What Questions Should Mental Health Research Answer?

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
Hi, I'm Craig and I'm the co-host of the MQ Open Mind podcast.
On behalf of my co-host, Professor Rory O'Connor, I want to say thank you so much
for watching the first half of season three.
We hope you were able to gain a further insight into the world of mental health research
whilst understanding a little bit about yourself and those around you.
For this very special episode of MQ Open Mind,
here are the questions that our guests would love mental health research to answer.
Open Mind will return in the autumn and we hope we'll see you again
for more mental health research and more lived experience stories.
Thank you.
Season three began with clinical psychologist and author Dr Martha DeRos Cayado,
where we discussed potential enhancements to CAMHS
and the impact of social media on young people's mental well-being.
So maybe then if we think then about, as this is a research podcast,
we're going to get to your book in a second
because we have some questions around what your book covers
and how that links to parenting and so on.
But before we get there, can you tell us a bit about,
so you've been grounding in research and you've said you have this passion for research.
So if you had all the money in the world, what would you think?
And suppose in the field that you're at,
really interested in paediatrics, family systems and so on,
what are the big research questions that you would like to address?
I've got two in my mind, but they're so different to each other.
So I'll start with one that I've always had or not had,
but there isn't enough research on siblings.
Like there just simply is not.
And when you work with child mental health,
you inevitably, if you work with one child, you work with the whole system.
And by the system, I mean the whole family.
You work with mum and dad and their siblings.
And if you work in paediatrics in a health related field,
I have my whole career, it's very obvious that siblings get impacted
by the fact that they have a brother or a sister who is unwell in some way.
Either because parents' focus of attention and time is taken from them,
because of course they have physical needs to look after,
and or for like anxiety about their sibling,
worry about what's going to happen to them when they come to hospital,
when they have an inpatient appointment, all those sorts of things.
And it's really not very well understood,
the impact that it has on siblings, like siblings who are OK.
There isn't really any good research looking at quality of life
for these siblings that would help, I think, psychologists like me
think about what are the services that are, what's the service gap?
Like what are we missing in these children?
And would it have to be somewhere like at school?
Would it have to be that like other members of our society?
Again, if we think systemically, you know, who are the adults
who can provide the support and care or meet the gap for these children?
And I think often these children have other mental health issues and issues,
such as school refusal, such as anger, such as low mood, such as anxiety.
And sometimes because the other adults in this child's world,
whether it's a teacher or I don't know, it could be a sports coach or something,
only see this child as a well child.
They're not really considering the impact that their sick sibling has.
And I know from families I've worked with
that not everybody shares that one of their children is really unwell.
So unless you know that child, you might not know
what the stresses are on the family.
And for me, there is just a huge, like empty space for sibling research.
That isn't looked into, I feel, very well.
And we used to run sibling groups in our hospital to try and fill some kind of gap.
But again, I feel like it was we were muddling at how to set them up.
Yeah, because I was curious on that because I agree it's an important area.
And I'm just thinking in my own family, one of my brothers has
one of their children has a life limiting illness.
And you can see from far the impact, of course, on
the siblings.
And to my knowledge, there's no the support that they've had
hasn't been through a clinical service necessarily on the sibling,
but through other charitable organizations, which and I think there is such a gap.
In March, we spoke to counseling psychologist and author Dr. Chloe Paidusa-Smith,
where we explained the process of grief and trauma on your mental health,
the truth about the five stages of grief and finding the light after a loss.
So moving on, then, Chloe, then, so this is a sort of mental health research podcast.
We've covered a breadth of topics, and we'll come back to
the sort of your book shortly and how that's come about and so on.
What would be helpful, though, is to think about,
so if you had all the money in the world, and somebody said, he writes,
what's the key research question in this sort of broad grief field
that we should be addressing?
And maybe similar in terms of your over the last number of years,
are there key advances in sort of the world of grief in terms of this evidence base?
And I suppose because as somebody who works in suicide prevention,
there's very complicated situation, people who are bereaved by suicide.
And obviously, there's different models or more tailored models,
I've certainly come across trying to understand grief in that context
compared to other traumatic deaths or deaths more generally.
So maybe I know that was two or three things there.
First of all, what do you see is if you had all the money in the world,
what would be your priority research question?
I don't think we can actually do this, but the answer I want,
sorry, I'm going about it a slightly different way is,
what is actually the key factor which means some people become so clinically unwell
as a result of trauma that all the good therapy in the world can feel inaccessible?
Nobody really knows what causes it.
There are different, as you know, various theories.
And I think I'd like to know that.
Is there something that we're missing?
Because my approach is always holistic.
And thinking about what you were saying earlier about advances,
the neuroimaging studies, particularly the work that Mary Francis O'Connor is doing in the US
is so, so brilliant, so interesting.
And I do refer to it in my book, looking at the neuroscience of grief
and how it does actually impact people on that sort of neurochemical level
and how we can support that as clinicians and psychologists and therapists.
That I'm really fascinated by.
But do we know anything? No, that's a great suggestion.
On average, we spend a third of our life at work.
So it's very important for our mental health to be supported in the workplace.
We spoke to the CEO of PeopleForward, Georgie Mack,
and Head of Data Analysis and Insight, Dr. Kate Duckworth,
to discuss the Building Mentally Healthy Workplace report
and understanding the truth about burnout.
And one of the questions, Craig, that I think you asked us to think about,
which is, you know, what answer do you wish research could provide?
And one of the things that I wish is that employers,
if we could research into why organisations don't do more in this space,
given the impact on the bottom line, I would love to get my head around that.
I constantly think about that.
And I think maybe it's just because organisations,
they've just got by in the past.
And maybe they're just used to functioning
in terms of when it comes to the energy of their people,
just in a very mediocre way.
We're just very used to mediocrity.
That's my little pet theory I'm trotting out on this.
And I think you were saying earlier about, you know,
we would like to think that people and businesses act morally,
that you should want to have a healthy workplace
and where people flourish and thrive.
And so there's a sort of moral case to act.
But all too often, that's quite a dangerous and scary thing to do.
Once you know how many people in your organisation
or the proportion of people in your organisation
who are at risk of burnout,
then you have to do something about it.
So looking in the mirror is quite an uncomfortable thing to do in many respects.
But when you think about,
when we sort of put the numbers a bit more kind of starkly of saying
somebody who's at high risk of burnout
costs an organisation 11 times more
than somebody who's got manageable levels of stress,
measured in terms of their likelihood of leaving,
their presenteeism,
so their loss in productivity,
their absenteeism rates,
they cost 11 times more.
That's up to 120,000 pounds.
People who are at high risk of burnout
are seven times more likely to leave an organisation
than somebody who's at manageable levels of stress.
And so when there's a business case,
we would like to think people would act on the moral case.
But what we're trying to also highlight to people
is that good business is good business.
If you've got a good business,
it's good for you and it's good for your people.
Yeah, I know the economic case is so stark,
but as you say,
if you're not convinced by the moral case,
sometimes it is easier,
depending who the audience is,
to make the economic case as well.
Kate, just on the question that Georgie also already answered.
So what would you say is the big question
we should be addressing in mental health and workplace?
It's almost the kind of the flip side of that.
It's the valuing of good research.
It's measuring it properly and robustly
and with valid assessments
and not just gathering data for data's sake,
but gathering good data that will help you to understand
what's happening in an organisation
and being able to use that
rather than just tick box exercises
of make them fill in this and make them fill in this.
Employees don't want to fill in 101 different questionnaires
and nothing's going to change.
People know when workplaces are difficult
and it's really tackling those kinds of issues.
But it's more, yeah, I think the reverse of it,
that people to value.
I mean, I would say that I'm the data geek, right?
So the research matters and measuring it
and measuring it over time
and seeing how it changes
and understanding it properly
is the way we advance our understanding
and having a good solid evidence base.
Well, I think that's a really positive message
and a really important one.
And one of the things I take from your conclusions
in the report is, I mean, you've a bolded headline,
which is the good news is that by monitoring the data,
doing all this analysis,
then you've got the employers can do so much to solve it.
So it's not as if it's a powerless situation.
It's economically makes sense
and it's within that domain,
that control of organisations.
To discuss the Mental Health Act and his work at NHS,
we spoke to Regis Professor of Psychiatry
at King's College London,
Professor Sir Simon Resley,
who also explored the process
of reviewing mental health legislation
and his research on Gulf War veterans.
In terms of the unanswered questions though,
because we're a research podcast,
so I'm keen to see what don't we know
that you wish we didn't know.
Well, I think what we don't know, we won't know,
was because the first I'd heard about the war was in 1991.
The first, I'd been in the press,
but the first time I'd met anyone
and spoken to them was in 1994.
Already three years had passed
and we didn't start the research until 95, six
and there were no records.
The records keeping was awful,
wasn't electronic in those days.
So the first thing I would have said is,
for God's sake, keep records.
Don't get rid of records, which they did.
And that led to all sorts of conspiracy theories.
And I think that there will be this gap in knowledge
that won't be filled.
I mean, we eliminated a lot of possibilities,
but we were left with a smaller number,
which will never be sorted out now.
And the other thing was how research was so important
was that we were able the next time
to kind of show very early on what wasn't happening.
There wasn't an increase in cancer,
that the vaccines in the end,
although a lot of suspicion was on them for good reasons,
in the end, because we gave the same vaccines in Iraq,
were safe, short-term side effects,
but didn't create long-term illness
and another kind of potential villains
we were able to eliminate.
And so it was then the main focus
ended up being on mental health,
the psychological and emotional cost
to people, families, et cetera,
because the other issues had either not arisen,
or we had the requisite data to say,
look, this isn't what's happening.
And there was no repeat of Gulf War Syndrome.
There was no Iraq War Syndrome.
And to this day, that's fascinating.
Yeah, absolutely.
Although when we tell the military this,
I remember General Sir Mike Jackson,
who was a very famous figure then,
I said, we showed him the day,
said, so history has not repeated itself.
There isn't an Iraq War Syndrome.
He said, excellent.
So we did our job.
Well done, chaps.
Stood up and left.
And I was about to say, isn't that interesting?
Wouldn't you like to know why?
He'd gone.
Yeah, they're not curious about those things.
He just wanted to make sure
that it hadn't happened on his watch.
And you've given him the right answer.
We've given him the right answer.
Absolutely, yeah.
And they're great for things like that,
because when we found, for example,
that the reserves were getting
more mental health problems than the regulars,
we told them this is what we'd found.
We had it accepted in the Lancet.
So we gave them a copy in advance
because everybody, politicians,
everybody hates being sandbagged on the day.
So we said, look, this is the paper.
It's coming out in six weeks time.
And they said, okay.
And then, so we then had, you know,
did all the morning press conferences,
which I have to say I like.
Then, I can't remember who the Secretary of State was.
One of them stood up in the afternoon,
welcome new research from King's Coalition announced,
and we're going to open a new programme
of mental health support for reservists.
And, you know, you don't get that response in the NHS.
You've never had that in your career.
You've published a paper in the morning.
And in the afternoon, they say, right, sorted.
This is what we're going to do, gentlemen.
It always was gentlemen, by the way.
Thank God, if everything was as easy as that.
I know, I know.
But then when they don't want to do something,
nothing will persuade them to do it.
In April, we spoke to the Head of the School
of Academic Psychiatry, Professor Alan Young,
where he explained the common misconceptions
about mood disorders and how jet lag can affect your mood.
I think, you know, you shouldn't be looking at drugs
or pharmacotherapy on their own.
They should always be combined
or at least controlled for studies.
So the, what you might call the psychotherapeutic
or the psychological approach
in bipolar disorder is extremely important.
The best evidence, in my view,
treatment is what's called psychoeducation.
And that's really, I mean,
that originally came from other branches of medicine.
I think it originally started in TB treatment,
but as did many psychotherapists.
But the psychoeducation was pioneered
by the Barcelona Group, by Colón and Vieta.
Interestingly, there's, you know,
a number of psychoeducational sessions
that look at the nature of illness,
triggers, early warning signals,
physical health, and so on and so forth.
This has been shown to reduce relapse rate
over a long period.
It's actually been shown
to improve adherence to medication.
One of the interesting wrinkles
is that it's much better in a group format,
which I think can be online.
The work was all done before all the groups went online.
And that's because it's not all
about a didactic delivery of information.
Because in, of course, the group,
people will get challenged
by other people with lived experience.
So in one of our groups,
there was someone said,
well, you know, I just don't think
bipolar disorder is a proper illness.
You know, I'm not taking these meds, you know.
And we very often find that the first few years,
and sometimes tragically longer than that,
the illness, people deny,
they want to, you know, not have it
because it's somehow intangible,
except when they get ill.
But one of the other members of the group said,
well, I'm bipolar,
but I'm also HIV positive,
and I'm on medication for that.
If I look at the figures,
the outcome for the bipolar
is possibly even worse than being HIV positive now.
So why wouldn't I take the recommended treatment for both?
And that was a very powerful challenge.
And it was much more powerful coming from that person
than it would have been from the doctor,
the nurse, the therapist, the psychologist, or whatever.
So I think that's a bit of a clue
as to why the group format.
Now, there are some places
where you can't do the group format.
Some cultures don't necessarily want to have it.
But I think psychoeducation is extremely important.
It's best combined with optimized medication,
which is what we do in our service.
I think the other treatments,
there's not a huge amount of research on it,
but my view is that the other psychological treatments
are perhaps best done in a bespoke way,
more targeted to individuals
who you think they might benefit.
So a very good example is David Miklovits,
who's a friend of mine in Los Angeles,
a psychologist that does work on
what he calls family-focused psychotherapy for bipolar.
And I never really understood this
until I happened to sit up the back of a bus with David
at a conference going to a dinner,
and he explained it all to me.
And essentially, if you're trying to do psychoeducation
with a 16-year-old in Los Angeles,
you're saying you've got to have a regular routine,
you've got to avoid destabilized influences,
this, that, and the other.
And they're living in a household
where no one is doing that.
You've got to go in and intervene with the whole family.
So David has got evidence showing
that this works in that particular context.
Jan Scott did a great study of CBT in bipolar,
which overall didn't come out as being effective.
But if you look at the subgroups,
the group who were earlier in the illness,
who were more what you might think of being intact,
especially cognitively,
cognitively I mean, but neuropsychologically,
they seem to really benefit from it,
whereas people who were earlier in the illness actually didn't.
And there's other things like
interpersonal social rhythm therapy.
I mean, we're doing some work with-
Hold on, what's that?
I've never heard of that.
Interpersonal social rhythm therapy.
Well, lots of people think bipolar disorder
is very related to disruption of your circadian rhythm.
When you get older, your sleep goes off and so on.
I thought, sorry Alan,
I thought you said social rhythm
when you said circadian rhythm.
Well, hold on, I did.
Oh, you did, you did, you did, right.
I thought you had something to do with dance or something.
Well, yeah.
Well, we've got a project with dance with Parkinson's,
but that's another topic.
But one of the best triggers for,
not the best,
one of the most powerful triggers
for people with bipolar disorder getting manic is jet lag.
So years ago, they did a study looking at
people who arrived at Heathrow and were manic.
And of course, it's much more coming from the West to the East
than coming from the East to the West.
That's because coming from the West to the East
is much more disruptive.
It's easier for us to have our days length.
So I'm sure you've noticed this Rory,
but when you go to our conference in America,
it's a bit easier to go there.
Coming back is more disruptive
because your rhythms get chaotically disturbed.
The group in Pittsburgh,
there's a great history of mood disorders research in Pittsburgh,
which of course does have a strong link with Scotland,
with Andrew Carnegie, you'll know Rory.
Ellen Frank and David Kupfer did something called
interpersonal social rhythm therapy,
which is all about regularizing your rhythm
so you don't disrupt them and therefore bring on an episode.
Although we see them regularly in the news,
how do journalists manage their mental health?
To discuss this, we spoke to BBC broadcaster,
author and counseling psychologist,
Dr. Sian Williams,
about moving from journalism to psychology
and how change can create endless opportunities.
If we were able to give you all the money in the world,
what do you think is the sort of
what we should be investing in that?
And what do you think are one or two key priorities?
What don't we know we need to know?
Any aspect of mental health, it's up to you.
Gosh, that's a huge field, isn't it?
I could choose loads,
but I will just choose.
As a mother of five,
so I've got children ranging from the age of 15 to 32,
so I've been mothering teenagers for three decades,
I think, and I've seen how the challenges
to teens' mental health, adolescents' mental health,
have increased over the years
because I've had teenagers in that 30-year period,
across that 30-year period.
I think what we need to look at
is how we protect adolescents' mental health
because they are going through
this extraordinary change in their brain
with that increased myelination and brain development
that happens during adolescence.
They're a lot more likely to take risks.
We know that their prefrontal cortex,
all that stuff isn't quite developed enough
to an adult stage,
and it's a difficult and complex world out there
and a lot more uncertain than it was
in terms of what jobs they end up doing,
the social media pressures, et cetera, et cetera.
So I guess I would like more research
to go into how best to look after our young people.
Yeah, that's a great suggestion.
I think there's no doubt in this world
that irrespective of which statistics you look at,
young people's mental health,
even before the pandemic,
has been just getting worse and worse, sadly,
and we just don't know the right answer.
There's no simple answer for why that's the case.
I agree that's a great answer to try and understand that
and hopefully then mitigate the risk.
Okay, that's a good suggestion.
In this episode,
we spoke to Professor of the School of Psychology
at the University of Nottingham,
Professor Ellen Townsend,
about the issues young people may face online
and why lived experience in research is so vital.
How does social media impact young people
differently to older people?
That's a really, really good question.
I don't think we know the answer to that.
The truth of the matter,
obviously, a young person can be anything from,
let's say, 11 to 25,
and that's the kind of age range
that we are exploring at the moment.
How things hit with an 11-year-old
might be very different to a 25-year-old,
and then, as you say, someone who's older.
Now, the additional risk for young people is
their exposure is happening at a time
that's really important developmentally,
so particularly in those mid-to-late teens,
which incidentally is the time of life
that the incidence of self-harm skyrockets,
starts to really increase,
and indeed suicides,
they kind of go up in consonance.
This is a time when your brain is reforming itself.
So, you know,
by a process called pruning,
connections that are being used get strengthened,
and those that get cut away,
your brain is literally kind of reshaping itself.
So that's one really important difference,
I think, Craig,
that you've got this really important developmental phase
that this technology is kind of getting in amongst.
Roy, I don't know if you wanted to come in there.
No, I agree entirely.
The only thing I would add is
we also know is that in that period of adolescence,
the young person is much more sensitive
to rejection, to shame,
or we often describe as social signals in the environment,
negative social signals in the environment.
So then it's not a direct consequence of social media,
but we don't know for certain,
but it could be then if you're,
I mean, I often talk about that psychological thin skin,
and it's particularly thin in adolescence.
And then if you're encountering,
maybe in a social media context,
bullying or whatever,
then you're more likely to be affected.
But of course,
that's not just in your online world,
that's in your everyday world as well.
But given we know that you're really at that age,
adolescents are so focused on social approval,
especially from their peers,
and the converse is when that's approval
is not approval, but it's harms,
and you're much more likely to be affected
would be my hunch.
Well, that's what the evidence would say,
but we need to know more
because we don't know whether that added sensitivity
has any long-term impacts
or whatever those impacts are.
And I suppose that's where the Digital Youth Project
is trying to build some of that knowledge.
It's a really important point,
especially about the kind of the peer impacts as well.
So we know that under risky conditions,
adolescents will behave very differently than adults.
If peers are present,
it's not an effect that we see in older adults,
but for adolescents,
they would rather do something as a risk to their health
or their psychological wellbeing
to avoid the social risk.
So there's that kind of important dimension to it as well.
To discuss the impact of services
for children's mental health,
we spoke to Professor Helen Minnis,
who also explained how to support families
before children are neglected and abused.
So we always ask everybody this question as well is,
so before we get to take-homes,
so if you had sort of all the money in the world type thing,
what would you prioritise?
What do you think is a big question
we should be trying to answer?
In your case, obviously with infant mental health.
What would I ask?
I would ask, how can we best support parents
so that children don't get abused and neglected
in the first place?
And actually, that's a huge question.
And it would really require a big programme of research
because...
A huge government intervention.
Well, once you've got the answers,
but I don't think we know the answer to that question.
I think all of the research that I've done
has really shown me,
and it's really got me to a point
where I think we've got to stop blaming parents
for children's problems.
Actually, virtually every child, every parent,
even if they are actually abusing
and neglecting their child,
99.99999% of them are trying to do their best.
Some of them are mucking up.
So how can we change that?
We need to get in much earlier.
We need to understand about how villages support a child
because I really think in the West,
we've forgotten that it takes a village to...
It takes a village to raise a child.
What is the role of aunties and grandparents?
What's the role of alloparents,
as the evolutionary biologists call them,
in supporting parents to support children?
How do we support parents whose child
is more difficult to look after than other children?
And that's something I think we really now do understand.
And that's one of the reasons
we wrote that BioExpo paper
is because actually all of those areas of science
show that no two children are the same.
And what that means is that
some children are easy to look after.
Some children are really difficult to look after.
And those parents will be tearing their hair out.
But that's a symptom rather than a cause
and we need to be supporting those parents.
How do we identify those parents?
How do we reduce the stigma?
How do we develop services
so they can walk through the door?
It's a huge area of research,
but that's what I would put money on.
No, that's a great suggestion.
You say pretty vast
and once we get the answer to those questions.
But I do think there's a bit of...
Even before we know the answer,
one of the things I've been saying
and really frustrates me is
over the last 14 years in the United Kingdom,
all we've done is take away support from early years.
And so we know if you put more support in early on,
of course, it's going to protect and help those parents
and help out those crucial periods.
100%. I mean, I don't know if you saw,
we co-chaired a report
by the Academy of Medical Sciences recently.
That's right, yeah.
It was so fantastic that they thought
that that was an important area of science
because we are really building up problems
for the future.
They found research that shows
that if we don't focus on the health of the under fives,
we're probably going to be costing ourselves
about 16 billion a year.
I mean, you're so right.
And it really upsets me that we live in a country
where children routinely now are going to bed hungry.
You know, it's absolute craziness
and that is going to bite all of us back.
It really is.
The latest statistics is that 20% of the population
came out I think last month or this month even,
pretty recently anyway,
about 20% of the population are living in poverty.
Deep poverty, yeah.
Deep poverty.
And I can't remember,
we translate that into absolute numbers of kids.
It's thousands upon thousands upon thousands.
And we're allegedly the sixth wealthiest country
in the world.
It's a moral outrage is what it is.
As the UK was gearing up for the general election,
we spoke to podcaster, journalist
and political strategist Alistair Campbell
to talk about the political nature of mental health support
and living with a mental health condition
whilst working in a highly stressful industry.
So if somebody said to you, right,
you're back in power and down the street,
you're going to invest in mental health research,
what would you see as the priorities
for mental health research?
Have I got an unlimited budget or not?
You've unlimited budget, yes.
Just for you.
Well, first of all, I would set up an organisation
that would be quite small
and which would do a really detailed audit
of all the mental health services in the world
and of all the serious mental health research in the world.
Because I don't,
even though we've got that sort of American so-called bible
about mental illness,
I'm still not convinced that we spread best practice
far less in mental health than we do in physical health,
I would say.
So in a sense, I think this maybe is a role for MQ,
but I think that that research of the research
we've already got is fundamental.
I think then I would like to see the scientific community
persuaded that it is in their interests economically
as well as morally, as you said earlier,
to understand the enormous demand that there is
for treatments and cures of various mental health conditions.
So have much better public-private partnership
between public and private sector
on the medical research side of things.
And then I think I'd like to see real mental health support
of a kind of model, I think, in schools
on what we used to do with classroom assistants.
People are just part of the class, part of the furniture,
but they're part teaching,
they're part mental health observers,
but they're also trained in the field.
And to have that in every school,
I'd like to see, probably on a voluntary basis,
and by the way, that monitored for the purposes of research,
what works and what doesn't, for what the trends are.
Give you an example.
We've persuaded ourselves as a culture and as a society,
most advanced societies have,
that social media is one of the reasons
for this sort of epidemic of anxiety
amongst young women in particular.
And it may be true.
It may be true.
But we don't know because we make assumptions.
We don't track things.
We don't monitor things.
We don't do the hard grind of checking things.
So I'd like to see that.
And then I would particularly like to see,
I'd like to see a tie up between our prison services
and prison services in places like Norway, Denmark,
where they have a very different approach
and see if we couldn't find ways of analysing
how we could bring that more rehabilitative
and successful approach into our prison service.
Well, I agree with all of that.
On the last point,
was it Dara McGarvey did a documentary recently on the BBC
and he actually highlighted some of those examples
from Scandinavia.
But on the other two points,
really, they were great suggestions.
On the social media,
actually, stuff we and many others would say,
yeah, we have to understand the role.
But the relationship between social media and mental health,
it's only one factor involved in the mix.
And actually, one of our previous episodes
of this podcast, we had Lucy Foulkes on it.
And Lucy Foulkes from London has done work on this
and is continuing to do work on that.
And then on your first point, Alistair,
I love the idea of mapping out the services
and the treatments.
So MQ, we have done something like that.
So I co-led this work,
which was published in Lancet Psychiatry last year,
which we brought together 40 experts
from around the world.
And it was looking at how do you prevent premature mortality
associated with mental illness and suicide.
And actually, we tried to do that,
but the bit we didn't do was map the services.
But we looked to see what's the answer, what works,
and let's try and get it into practice.
So they're great suggestions.
In July, we spoke to the Prudence Trust Research Fellow
at King's College London, Dr. Josephine Breedville,
to discuss preventing the onset of depression
and anxiety in young people
and the price of ambition in mental health research.
What do you see as the number one priority
for mental health research?
In this context, let's focus on young people, maybe.
If you had all the money in the world type thing,
what would you invest in and why?
Well, first of all, more money.
I recently read a report, I think it was from MQ,
that 3.9% of research funding goes to prevention.
And of course, I would focus on prevention.
That's my area of interest.
So if I had all the money and all the funds in the world,
I would try and really try to understand
how do kind of individuals respond
to preventative interventions and how do they work?
Can we better understand,
okay, we offer someone an intervention or an approach,
but what actually makes it effective for this person?
What are the processes that change
during these interventions?
And then a bit more of another more lofty aim
is then to have sustainable effects.
So to understand how we can get these approaches
to kind of last longer and also sustainable implementation.
So how can we actually get some of the approaches
that may work or don't work,
which we will hopefully find out
that kind of personalization earlier,
but how can we get these approaches implemented?
Because I'm surprised that sometimes
when I speak to colleagues,
there's still some hesitancy around
where do we actually deliver preventative interventions
and what is the most optimal framework for doing that?
So I'd be really interested in finding a solution for that.
So thinking about settings then,
so what's your hunch though, an informed hunch?
Where would we get our best bang for a buck?
Which setting would be most optimal?
Yeah, I think so one setting is online,
but I think from what I, you know,
from my conversations,
I think schools is probably a good place to get prevention,
but the challenge is kind of when you go 18 to 25,
the young adult group, where do you go there?
So it has to be a multitude of ways.
So schools maybe for children
who are in schools up until that age,
and then for young adults,
we can think of universities,
but also online, workplaces.
So I don't have like the one,
and I think that's also the challenge with prevention.
It's kind of in many settings in a way.
But if you think about the literature,
the mental health literature,
and I'm thinking about it
from the sort of suicide self-harm side where we work in,
and we know lots about mental health
up to your teens and 18s,
up to 18 say,
and then there's this big gap actually,
there's this huge gap in our knowledge
and understanding really in-depth work
on that 18 to 25, 18 to 30.
And actually a few years ago,
we did a national survey in Scotland,
and it was the first of its kind ever.
And I don't think a similar study
has ever been conducted in England even,
trying to map the mental health of young adults.
Now there's, as we know then in England and Wales,
you've got the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey,
whatever every seven, eight years, whatever it is.
But that's not large enough for you
to get a fine grained understanding of young people
because it's across the lifespan.
So yeah, no, I agree.
It's a huge gap actually
in our knowledge and understanding.
