Lecture 19

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Aug 10, 2024
[Music]
hello and welcome to another lecture of
classical motion of a single particle
now in this lecture we simply continue
our previous discussion of different
interesting features uh considering the
motion under a central force and just
just uh during the last lecture where we
really stopped and after that we solved
two small problems we discussed two
small problems but exactly I
mean like as far as the lecture contents
or the discussion uh is concerned we
actually stopped by just stating the
bartran theorem and bartran Theorem is a
super interesting theorem which says
that only two Central Force laws are
possible where every single bounded
motion is associated with a closed
trajectory okay however you have to uh
pay attention to the point that butr
theorem does not say that every motion
under these two force will always
associate a closed trajectory that is a
wrong idea so butran theorem simply
states that if you have a motion under
any of these two forces and somehow you
are guaranteeing that the motion is
bounded between a r Max and an R minimum
that means the motion now you can in
terms of the energy diagram okay for
Effective 1D motion you know that you
have two turning points two well-
defined turning points at some finite R
values then only you can uh expect uh
always you can always expect a closed
trajectory Associated to that motion
okay now and today in this lecture we
will start more formally several I mean
uh discussing several features of the
motion under a inverse Square law of
force okay so inverse Square law is
simply given by F of R which is equal to
Alpha over r² H where Alpha can be
greater than Z or less than Zer if it is
greater than zero it is repulsive Force
if it is less than zero then it will be
an attractive Force now F of R is equal
to - K by r² can be definitely an
attractive
Force if we claim that right from the
beginning k is positive okay so we will
throughout our study we will exactly uh
use this convention that F of R is equal
to minus K by R squ and K is positive
okay we should write
now the total energy conservation just
to I mean just to exactly uh analyze the
motion this VR by R motion under an
inverse Square law okay that is our
first goal so for that we write the
total energy
conservation half m r dot
s+ l/ l s / 2 M
r² plus the true potential energy fire
or sometimes we also say I should not
deviate much from my convention V of R
okay that is exactly equal to the total
energy total mechanical energy capital E
okay now L is the angular momentum
magnitude m is the mass of the particle
and this is known as the centrifugal
potential if you
remember which is indeed the cross
radial I mean which is indeed a part of
the kinetic energy and comes from the
cross radial part of the Velocity okay
so this is the true potential energy and
both of these combined gives us
something I just denote by this
color V
effective okay so our effective
potential okay and we said that in
general when we talk in terms of the V
effective okay or the effective
onedimensional Motion in a central Force
we plot V effective as a function of r
to analyze the motion now for a inverse
Square law what
happens I can actually write that F of R
is equal to minus K by
r² so V of R will simply be equal to
minus integration F of R Dr R and you
can easily see that this is so minus
there is a minus there is a minus that
will go away so it will simply have K by
r² d r R okay and then you will have is
equal to minus K by R plus some
constant okay now you can simply say
that when R is equal to Infinity I make
a convention such that my Vel my
potential V at Infinity is zero and that
actually makes this C to vanish and
simply your true potential energy will
simply be minus k/ r okay so that that
means for an inverse Square law the V
effective is actually l s by 2 m
r²
minus k/
r okay so that is
the uh part we can use here okay so this
exactly this function we will now plot
as a function of r here now for that we
just have to remember two things that
when R tends to zero a even before that
we have to make some uh careful
observations so in a true 1D motion your
displacement X can be positive and
negative however here
R is the distance from origin to the
particle in spherical polar or now in
this Central Force case it is 2D polar
coordinates system system so this is
simply the radial distance measured from
the origin to the particle so it cannot
be by definition negative so that's why
the energy diagram in this for this uh
effective 1D motion will be only
covering the first quadrant okay and
where I mean first quadrant of course
the I mean formally saying the first
quadrant and the fourth quadrant where R
is positive okay V effective on the
other hand can be both positive and
negative okay so this is my origin and I
can simply realize two things one is
when R tends to
zero then you see that this part and
this part okay they have both of them
okay are in the denominator but with the
different power so when R is tending to
zero so it is very small it's a proper
fraction so having proper fraction in
the denominator is actually saying that
it is always multiplied by a number
which is uh greater than one so when R
is getting smaller and smaller so this
term is actually getting also smaller
and smaller now since this term is
actually in the denominator of this this
centrifugal potential term gets greater
and greater and with respect to this
term this term is not get get enough
importance at this limit and that is why
when uh R is tending to zero V effective
almost behaves like l s by 2 m r² so
that means some constant by R square and
its nature so and this is with a
positive sign so V
effective starts like this so exactly at
Infinity I mean exactly at R is equal to
Z it is at Infinity so that's why it
starts from a w very very high value
over here and
then it decreases okay now of course you
can understand then it decreases to
certain value and finally this one also
comes into play and there is a
competition between the values of this
term and this term and at some point
both of them nullify each other to have
a v effective which is zero and then
this term shoots again okay and finally
what what happens if you see so of
course we know that it will decrease and
at some time it will touch V effective
will be equal to zero that we know again
we know that when R is tending to
Infinity then this term will vanish or
will how to say like uh drop off very
quickly because this is one upon R
square dependence and here this is one
upon R dependence so both of them will
go off but this one will go off very
quickly with respect to this one so then
effectively your V effective will be
determined
by this 1 / R term now this has a minus
sign before it and K we said that this
is always positive so it will try to be
zero but from the negative side so it
should be look like I mean it should
look like this so in between this two
okay okay one can do a much more
detailed analysis also by exactly
calculating the maximum minimum at this
point or you can simply say okay I can
simply just by using my intuition I can
add this two by saying okay the most
reasonable thing will be that okay that
there will be a point of local minimum
and then finally it again uh increases
and finally asymptotically reaches zero
but always being negative the V
effective curve okay so here you see
that this is the energy diagram for a
particle moving under an inverse Square
law and what is the uh most important
point is that whenever you have a local
minimum or local maximum in general you
have some meaning or some Physics
associated with it and here what is the
meaning of that now here is there is a
very interesting difference between a
true 1D motion and a effective 1D Motion
in a true 1D motion let's say if you
have something like that so at this
point okay so this is X and this is V of
X at this point when the particle is
having some minimum okay we say this is
an equilibrium point and where it is
having some for example stable
equilibrium that we have already
discussed now
here this is true but and and this is
simply this is just a point this is just
a point this is a I mean a value of
displacement certain value of
displacement but the once again in one D
so the motion or the trajectory is
always linear motion okay so this is in
a linear motion it is simply giving us
one point okay so for example when the
system is having certain energy where it
is I mean certain potential energy that
its displacement is this one okay that
means the systems has only one possible
I mean with this energy let's say I am
just talking about this energy e okay
and it cuts only at one single point and
which is the point of the minimum okay
of this curve of this potential curve
then if you just give this much energy
to the system the system will have only
one possible displacement okay so that
is the thing
here if I on the other hand gives the
system
some energy some magic amount of energy
where exactly this energy is equal to
the minimum value of the V effective
then what
happens then basically the system has
only one R possible what does it mean
that it will only have
1.1 possible displacement value no it is
simply saying that the system has only
one value of R point possible so in this
motion the r is constant and if in a
motion R is constant that means the
system is actually undergoing a pure
circular
trajectory okay so that is something
very important to understand here at
this
point this is nothing but
a circular
trajectory with this
radius equal to some R is equal to
r0 okay now coming back to some other
situations so for example let's say you
have an energy which is uh I mean equal
to some value over here then again you
see that you your system will have a
bounded motion with some R Min and R Max
and here sorry if I give you
a value of energy which is here let's
see e Prime okay then here you can say
actually this is e Prime and here this
is e Prime then you can simply say that
the particle only has one turning point
and so the particle is not having any
bounded motion so its R Min is finite
but its R Max can be Infinity okay so
this is unbounded motion this is bounded
motion and this is a special case of
bounded motion which is circular okay
now with all these things we can even
calculate the radius of the circle and
the corresponding energy for an inverse
Square law okay so how to calculate the
radius first of all so we already
understand that
for a
circular
orbit okay we should have DV
effective
Dr r z should be zero
okay then you can do simply the
calculation just by keeping in mind that
V effective is equal to l s by 2 m
r² minus I just have to check K by R
right yes K by
R so then DV effective d R will simply
be equal to - L ² by m
rb+ k by
r² and that should be evaluated at R is
equal to r0 sorry
r0 and which should finally vanish then
you can simply say that okay K by r0 S
should be exactly equal to to l s by m
r0
cub and my r0 will be simply equal to l
z l squ by
MK you see this is the very fantastic
result for a motion under an inverse
Square attractive inverse Square Force H
here we are talking in terms of the
attractive inverse Square law so r0 is
equal to l s by MK L Square is nothing
but a constant of motion A and K both
are constant of motion so for a system
for a for an inverse Square law what
would be the radius of a particle for a
given inverse Square law you can easily
calculate from the initial conditions
from the knowledge of constants of
motion equivalently and also from the
exactly if you know the law of force
that means if you know what is f of
r equ alal to Min - K by r² so that K is
also very important okay now one can
also ask that what will be the
corresponding potential energy I mean of
course the effective potential energy so
that will be then V of
r0 which must be I would say V effective
r z which must be V effective
minimum is equal
to Min - K by r0
right plus l s by 2 m r0 s okay now
already we have seen that what is r0 squ
is l s by MK okay so I can easily write
this is min - K by
r0 plus l s by 2 m r0 s is L to the 4
uh let me just check I can do another
thing actually I can do like this I can
do one thing I
can yes I can substitute for the first
term that will be even easier to
understand yeah both are actually
equivalent so I can do one thing I can
simply write this R Zer this R zero okay
I can write K by l s by MK so this r0 I
can write l s by m k over
here plus then I also have l Square by
r0 squ now this is true that whenever
you have such things one can actually
make that r0 s is L to the 4 by m² k s
okay so one can actually then write that
r0 squar so l s by 2 m r0 s is L the
4/ m² k
s and that L to the 4 and L Square will
go away to give me L
squ and that m m Square will go away and
finally will
have
minus m k s by l
s then also you will have have here
plus
m k s by 2 L
S and you will have so this is just
double of this with a minus sign so
finally it will have minus m k s by 2 L
S Which is less than zero so this is the
total value of V
effective when the particle is having
its minimum effective potential energy
and particle is actually exhibiting its
motion in a circular orbit under an
attractive inverse Square law of force
okay and since this is the minimum value
of V
effective I can always write that any V
effective can always be greater than or
equal to this value minus MK s by 2 L
Square okay that I can write I can
write okay
since Min - m k s by 2 L S is V
effective
minimum okay if I write that I can add
some positive definite quantity which is
nothing but the kinetic the effective
kinetic energy for of the particle
like this and which must be greater than
equal to zero will also be then greater
than equal to minus m k s by 2 l s that
much I can write okay this is quite easy
to follow then I finally
write e which is the total mechanical
energy must be greater than or equal to
- m k s by 2 L S okay okay that much I
can also write and it simply gives me
e+ m k s 2 L
S greater than equal
to0 and now you do something m k s by 2
L
S I will have 1 + 2 e l s
by m k
squ okay you see this is something which
I can write so I can simply take this
term common from here and then I can
write here here you have to just take a
caution this term is in general negative
and this term is positive definite the
sum of this two is I mean not a positive
definite quantity so e can or cannot be
positive that you have to always take
into account okay this fact so when I
say e is greater than equal to this it
can simply be a negative quantity but
the value will be greater than I mean
the I mean the how to say like this will
be simply can be negative but it will be
greater than this this value that much
we can claim now we can also say that if
we have this I can say another thing
which is very interesting is that this
is a quantity which is you can simply
see from here m k s by 2 L sare which is
greater than equal to zero actually
greater than zero you can say because
this is positive
quantity and since the multiplication or
the product of these two terms they are
greater than equal to zero that's why
this must also be greater than or equal
to zero okay and actually we will see in
a next discussion that that is
completely inconsistency with our
geometric understanding of the
trajectories of a particle under a
inverse Square law of force okay so
before I mean before going to the I mean
before going to the details of that let
me just call this positive for quantity
since this is a positive quantity I can
always express that as a square of a
real number huh which I call E huh and
we will see that this is nothing but
geometrically the
eccentricity of the conic section uh
which is nothing but uh a trajectory
okay already in a previous lecture we
have seen that the trajectory of a
particle under an inverse Square law is
given by a conic section
and more precisely under an attractive
inverse Square La is given by a conic
section so and for that conic section uh
we have to have some eccentricity we
will actually see that this quantity is
nothing but the square of that
eccentricity okay thank you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
