Ranking the BEST Man Utd managers since Sir Alex Ferguson… 👀 | Saturday Social

Sky Sports Premier League
84 followers
Sep 8, 2024
Right, today we're going to ask Spencer and Rory to rank the five best managers since Sir Alex Ferguson
left the club to see where Eric ten Hag stacks up against those bosses. Each of our guests are going
to do their own list. There's six candidates to pick from because they've got to have managed
over 20 games for Manchester United so that discounts the likes of Michael Carrick who
were there on a very very short term basis. We'll start with Ralph Rangnick. Have either of you got
Ralph Rangnick in your top fives? Yes. You have? I have him fifth in my top five. I'm going to put him
in the fifth slot then because I don't think you've got him. Just the number. Move him over,
move him next to the five. Yeah, you haven't got him Spence. Why have you not got Ralph before we
come on to Rory's reasons? This is a very counter-intuitive list in my opinion right
because I'm talking about what they did as managers and achieved at Man United, not necessarily
what they were trying to do. So I actually think Ralph came in and actually sort of addressed the
problems and sort of said look this is a team with a lot of issues here but he wasn't actually
able to fix any of them. I don't know if any managers were able to fix any of them in the
pre-Jim Ratcliffe era at least because I don't think they've had the tools and the ability to
run the club the way they wanted to. So if I'm judging him as a manager I just think it was a
bit of a mess. He came in and you know whether he could have done better is a different question.
So I'm not judging him like whether he was the right man for the job and all this thing. I think
he's come in and he's not really a manager. I think he's someone you have in your club
it's actually weirdly maybe links to what we're going to talk about later with
I actually think it's what Gareth Selfgate should be doing as well to be honest. I don't actually
think he should be a manager. I think he should be someone that helps identify problems in a
culture or in a club and that's what I think Ralph is and leading a philosophy on the pitch
but as a manager I wasn't convinced. As a manager how have you got Ralph Rangnick in your top five
then Rob? Well I don't necessarily disagree with anything that Spencer said there which I think
actually justifies him being here because it's a ridiculous appointment. Like Ralph Rangnick,
you know when he got the job? Yeah. I remember Manchester United fans, there's a
fantastic clip actually that goes around on social with Manchester United fans reacting to the news
that he got the job. So full of it, so happy, we finally got the right man and I didn't know too
much about him so I looked him up. Do you know what his CV was? Bearing in mind that Manchester
United, the Manchester United job is probably what? Top three jobs in world football, the hot seat of
Manchester United, biggest club in England, biggest club in the Premier League, the hot seat of
Do you know what his CV was? One, Intertoto Cup at Stuttgart in the year 2000. But he was being
brought in to go upstairs afterwards wasn't he? He was the manager but he was brought in as the
Manchester United manager. Never has anybody so undeserving an Intertoto Cup at Stuttgart
two decades previous been given the keys to the fastest car in the country. But it was just a
short-term key wasn't it? It was a key that was going to change after six months as he stepped
upstairs. I think in fairness to Ralph he was thrown into a position that he wasn't necessarily the manager.
He stinks of lack of strategy again because he's going to do this, he's going to do that
but he ends up leaving. 11 games, one of 29 in charge, win percentage just 38 percent but going
back to it you have got him in your top five because you don't think that's the fault of him
you think it's the appointment is the issue. I'm just trying to factor in how he's made. I think it's symbolic
I think the appointment of Rangnick, giving him the job is symbolic of everything that went wrong
at Manchester United and therefore he deserves to be on this list. I think what we'll do next is we'll
go to a manager that you don't have on your list but you do have on your list. Yeah. Interestingly
I think this one is David Moyes. You've got him at four for you, you don't have him in the top five raw.
So you've got to use context here okay so you can think back to the year he came in and obviously
what you've got one season whatever and you know didn't go amazing right. If you actually look at
what he did in the amount of games he played the win percentage you know compare it to the other
53 percent win percentage by the way 27 wins in 51 games. Yeah so obviously he came off the back
of a title winning season right but we all know that was not a title winning squad that he inherited
so it's very different for example the Arnold Slott situation with Liverpool. Arnold Slott's been able
to come in and not even have to buy anyone because Klopp has left him in such good shape and that is
partly why Klopp moved on when he did. Man United, Sir Alex had his own reasons for moving on and I
respect them but there was some weaknesses in that squad that Moyes inherited and that was a poison
chalice it was always going to be a tough gig to follow the legendary manager. In hindsight you look
back at not just Moyes but the other managers that have followed you look back at what he's done at
West Ham which we can't take away from whether you like his style of football or not he won a European
trophy you know and improved our club. To get that job of course. Improved our club yeah and he struggled
to bounce back at first because it was a massive reputation blow what happened to him probably never
should have taken the job people were probably going to say I'm being West Ham biased. A lot of West Ham fans
don't like Moyes it's not like a West Ham across the board thing it's more a case of the whole
strategy stinks from day one since Sir Alex left the minute Sir Alex left the glazers went right
now the man who's run everything he's been hiring the tea ladies and the kit men and everything he's
gone we can run this club the way we want to run it and it's been awful it's been horrendous you
talk about the money they've spent every one of these managers apart from maybe one I don't like
any of their performances at the club but I don't necessarily blame them blame the people at the top
well you've not got Moyes in your top five is that right that's right that's right I don't I don't
necessarily think that he is that he is worthy of being on this list if you think about the job that
he did when he went into the club he was as Spencer said he was given a poison chalice such a difficult
job such a such a over promotion from him and I also think that people now because it's because
it feels like a long time ago I think it's very easy to to kind of paint it in being a better
better performance than it was Manchester United then the standards were through the roof they
were a club that demanded the best from everyone at the club and they were champions and he came
in and that was the start of the demise you think he was worse than Rangnick I mean there's this
two bald geezers arguing over a comb here isn't it but but yeah I do obviously we're talking about
we said that he's only in charge of 51 games obviously took over title winning side they
were ninth in the table I believe after 15 games so we know it it didn't work out yet one thing I
will say just for balance perspective is whenever any job comes out any tv presenter radio presenter
in any walk of life replaces someone so big everyone compares it to it's like replacing
Fergie it's like everyone talks about Moyes replacing Fergie as the impossible job in any
walk of life when when big shoes are set to be filled so it was almost like that was as you
described it a poison chance it's always going to be a tough gig for whoever replaced
everything that has come since if that appointment had been correct if actually
if they had appointed Mourinho then the Manchester United of today could be a very different club
and what would Mourinho have taken the job did certain players to certain managers almost I
don't know he was like his choice I think Mourinho was keen I think I think Mourinho was keen but I
think it was Sir Bobby Charlton he said absolutely not interesting because that's the other thing is
right because when Moyes take took over so Alex was still a bit more active I think involved in
terms of overseeing things and as the years have gone by he's taken that step back so how much
harder did that make Moyes his job essentially living in the shadow of that great man if we're
honest I know it's history will be very kind to David Moyes because of what's happened since
because of what's happened at West Ham winning their first trophy since 1980 it's all significant
and does add to the to the legend and aura of David Moyes but he was never deserving of that job
he was it was he was never the correct man for that job he'd done a very good job at Everton
he hadn't won anything he went into the biggest club in the country who were champions like
it was it was such a bad appointment and he made a pig's ear of it all right let's go to the next
name Ollie Gunnar Solskjaer yeah I have him in yeah I cannot believe as a as the Manchester United
voice on this sofa I can't believe how low you two have got Ollie I actually agree with that
yeah you're mad man I think having Solskjaer on fire you've got red devil tinted spectacles on
you think you're thinking of the new camp 1999 I'm not I'm honestly like when I tell you Frank
Lampard was brilliant at Chelsea I don't think there is there are clear differences there I
think the most exciting football United played poster Alex 100 played by Ollie I think that
proves that in the numbers as well most goals scored in a single season he also finished second
in the league which was an achievement that I think a manager we're going to talk about later
detailed as one of his greatest ever accomplishments yeah you know he's won
an awful lot and Ollie was a penalty away from winning the Europa League final I think that
yes you might not have him high against who Villarreal so you should be winning that game
in 90 minutes shouldn't you I mean ostensibly yes but Villarreal haven't had an excellent Europa
League record at the time and like I know that Ollie Gunnar Solskjaer on paper Manchester United
the stronger squad has spent more money but it's never that easy is it football's not played on
paper and I think Ollie overall when when we look back on his time now it looks even more
favourable I actually do agree with that and it's not just a second as well if in the three seasons
sixth third and second you look at the start yeah I think you want 14 of his first 19 matches
managers which is one of the best in Premier League history I think his first nine games
is the best but as you're looking back on it it's silly aren't they the PSG games tell me what he
won but if you tell me what he won so do you think this list should be based just all about that
well it's Manchester United you've got there you played the most games of any of these people on
the list I believe as manager right at the most games I think ten hogs catching him up but like
and what's he won Manchester United no take your spectacles off right so we don't care about
necessarily as non-man United fans it's not my job to tell you how exciting they were I can look at
it a bit more further removed right I do think exciting when there's a massive part of it if
you ask Man United fans just like if you ask West Ham fans oh how good was Dimitri Payet I made me
feel great another person could say yeah but what did you do on with him like it's it's about
achievements if you're asking me as a neutral person which I think is important what he did
I think he got given so much more time than anyone else on this list because of what he did there as
a player which maybe is worth something but still we're talking about people with their skills as
managers what else has he done in his managerial career he's not a great manager he's not a good
manager in my opinion I think he's underrated I think honestly I think he's been really underrated
um probably not no okay no but I don't think that's a disrespect on on what he was able to
achieve with that team which was not a trophy but it was definitely progression in the moment I
totally agree towards the back end you know it became untenable didn't it I think it was one
winning seven that four one loss to Watford that is when it became untenable but you can't take
away there were some extremely high moments in that if clock just left Liverpool right and had
done everything he'd done but not won the trophies would say exact same thing that's a different
situation because Liverpool were coming no because Liverpool were coming from an era of really not
being apart from a Champions League with Rafa really not being an amazing side we've all grown
up in Man United like they are the team no one can beat them it's amazing how quickly you've got
them below Moyes so you think the job Moyes did at Man United was better than the job
this is where subjective right it's not so much about it's about the tools they had and how hard
it was I think he had a harder job because he had to follow and I think he was mistreated I don't
think the fact he was given a season he he should not been given more than season based on the same
logic of what he got but Ollie's first season at Man United was excellent yeah but he's 14 14 wins
early doors money had been spent on that squad by the time Solskjaer got it now I know a lot of
money had been sent spent under Sir Alex of course but I think we were speaking a minute ago about
the man the ownership not um sort of managing downwards very well not putting people in the
right spot yeah that's why I say all these guys in this list that there's there's another list
that should be made which is the top 20 owners in the Premier League and your owners are right at
the bottom in my opinion because what are the asset they've taken over and what they've done
to it also also to focus on the first 14 games to focus on the exciting football it's not focusing
on the whole picture it was so turgid by the end it was so toxic by the end but his second season
he finished second no but again you know when you come with stats and facts like that that doesn't
that that tells us part of the story but it doesn't tell us the whole story it tells what it
tells us is that maybe the league wasn't particularly strong that year I don't know who
finished that I can't remember off the top of my head but that doesn't mean that it's acceptable
it doesn't mean that the performances were acceptable and Manchester United under Solskjaer
if you can cast your minds back to the feeling around the club it felt so flat towards the end
I agree I think it was actually the third second season second third season when it's sixth third
second yeah I think I think so there's actually improvement in that but I think if you're judging
on trophies then that that's one angle it depends how you it's your list now if he gets the games
he got he wins a trophy my opinion if he gets the games that he got there's as much chance at least
to get a trophy than he did well I I'm very surprised you've got him so low but should we
go to the next let's move on to the next one yeah let's go uh who's for the next Louis van Gaal
yeah I've got van Gaal next so you've got Louis above Oli yeah I mean he's undoubtedly a better
manager exactly he's undoubtedly in a wider context yeah you know what he's achieved at
Ajax and Barcelona I totally agree but as Manchester United boss do you think he did a
better job than Oli if in my opinion if he played for Man United and he didn't we wouldn't have this
discussion agreed 100% we're not having this discussion I I just the football I think it's
admirable the love that you're demonstrating to social I totally empathize with it but I also
think that it almost makes your it almost makes your take on it redundant because you have you
have such a love because you have such an apparent love for Oli Gunnar Solskjaer I think that if we
just remember how Manchester United fans were feeling during the the back end of that social
era I think it's possibly lower than it's ever been but I think you could say the same thing
with Louis van Gaal yeah the season when United finished with a cup he finished with the FA Cup
but I think that covered up an awful lot the the season when United scored 49 league goals
like the football yeah the 4-0 loss to MK Dons there was like there was low points in that one
spent 260 million the likes of Di Maria, Martial, Shaw, Depay, Schneiderlin, Schweinsteiger, Herrera
did win the FA Cup so Spencer am I right in thinking you're a big part of your list is
based on trophies and that's why you have van Gaal over the others is it because
is that where your logic comes into it trophies games played amount of time they were given
like that's essentially do you think prestige counts as well so for example although it didn't
work with van Gaal long term Louis van Gaal was a noble appointment an appointment that could have
worked an appointment that suited the stature of the club and okay not all of them are going to
work but it was an appointment that you could see working appointing the Geyser from Molde
appointing the Geyser who won an Intertoto Cup they're bad they're bad appointments they're
never going to work at least Louis van Gaal Joe really wants to jump in this is why I think this
is somewhat arbitrary because the issue is I don't think anyone was ever going to be good in
that era because of the owners and maybe now and Jim Ratcliffe's come in and it's got a bit more
saying things I think it could turn there's one era where it could have been good I truly believe
that if they'd got the appointment correct when Sir Alex Ferguson left that first appointment
when they went with Moyes I think that was such a pivotal moment and everything that we've learned
about Manchester United since then can actually be traced back to getting that but I think that
without a Sir Alex type in charge i.e. someone that had the keys to the city and could do
whatever they wanted and obviously was a world-class manager combined with that
it was never going to work under those owners and no no manager has been given that that luxury
the only kind of person that's going to get the keys to the kingdom is a European Cup winner with
heritage and prestige not the fellow from Everton who hasn't won a trophy well let's let's see your
two and one together because there's no point revealing just one is there so we may as well
see who you've got one who you've got two wow same top two so why have you gone those two in
that order right I actually think ten hogs rubbish I'm just going to say that out there
right this is a sort of me coming at my own list here definitely a Spencer those are the thoughts
of Spencer I think ten hog is no good I think the only reason he's still there is because Jim
Ratcliffe is got a bit of loyalty about him and he won a trophy last year if that trophy wasn't
there I think he's already contextualized last season as having massive injury problems
yes still managing to get over the line of course I was going to get to that he ruined
yeah he had to deal with Ronaldo the first season was excellent yeah he had to deal with a lot of
issues 100% I completely respect that I can't get over the the lack of judgment he's done in some of
his transfers the amount of money he's given Iradovici clubs and you know potentially his
agent as well some people that have come in are just it's criminal he managed Kudus he let us buy
him for a third of the price you bought Anthony who would you rather have right now that's on him
that's on him you see he's the expertise there he makes a lot has made a lot of poor transfer now
transfers have improved this summer I really like the transfers he's also got really unlucky
that you know Hoyland's got himself injured and obviously Euro's injured as well right
and they've got delete he's a lot of these areas improved but I'm not giving him the credit for
that because they've made appointments behind the scenes that I think are a massive part of that
and I think his time is very much numbered I'm very uninspired by him I think he has dealt with
some difficult issues but he's had a lot of games and he's been saved by a couple okay those are
I think that Eric ten hog speaking really broadly here has done a fairly good job overall if you
think about the club that he came into if you think about that first season if you think about
all of the issues that he's had to deal with handling that Cristiano Ronaldo issue I thought
he handled it perfectly the way that he dealt with Jaden Sancho he gave Jaden Sancho time off
to try and rediscover his form to try and find himself and was treated abysmally Jaden Sancho
effectively declared war on him pinned something to the top of his social media profile makes life
almost impossible for a manager I think ten hog has got an awful lot right and that's why he's so
high it's not necessarily about Van Gaal or Solskjaer I just feel like ten hog needs to be
up there consecutive seasons with silverware I don't know if I don't know if I'm I'm going mad
here but I feel like people are so sneery towards silverware now winning silverware is the dream
winning silverware is the ambition winning silverware is historic this guy's has done it
twice in a row like he has made history and also let's remember the significance of the
cut win last season not only was it a cut win for Manchester United which in itself is historic
and worthy of worthy of exactly yeah it's what it meant it's it's beating Manchester City it's
stopping Manchester City winning the double it's stopping Manchester City in fact winning the
double double and he did that and every single time you think that it's over for ten hog every
single time you think that the players have given up on him or whatever they never have
exactly what the debate is this week is obviously you point into the fact that the money is spent
over 600 million in three uh three summers I believe it is obviously you point to the fact
that he has won back-to-back trophies so it is a debate that will rumble on uh Jose Mourinho
just very quickly easy he's a jewel in the crown he's a jewel in the crown they just they just got
the timing wrong they just got the time they just got the timing wrong again you've got to remember
that Jose Mourinho took that Manchester United team that felt like they were in quite a difficult
place he took them to Sweden and they beat Ajax in a European final like that's that's amazing
I don't know when we all became so on the league cup of silverware yeah yeah and I think exactly
silverware is ultimately the main thing on this list I think and then I don't think Jose is now
what he was I think his time has come and gone as it happens to all of us but I think that
of this list he was the one that was able to come into a quite challenging environment and
get things done okay so there is confirmation of who Spencer and Rory agree are the best five
managers since Sir Alex Ferguson let us know what you think of that I think Joe disagreed with a
couple of those selections based on your body language but let us know what you think at home
