For more on the Trump–Musk conversation on X Tuesday night, NTD spoke with Steamboat Institute Blankley fellow and co-founder of the Based Politics podcast, Brad Polumbo.
For more on the Trump-Musk conversation on X last night, we have Steamboat Institute
Blankly fellow and co-founder of the Based Politics podcast, Brad Palumbo.
Brad, there's a lot to talk about with this conversation.
It got off to a bumpy, delayed start caused by what Musk is calling a massive cyber attack.
What parts of the conversation stood out to you the most in terms of the actual content
of their talk?
Yeah, well, you're right to note that it got off to a rocky start.
I had trouble joining.
I was trying to tune in and struggled to, and was only eventually later able to listen
to the whole thing in full.
But I think it's sad that people would really try to just stop somebody from having a conversation.
I don't understand what they're so afraid of, that a former president would be able
to speak publicly to millions of people.
To me, the most interesting part of the conversation was hearing Trump recount the assassination
attempt in a more casual and personal setting, right?
They weren't on video.
He wasn't in a high stakes interview, and he just talked about the human side of how
it made him feel.
And I think no matter your politics, no matter whether you love Trump or hate him, the man
barely survived with his life, a really harrowing incident.
So that was really fascinating to hear his insight into it, and to see him engage with
Musk, who is an eccentric figure, to say the least, and very far from a traditional
media interviewer.
When they got into policy, I thought it left a lot to be desired.
But the more personal elements of it, I thought were compelling.
And Trump is known for these sort of publicity stunts, social media stunts.
What do you make of this use of social media by the Trump campaign?
Is it likely to bring in a wider pool of voters and resonate?
I don't think so, to any large extent, because Twitter is still a fairly niche app that most
Americans don't use.
Now, the coverage of it is going beyond the app, but if you were trying to reach Democrats
or moderates or independents, this is probably not the way to go on Twitter.
It's become more right-leaning in its audience and its base since Elon Musk took over.
But it is still an interesting new way to get out your message to the public, and it
has been heard and seen clips and excerpts millions and millions of times.
So I don't think it was an ineffective tactic, but it's not super well-targeted to swing
state voters or independents or anything like that.
But it is just interesting, and especially interesting in contrast to Kamala Harris,
who won't give an interview to anyone, let alone a two-hour conversation for the world
to see.
I would love to see her actually sit down with anybody and be asked about some of her
huge flip-flops, some of her inconsistent positions, some of the way that she's trying
to be all things to all people, to simultaneously be a establishment moderate Democrat and a
radical progressive from California.
I would love to see her have to square that circle in real time by any sort of interview,
even one that would hardly be adversarial if it was a mainstream media interview.
But she's just totally hiding from the press, and I think that's doing the public a disservice.
So obviously it was a softball.
It wasn't meant to be an adversarial interview with Trump and Elon, but at least he's doing
stuff.
He's also done more adversarial interviews, and he's getting his message out there to
the people.
Yeah, there's definitely a contrast between the Trump and Harris campaigns in terms of
unscripted interviews.
Now, Musk endorsed Trump shortly after the assassination attempt on Trump's life.
Tell us about Musk's reasoning here and the impact you think his endorsement could have.
Well, I think his endorsement is largely kind of a news item.
He's a super famous figure, and it could have some financial assets because Musk does have
resources to invest in a campaign.
But I will say I find Elon Musk's logic kind of bizarre to endorse someone immediately
after the assassination attempt against them.
That doesn't make someone more or less qualified to be president.
It doesn't make their policy ideas more or less correct.
Simply the fact that they barely survived an assassination attempt with their life in
some ways, Trump was heroic during all of that, I'll certainly acknowledge.
But to go and say, therefore, I'm supporting him for president doesn't make a whole lot
of sense to me as a logical matter.
It seems more emotional, emotionally driven, just, you know, I feel for him.
He just barely survived with his life.
But again, that doesn't tell you much about policies.
So if prior to that event, you weren't on board with the policy agenda of Trump and
now you are, that doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me logically.
Yeah, it's interesting wondering what else there could be behind that endorsement.
Recently Musk has received criticism from some countries for not policing content on
X around, say, the Venezuela election and riots in the UK.
Just before this interview, in fact, the EU seemingly warned Musk to watch what he and
Trump discuss.
What did you make of that, that letter that he received?
Yeah, I think it's an authoritarian attack on free speech from European bureaucrats who
are trying to exert control over American companies.
They have absolutely no right to dictate terms to.
I think Elon should tell them in no uncertain terms to go and just get that out of here.
We're not going to have any sort of intimidation or bullying us into censoring people on our
app, because, look, nobody elected these European Union bureaucrats to be in charge of American
companies.
Our American companies have a First Amendment right in their own to host whatever speech
they feel is appropriate.
And that is not subject to the whims of unelected European bureaucrats.
We are not a member of the EU.
They do not get to dictate how our companies are run.
And you know what?
Ultimately, if they want to play hardball, then they can turn off X in the European Union,
right?
They can play hardball, but I don't think the EU really wants to play this game or has
the spine to actually disentangle itself from America's innovative tech sector.
But we cannot counter their demands and let them start demanding and controlling how our
most innovative sectors are run.
All right.
In closing, Brad, during last night's conversation, Musk talked about the need to make the federal
government more efficient.
At one point, he offered to be part of an efficiency commission, to which Trump said
he'd love to see that.
Could we see Musk involved in the Trump administration somehow?
If Trump is elected.
It's an interesting idea.
He certainly knows something about how to run a successful company.
Now, the whole, you know, running a business so I should run the government thing doesn't
always translate super effectively.
But I will say, with our current federal government's massive blow, losing hundreds and hundreds
of billions of dollars to fraud and waste during the COVID debacle, all of this, you
know, they could use pointers from anyone.
So if we could get some efficient, effective, proven CEOs with a track record in there to
advise them, I think that couldn't really hurt.
And it maybe could help a little bit.
Yeah.
I mean, you have Trump, who had no political background before his administration, you
know, achieving records in unemployment.
All right.
Brad Palumbo, co-founder of the Based Politics podcast.
Thank you so much for joining us today.
Thanks for having me.