Most cities in California have been impacted by homelessness. Recently, a Supreme Court ruling granted local governments the authority to clean up encampments. We sat down with Los Angeles City Councilwoman Traci Park to discuss what this ruling means for her city and how the city plans to navigate this issue.
“There are a lot of unanswered questions, and as a matter of policy, we need to get it right. Otherwise, I'm concerned that problems here in LA could actually get worse,” says Park.
We also spoke with Dane White, mayor of Escondido, one of the first cities in California to ban homeless encampments. He shares his personal experiences with homelessness and how they shaped his approach to policy.
“I'm of the mindset that jail is not good rehab for people on drugs, but we've created a situation where there are no alternatives. I was given the choice: jail or rehab,” says White.
Additionally, we talked to Greg Anglea, CEO of Interfaith Community Services, an organization that assists over 20,000 homeless individuals annually. Join us as we explore the future of homelessness in the Golden State and whether the Supreme Court decision could be a turning point in addressing the crisis.
Most cities in California have been impacted by homelessness and now California cities can clean
homeless encampments based on the recent Supreme Court ruling. Today we sit down with Los Angeles
City Councilwoman Tracy Park to discuss what this ruling means for L.A. and how the city plans to
navigate this issue. Will it get worse or will it get better in the city of Los Angeles? I think
there are a lot of unanswered questions and as a matter of policy we need to get it right
otherwise I'm concerned that problems here in L.A. are actually going to get worse. We also speak
with Dane White, mayor of Escondido, one of the first cities in California to ban homeless
encampments, who shares his personal experiences being homeless and how these experiences led him
to come up with these policies. I'm of the mindset that jail is not a good rehab for people on drugs
but what we've done is created a situation where there's no alternatives. I was given the alternative
jail or rehab. We also talked to Greg Angela, president of Interfaith Community Services,
an organization that helps over 20,000 homeless people every year. He'll share his perspective
on how this ban on encampments could impact the homeless people on the streets. If we say morally
it's wrong for anybody to be on the streets we can absolutely reduce and potentially someday
eliminate homelessness in California. Make sure to stay tuned because there's a lot of interesting
perspectives in this episode and this can tell you where homelessness is headed in California.
And will this Supreme Court ruling end homelessness in California? I'm Siamak Waremi, welcome to
California Insider. Tracy it's great to have you on, welcome. Finally, I've been looking forward
to sitting down. Excellent, we want to talk to you about a very important topic for Californians,
homelessness, and recently there has been a Supreme Court ruling that allows the cities in
California to clean up homeless encampments. Can you tell us more about this ruling? So the case that
you're referring to is the Grants Pass decision that recently came out of the U.S. Supreme Court,
but really to talk about it we need to back up to 2018. And that was when the Federal Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals issued its decision in the Martin v. City of Boise case. And there the Ninth Circuit
held for the first time that it would violate the Federal Eighth Amendment Prohibition Against
Cruel and Unusual Punishment to prosecute someone for sitting, sleeping, or lying in a public place
unless the local government first offered shelter. As a result of that decision in 2018,
cities across California had to suspend their local municipal camping ordinances.
And if you'll remember, that's right about the moment in time that we started to see the explosion
of homeless encampments here, not just in California, but all over the entire western
United States. Cities like Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Diego were all impacted
by that decision. Then a couple of years ago the court doubled down on it when it decided Grants
pass. And now finally, five, six years later, both of those cases have been overruled by the United
States Supreme Court, which has now definitively clarified that local government does in fact
have the right to regulate encampments in order to protect public health, safety, and welfare.
The Federal Eighth Amendment is not implicated, and we are not legally obligated to provide
shelter when there is a legitimate justification to clear an encampment like that. So while the
recent Supreme Court decision opens the door and gives cities more flexibility and more latitude
in addressing these public encampments, it doesn't actually mandate that they do or change anything.
So here in the city of Los Angeles we now have an opportunity to revisit some of our approaches
to homelessness, but I think there are a lot of unanswered questions and as a matter of policy
we need to get it right. Otherwise I'm concerned that problems here in LA are actually going to
get worse. So most people might think that this is going to help kind of end the homeless encampments
that we see. Can you tell us why you think it might be otherwise for Los Angeles? Well my concern
is that other cities, especially smaller cities that are a lot more flexible and nimble that can
accomplish things more quickly, are already working on citywide camping bans. And if they
are not addressing the population that's residing on their streets, almost inevitably those folks
will be pushed into the city of Los Angeles. So if we don't address and revise our own policies
and start to tackle this with some urgency coupled with enforcement and regulation of our public
spaces, we are going to end up absorbing what is a regional, statewide, and national problem.
We've already seen that happening for a number of years here, but now with the Grants Pass decision
it could potentially give other cities carte blanche to shove their problems right here to LA.
So for average people in California that they hear about this Supreme Court ruling,
does it mean that their cities have to pass laws or can their cities just go after the encampments?
The burden falls on individual cities to adopt those policies and those regulations that would
address things like sidewalk camping and vehicular dwelling and things like that.
So here in the city of Los Angeles we have certain limited legal tools currently that we can use to
address encampments. We have our city's safe schools and parks ordinance, that's section 4118
of our municipal code, and that allows us to create a buffer zone that prohibits encampments
around certain sensitive uses like schools, parks, daycares, and libraries. I have already
introduced legislation that would expand those covered areas to include environmentally sensitive
habitat areas, our very high fire severity zone, and around our critical infrastructure. We
certainly saw what happened with the fire under the 10 freeway and the very, very real risks of
lost lives and infrastructure because of those types of events. And then on the heels of the
Grants Pass decision itself, I was joined by six of my other colleagues in introducing a motion
calling on our city attorney to review our current approaches to homelessness,
prior settlements, legal settlements that have tied our hands in Los Angeles, as well as pending
litigation related to homelessness, so that we can reevaluate that in light of the clarity that
we now have from the Grants Pass decision. Certainly not all of the leaders here in Los
Angeles agree on what the right thing to do or what the next steps are going to be, but by putting
these motions through and making these efforts, we at least are going to have a conversation about
what needs to be done here in Los Angeles so that we don't become the dumping ground for other cities
and counties and states. So you see that some of the surrounding cities and some of the smaller
cities in California, they're going to pass ordinances to stop encampments in their areas,
and then those encampments will go to the cities that are open to the encampments,
maybe larger cities. So if you guys in the city of LA don't do the camping bans,
what will happen? Well, I think that folks will continue to arrive here from other jurisdictions.
We are going to see a reversion to how bad things were back in 2020 and 2021,
and I know that on the west side of Los Angeles, my constituents in every neighborhood have
experienced circumstances that no community, not here in Los Angeles, not anywhere in California,
should have to put up with because of these encampments. Shootings, stabbings, fires,
environmental degradation. This has gone on long enough, and I am going to be a big proponent
here in the city of Los Angeles of compassionate solutions. I do believe that we need to provide
shelter and interim housing. We do need to continue the production of affordable and
permanent supportive housing, but we also have to have a very honest conversation and acknowledge
the fact we are not going to build our way out of this problem. It would cost us somewhere between
50 and 100 billion dollars just to address the 70 or 75,000 people who are homeless in Los Angeles
County. We don't have those dollars today, we're not going to have them next year, and we're not
going to have them a decade from now. We do need to invest in shelter and our supply of interim
housing and, like I said, affordable housing. For far too long, all of the funding related to
homeless housing production has been tied to housing first theory and harm reduction, where
individuals are not required to get sober, they are not required to engage in the services or the
programming that's being provided to them, and if we don't fix the addiction or the mental health
issues, we're never going to solve the overall problem of homelessness, and if we don't invest
in the addiction recovery to get people well and stabilized and back on their feet, we are going to
be on this merry-go-round to nowhere into perpetuity, and we just can't let that happen, and
now we have a chance to fix it. Now, let's say you guys pass this ordinance and here in Los Angeles
and you guys get the political consensus to do it. Good luck. What would it look like? Are the
jails going to get filled up? What does that picture look like? I don't foresee that happening
here in Los Angeles. Never in the history of our Safe Schools and Parks ordinance has someone
been put in handcuffs and taken to jail just because they were camping and didn't have a place
to go. We've got to be compassionate about this, and we have to recognize that jail isn't the right
solution, but it's not necessarily a million-dollar condo that's the answer either. We've got to have
different kinds of housing to support different populations and levels of need. I think one of
the challenges that we have in Los Angeles and certainly in my council district stems from the
fact that in the past homeless housing interventions have been mismanaged. The story of the Venice
Bridge Home, which opened in 2020, is the perfect example of why so many communities don't trust
local government to solve the problem. Can you tell us what that was? Or to build the housing in the
community, sure. So when the Venice Bridge Home, which was a shelter, interim housing and shelter
for homeless folks, was proposed to the community, it came with the promise that the streets around
the facility were going to be kept safe and clean, that it was going to be used to house people who
were already on the streets in Venice. And unfortunately, pretty much from the day it
opened, it went off the rails. Immediately, the facility was surrounded by about 150 tents.
Calls for service to LAPD skyrocketed, tripled and quadrupled in just a matter of weeks.
And that breach of trust with the community was egregious. And it's something that now for me,
as the new council member for this district, has to work even harder to restore that trust.
So when I took office, getting that particular encampment cleaned up to keep the promise that
had been made to Venice constituents was one of my top priorities. And that was the very
first encampment that we cleared on the west side. That was a joint partnership between me
and Mayor Bass's Inside Safe program, and we are so grateful for that. We have continued that work
all over the district. I didn't need an order from the governor, and I didn't need the Supreme Court
to tell us on the west side of Los Angeles that this was urgent, and that we did actually have
a right to do it. We've done it compassionately, we've done it coupled with offers of interim
housing and services, and we've been very successful at it. But we also have a constant
inflow problem. And there are some things that we really don't talk about very publicly that I think
are important. For example, our beach communities are the literal end of the line. And so when folks
get off transit in Santa Monica at the end of the night, there are dozens of new non-destination
riders who are exiting into our beach community with nowhere to go, no money, no plan, no job.
They're just there. Are they from LA or are they from other states? Sometimes those folks are from
Los Angeles, sometimes they're from points outside of LA and outside of California. Something else
that we don't talk about very often is LAX and how that is a point of entry for homelessness as well.
On any day of the week, you can roam through LAX. So people fly to LAX and then they just...
And we have outreach teams every day on the ground there who are intercepting people who
are getting off of airplanes, no one to pick them up, nowhere to go, no plan, no job. And their
first question is, where can I get housing and resources? And how many people are coming like
that to LA? Do you have any numbers? So I don't buy a LAX off the top of my head. But if you talk
to the mayor of Santa Monica, he will tell you that just through Metro, they're getting about
100 a day. Some of those folks stay in Santa Monica, others wander into Venice and other parts
of Council District 11 on the west side. And it's a really unfair burden and an unfair task
to be working so hard to service the population we already have, to get the people who are already
there on the streets into safer settings, to now have to continually absorb folks-
That are coming from other places. And there are some people who are homeless on the west side
who were living there when they became homeless. But overwhelmingly, the population that we're
dealing with on the streets did not become homeless living on the west side of Los Angeles.
They've migrated there from other places. Now the governor has actually issued a
recommendation. I assume it's a recommendation, it's not anything forced, but he's recommending
for cities to kind of clean up and do what Caltrans has been doing. Do you think other
city leaders would work with you on this? What are your thoughts?
It's been interesting seeing the range of reactions to the governor's order, which,
as you mentioned, really just directs the state to clear encampments off of state property.
It encourages cities to begin the process as well, utilizing best practices that we
already use, that we're already familiar with. But I think the governor is sending a message.
He's setting a tone for what he wants to see here in California. But I'm going to be keeping a close
eye on the resources that they're bringing as they begin clearing their encampments,
because I want to be very clear, shoving it out of a state-owned property in my district
into a city-owned property in my district is not going to fly with me. So this is going to
have to be a collaborative effort. And we have got to have a place for folks to go, shelter,
and we've got to have services. But we also have to have the legal tools now to start forcing the
issues with folks who won't go, who refuse to go. And we see an awful lot of that on the streets too.
How much is that? Do you have any statistics or numbers that people that don't want to take the
housing and they're totally fine being on the streets?
Yeah. So actually, if you read the Grants Pass decision, one of the things that the court
pointed out was the extremely high rates of individuals refusing shelter. In Portland,
that number was almost 70 percent. In Seattle, 60 percent, and nearly 50 percent up in San Francisco.
These are people that doesn't matter what you offer or how many times you ask,
they're not going anywhere. There are also individuals who are too unwell to say yes
when the help is offered. And we need to have legal tools to deal with both. Whether that is
an anti-camping ordinance that gives me the ability to force someone to move or to leave
a certain area. But we also need the legal tools to deal with folks who have the mental health and
addiction issues. You, I'm sure, are aware of SB 43. That was bipartisan legislation out of
Sacramento to expand the definition of gravely disabled in our conservatorship laws. And
unfortunately, only two counties so far, San Luis Obispo and San Francisco, have implemented those
new criteria. Our board of supervisors here in L.A. County elected to defer that for another
couple of years. That is an absolutely essential tool that we need to open necessary pathways to
care for individuals who, frankly, are not well enough to take care of themselves.
Now, Tracy, you are in L.A., you're serving on the council, and you're seeing the people in L.A.,
their reaction to the situation with homelessness. Do you think this type of way of living has
become part of the fabric of L.A.? In a sense, do you think things will change?
I am very hopeful that things will change, and I want to give a lot of credit to our mayor,
Karen Bass, with her signature Inside Safe program. We have greatly expanded the availability of
interim housing. We've been able to make some improvements, and we are, for the first time,
starting to see a drop. So I am hopeful about the future. I don't want people sick and suffering
and living on the streets to be baked into the fabric of our culture here in Los Angeles.
We have an opportunity to course correct on this. There are compassionate, humane ways to do it.
But if we continue to wring our hands and clutch our pearls and claim, well, I can't do it because
of this legal reason, or I'm afraid of a lawsuit over that, we are not going to fix this problem.
And if the county doesn't step up to the plate with the mental health and addiction services
that are going to be necessary, we're never going to get ahead of it. A lot of people look at L.A.
as a global destination and a city with a really big brand across the globe. Do you
think L.A. will come back? In a sense, some of the brand has been damaged over the last few years,
but do you think L.A. will come back to have that brand? Yes, I think L.A. is going to come back,
and I have a few reasons for that. One, I am really confident in our mayor and her focus on this.
She has been a great ally advocating at the federal level. She's been a great partner to us
on the west side. But we also have some really big international world events coming to Los
Angeles. We have the World Cup coming in 2026, and of course, the Olympics will be here in 2028.
Tracy Park, Los Angeles Councilwoman, it was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you so much for having me. We'll see you soon.
To understand how the smaller cities are going to deal with homeless encampment bans after the
Supreme Court ruling, we went to Escondido to meet with the mayor. Escondido was one of the
first cities to ban homeless encampments. This area in Escondido is known as the jungle. It
is the largest and most consistent homeless encampment in the city of Escondido. At any
given time, there's a hundred or more individuals living right down here, and I know it looks a
little bit secluded right here, but as you saw in the drive-in, I mean, it overflows into the bike
path. This portion of Escondido is known as the Escondido Creek Trail. It's actually supposed to
be a family-friendly bike trail and to be used as for transportation, but we actually recommend
people do not use this portion of the trail. And this has been going on, I would say it exploded
around five years ago. It started maybe 10 years ago, but this is the biggest area of concern for
the city of Escondido. The impact to the environmental is absolutely detrimental.
So in a couple of different areas, they have it dammed up to use as showers and bathrooms,
but then more importantly, when it rains, anything that's in there, whether it be a human waste,
condoms, trash, needles, anything like that, immediately just flows straight into the ocean
and it passes through every other city on the way over there. It's an environmentally sensitive area
that is just being absolutely destroyed. On top of that, you know, I get, there's a mobile home
park right over there on the other side of this fence where I have the residents emailing me
pictures of black smoke coming out from under here because they're lighting fires, sometimes three,
four, five different fires in a night. And you worry because not just the mobile home park,
but right across from here is critical infrastructure for the city. It's kind of a
ticking time bomb in multiple ways. So the ordinance specifically mentions, as I said,
environmentally sensitive areas that falls under this. With the amount of people that are here,
it's going to be a lot of work to get everybody out. And we don't want to do it until we can
guarantee them not have a way to get back in. So we're working with an organization right now.
They're going to come in, get it all cleaned up, all the trash and everything, trim all the trees,
do all of that work. And then immediately after that, the city will pay to have it fenced off
with an eight-foot, cut-resistant, climb-resistant fence. What this does in reality is just displaces
people. They're going to move from one place to another and to another. And that's because of an
overall lack of resources like drug treatment facilities, mental health facilities, homeless
shelters, housing, things like that. And you faced homelessness yourself, right? And how does that
experience, because one of the main tasks you have as a mayor is dealing with the homeless situation
in Escondido, right? How does that experience help you in the process you're in now? I get that
question a lot. And I tell everybody that my experience is my experience, and it's not the
same as everybody's. But I do think that my experience with drugs and mental health issues
gives me a unique perspective into what's going on now. So my experience does shape some of the
policy that I introduce here at the city, and it plays a huge role in the strategy. I think
there's two mindsets right now. One is that the majority of people on the streets
are down on their luck, and if we just give them money and needles and safe smoking supplies
and a place to sleep, then once we meet all those needs, they'll make the decision to get help.
I don't agree with that. That wasn't my experience, and I think that that is detrimental to the cause.
On the other hand, I think for me, I experienced tough love. Imagine somebody grabbing you
by the collar and saying, this is unacceptable. The way you're living your life is wrong, and you need
to get help. Eventually for me, I was facing another arrest for a public intoxication,
my fourth or fifth one, and a judge finally said, look, you're going to either do six months in jail
or six months in rehab, and that's tough love. I chose the rehab, and it worked. I don't know how
many times you hear the people on the streets don't want help. You know, you mentioned whether
or not they would accept services. There is, I think, a popular sentiment that people don't want
help, and when I was standing in front of that judge, I would have told you I didn't want help.
But when it was offered, I took it, and it worked, and I think that that is an important distinction
for people to remember, and that's sort of what shapes my overall view of what you're seeing today.
So you're saying the help we have been giving them is not the kind of help they need. They need a
different kind of help. No. One of the biggest examples of that right now is harm reduction.
I don't know if you've heard of harm reduction, but harm reduction is the idea that if you provide
people with needles and crack pipes and marijuana pipes and wound kits and condoms, it'll reduce
the overall harm caused by addiction, things like hepatitis or HIV. It'll reduce the spread of those,
but what's happening is you're enabling an entire population of people to just perpetuate this
lifestyle that they're in, and that's just one example of that. Now, for those that might be
critical of your thoughts or your ideas, they might say you're criminalizing poverty.
What are your thoughts on that? When you take that approach, you're removing all personal
responsibility from the people who are on the streets. You're not criminalizing poverty and
homelessness. I think that it's totally acceptable. Right behind you is Grape Day Park. It's a
beautiful park. Historically, it's been full of tents. The bathrooms were unsafe to go in because
there was people shooting up drugs in there, and I think it's totally reasonable to say,
look, you cannot be here and you cannot do this. That park is for families. It's for people to
park in. You know what I mean? To allow that to go on robs everybody else in the city of an
opportunity to enjoy time with their family in the park, and it's not like we're coming up and
saying, you know what, you're here now, so we're going to write you a ticket. We're giving them
an opportunity. Our policy states that you have to put up a posted notice. You have 24 hours to
clean up your stuff and to move on. If you cannot gather all of your belongings in that 24 hours,
we'll send some public works staff out. They're going to document every item you have. They're
going to itemize it, and they're going to store it for a minimum of 60 days in our public works
yard. I think that's a reasonable compromise, and look, if you don't want to follow that,
then yeah, we're going to write you a ticket, and I think that that's reasonable.
So you're passing ordinances, and a lot of small cities, like the cities like your size,
you have 150,000 people, and a lot of cities in San Diego, around San Diego, and in LA,
they're going to do that, but this population will go to other cities, and some cities that
are not passing these ordinances, they're going to get filled up with a lot of encampments. What
are your thoughts on that? We're a victim of that as well. People come into the city who
aren't from here to set up their tents. I think it's just part of the natural consequence of this,
and at the same time, I would hope that some of the cities who have not passed these encampment
regulations, when they start to see an influx, maybe they will decide then to start contributing
to some of the solutions. In San Diego County, you have a handful of cities with all of the
resources, and the cities that don't have resources don't have quite the experience
with encampments as we do, and so hopefully it motivates them to start contributing to some of
the solutions and funding more shelters and drug rehabs. You guys are banning encampments, and
essentially after the Supreme Court ruling, you're telling people to move your past ordinances to do
that. How's that going to help to change the way homelessness has been in California? I think that
it does some good in the sense that you can target some areas that have historically been a problem.
You can free up parks for families. Nothing else is going to change until we change some of the
other policies in the state that are enabling this. You cannot just allow people to do drugs
openly in public and face no consequences. I'm of the mindset that jail is not a good rehab
for people on drugs, but what we've done is created a situation where there's no alternatives.
I was given the alternative, jail or rehab. We need to come back with policies like that.
Is it going to be possible for you guys, when you pass this ban, is it possible for you guys to clear
the current encampments that are there? Yes, so this allows us to clear encampments pretty much
anywhere on public property. And will you guys do it? No, I mentioned earlier we don't have the
resources to be proactively enforcing an encampment ban. Our police department is very reactive. If
somebody calls and reports an encampment, they will respond. And then the policy lists priority
areas where they will be proactive, but there's only a small handful of those priority areas.
We just don't have a crew that's out there driving around looking for encampments and cleaning it up
as they're spotted. You mentioned people will get citations, but that doesn't mean that they are not
allowed to stay there, right? How would that work? Yes, so after you post the notice, if they refuse
to leave, yes, they can be issued a citation. But this is a whole other issue that we should get
into. If somebody has issued a citation, right, you need to pay a fine or go to court. If that
individual doesn't pay the fine and doesn't show up to court, a warrant is issued for their arrest.
You actually faced homelessness yourself, and you're among the first cities to ban
encampments. Can you tell us more about your experience being homeless? Absolutely. I mentioned
before I spent my first few nights on the street when I was 15 years old. That lasted for a very
brief period of time. I ended up moving in with my grandfather, who was kind enough to take me in.
It wasn't too long after that he kicked me out, and from 17 on to 21, that whole period of my life
was spent in and out of homelessness, primarily due to drug addiction. I think some mental
health issues that stemmed from my childhood, and spent that time just taking advantage of anybody
that I could. I would spend a brief period of time on the streets and be able to leverage
some relationships, manipulate those people out of every possible thing I could get from them
until that bridge was burned. And that continued on, still very resourceful on the streets. I knew
how to, again, manipulate people out of five or ten dollars to be able to get by with what I needed.
I knew I could use a $10 a month gym to get any showers I needed. But that's what it was like
in and out of for four or five years. But when I was 21, I mentioned standing in front of a judge
and having a choice between jail and rehab. And it's interesting, I actually made the decision.
I told him rehab, but that was in Utah. And as soon as I walked out of the courtroom, I realized
I don't want this. And so I fled the state. I came back to Escondido, and the plan was to not go to
rehab. I'll just never go back to the state of Utah. But that New Year's Eve, I was 21.
New Year's Eve, I had an experience where I overdosed. And I was curled up on the bathroom
floor, and I heard a very distinct voice in my head that said, you are going to die.
And it's interesting. Before then, I didn't have anything worth living for,
but I certainly didn't want to die. And it changed something in me. And so the next day,
I Googled rehabs in Escondido, and I found the North County Inland Regional Recovery Center
right here on the corner of Ash and Washington. Unfortunately, the building now is the 7-Eleven,
but back then it was a rehab. And they took me in immediately. For three months,
I did exactly as they told. I changed my phone number. I went to NA. I went to AA. I worked the
program. I didn't contact any of my friends. I worked my job. And halfway through that program,
I was more miserable than I had ever been, ever been in a drug addiction. Now I'm sober. I have
no friends. I have no life. I have nothing. And I went to my mom's house one day and told her,
I'm done. I did exactly as they asked, and I'm more miserable now than I've ever been.
This isn't worth it. I'm done. And she's very sweet. My mother's very sweet. And it's funny.
She knew exactly how to handle that situation. She said, Dane, you are my son, and I love you.
And I will love you no matter what decision you make. But before you make that decision,
why don't you say a prayer and be very specific about what you want? And so that night,
I said a prayer, and it was very short, something to the effect of, God, if you want me to succeed
in life, I need three things. I need new friends. I need friends who will ride bikes with me. I'm
big into motocross and cycling. And I want a new girlfriend. The next day, I'm laying in bed.
I had met some Mormon missionaries a year beforehand, had lost all contact with them.
I'm laying in bed, and I get a text from the missionaries. Hey, Dane, it's the missionaries.
Would you like to meet up? And I kid you not, I met with them. And within 30 days, I had a new
core group of friends who all rode bikes, and they introduced me to the woman who is now my wife.
Right at the point where I was ready to give up, I received some divine intervention.
I said, I got new friends. They rode bikes with me. I got a new girlfriend. But that's not it.
I was then given the resources I needed to be successful. I said I was working the program,
and all of a sudden relationships, family relationships, those bridges that I had
burned started to get rebuilt. Meeting my now wife, she was a student at BYU. She was only
here for a brief period of time. Her dad befriended me. Her dad was one of the people who would ride
bikes with me. He took me out every Saturday, and we would go mountain biking. All of a sudden,
I had a new male role model in my life that had been missing for a very long time.
For me, you have to replace that lifestyle with a new lifestyle, and it's not easy. It's a very
difficult adjustment, especially with something as rigid and structured as the Mormon church.
But I needed that. I needed structure. I needed discipline. I needed people like my father-in-law
to give me that tough love, but also forgiveness. It wasn't easy. I didn't all of a sudden become
sober. I had relapse after relapse after relapse. But I had somebody, again, to grab me by the
collar and say, this is unacceptable. Stop now, and also forgive me immediately. You need that.
This is what's difficult. You asked me about housing a little while ago, and if that's part
of this overall problem, how do you expect people, especially in a state like California,
or the county of San Diego, which is the most expensive county in all of the United States,
how do you expect them to just pick themselves up by their bootstraps and figure it out?
It's near impossible. Even if you go through the whole process like I did, you go through a rehab,
you try to get your life together, you work a job, chances are that job isn't going to provide
you enough income to be truly independent and living on your own. And that's where society
needs to step in. We need to say, okay, if you're willing to put in the work, so should we. We're
going to help you out. That is where opportunities like affordable housing could come in.
Was there a moment that you thought you cannot make it?
Almost every day. I remember the first time I went into my now-in-law's home. I was in rehab
for about four months. I started spending time with my friends and naturally ended up
over at their house. And the first time I walked in, their entire family was there. And I remember
thinking, I am not good enough to be here. And I think that that is something that people struggle
with every day. Even if they go through that process, they feel like they're still not good
enough. They're still not worthy. There's a ton of guilt, a ton of shame. And to be able to get over
each one of those mountains is very challenging. That in and of itself is a whole nother long
process. And what do you recommend to the people that are on the streets that kind of you took
the journey, you had opportunity and you had people that supported you. What do you recommend
to the people that are in these encampments now, if they were watching? You know, so much of what
I say because of my experience with drugs and mental health relates to those specific people,
which I do think is the majority of them. But it relates to them in in N.A. or A.A. or pretty much
in any 12 step program you go to. They tell you to find your higher power. So for me, that ended
up being Jesus Christ. But it doesn't have to be. You just need to find your higher power. Anything
that motivates you to do good and to be good cling to that. So Dane, it seems like you care about
your city, right? Ran for mayor. You grew up here. Why are you doing this? It's a good question. I'm
fifth generation. My family has been here for over 100 years. Obviously, I've spent my entire life
here. And you've noticed a decline, a decline in quality of life, in overall health and everything
else that you see out there. This is my opportunity to give back. It's my opportunity to take my life
experience and put all of that into something good. I'm a believer that when you experience
hard times, it becomes your duty to turn around and to help the next person in line who's facing
similar challenges as you did. And that's what's unique about my position as mayor and my experience
with homelessness and addiction and mental health struggles. It's created this space in my heart
to take what I've learned and do the best I can to help anybody else. I think that if there's
one person on the streets that learns from my experience and becomes even, and I'm able to
become half of what they become, being able to change a life like that is something that not
many people get to experience. I think that's my overall goal. I would love to see it happen
with everybody here that's homeless and on the streets. I don't know if that's reality,
but that's what I'm trying to do. Dane White, Mayor of Escondido. It was great to have you on
California Insider. Thank you. It's good to be here. We've been covering homelessness from all
perspectives, and sometimes it looks like there is no solution for the state. But we recently
interviewed Ken Houston, who's come up with a very innovative way to deal with homelessness,
how cleaning up encampments, hiring the homeless people, teaching them how to get jobs,
and he's come up with a system to solve this. Okay, okay, let's gather around. Let's get this
tailgate meeting going. People know him as the son of Oakland, and he has a unique plan to turn
the city around. What we're supposed to do is when we go out there, if somebody's jumping after the
city leaves, we clean it up like it never existed. Small things. If you can go there and start with
the small things instead of trying to do these huge wins, you'll be able to cure and heal the city.
Ken Houston is the third-generation Oaklander and the director of Beautification Council.
We work directly behind Oakland Public Works, and it's called HIMSS, Homeless Encampment
Micro-Cleaning and Sanitization. We only hire justice-impacted and unhoused individuals.
How you figured out to hire the homeless and the justice-impacted? They come to me.
We clean it up, and they would come to us. Hey, man, I want to work. I said, okay, come on,
sign your name here. All these lives would not be out here making living wages,
dignity, respect, responsibility with living wage. That makes change.
It's been the best thing that's happened to me since I wanted to be an example for my kids. I
can pay doctor bills. I can pay for medicine. I can do all that kind of stuff. I can help my mom out.
Our episode with Ken Houston got a lot of attention among leaders in the state,
including Governor Newsom. It was highlighted by a representative for Epoch Times,
and I appreciated that framework that we're hiring formerly homeless individuals.
I encourage you to watch this episode. It's an amazing solution to homelessness.
We're going to leave you a link in the description below. Now, let's go back to the episode. We're
going to talk to Greg Angell, who's a homeless advocate who has a different perspective on
homeless encampment bans. Greg, it's great to have you on.
Thank you for having me.
You've been helping the homeless people. You operate shelters and a lot of different programs.
Can you tell us your thoughts about this ruling?
So poverty is almost always the cause of homelessness. You think about it,
the definition is somebody who can't afford a home. That is poverty. What we see is that addiction
very rarely causes homelessness. It does. But on a society level, if you look at the community with
the highest rate of addiction in the United States, it's West Virginia. West Virginia has
a very low rate of homelessness. Why is that? It's because housing affordability in West Virginia is
very different than it is here in California. So just because somebody's struggling with addiction
doesn't mean that they're going to end up homeless unless they're not able to afford housing. And
that's the through line with homelessness here in California. The other side of that, though,
is that when somebody does become homeless and they are living unsheltered in encampments,
their likelihood of using drugs and alcohol skyrockets. And so it's really important for
those of us who are helping people overcome homelessness that we provide ways for them,
we provide alternatives to drug and alcohol use. And those are often drugs and alcohol used as
a way for somebody to numb the pain that they're feeling, to numb the fear of being attacked,
of being assaulted. Unfortunately, here in our community and in many other communities,
there aren't enough safe places for people to go. What's the transition look like when somebody
loses their home? Yeah, I think when people, when the public thinks about somebody who's homeless,
they often think about somebody who has probably been on the streets for a very long period of time
for many months, many years, maybe even decades. What they don't see is what that person looked
like and what their situation was like the very first night that they were homeless.
When that happens, that person probably looks a lot more like you and me than they do now after
years and years on the streets. And so unfortunately, the streets are really bad
for your mental health. They're really bad for sobriety. They're really bad for just personal
safety and hygiene. And so people unfortunately spiral downward very quickly and will find it
difficult to secure housing, to secure a job when they don't have a place to go take a shower,
when they don't have clean clothes, when they don't have the ability to sleep through the night
and be in a good enough headspace. When somebody is experiencing street homelessness,
their brain is operating in a fight or flight mentality. And survival mode is a very challenging
place to grow from. Survival mode is all about getting by day to day. How much of it is families
in your estimation? So families are among the fastest growing population of people experiencing
homelessness. Here in San Diego County, we saw a 56% increase in family homelessness in just a
two-year period. And that's just the small amount of families who are homeless who were able to
identify are in that situation. Most families with children who have lost their housing are
doing everything in their power, the parents, everything in their power to support their
children during a really tough time. So they're making sure that their kids don't feel like
they're homeless. One family we worked with told their kids that they were going to go on a
camping adventure. And they used their last bit of savings to buy a camping pass. And they went
from campground to campground over the course of a summer while the kids were out of school and
they'd lost their housing. We helped them to find a new job. The dad had been sick and so he
had been out of work. He was able to get a new job pretty quickly once he was physically able.
That family we then helped with, you know, it costs a lot to move into a new apartment. You
got to pay the first month's rent, the last month's rent. You need to also show that you
often have three to four times the monthly rent in income. And so we helped this family with
the move-in costs to get them moved in. That family, the last I heard from them, had bought
their own home in Texas. And they were doing great and were reaching out to us to show just
how much better their life had gotten. Their situation was health. You know, the dad had
gotten sick. And then a lack of housing affordability. They couldn't afford the
apartment they were living in anymore. And were it not for an organization to help them with
pretty minor issues, a little bit to help with employment, and then a little bit on the move-in
costs, who knows what would have happened. Because their homelessness only lasted a matter of months.
But that family, if you had seen them at the grocery store, you probably would have never
guessed that they were experiencing homelessness when they did. Housing is more expensive for a
family because they need larger apartments that cost more money. There's fewer of those
apartments. A single adult can share an apartment with another individual. There are what are called
independent living facilities, independent living homes, that are homes that rent out
rooms. So you might have a home with six rooms and they're renting out those rooms to a number
of individuals at rates that are about as cheap as housing gets in our community. Those are
appropriate and often where single adults will move out of homelessness into, those don't work
for families. So it's harder for families to actually pay for housing because it's more expensive
and they usually don't have as many breadwinners. You got mom and you have dad and the kids, if
they're young, you know, are obviously focused on school. Now about the ruling, the Supreme Court ruling,
your city, Escondido, has passed this ordinance to clean encampments and we were at one of these
encampments, the largest one that you guys have, and we saw the situation out there. What are your
thoughts on that encampment? It's not a safe place for people to be and so we don't support people
living in those situations and we work to provide safe places to be able to outreach to those
individuals and get them out of there so they can get into a better place. So we're generally against
encampment bans as a standalone policy. What we are in favor of is working with local
government to create places for people to go and so we're doing that here in Escondido, working in
particular on opportunities for drug and alcohol addiction services, creating some more beds for
people to go for that, and also general shelter beds. Not everyone has an addiction issue.
A lot of people just need a place that they can rebuild their life from that's not an encampment.
So we do support and we are working with the city of Escondido and with other cities in the
communities that we serve to do that. We acknowledge that the Supreme Court has made their position
clear on this. The California governor has made his position clear and that more and more cities
are going to be increasing enforcement and passing these encampment bans. So we are here to work with
all of those levels of government and most importantly local businesses, local community
members to say, okay, this is a problem here in our community. Let's find a, let's create pathways for
people out of these encampments that don't just push them around but actually provide them a place
to end their homelessness. One of the complaints that some city leaders have is that there is this
policy, some people have told us it's a federal policy, the state is following it, everybody's
following it essentially is they call the housing first. Okay. Where you want to give housing to
people and then there is an element they call it harm reduction. What are your thoughts on that?
The idea behind harm reduction is that, you know, we operate drug and alcohol treatment programs.
So as one of our counselors said, I can't get you clean if you're dead. So the idea is to keep
people from dying and if somebody's going to die then we can't help them anymore. And so if we can
provide resources to prevent them from overdosing and dying, if they're at that stage of their
addiction, then we want to do that. We want to keep them alive so that we can help them realize
that there's a better path forward for them. Harm reduction is not about enabling and supporting
people to continue using. It's about preventing them from dying so that we can save them so that
they can live. The idea of housing first is that housing is the primary cause of homelessness.
I shared about the example that the state with the highest addiction in the United States is West
Virginia, but yet they have a very low rate of homelessness because their cost of housing is so
much less than we have here in California. So the idea is that housing has been a big part of that
person's homelessness. Let's provide that housing and then we can better help them address their
addiction issues. We don't believe in any one strategy is the right fit for everybody. We, our
own organization, operate more than 75 programs and they're all different and they're all tailored to
meet people where they're at. Some require 100% sobriety and drug tests every day. Our drug and
alcohol treatment programs is one example. Others focus on making sure somebody is safely housed
and then addressing their addiction issue. We find that a variety of tools and resources are needed
for a problem as complex as homelessness. A lot of people are frustrated that they see this in
their community like because it's exploded over the last few years and then also people that are
in the streets are suffering. What are your thoughts on a solution? So we operate a recuperative
care program for people who have been discharged out of hospitals and are homeless and still have
a medical need. And I was just there yesterday and touring one of our new board members and the board
member asked the head of our post-hospitalization recuperative care program, so these are sick,
homeless people, what is your biggest need? What's the biggest problem? And you would think it'd be
something health related, something related to the fact that the person just came out of a hospital
and is homeless. She didn't even pause. She said housing affordability. She said we have seniors
here on fixed incomes, seniors here who have disabling conditions, who have worked all their
lives and no longer able to work, they're older, they have a set amount of money every month,
that doesn't cover the cost of housing anymore. So housing affordability is paramount and it's
something that we really need to prioritize in communities that are as expensive as California.
How do we make it affordable for the people who built this community, for the people who maintain
and work in this community, to live in this community? Now Greg, you seem very passionate
about helping the people you're helping. Is there a reason for this? Where does it come from?
Well, I'm a preacher's kid. My mom was a Methodist minister and I believe very strongly in making the
world a better place. When we think about homelessness, homelessness is really the result
of all of our challenges as a society. It's the result of people not having the support network
that so many of us are very thankful to have. It's the result of somebody not being able to afford
a roof over their head. I host a podcast where I interview people who have experienced homelessness
and we've recorded hundreds of episodes and in every episode we get to know people,
where they come from, who they are. And it's very sad because more often than not,
individuals who have become homeless had significant childhood traumas that really
turned their life in a way that they weren't able to overcome yet or before falling into homelessness.
I'm passionate about this because I know that homelessness is solvable for every single
individual, one person at a time. I don't know if we're going to get to a point where we don't
have anyone who's homeless on our streets. That's a very long ways away, but I can tell you with
certainty and from experience and with proof of the work that we do that every individual
can overcome homelessness if they're provided with the right resources and if they take
advantage of those resources to move forward in positive ways.
Do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
Homelessness was created by people. Homelessness wasn't a mandate from God. It didn't appear out
of thin air. It developed slowly in this country over multiple generations and it was the result
of decisions and actions that people have made. That's challenging. It's hard for people to
understand. But the upside is that if homelessness was created by people, homelessness can be
eliminated and solved by people. And so as a society, as a community, if we made the decision
that we were not going to allow for people to be homeless in our communities, we could make
homelessness go away very quickly. I'll give you an example. Veteran homelessness became a really
big problem in this community, in this country. After 9-11, when the support and patriotism for
our veterans increased so dramatically, more people cared and looked at how many veterans
were experiencing homelessness. And from the height of the Great Recession in 2009
to the end of 2020, this country reduced veteran homelessness more than 50 percent.
At a time where homelessness among the rest of the population skyrocketed. Why? Because we morally
committed to helping veterans not experience homelessness. We invested in what? Housing and
services. And what do you know? Homelessness dropped 50 percent among veterans while it was
skyrocketing among others. It shows that if we commit to it, if we say morally it's wrong for
anybody to be on the streets, we can absolutely reduce and potentially someday eliminate
homelessness in California and in our country. Greg Angel with Interfaith, it was great to have
you on California Insider. Thank you so much. So what do you think of this Supreme Court ruling
and do you think homeless encampments will be the thing of a past in California?
Make sure to let us know your thoughts and you can email me at siamakatcaliforniasider.com.
And don't forget to send us stories that matter to you. We read every email. In our upcoming episode,
we're going to discuss a really important ballot proposition that could change California. It's
Prop 36. We're going to have two opposing views, very interesting perspectives on this. So make
sure you stay tuned to see these episodes.