Entre surcoûts, malfaçons et incompétence: que se passe-t-il réellement dans la division spatiale de Boeing ? Quelle est la situation ? Entre les problèmes avec le SLS et Starliner, la NASA peut-elle encore compter dessus ? On fais le point !
j'espère que cette vidéo vous plaira, si c'est le cas, ou pas, n'hésitez pas à venir discuter dans l'espace commentaire ( sauf pour les platistes ), il est ici pour ça , vos questions etc !
what is happening with Boeing if you
follow space news a little
you are probably asking yourself this
question it must be
admitted that these days we often talk about
Boeing and when we talk about it it is to
talk about delay suddenly poor workmanship and
other fairly significant problems in this
episode I suggest you take a
quick overview of space for
Boeing, current problems, causes
and what to remember before
tackling them, however I wanted to
quickly invite you to subscribe
you are not yet as well as to
like comment and share this episode
finally if you are considering the end of
Astro material and wish to support the
channel without going through teepee do
not hesitate to take a look at astroshop
as for your purchases of
Astro material meteorite and other
plush toys in the shape of a planet but in short
I have already talked enough so
welcome to you for a new dose
of space
before fully starting the video
I would like to clarify one point important
I will not talk here about the
aeronautics part of Boeing but only
about space if the causes of certain
problems are common and I will
obviously mention them Stardust has
already made a very good video looking
at Boeing's problems with their
planes and I wouldn't have much
relevant to add but
here it is, Boeing is not just about
planes either, the company is in fact
particularly active in space and
has been for many years
already in the 1960s. the company
built the first stages of the
Saturn 5 launcher the s1c stages even if
Boeing was not responsible for the
design it will be the same
thing for the lunar buggy the Lunar
roving vehicle used from Apollo
15 but be careful Boeing will not
only build what it is told
in the mid-70s
the company will notably develop
the inertial upper stage a
solid fuel upper stage which
flies many times on the
space shuttle until
1999 participating in flagship missions
such as the Chandra space telescope, the
sound of jovienne Galileo or the Venusian
Magellan in the end the stage will retire in
2004 with the last flight of the
Titan 4 launcher but the company is also
active on many other module fronts
pressurized for the space shuttle
habit in spacio and I enasse while in
1996 Boeing also bought Rockwell
international main developer and
manufacturer of the space shuttle
before refinishing McDonald Douglas in
1997 more with the creation in 2006 of
United lunch alliens co- company between
Boeing and lckin Martin the two
companies leverage their
knowledge in the field of
launchers Boeing already dealing with the
Delta 2 3 and 4 launchers and I'm
not even talking to you about the multinational joint venture
seunch founded in 1995 and
10 in 2014 which was the opportunity
to operate the
Zenite launcher I am only touching on
Boeing's activities in space here,
excluding for example the company's activities
with the autonomous space shuttle
x37b and the
previous prototypes the work on the
supporting bodies and others but you see the
picture Boeing has always been a
major space company and has
always been renowned for its reliability,
its more than excellent results both in
terms of safety and innovation and
many others
but unfortunately everything is not is not rosy either
in the 90s already the company
was talked about badly for a
espionage affair of its competitor
at the time lckin Martin before in
the mid-2000s being talked about
for a affair of sharing and
sale of missile expertise
with the end thus between sanctions
against Boeing we saw in particular
the ban on launching
government satellites reprisals against
certain employees and others the situation is
already slowly starting to
deteriorate and this is not the most serious
because for several years already Boeing
has relied heavily on the contracts it
wins with the
American government and which are linked to defense
the x37b on the one hand but also the
launch of military satellites and
other space technologies are
particularly lucrative contracts but
are also a source which has
slowly dried up. American defense is
increasingly leaving room for
competitors and is also trying to reduce
the budget when it can. Boeing
also started in the same period. e
absolutely want to maximize the
profitability of the company so I
summarize in one sentence what should be
detailed for 30 minutes but
the company will make savings on
staff training, on the quality
of engineers and in short on a lot of
important areas for the future of
the company because unfortunately with
the budget cuts on the quality of
personnel unfortunately come the
problems that we all know if we take
for example the case of the SLS a recent
NASA audit on its future evolution
the block AB is more than
drastic increase in costs lack
of qualification of employees and above all
a gaping lack of respect for the
standards in terms of safety and
quality required to launch
astronauts the overcooked delays
thus follow one another for the SLS and its
future evolution which should fly for
the first time in 2028 and the picture
is particularly dark with
non-compliant welds of the parts which must
be revised even worse in 2023 the
members of an inspection will see for
example a section of the tank of the
SLS of Artémis i abandoned and awaiting
evacuation which had been abandoned
because of the poor quality of the
welds and the lack of coordination and
qualification for the latter
Boeing thus plunged with it the
lunar program for which the SLS is
crucial and the various actions
attempted by the company seem to be
a plaster on a wooden leg with
results described as insufficient and
even if NASA begins to look into
financial penalties and put
pressure on boy
to make things improve nothing
seems to be gaining either it is thus very
complicated not to make the
connection with the difficulties
encountered by their capsule the Starliner
currently docked at isss and which suffers
from a problem of helium fu used by
the RCS propellant thrusters and also
in embarrassment so let's say- The
problems are extremely slight but
enough to doubt that the
astronauts will be able to return to Earth
with the capsule and not with a
Dragon crew capsule from Space X and the
two entities are also in
discussion to try to adopt the
best approach but NASA, both
internally and with Boeing, seems to have
difficulty finding a unanimous solution.
If Boeing is far
from being the only space company to
be anything but impeccable, we can
notably cite SpaceX which is once again
singled out for finger for
soil pollution problems for example, it is
unfortunately a much more
serious situation than normal for Boeing and if
we see the cost of developing the SLS
which in 2021 had cost nearly 9
billion SOAP, double the
initial Boeing budget finds itself in a
delicate situation
it is slow has serious
quality control problems and pin has
solved the situation and it is
even more worrying that the problem
is unfortunately much deeper and anchored
in the DNA of the company than
simply in in the space sector we
find exactly the same criticisms
with planes even if many of the
accidents we talk about in the media
are more linked to the maintenance of
companies than Boeing itself but in the
end Boeing's space division
may seem a little less impacted by
the situation the defects and poor workmanship
are often corrected before the
launch at the delivery of equipment and
so far fingers crossed
no major fiasco has taken place better
still the first stage of the SLS of Artémis
1 which took off in November 2022 has
succeeded a great feat by making a
mistake and reaching the
standard ST required for manned flight on the
first try and the Starliner is for
the moment far from being a Fico
even if the problems encountered by Boeing
are more than worrying on the
various flights because Boeing has
responsibilities and it is high time
that it takes them the development of
new space the arrival of new
capsules new launchers and others
will only continue to
overshadow the company and if other
companies respect the quality standards
for future contracts and are
sufficiently qualified and well
things risk becoming even
uglier for Boeing but that is still
too early to talk about it especially since with
some resuscitation the company can
also quite quickly resolve the problem and we
will now have to see the continuation of
events both for the Starliner and
for the SLS and Boeing in general but
be sure that I will talk about it again when the
time comes so until then see you soon
for a new dose of space
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]