Quentin Kopp, who served as a California state senator in the 1980s, was one of the first to introduce the idea of high-speed rail to California.
"There's a new kind of train here now. They call it high-speed. The first line is from Paris to Lyon. I said, 'Well, let's try it,'" Kopp said, recalling the first time he experienced high-speed rail when visiting a friend in France in 1985.
Kopp initiated and persistently advocated for the idea of building California's own high-speed rail system. His efforts led to the creation of the California High-Speed Rail Authority and a $9.5 billion bond for the project.
"I've traveled to Japan, France, Germany, and Great Britain, studying high-speed rail. The ballot measure that voters approved called for the first section to run from San Francisco to Los Angeles in two hours and 40 minutes, which would rival air travel," Kopp said.
However, over the years, the project has strayed further and further from its original design.
"My biggest accomplishment could have been high-speed rail, but that's a pipe dream ... They changed the plan. Their idea is to build it from Merced to Bakersfield, which is nonsense," Kopp remarked. "Today, they estimate the cost is over $100 billion, and they don't have any money."
In part 2 of our interview with Quentin Kopp, we explore what happened to California's high-speed rail and why he still believes politics is a noble profession.
We are having the second episode of the Quentin Kopp interview.
Last week we talked about his beginning in the Air Force and in the San Francisco Board of Supervisors.
The biggest mistake was believing Dianne Feinstein when she said she'd endorse me for mayor.
Of course, politicians lie.
Anyway, they changed. They changed the idea.
Now their plan is to build it from Merced to Bakersfield, which is nonsense.
Nonsense.
There aren't enough people living in the Central Valley.
Why was the plan changed instead of San Francisco to L.A.?
Because they couldn't raise anybody.
It was difficult to pass that bond issue.
Today we'll continue the discussion among the different aspects of politics and law that he's been involved with later in his life.
Welcome back to part two with our guest and Bay Area innovator, Judge Quentin Kopp.
Judge Kopp, welcome to part two of our interview.
Thank you.
What I want to go next to is about the high-speed rail.
You've been very involved with this. You've been the chair of the association there.
There's a lot of discussion about it taking too long and being very expensive.
Tell us what are your thoughts about it and how is this going to end?
To do so, I have to provide some history.
My older son went to Dartmouth College like I did.
In his junior year, Dartmouth had arrangements with universities in other countries.
He went to France, went to the University of Lyon, lived with a French family.
Then I had a friend, a San Franciscan, whose family came from France.
They owned a large ranch growing wine grapes near Bordeaux.
France for wine. It's very well known.
After he finished his time at the University of Lyon, I arranged for him to work for this friend of mine at his ranch or farm in France.
I had never been to Europe.
I had a couple of weeks to decide to go to Europe.
I flew to France and he met me in Paris with a car from my friend's ranch near Bordeaux.
About a day later, he said, I'd like to go to Lyon and say goodbye to the family I lived with.
He said there's a new kind of train here now.
They call it high speed.
The first line is from Paris to Lyon.
I said, well, let's try it.
By that time, I'd been on the Board of Supervisors some 14 years.
But anyway, we did.
And we loved it.
When I came back to the United States, the next year in 1986, I ran for the State Senate and I was elected.
My son graduated Dartmouth in June of 1986.
He was in charge of the House Sign Committee in my campaign.
I was elected. I was sworn in in December of 1986.
I had one conflict because I wanted to be on the Judiciary Committee.
My campaign manager, who served that first year as my number one aide,
said, your constituents don't care about the judiciary, but they do care about transportation.
So you better ask to be appointed to the Transportation Committee.
The Democrats then, as now, have the majority in the Senate.
Politics is a rough game.
And I became the chairman of the Transportation Committee.
That led to my interest in high speed rail about seven years later.
I was chairman of that committee for 11 years.
And so I introduced a bill to establish the California High Speed Rail.
Because of term limits, my term ended at the end of 1998.
In the California Senate?
In the California Senate.
Then Pete Wilson had asked me a couple months previously what I wanted to do after my Senate term ended.
And I said I want to be a superior court judge.
Trial court judge, not an appellate court judge,
which was usually the case with the members of the legislature who were lawyers and would qualify to be a judge.
They all want to be on the Court of Appeal, if not the California Supreme Court.
But anyway, Pete Wilson and I had known each other since the mid-70s when he was mayor of San Diego.
And he told me, let me know when the time comes.
And that time did come.
And fortunately there was a vacancy in San Mateo County.
I had represented in my Senate district 10 of the 20 cities in San Mateo.
And that's why I was appointed to the San Mateo County Superior Court.
That also meant that I could qualify to sit on the High-Speed Rail Authority Government Board.
Anyway, then I got elected chairman of the High-Speed Rail Authority Board.
And we put together a ballot measure in 2008,
an issuance of a state general obligation bond in the amount of $9,950,000,000.
And I was chairman of that campaign.
It passed 52 to 48 percent.
Wasn't easy.
Then we had a plan to raise money from local governments
because they would benefit if you had a high-speed rail station in their county or city.
And private money, as was the case in France and Japan.
It's a long story, but I've traveled to Japan, to France, to Germany, to Great Britain looking at high-speed rail.
And the ballot measure, which voters approved,
calls for the first section to be San Francisco to Los Angeles.
In two hours and 40 minutes, which would rival the airplane
because you had to be careful of airport or airline opposition
because they're going to be vying for passengers.
Anyway, that passed and I served through 2010 or 11.
Then Jerry Brown was reincarnated as governor.
He had always been a high-speed rail enthusiast,
but he had new appointees to make.
Anyway, they changed the idea.
Now their plan is to build it from Merced to Bakersfield,
which is nonsense.
Because there aren't enough people living in the Central Valley.
Number one.
Number two, Amtrak already runs trains.
They're not high-speed, but they're trains along that same corridor, Highway 99.
And they propose that the first section will be from Merced to Bakersfield.
Now they're lying and the media, to my knowledge, hasn't exposed the lies.
There was one reporter who followed it until he retired from the LA Times.
Ralph Vardabedi.
And he wouldn't accept any of their nonsense.
So now they claim that will be the first segment.
And they haven't even, to my knowledge today, laid a single foot of that track.
Why was the plan changed instead of San Francisco to LA to be in the middle of the Central Valley?
Because they couldn't raise anybody.
It was difficult to pass that bond issue.
There were non-believers.
I addressed the meeting of the County Supervisors Association in October of 2008.
And I'd been president of that association when I was a San Francisco supervisor.
And they didn't believe it.
I said, the bond issue contains a provision that there will be no government money applied to the operation of high-speed rail.
High-speed rail will generate its costs and expenses from the fare box.
That was a promise to voters and a legal requirement.
And we estimated then it would take about $32 billion from San Francisco to LA to Anaheim.
Anaheim was added.
And then there would be a separate segment going to San Diego.
And then John Garamendi, who'd been in the State Senate, was now in the House of Representatives representing northern Central Valley and into Sacramento.
He demanded that we run it to Sacramento from Merced.
So that was the plan.
And today they estimate the cost is over $100 billion.
And they don't have any money.
Barack Obama was elected president in 2008, so 2009 he gave California, I don't know, $3 billion or whatever it was.
And as long as there's a Democratic president, they might get a little federal money.
But all they're doing is wasting money.
Now, that isn't high-speed rail.
It isn't from San Francisco to LA.
It's a boondoggle now.
As somebody said, it's in the cemetery of boondoggles.
And we are the only nation in the world of our size and stature which doesn't have high-speed rail.
China, of course, as a communist nation, can just go ahead and spend all the money it wants.
And it has probably got the second largest miles of high-speed rail in the world next to the Japanese and the French.
Your memory of not just events, but dates and things that happened in history, it's unbelievable.
I wish I had that right now.
I want to switch gears again and talk about your years on the Superior Court Judge.
How were you able to determine if someone is telling the truth or someone is lying when you were on the bench as a judge listening to the two sides?
It's difficult.
You do it based upon prior statements, for example, of the witness or statements of people who were present.
So that you match sources of information to a witness's testimony about the same subjects of such information.
And I've been a trial lawyer since I opened my own law office in April of 1959.
And I continued to try cases as permitted by law while I was in the State Senate.
And so I was experienced.
And as I indicate, I was 70 when I became a judge and I was in good health.
I loved being a Superior Court Judge.
Better than anything I did in political office.
I'd like to ask you, what would you say is your biggest accomplishment and your biggest regret in your career?
My biggest accomplishment could have been high-speed rail.
But that's a pipe dream.
And maybe the biggest mistake?
Well, the biggest mistake was believing Dianne Feinstein when she said she'd endorse me for mayor.
That one's easy.
Of course, politicians lie.
But I was accustomed to people like John Barbagellata, who wasn't a politician and he never lied.
And even friends of mine on the Board of Supervisors, like Ron Pelosi or Bob Mendelsohn, who never did.
David Roberti was outstanding as the presiding officer of the State Senate and he never lied to me.
His Chief of Staff was handling most of the detailed responsibilities that the President Pro Tem of the Senate has.
Cliff Berg was his name.
And he never lied to me.
There's now talk about AI.
AI is growing so fast.
It's taking everything over.
There's talk about AI replacing judges in making court decisions.
I want to hear your thoughts about that, knowing that you're more traditional when it comes to this.
Well, I'm the wrong person to talk to about technology.
And I oppose it.
And I don't like the custom and practice caused initially by the pandemic of COVID-19,
which means appearing on Zoom at court hearings of one kind or another.
I like to appear personally as a lawyer before a judge.
And if I were still a judge, I would want that.
The closest technology, when I was on the San Mateo Superior Court,
was in departments like law and motion, where you're not deciding or participating in trials,
but these are pre-trial motions of one kind or another.
And an attorney was allowed to participate by telephone.
And that kind of functioned satisfactorily.
I remember one trial where the lawyer wanted to introduce evidence by the internet in front of a jury.
A jury trial, not a so-called bench trial, where a lawyer will decide the conflict, not a jury.
And I would find it difficult to have that same kind of personal conduct that personal appearances generate.
Any final thoughts, any advice you would like to give to young people based on your experience and your career,
how they can approach politics and law?
I think politics is still a noble profession.
And I remember on the Board of Supervisors, one of my colleagues, Bob Mendelson,
who had been elected four years before I was, he never went any place after the Board of Supervisors.
But during a speech one day in the Board of Supervisors chambers,
he made that comment about another supervisor who was an honor to our profession.
And that elevated the political undertone and overtone of Board of Supervisors membership in an appropriate way.
It is a profession.
It shouldn't be subject to term limits.
And the author of Term Limits, now deceased, Pete Shabaram,
who became a friend of mine when he was a Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors member,
and I was a member from San Francisco's Board of Supervisors,
introduced Term Limits, which was an initiative voters passed.
And I hear people say the same should apply to the Congress of the United States.
It shouldn't. I oppose term limits.
People go in to running for City Council or County Board of Supervisors because it is a profession.
And if they want to pursue that profession, they should be allowed to do so for 20 years, 25 years,
if they so desire and they perform satisfactorily for voters to re-elect them.
Please tell us, why did you like being a judge more than your Senate and Supervisors roles?
I'll approach that answer by starting with a one-time colleague of mine in the State Senate.
His name was Ralph Dills.
And he was an FDR Democrat.
Came from a family which started in Oklahoma and moved to Southern California.
And he was a State Senator from Gardena, which used to be famous because Gardena was about the only city which allowed gambling and poker games.
He had been a Municipal Court Judge under the years that Edmund G. Pat Brown was Governor of California.
And I asked him, Ralph, why would you leave the bench to go back into elective politics?
And he said, well, I got tired of doing things to people and I wanted to do things for people.
I never had that feeling as a judge.
The human condition means disagreement.
And that also includes dishonesty from time to time.
And it certainly includes terrible events like motor vehicle accidents, airplane crashes,
disputes among survivors of a deceased person in terms of wills and trusts.
And I think it's more intellectually stimulating than being a County Supervisor or a State Legislator.
And I enjoyed continuing a legal career.
I never found it obnoxious to work into the evening hours researching cases that applied to particular disputes in my courtroom.
I loved juries and I loved the process of selecting a jury.
And even though I lived in San Francisco by virtue of representing half of San Mateo County,
I knew people who would appear for jury duty and people were wonderful.
There were only a few exceptions of people who tried to get out of jury duty.
It's the best system I know for disposing of disputes.
I still have a couple of questions.
The next one is, how do you feel when you drive on Highway 380, which carries your name?
You probably came there today.
Well, I'm used to it now, but that was an auspicious occasion in my life.
And that was engineered by Senate Transportation Committee Chief of Staff, Mady Morrissette,
who got one of my Senate colleagues to introduce the bill that renamed 380.
Not the world's shortest freeway, but the Quentin L. Cobb Highway.
And it was a joyous occasion, the best part of which I recall was my daughter.
She probably was in her late 20s and just starting her career in the wine industry in Napa County.
She gave the speech at the dedication and it was beautiful.
As an auspicious part of the California highway system,
I used to call the Department of Transportation District 4,
which has its office now in Oakland,
and tell them if their signs were being overgrown by trees or bushes in the spring of the year.
I have one more question.
How do you stay in shape? Are you still going swimming?
You're turning 96 in a couple of weeks and you're looking great.
I started swimming maybe 35, 40 years ago at the Olympic Club, which I've been a member of since 1975.
I'm not a great swimmer. I wasn't a competitive swimmer.
But I learned to swim mostly because of my father, an immigrant.
And we had a lot of lakes around Syracuse.
I learned to swim when I was seven.
I now swim every morning, except Monday when the club is closed, a half hour each morning.
That's not the most. I've got a younger friend who swims at the College of San Mateo pool an hour every day.
But a half hour is fine.
And that's really how I stay in shape.
I used to walk during the pandemic.
And my wife, God bless her, she walks every afternoon around our block.
But that's a little more difficult for me.
I'd probably have to use a walker as she does.
But swimming, it's a terrific sport.
Well, I was in the swim team. It's great. It's fantastic. It's a great sport.
Quentin, thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate it. It's an honor for us to have you on our show.
Well, thank you. I've enjoyed it immensely.