ENGLISH SPARKLING WINE vs CHAMPAGNE! Tasting Nyetimber & Taittinger side by side

Sparkling Collection
4 followers
13 Video Views·Aug 6, 2024
It had to happen sooner or later! This was not a blind tasting, nor do I make any claim to being impartial - so you can probably guess the outcome... but I think it was an interesting exercise to highlight some of the similarities and some of the differences.
Hello. Welcome to another English Sparkling with Tweenie video, based on a suggestion from
Funky Trumpeter. I thought I would do a tasting of Champagne versus English Sparkling. This has
obviously been done many times before and I believe some people in the English wine industry
were recently saying at a conference that they were sick to death of these comparisons. So I
thought it would be interesting for me personally to try what I think are roughly fairly comparable
wines from the two regions side by side, see what the differences are. I'm not going to be doing this
blind and at least partly because I don't have anyone to hand to do the setup for me. You really
need somebody else to sort of hide the wines and so you don't know which is which. But also I'm
including Nightimber in this and it's a wine that I'm very familiar with and if I knew in advance
that one of the wines was Nightimber, the other one was a Champagne, I'm pretty sure I would
recognize the Nightimber and that would then bias my whole judgment. So, you know, to do this
properly I would need to not know what the wines are, I think, and perhaps not be familiar with
them either. I spent some time thinking about the particular choice of wines. A lot of the English
Sparkling wines I drink are actually from quite small vineyards. Some of my favourites are things
like Breaky Bottom and Eastme on tiny vineyards and you can't really compare them to big names
in Champagne. So they're probably more the equivalent of grower Champagnes, I suppose,
small independent grower Champagnes. So what I've tried to go for is a big name from England
against a big name from the Champagne region. So this is Nightimber, this is Tattinger. We should
quickly talk about the prices first. I tried to find two things that were in roughly the same
bracket. I bought two half bottles for a start because it just seemed like a cheaper way to do
that comparison. This particular half bottle of Nightimber came in at £22 but as a caveat to that
the full size bottle was on special offer in Waitrose at only £29.99. Normally I think that
would retail for £39.99 so if we're comparing full size bottle prices we've got a £40 bottle here
whereas I think the full price full bottle of this is £45? £44? £45? And confusingly this
half bottle was on special offer. So of the two of these half bottles this one came in at slightly
more expensive £22, this one came in at £20 but had I bought the full size bottles this would
have been the bargain of the two at £29.99 and this would have been £45. I also tried to pick
two wines that had roughly similar blends of grapes in them. So we'll start with the Nightimber.
There is a little code on the back so you can tell the very specific batch that this came from
and the blend information there. It is 48% Chardonnay, 33% Pinot Noir and 19% Pinot Meurnier.
The Tattinger is actually reasonably similar, it's not exactly the same. 40% Chardonnay, 35% Pinot Noir
and 25% Pinot Meurnier. Interestingly on the Tattinger website they note that the proportion
of Chardonnay there is unusually high as they put it in fine non-vintage champagnes. It was a surprise
to me actually that lots of champagnes seem to be more Pinot Noir dominant rather than Chardonnay
dominant. That's a thing that is more common in English sparkling is to have the Chardonnay be
the single biggest grape in the blend. There are probably some differences as well here in the
length of ageing involved. At a high level both houses say that the wines have been aged for three
years or more but when you get into the details it's quite different. Again that code on the back
of the Nightimber bottle gives you some very detailed information about bottling dates, about
riddling dates, about disgorgement dates and I think this has only had something like 16 months
on the lease which is surprisingly short and I think that statement of the wine having been
aged for three years comes partly from the fact this is a multi-vintage. The most recent vintage
is 2020, bottling started in 2022 so even the most recent, the newest portion of this wine
had aged prior to bottling for about 18 months. The other reserve vintages go back to about
2015. There is less detailed information on the Tattinger website other than, as I say,
them saying that it has aged for three years or more so not clear based on that information
whether that's ageing on the lease or ageing in some other form. At least one other source I read
said that this has been aged on the lease for at least three years so I would guess of the two,
the Champagne here, the Tattinger has probably had more time on the lease so probably will exhibit
more autolytic character, more of those sort of bready, yeasty kind of notes. The last thing we
can compare these on in terms of technical information is dosage, the amount of sugar
that is added when the wine is topped up after disgorging, after removing the dead yeast cells.
We have a precise figure again for the Nightimber that is 8.5 grams a litre. As a quick reminder,
the Brut range, the most typical style today of both English sparkling and Champagne, is between
6 grams a litre and 12 grams a litre so 8.5 roughly in the middle. I couldn't find a precise figure
again on the Tattinger website but other sources said around 9 grams and I think I saw different
sources yet saying 10 grams so I think they are roughly similar. They're both kind of more or
less in the middle of that range that you describe as Brut so the sweetness levels I would anticipate
to be roughly similar between the two. Let's open these up, pour them out, start with the Nightimber.
I've tried to use the same stemware, I don't know if these are ideal sparkling wine glasses, they're
a little bit on the big side but at least it's a fair comparison. We have similar sized glasses for
each. So there is the Nightimber, quite a different shape to the Corks there as well. I'll put those
side by side to get a sense. The colours to me look remarkably similar actually,
they're both kind of pale gold. I'm seeing similar-ish levels of mousse, perhaps there's a
little bit more mousse remaining on the Tattinger rather than the Nightimber and at least visually
it looks like similar sized bubbles. Let's start with the Nightimber, something I'm already familiar
with. The classic sort of characterisation of Nightimber for me is always lemon pastry but
that lemon can veer a little bit more towards apple. I think today I'm getting slightly more
of a sort of apple-y sense to that fruit character-wise with some citrus hints to it as
well and then there are these kind of delicate pastry notes. I've always assumed that is autolytic
character but that might actually come from somewhere else and again I'm surprised to learn
that the amount of time on the Lees is relatively short, 16 months, so we're not expecting to find
a lot of ready yeasty kind of notes here. I wouldn't expect to find a lot with that relatively
short Lees aging period. Apple, possibly baked apple, citrusy notes, pastry on the nose,
quite a nice zing to that, slightly zingier than I remember last time I had Nightimber.
Within English sparkling wines tends to be a relatively lower acidity in Nightimber,
they're quite big on malolactic fermentation which tends to soften some of that malic acid
which gives it that really kind of powerful green apple zing, replaces it with lactic acid which
makes it sort of creamier and softer. Decent amount of zing on that, a classic English sparkling
wine trait, correspondingly some green apple in terms of fruit character on the palate,
all quite zingy, quite mineral, fine bubbles. Let's give the Tattinger a nose. Seems a bit
more subtle to me, I'm certainly not getting either apple or lemon initially, they're hallmarks
of Chardonnay in England and this has a, you know, a tiny bit less Chardonnay in it but still
a decent chunk, it's the single biggest grape of the three, 40%. Much more delicate sort of a nose
there with, if I had to pick a fruit character I think we're looking at something in the stone fruit
sort of category, possibly white peach, but very subtle. Maybe something nutty there as well?
What I'm surprised by is I'm not getting right now a lot of autolytic character, I thought by
comparison with the Nightimber I would get a lot of brioche-y, bready sort of notes, maybe a little
bit of that's coming through now. Peaches and almonds I think I have so far on the palate,
there's still a decent amount of acidity there, not quite as zingy and green apple-y as the
Nightimber was, I would say that's a little bit more like the tartness you could possibly find
in something like a peach. It's overall less fruity to me, it's drier but not dry in the acidic way,
dry as in the absence of sweetness and a bit more savoury on the palate. If I had to pick a fruit
character there I would say stone fruit, peaches. So overall I'm getting a lot more of a pinot style
of wine here, which is interesting again because Tattinger really seemed to make a point about this
is an unusually high percentage of chardonnay. I feel like I'm tasting more pinot type character
notes there. I like the texture to that, the fruit expression is definitely less clear,
might be worth briefly pausing to compare the corks. I believe that is a Diam cork,
I think these are sometimes referred to as technical corks, it is still essentially a cork
fabric, I don't think it's anything synthetic. I believe these are sort of treated in a way to
prevent any kind of or lessen the chance of any wine faults that may come from interaction with
the cork, whereas the Tattinger cork looks to me much more like a traditional pure cork. I actually
think that is a better looking cork, it just looks more corky, whereas this they do look a little bit
space age and artificial almost, but I think a lot of wine makers now say that this is just a
much safer way to go in terms of reducing the chance of faults. I feel like we should go for
a round two here, so back to the Nightimber again. On second visit the fruit there, the apple,
definitely more apple today than than citrus, and that's got a little bit more baked apple
and I'm getting a bit more of a sense of that pastry, so we really have a kind of an apple pie
character, that's not something I always find in Nightimber, like I say it tends to veer a bit more
towards the citrus, and maybe I'm getting subtle notes of things like honey, there is a sort of
nice sweet edge to that. Yeah, baked apple, honey, bit of pastry, but then absolutely no danger of
this being cloyingly sweet. First met with that lovely zing on the palate, very fresh, it's very
light, zingier and fresher and lighter than I remember Nightimber normally being, and again
there are these sort of edges of fine patisserie and some sort of baked goods, but not bready or
yeasty at all, do round two on the Tattinger. Something new is developing there, still not
really fruit character but it reminds me a bit of kind of sugared almonds, that is kind of lovely
actually, that's some yeah sort of sweet almondy kind of note, still not really expressing fruit
but that's nice, I like that, and again certainly is a decent amount of acidity there, I wouldn't
say that is lacking in it, it's a slightly odd transition to go from that sweet, again possibly
there's bits of honey here, sort of sugared almonds, to that really quite dry palate. If
anything of the two I would guess this actually had slightly lower dosage and less presence of
fruit there. A vague suggestion of stone fruit, something peachy, but not abundantly fruity.
I feel like I should provide some kind of summary then, again lots of caveats here, I'm clearly very
biased in my preferences, I run a channel about English sparkling wine so you can tell which side
I'm bound to fall on, and I had some preconceived notions of what I thought the overall stylistic
differences are between the two wine regions, and of course we are just comparing one wine from one
region with one wine from another region, there certainly isn't a holistic assessment of the
entire output of one versus the entire output of the other. It has reminded me that some of the
things that are really nice about English sparkling are the zing, that sort of bright bold acidity,
but that's certainly not completely lacking in champagne. I'd say it's more pronounced
in the Nightimber, but not completely absent in the Tattinger. Fruit expression, I've heard this
said before about English sparkling, I do feel like there's more easily discernible fruit character.
Once again these are roughly similar grape blends, there's a little bit more Chardonnay
in the Nightimber, but you know they're as close as I could get for two wines from completely
different regions. Roughly similar breakdown of the three main champagne varieties in here,
and yet there's a lot clearer expression of apples with that backdrop of citrus here,
whereas in the champagne much harder to get a sense of the fruit character there. I'm not sure
what the Chardonnay is bringing to the party at all to be honest in the champagne, but there are
some subtle but nice peachy notes which I assume come from the Pinots. In the interest of fairness
I would say in the Tattinger there are some really interesting, I don't know if these are secondary
or even tertiary notes, but that sugared almond, those hints of honey on the nose really quite nice
and there's something beyond just straightforward primary fruit character. But then the palate,
I don't know, I found a little bit underwhelming if I'm honest. It was kind of restrained and
savoury and wasn't giving off a lot of fruit. Texturally fine, I don't think there's much to
choose between these in terms of the mouthfeel, the quality of the bubbles, the fineness of the
bubbles, but slightly less zing, just a little bit less interest on the palate in terms of fruit
character or anything else. I think once you get past the nose, which I do quite like, sort of tails
off in interest for me a little bit. Once again this is clearly not an impartial comparison,
very clear which side my bread is buttered on. This is a wine that I know and love already versus
something that I've just sort of picked somewhat at random, but I think it's a fair-ish comparison
in the sense that they're stylistically quite similar in a lot of ways. So I hope that's been
useful and or interesting. I'm sure there are much more professional versions of this comparison
out there and apologies to anyone actually in the industry who is sick to death of hearing
these comparisons. I found that quite an interesting exercise actually. I think there
are still interesting things going on in champagne. Possibly in the future it might be
interesting to compare a small vineyard from England, a small producer from England versus a
small producer, one of those sort of grower champagnes as they call them from the champagne
region, and in a way we might be comparing more the sort of best with the best rather than the
sort of the biggest with the biggest or some of the biggest with some of the biggest. Anyway, cheers!
