How the U.S. insurance system makes finding mental health care difficult
2 Video Views·Sep 2, 2024
More than one in five adults in the U.S. live with a mental illness, but only about half receive
treatment. Many struggle to find a therapist that will accept their insurance. An NPR ProPublica
report aimed to figure out the reasons why. Stephanie Sy has that story. The investigation
found that many therapists who initially join insurance networks end up leaving because of
difficulties getting reimbursed by insurers. That leaves a lot of patients paying out of pocket
or being unable to access care. For more, I'm joined by Annie Waldman, who covers health care
at ProPublica. Annie, thanks so much for joining the NewsHour. So for this report, you and your
colleagues interviewed, I understand, hundreds of psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists,
and you did find that it's insurers who often ultimately decide the length of care and
ultimately who gets covered treatment. Is that right? Yeah, that's right. In the most simple
terms, we really wanted to understand why is it that even when you have insurance, it can be so
hard to access mental health treatment. And what people don't realize is that insurance companies
play a big role in this and have a big say in how much treatment you get, how often you get treatment,
how frequently you get treatment, and what kind of treatment you get. And providers also told us
that they experienced a lot of red tape dealing with insurers, delayed and low payments, audits,
and reviews. Therapists really told us that they tried to stay in network. They are committed to
their patients, are committed to delivering mental health care. But these practices from insurance
companies are squeezing them out. So there's red tape, there's bureaucracy in having to file these
claims, and there's also what you describe as below market rate reimbursement from insurers,
therapists that describe having their rates not shift in years. And obviously, we all know
inflation's been a factor, but that reimbursement rate has stayed the same. Yeah, that's right.
In a lot of our interviews, therapists told us about how their rates have been largely stagnant
and notoriously low. Therapists on average earn about $98 for a 45-minute session of therapy
from commercial insurers. But if they went out of network, they could get doubled that. So a lot of
providers say that it's just not sustainable for them to stay in network and get these rates that
are really low, in which all their expenses of their office, their own health insurance,
they can't keep up with them. So there are also many claims that get denied on the basis of what
the industry calls medical necessity. You spoke to a therapist who experienced that. Here's what
Anna Denodo, who provides therapy for children with autism, had to say. They started to say that
the amount of time we spend with the patient wasn't supported by the documentation.
And so it's things like that where they say, well, you're not demonstrating medical necessity,
but then they won't give you what the rubric is for medical necessity.
Annie, in disputes over what is medically necessary, I understand that there are not
clear guidelines in mental health care the way there may be in physical health care. Is that
the crux of the problem? Yeah, the term medical necessity is frequently used by insurers to deny
claims. Many people assume that if your mental health provider believes that you need a certain
type or length of treatment, that they are the expert and they should have the final say. But
our reporting found that's not entirely true, that insurance companies generally face few
limitations on how they define what kind of care is medically necessary. And they sometimes even
create their own internal standards instead of relying on the ones developed by nonprofits
or professional medical societies. And these standards can be used to challenge diagnoses
or treatment plans, which can lead to denials of care. You also report instances when the therapists
were told by insurers to spend less time with patients who the therapists, as you call them,
the experts, felt needed long-term care. Again, here's what Anna Denoto said.
It's really concerning and unethical in many ways, in my opinion, because it's like saying to a
surgeon, we're going to give you four hours to be able to do open heart surgery and sorry, not
sorry, like if you can't finish, like we don't know what to tell you. Anna Denoto was not alone.
You interviewed dozens of therapists, some of whom felt that insurers were reducing care for
patients who were even on the edge of self-harm, even suicide. So what impact did the therapists
describe these insurance policies could have on their patients? Yeah, you know, what's so striking
from what Anna Denoto experienced is that under the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act,
which is also known as MHPAEA, it's a federal law that requires insurance companies to provide
the same access to mental health and physical health care. But we heard numerous stories from
patients and providers about how mental health care was discriminated against and often scaled
back in ways that medical care may not be. You know, for example, if you have cancer and your
doctor says you need chemotherapy, an insurance company likely wouldn't say, well, you can only
have that chemotherapy if you first try a less aggressive, less intensive, less costly medication
first and show that it doesn't work. But with mental health care, we heard stories of scaling
back care for acute disorders, often someone in the midst of a mental health crisis who needed
intensive treatment, and then the insurer will only improve coverage for a less intensive treatment
first. Such limitation means patients can risk bodily harm or even death through overdose or
suicide. What do insurance companies tell you by way of explaining these reimbursement and care
issues? Yeah, we reached out to several insurance companies for our reporting and they told us that
they are committed to ensuring access to mental health providers. They also emphasize that their
plans are in compliance with state and federal laws. Insurers also said that they have practices
in place to make sure reimbursement rates reflect the market value to support and retain providers,
which they're continually trying to recruit. But that doesn't match up with what we heard from
therapists or the previous analyses that policy experts have done and mental health advocates have
done. Annie Waldman with ProPublica. Thank you so much for joining the NewsHour and sharing your
reporting with us. Thank you for having me.

