"In 1970, I became active in trying to stop the busing of elementary school children in #SanFrancisco," #QuentinKopp said about what led him to run for the San Francisco Board of Supervisors.
In 1971, the San Francisco Unified School District (#SFUSD) implemented a busing program to racially balance its schools and overcome neighborhood segregation. However, the program disrupted many families who preferred their kids to stay where they were, especially for the Chinese community in San Francisco.
"And people would say, 'What's that got to do with the Board of Supervisors?' And I just say, 'Because it involves the rights of citizens of the city and county of San Francisco,'" Kopp said.
After being elected and serving on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, Kopp held a seat in the California state #Senate for 12 years before being appointed a Superior Court judge by Gov. Pete Wilson.
Days before his 96th birthday, he continues to practice law and remains an active, influential voice in San Francisco and beyond.
Here's part 1 of Judge Quentin Kopp's legendary story.
Our innovator today is a legendary figure in San Francisco politics and law, Judge Quentin Kopp.
Quentin has dedicated much of his life to public service, beginning with his service in the United
States Air Force in the 50s during the Korean War. The guy got a letter from then President Harry S
Truman saying that I was accepted into the United States Air Force as a second lieutenant
in the Office of Special Investigations. He went on to serve on the San Francisco Board of
Supervisors and then held a seat in the California State Senate for 12 years.
And people would say what's that got to do with the Board of Supervisors? I'd say because it
involves the rights of citizens of the city and county of San Francisco. I was fortunate
to be elected. Before his 96th birthday, he continues to practice law and remains an active
influential voice in San Francisco and beyond. This is Bay Area Innovators and I'm your host
Steve Esposito. Quentin, it is an honor to have you on our show. Thank you very much.
Always a pleasure to be with reporters and commentators from the Epoch Times.
Thank you for being here. So, first question I'd like to ask you, it's about your service
in the military, in the Air Force. Please take us back in time to the 50s. What was it like
and why did you join the Air Force? Well, I'll answer that last question first. I joined
because I would have been drafted otherwise and I'd rather be an officer
than an enlisted man. I graduated college in 1949 and I was at Harvard Law School
and just completed my first year of a three-year educational program. When the North Koreans
invaded the Republic of Korea, also known as South Korea, several of my classmates had served
in World War II. They were called to duty immediately that summer. The war began on June 25,
1950. In October, after I'd started my second year, I got a notice to report
to the Boston Army Base for a physical examination prior to going in the Army.
Two other classmates were with me and the last step was at a table with two U.S. Army medical
doctors, one of whom said to the three of us, is there any reason you shouldn't see service?
Because we had passed all the physical exams and one of my classmates was a wise guy
and he said, I have no guts. Anyway, as soon as we left there, I called my mother in Syracuse,
New York, my home. Harvard is in Cambridge, Massachusetts. I told her what had happened
and said, would you please call the draft board and ask why I wasn't classified 1-A-S.
What is a 1-A-S? What is that?
1-A means you're fit and ready for active duty. S stood for student and she did that
and the chairman of the draft board, which consisted of three Syracuse citizens, residents,
said there was a mistake and your son should be 1-A-S. So I wasn't drafted.
Year later, about May of 1952, the war is still occurring and I finished my third year
and the first bar examination was given in the District of Columbia about the 20th of June.
This is 1952. It's a three-day exam and anyway, I finished that and previous to that, I had applied
at an air base near Boston for a commission in the Office of Investigations and I had been accepted
and I got a letter from then President Harry S. Truman saying that I was accepted into the United
States Air Force as a second lieutenant in the Office of Special Investigations.
I was waiting at home in Syracuse for an order to report to active duty and that came
about the 1st of August and I was ordered to report to Wright-Patterson Air Force Base,
which is 10 or 12 miles east of Dayton, Ohio and I got on a train and reported there on August 19,
1952 and it turned out that not only were there a couple of classmates of mine from
Harvard Law School, but also people in classes whom I knew at Dartmouth College and
I got notice from the District of Columbia Bar Association. I had passed the District
of Columbia bar examination, which made me eligible for the Judge Avica General Corps
and that had one advantage. If you were accepted in that, you were promoted automatically from
second lieutenant to first lieutenant, which also meant you were paid more money every month
than a second lieutenant. You seem to recall all of this so well, including the dates,
even though this is 70 years later, so it must have been very significant to you. It was. What
I want to ask you is what was the feeling that young people had at the time? Is this just
World War ended and people were looking for peace, right? There's always a problem of a draft
dodger. That was true in World War II, was true in the Korean War. President Harry S. Truman
was extraordinary in many ways. He had only a high school education. He'd been an officer in
the United States Army during World War I. He read history and he knew history and even though
he was the product of a political machine that was known for dishonesty and corruption, the
Pendergast machine, he was honest, protective of democracy. He also knew the military. He had been
a captain in either, I think it was the artillery during World War I. He served in France with the
American Expeditionary Force. He had the support of not just Democrats in the Congress of the United
States, but also Republicans who respected his decisions about the war. And as history tells us,
the only problem came a couple years after the war started when the general in charge of all forces,
the famous Douglas MacArthur, wanted to invade Communist China and go across the
Republic of Korea-China border. And Truman was fearless and he relieved MacArthur of his position
as commander-in-chief of all forces in Korea. Korea also was a war that the United Nations
came to assist in. There were 17 other nations who fought with the United States of America
against the North Korean Communists and successfully repelled them.
Next, I'd like to switch gears and move forward to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors.
You are known for your independence and for finding solutions to problems.
How did this pragmatic approach fit in San Francisco politics?
I, like my parents, was a registered Democrat from the time I was eligible in 1949.
Unfortunately, that was one year after Harry Truman upset Thomas E. Dewey to be elected
President of the United States. I was active in Democratic politics in San Francisco starting in
1958, supporting then Superior Court Judge Stanley Musk of Los Angeles for the Democratic nomination
for Attorney General against a state senator from Marin County who was a San Franciscan by birth
and by upbringing. In 1970, I became active in trying to stop the busing of elementary school
children in San Francisco. I had, at that time, three children. The first two were boys and the
two boys had started kindergarten. The younger one was in kindergarten. The older one was in the
second grade. Instead of being able to walk to school in the outer Richmond district of San
Francisco where we lived, they were bused. I thought it was wrong because there was no evidence
that the education in schools in different neighborhoods was worse than it was in our
neighborhood. I was asked to represent the families who fought busing and we filed a suit
in the United States District Court. We were assigned to a very unsympathetic judge. It's not
a type of case which entitles you to a jury trial because it's all based on the law.
Then the U.S. Supreme Court decided a case involving the school district in Charlotte,
North Carolina. The effect of that district was to permit busing of school children in Charlotte
to suburbs and vice versa, the busing to Charlotte schools of children attending
grade schools, elementary schools in the outlying suburbs. There had been a pending lawsuit
brought by about nine families, including one African American family. That case had been
stayed, in other words, delayed until this United States Supreme Court decision was issued.
The lawyer who had been representing those nine families,
pro bono publico, which means without charging a fee, was tired of doing so. He was exhausted.
He had to make a living. I became the attorney for six or seven of those families. My friend
represented the rest. They included at least two, maybe three Chinese parents who made the argument
that the Chinese and Japanese and other Asian country people had been the object
of what the Supreme Court had called invidious racial discrimination during the late 19th century
and until about 2005 when President Theodore Roosevelt negotiated a surrender of an
armistice between Russia and Japan in 1905. Part of that negotiated settlement was
California repealed its statute that Asian children had to attend their own school.
So we applied that to the present case saying I argued that my clients have been the object of
racial discrimination and they are entitled if they want to attend a school which has a mixed
racial population but they don't want to because in Chinatown there were two or three elementary
schools and after school ended for the day, usually 2.30 or 3 o'clock, they would go to
Chinese language school to perpetuate their knowledge of Chinese language. The same judge
in U.S. District Court in San Francisco wouldn't allow us to intervene in that pending law school.
In the meantime, I had become well known because we had two newspapers in San Francisco then and
radio and television covered this litigation almost every day and I decided that enough people
had heard of me or knew me that I could run for the Board of Supervisors and so that's what I
decided to do in June of 1971 and I had my announcement at Commodore Stockton School
in Chinatown because I'd been associated now with Chinatown for almost two years.
I campaigned on stopping busing of elementary school children and people would say,
what's that got to do with the Board of Supervisors? And I'd say because it involves
the rights of citizens of the city and county of San Francisco. I was fortunate to be elected.
I was elected sixth. There were about 21 candidates all together but I defeated
a fellow by the name of Peter Finnegan who was part of the so-called Democratic establishment
which supported busing even though he had two children who were bused and he
made a mistake in doing so because I beat him in what was considered an upset.
You ran for mayor in 1979 and there was a... 1979. Yes. Yeah. It was a very close election
and it was against Dianne Feinstein, the late senator.
Please tell us about that, your experience. Well, that's quite a story.
I had met Dianne Feinstein shortly after I moved to San Francisco. I arrived in San Francisco
December 20, 1955 and I think about a month or two months later I was introduced to Dianne
Goldman which is her maiden name. Her father was a medical doctor. Anyway, I had met her then.
She'd gotten elected in 1969 to the Board of Supervisors. She had said to Joe Alioto she'd
never run against him. Of course, she lied. She ran against Joe Alioto in 1971 and then in 1975
she ran again for mayor. In the meantime, a fellow by the name of John Barbagilata
who was a real estate broker on West Portal Avenue in San Francisco and he was a registered
Republican had been elected to the Board of Supervisors in 1969, the same time as Dianne
Feinstein. I had met John in 1964 during the Pierre Salinger campaign for U.S. Senate.
Even though he was a Republican, as a graduate of the University of San Francisco like Pierre
Salinger, he worked in that campaign and he was an unusual person in politics
because if he said he was going to do something, he did it. He proved himself during the Salinger
campaign by enlisting a lot of high school students to distribute literature lauding Pierre
Salinger for U.S. Senate. He wanted me to run for mayor in 1975 and I said I can't do it because
another candidate for mayor was Superior Court Judge Jack Ertola who I had known since 1958.
He was part of a group who formed a San Francisco Democratic Club and I wouldn't run against
Jack. I also didn't think I had in four years learned enough to be mayor. That never bothered
Feinstein who ran after only two years and now she's running again four years later.
Well, John Barbara Gelada failing to persuade me to run for mayor then decided he would run
and he concentrated on one thing only and that was defeating Feinstein,
finishing ahead of her so then he'd be in a runoff because the favorite was then State Senator
George Moscone who'd been elected State Senator I think in 1964 and was an energetic,
bright young lawyer my age. Anyway, John did that and his literature concentrated on
documents which compared his votes with Feinstein's votes on issues during the
six years that they were on the Board of Supervisors together and he was successful.
He finished second and so then George and he were in a runoff four weeks later,
first Tuesday in December and he was not sophisticated politically and George was.
If you asked for something upon his election, he'd say automatic. He'd promise anything,
George. So John lost. Then came the change to district election of supervisors
which resulted in the election of Harvey Milk who had run before unsuccessfully and whom I had helped
with problems in understanding city and county government by giving him information particularly
about the budget and then Dan White who never would have gotten elected in a at-large election
of supervisors and that resulted eventually in Dan White murdering George Moscone, Harvey Milk.
In the meantime, after district elections were approved by San Francisco voters,
an initiative in November 1977, Feinstein had run from Pacific Heights where she lived.
She had about four opponents and I live in Lakeshore Acres and there were five of us
in the district that was drawn including St. Francis Wood and Ingleside Terrace
and the other four who lived there were disgusted. They didn't want anything to do
with local government and they didn't run. So I was the only candidate and I got the most votes
of anybody about 22 or 3,000 compared to what you had to get. The first time I ran in 1971,
I got 116,000 votes. The highest vote getter got about 153,000 and the custom was it wasn't
written into an ordinance or the San Francisco charter but whoever got the most votes would be
president. So you didn't have for two years till the next election and Feinstein had been beaten
for mayor twice and John Barbara Gelada came up with the idea of letting her be president of the
board if she'll endorse you for mayor against George Moscone and everybody including George
knew I was going to run in 1979. So I did that and five of us met including three of the supervisors
who lived in the same neighborhood and weren't running and she stated unequivocally that she
would endorse me for mayor if I let her be the president of the board of supervisors.
And I still recall that two of the supervisors who had served with me before district elections
said to me the day of the vote when we're sworn in as supervisors, what's going on? Why aren't you
going to be president? I said I'll tell you later because I was ashamed. I didn't want to tell them
I'd made a political deal and I had asked her when are you going to endorse me and she said
because we're sworn in about January 7th of the year after the November election.
She said probably April or May. Well her husband got cancer. His name was Dr. Bert Feinstein
and he died and I didn't want to invade her mourning over the death and then she
got a new boyfriend Dick Blum and he was a explorer in a manner of speaking especially in
the Pacific and in Asia and they went on some trip to some one of the Asian countries
and when they came back she was had just come back the day before Dan White assassinated Harvey
Milt and George Moscone and under the law she became president. In the November ballot
she got 44 percent of the votes and I got 42 percent. A fellow by the name of David Scott
who was gay, a real estate broker on Market and Castro Street who had moved here from Pennsylvania
where he'd been a Republican aide to a Pennsylvania legislator then was not in the runoff
and usually used to get anywhere from 15 to 20 people running who weren't going to be elected
but they got their name in the paper so it gave them a rationale to run. Anyway he wanted to
endorse me and he came down to my law office and he said I'd like to be appointed to the
Airports Commission and that's a violation of the California election code to promise something
of value in return for a vote and I said David let me I said think about it because
there's a legal problem. I couldn't do it but she did it so then he went to her
and she promised him an appointment to the Airports Commission so he told all his voters
to vote for her and that's how she defeated me to be elected mayor. Quentin thank you so much
for your time. This is the end of part one of our interview. We'll be back with part two.
Thank you for watching and next week we'll watch part two of this interview.