literally translates to without colour.
Here we're looking at a scene of a lake in monochrome, without colour.
There is a degree of detachment, a sense of one step removal from the reality of act one and a stepping into a world of fantasy.
In act three, Siegfried returns to his earthly plane of existence and we're back in the material plane again.
It's a lavishly decorated palace ballroom with a large window at the back, behind which we will later see the image of Odette being betrayed.
We watch the plot unfold, how Siegfried succumbs to the temptations of material existence during the bewitching pas de deux of the black swan.
Interestingly, Alexei Ratmansky, who has reconstructed Swan Lake with the Stepanov notation for the Zurich ballet, mentions that the black swan was originally costumed in a multi-coloured tutu.
How appropriate for the magician's daughter to be casting her spell over the prince in such a blinding array of colours.
Finally, in act four, we return to the monochrome of the lake, the betrayed Odette and the sacrifice she makes to release herself from her enchantment.
She jumps into the lake as a human, followed by Siegfried, and the ballet ends with the death of Rothbart and the breaking of the spell.
Sometimes, versions will show an apotheosis of Odette and Siegfried ascending into heaven in a chariot, as in the 1895 version, or with the swan companions reverting to their human form.
To summarise, Swan Lake has four acts. Act one is set in the material plane, act two, the white act, in the ethereal plane, act three, we're back at court, the material plane, and act four, we're back at the lake, the ethereal plane.
What is the meaning of the lake?
Water is the element of emotion, energy in motion, e-motion, but it has other mystical meanings as well.
Bodies of water being made out of tears appear in myths and legends and spiritual traditions.
A rising out of the lake is a goddess embodying the best feminine qualities such as compassion and creativity.
Odette's mime to Siegfried at the opening of act two says that the lake is made of her mother's tears.
The lake can also be seen as a mirror, which suggests several metaphors, reflection, illusion, mysterious or unknown depths.
In act two, the lake is calm and the moon is reflected in the water. It's setting a calm atmosphere.
Whereas in act four, the lake is disturbed by a storm, the atmosphere is charged with suggested danger and impending doom.
What is the meaning of the moon in the lake?
The moon illumines the scene for the fantastical elements of the story in act two.
It's usually a full moon shining a cold white light in contrast to the warm yellow daylight of the sun.
Full moons have their own long held associations with madness and magical goings on,
and the reflection of the moon in the water further emphasizes the sense of illusion by reflection.
It's such an obvious comparison we wouldn't give it a second thought,
which is fortunate when watching a ballet where the story is coming on a pace and the symbols laid on so thick and fast.
So it adds to the subconscious building up of the story and invites us to believe in the magic.
We're already familiar with these symbols and don't need for them to be explained through dancing or in the program notes.
Let's talk about infinity and eternity.
The lines and the formations in Swan Lake act two made by the corps de ballet,
which seem to go on and on and on into infinity, like those mirrors you see where you put one against the other
and they reflect you until your image gets smaller and smaller and smaller and disappears altogether.
Lev Ivanov created the choreography for acts two and four of Swan Lake.
It wasn't Petipa. Petipa created the choreography in acts one and three.
When you read about Lev Ivanov, he didn't seem to be the world's most happy man.
I would like to assume that he had quite some knowledge about what he was doing when he created those beautiful formations in Swan Lake.
When we look at those girls in those dead straight lines,
surely that has to have some kind of effect on the viewer in the audience
because you have the repetition of each girl in the line
and the way that the back of the line seems to disappear out at the back of the stage
so it looks like the line is going on forever.
Interestingly, apparently, originally the taller corps de ballet dancers would have been at the front
and the shorter corps de ballet dancers would have been at the back of the line
and this was to increase the sense of perspective.
The arabesque line here.
If you drop the elbow slightly and lift the fingers slightly
and then the eye focus is directed beyond the fingers out into the distance
we have a sense of a line that carries on into eternity.
And without saying a word, when you have 16 or 24 dancers in the corps de ballet
everybody in the same line, everybody with the same eye focus
perhaps as an audience we do interpret this imagery on an intellectual level in a subconscious way
and maybe this was the design of Lev Ivanov when he created Swan Lake Act II more than 100 years ago.
Who is Siegfried really and what does he represent in terms of the human condition?
Siegfried first appears in Act I at a party with his tutor and friends.
His mother, the princess, appears and asks that he choose a bride.
Instead of behaving like a prince about to reach manhood and take up his responsibility to govern a kingdom
he would rather remain carefree and unattached.
This keeps him stuck in his adolescence and could lead to debauchery
because we see how the old tutor is a character of dubious moral behaviour, lecherous and dissolute.
Fortunately Siegfried realises his duties, somewhat reluctantly
and on the last night of freedom decides to go swan hunting with his best friend Benno.
This is where it gets interesting.
He goes hunting swans with a bow and arrow at the start
but he's not really searching for swans, rather he's searching for himself.
Then just as he's about to shoot the swan
she miraculously changes into a dazzling white clad enchanted swan queen.
Siegfried at the lake has met not only his soulmate but also his soul in the form of Odette.
The symbols of attachment, both ethereal and corporeal, abound
and they are reiterated throughout the choreography.
Odette either wraps herself around Siegfried, suggesting the graceful form of the swan with its long neck
and showing a physical and earthly attachment to him
or in contrast trying to fly away from him
as if to suggest that the soul is only attached to the body as long as that body is corporeal.
Many myths and legends around the world feature journeys
which are as much about the inner development of the hero or heroine as the outer physical journey.
The inner quest in all spiritual traditions seeks the kingdom of the self and it's where God resides.
What is the relevance of the chapel Odette emerges from in some versions?
Why not just a pathway in the woods?
The swan queen emerges out of the ruined tomb-like chapel as a glowing form
like the resurrected Christ.
A significant image that would have been very familiar 100 years ago
for any audience in a Christian country such as Russia.
From another perspective, in Eastern philosophical traditions
the journey towards nirvana or enlightenment is an inward one
going to the cave of the heart where the soul shines in the heart of the city.
Coming out of the woods has another meaning too.
Woods are found in nearly all fairy tales and represent confusion along the path
the illusions causing the truth from man to be hidden from him on the earthly plane
or the Maya in Sanskrit.
Dante's Inferno begins,
I found myself in a forest alone.
The swan queen Odette is not on a spiritual journey so she doesn't come out of the woods.
Siegfried on the other hand is
until he stumbles across the lake with the ruined chapel on its edge.
What do the white swan and black swan characters represent?
As I mentioned Odette is not only Siegfried's soulmate, she's also his soul.
The symbolic associations of the white swan represent those elements I discussed earlier
purity, grace, freedom and strength
also known by the word virtue.
In contrast the black swan represents sensuality, bewitchment
power used for nefarious means.
Whilst Siegfried is dazzled by Odile
he falls under the spell of the Maya
the illusion of the material world and all its temptations and pleasures.
He's not only betrayed his soulmate Odette
but also potentially his soul's real purpose in this lifetime.
And so Odette must perish.
Finally in Act 4 we return to the monochrome of the lake.
Odette sacrifices herself to break the curse.
She jumps into the lake as a human followed by Siegfried
and the ballet ends with the death of Rothbart and the breaking of the spell.
In the original version of 1877
there's an ambiguous more gothic ending.
Odette and Siegfried are engulfed by the rising waters of the lake in the storm
and overhead an owl grabs the crown that was on the swan queen's head.
As the storm subsides the moon pierces out between the clouds
and the audience is left with the image of swans gliding across a calm mirror-like lake.
This ending is altogether more ominous
it suggests that if you take the wrong path in life you too will come to a bad end.
Swan Lake the ballet is a bit of a hybrid of myths and legends as I mentioned at the start.
If you'd like to read about the different sources that may have been used in the original synopsis
I recommend The Ballet Called Swan Lake by Cyril Beaumont published by Dance Books.
Just a reminder I've made a film called Ballet Secret Code.
It's a one hour documentary available on YouTube on this channel for free
it took a long time to make I'm very proud of it and it's all about ballet technique.
You can find it on YouTube or click on the link below.
