Lecture 14 : Sauerbrey Equation and QCM-D

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Aug 2, 2024
[Music]
so welcome back so we are into the third
week as I mentioned in my earlier class
that from this section we will be
talking about this is the basic
of the mass sensitivity of qm now when
we talk about the mass sensitivity now
let's see how the frequency change is
happening so this is on the y axis you
have the frequency change and this
is the basic Crystal sitting out there
now you have some molecules which are
added the very moment the molecules are
added automatically as I say you if this
is moving at a certain frequency once
you add this the frequency is going to
come down as you could see come down and
if you add more
molecules three now here you see almost
six
molecules other I'm adding few more of
these on it it is going to go down even
further you realize that's exactly what
you are seeing how this curve
is coming down so this is how so say for
example now if you remove some of them
practically then this is now going to go
up remove more of those is going to go
further up okay so you see in a real
life you can actually see the addition
and subtraction of the mass which is
happening so a quartz crystal oscillator
at a constant frequency when an
appropriate voltage is applied so you're
applying a voltage and maintaining
constant frequency the oscillation fre
frequency starts to decrease as
molecules begin to deposit on the
crystal surface okay and the frequency
further decreases as more and molecules
get
deposited
now if you replace these molecules with
say
antibodies
DNA
proteins toxins
of
Anthrax this is one approach where they
have a very sensitive
balance which has the ability to
detect the changes which are happening
in the frequency
domain so two things to remember change
in
frequency Delta
F and Delta M and if you have expression
for this what s equation offers
you Delta
M which is change in mass is equal to
constant C which is okay when we talk
about the constant C so this constant C
comes
from some of these parameters the
density of the quads to
added
Mass velocity thickness of the quartz
crystal and all those things okay from
where and the detailed equation is
pretty interesting so minus c 1 upon N I
told you look for the vone number and
Delta
F so by changing the voltage you can
maintain it at a certain frequency and
if you keep the voltage constant it will
continue to vibrate at that c that
unique frequency but if you add a mass
on
it that mass change will alter the
frequency so if you look at the equation
it's almost like there is a
straightforward linear relationship
between change in frequency and change
in mass so if you see here as the mass
is increasing frequency is
decreasing so it's a very very linear
relationship but there's a catch where
this linear relationship holds and the
catch is here when I was showing you the
first slide I told you I'll come back to
this slide is out here there are a few
small lines which are written here and I
did not discuss
this so change in added mass m on the
crystal can be treated as an equivalent
of the crystal itself
provided provided that the added Mass is
now three conditions
important small compared to the crystal
Mass like you cannot add something which
is more than the crystal Mass you
understand so if the crystal mass is one
unit what you're adding must be far far
less than one unit point
one rigidly absorbed with no slip or
deformation imposed by the oscillating
surface that means when something is
getting there it should rigidly absorb
on the surface it should get entrapped
into the surface if it is not if it is
behaving like a vastic material or if it
is kind of slipping out of the surface
it's rolling on the surface it's moving
like this it's not going to work so when
I adding something like this should
remain like this it should not be like
you know it's slipping away
or it's it's moving like this and all
those kind of things won't work so quart
Crystal microbalance you have to be
extremely
careful standard quartz crystal
microbalance won't work under those
situation and evenly distributed over
the surface why it is evenly distributed
over the surface because of this
situation if you look at
it if it is not evenly distributed what
will happen say for example your film is
like this so for example this is your
Crystal surface and your film is like
this the Shaded part is the
film so you will see some
different kind of frequency at this Zone
and a different kind of frequency at
this Zone and different kind of
frequency at this Zone and this whole
thing is going to
go
completely in a different tangent first
of all it should absorb firmly on the
surface 01 it should not slip on the
surface
and second thing it should be uniformly
distributed on the
surface if we maintain that then quartz
crystal microbalance is a really
powerful tool to measure the changes
now how the instrumentation really looks
like so here you have the quartz
crystal you have the crystal holder
sitting out here now here is the o
illat which generates a frequency
counter at what frequency things are
happening and this is attached to the
personal computer this is a very simple
and very actually it's extremely
simplistic way of showing it but
essentially it's out
here this is the basic thing now having
said this think
of a slightly different situation
we are talking about what Crystal
microbalance so we are assuming
everything should stick properly absorb
properly but so when we talk about
absorption we see these kind of
absorptions with gas
molecules or in the dry conditions
things which adhere on the surface but
when you talk about the molecules like
what we have been dealing
these kind of
molecules these are not molecules or
these are not things which remain very
dry they are always they always work
better in the presence of
water and the water enters into the
system then it's a very different Bame
so say for example when I'm showing this
is is in the air so say for example this
is inside the water or there is a thin
film of water then how it is going to
behave how this all this frequencies are
going to change are we realizing the
problem because when we talk about the
biosensing we are talking about
molecules
which does best in the presence of water
molecules
so for such
things will qm
work okay so coming
back the limitations when you talk about
the limitations of and the failure
of sber
equation for the sber equation to hold
the layer of the sensor must be thin and
rigid interestingly rigidity is not the
way biological
molecules
work and firmly attached to the crystal
surface if these conditions are
fulfilled sber equation could be used to
calculate the mass of the added layer
however however if the sensor layer is
soft which is exactly the biological
molecule thick or not coupled to the
sensor surface so it's kind kind of
there are slips the solber equation is
not valid the model will fail in these
situations and the calculated mass will
be
underestimated so you realize
for standard solber equation to work
there are some prerequisites so that's
why for a long period of time solber
equation has been used the qm has been
used
for gas sensing
so where what you do you pass the gas
through a chamber where you get rid of
the water and
everything so you dry up the gas and you
put it on the microbalance and measure
it it's a fantastic sensor for that kind
of situation but not for this kind of
situation okay so that brings us
to a Next Level what happens in weight
conditions the real biological scenario
the real life situation for biosensors
quartz crystal microbalance with
dissipation which is called as qcm D
where d stands for the
dissipation so first of all let's try to
imagine the situation so say for
example this is
uh something which vibrates like this
okay in air now think of it this is all
happening in the
air now if I take it inside the water
will it vibrate like
that by your common sense you can take
it won't vibrate like that because there
are film of water which is going to
prevent its
movement
now if you look at the SL in the liquid
environment however molecular absorption
includes contribution from assoc iated
liquid molecules as an additional
Dynamic
Mass via direct hydration solvation and
inment within the absorb film absorption
can produce soft visco elastic film so
to imagine it something like
that say for example this is the Crystal
and you
have water
molecules you have your analyte sitting
in them so there are
this material
is
now this situation is more like
a visco elastic film it is kind of you
know like
this film is slipping on the surface
okay and the resulting layer may not
fully coupled to the oscillating Crystal
so if you remember the conditions which
were laid for sorra equation to work
so it should be rigidly coupled on the
surface there should not be any slip and
the mass of course has to be very low as
compared to the mass of the Crystal but
here you see it is not fully coupled
this can lead to the dampening or energy
loss of the
oscillation because such situation say
for example something which is kind of
you know oscillating like this you put a
lot of water into this you will see the
oscillation frequency is going to go
down because it becomes
heavier so if you use a sensor which is
already now emed with water or has
absorbed lot of water then you have to
alter the equation because then your
Baseline has changed the frequency the
Baseline frequency has completely
changed and your basic theory is not
going to work here that Del Delta
m is linearly related to Delta F where
Delta m is your change in mass and Delta
f is your change in frequency because in
this situation your frequency is working
a very different way there is a
dissipation because of the it is
absorbing so in a real life what is
happening say for example this is a dry
Crystal and I put a say phosphate buffer
saline containing antibodies on top of
it
now these water molecule will get
absorbed on this surface so it will show
a different kind of dampening onto it so
the frequency change also will include a
dampening process coming back to the
slide this can lead to the dampening of
or energy loss of the oscillation this
is what I was trying to tell you there
will be a loss of energy in the
oscillation process of it the mass of
such film cannot be determined
accurately by measuring the
frequency change alone both frequency
change Delta
F and energy loss that is measured as
dision energy so Delta F now another new
term is coming into the game Delta D
or Delta D whichever we want to denote
it which is the dissipation changes need
to be measured to determine the mass
change
of a visco elastic film so now Delta M
or change in mass is
related
to Delta F and Delta D which is the
change in frequency and this is
dissipation changes furthermore by
monitoring both Delta F and Delta D
additional structural information
confirmational change in the film cross
linking swelling can be obtained because
now you are monitoring an another
parameter which is the dampening
parameter and we'll come to that how the
dampening parameter Works in this
situation now when we talk about qcmd
and its utility in
biosensing
qcmd also provides realtime information
on the visco elastic property most of
our biological molecules what we see are
visco elastic in nature most of these
polymers are visco elastic in nature of
the absorb FM such as
viscosity elasticity and density now you
are dealing with three different
parameter viscosity is resistance to the
flow of friction which it offered during
the flow elasticity all of you know and
density is mass per unit volume okay the
maximum Mass sensitivity of the
technique in liquid is less than 1
nanogram per cm square which is a unique
thing 1 nanogram per cm squar is no easy
feet the maximum film thickness that can
be measured varies from several to 100
nanometer to a few Micron depending on
the rigidity of the film qcmd has wide
range of application in various fields
of science some examples include
molecular interaction that is protein
protein interaction molecule to surface
interaction the Affinity of of the
biomolecules to The Binding site of the
functionalized surface the buildup of
polymer films and their interaction with
different constituent of liquid medium
and the effect of surfectants on various
Coatings biosensor application Etc so if
you look at the utility of
qcmd it is extremely extremely
robust only point is that you will have
one more parameter with along with Delta
Dela change in frequency will be Delta D
you have to have the
dissipation parameter to be taken into
account and then you can actually change
the change in mass not only that say for
example a protein in the initial phases
like this then it becomes like this this
change also can be
monitored how the conformational
geometry of the protein changes
depending on the situation adherence and
over period of time so you could have
a real
time monitoring using
qcmd and that's the beauty of this
technique of qcmd that you can monitor
multiple things and again to reiterate
protein protein interaction so for
example you have one set of protein and
there's another set of protein how
they're interact AC ing you can monitor
it molecule to surface interaction so
you can quote the surface with certain
things whether it's hydrophobic surface
or a hydrophilic surface based on its
viscoelastic nature because you are
taking into account the viscosity mind
it elasticity and density you can see
the
change how much is the interaction
happening what kind of interaction is
happening buildup of the polymer films
how the film is forming does it forming
a continuous film say for example
polymer sometime polymer forms a
continuous film self assemble monol
layers sometime it forms broken up films
you can actually monitor
such
unique um I would say molecular events
which otherwise is not feasible with any
other form of sensors okay so apart from
it you can also understand how different
kind of liquid medium could change the
conformational geometry and
movement self assembly of the different
molecules okay now qcmd is a deviation
from the classic SRA equation okay the
linear relationship between frequency
and mass as defined by the Sor fails for
vastic film hence it is important to
take dissipation into account when
quantifying vastic Mass remember this
word visque elastic mass okay
dissipations defined as the inverse of
crystals quality Factor Q as expressed
by D is equal 1 upon Q where e
dissipation upon 2 pi e which is a store
where e dissipation is the energy
disputed in one cycle and is stored is
the energy stored in the oscillating
system okay followed this there are two
ways you can
Define this qcmd it could be defined
either by equivalent circuit model or it
could be defined by the mechanical model
if you define it by the mechanical model
this is where the mass we were seeing
okay so
when you are defining it based on these
two models when a p Electric quartz
crystal resonates both electrical
current and the mass oscillate
simultaneously okay therefore quarts can
be represented by either its equivalent
electrical circuit as shown in the
figure or a mechanical circuit shown out
here okay the electrical circuit model
consist of
inductance Henry
capacitance
resistance in series these are all
connected in series and a parallel shunt
resistance Co the mechanical circuit
model consist of mass m as I showing you
connected to a spring with a spring
constant of K this is that spring with a
constant k and a dashb with a dampening
of
Y the two models can be compared as
follows L1 represent the oscillating
Mass C1 represent its elasticity and R1
represent the energy loss in the system
and c0 is a shun capacitance due to the
overlap of the electrode on the crystal
surface c0 is purely electrical and does
not have any represent in the mechanical
world so this particular thing this
component this is purely purely
electrical thing there is no equivalent
mechanical counterpart into the system
and if you look
at energy dissipation in electrical
circuit model can be defined as as I
mentioned D is equal
to 1 upon
Q R1 upon 2 pi multiplied by frequency
by where F refers to the frequ quency
the two most common approaches that use
electrical circuit model for measuring
energy dissipation as resistance
analysis or impedence analysis there are
two ways you can do and mostly it is
there is a third technique which is
being used most currently so if you look
at the resistance
analysis in resistance analysis what you
do in qmr the resistance of the crystal
can be measured by introducing small
resistor into the circuit and measuring
the voltage change so you introduce a
small resistance or resistor into the
circuit and you measure the change in
voltage if the shun capacitance c0 has
been cancelled and measured current of
the resonating crystals equivalent
circuit will be proportional to the
crystals resistance R1 which is the sum
of the losses this approach however does
not provide an absolute value because L1
is not known so if you look at L1 here
that's what I was trying to tell you
this this value is not
known so L1 is not known in this type of
measurements also the true cancellation
of c0 may not be achieved if the crystal
is significantly loaded for these
reasons the resistance approach provides
relative structural data you do not get
a very unique Absolute Data in this but
when you talk about the impedence
analysis
it is slightly different in impedence
analysis qcm Z which is represented
by is a more defined approach for
measuring energy loss in this method all
four elements of the crystal equivalent
circuit can be determined by impedence
analysis so how you do so it's very
interesting here is the equivalent
circuit
okay now in order to so you have to
determine all the four elements like L1
c r
and the shant
resistance okay the setup includes a
frequency generator that provides varing
input frequencies to the equivalent
circuit the current and phase are
recorded at each
frequency of the frequency sweep
allowing all the four component L1 C1 R1
and the shunt to be numerically fitted
the limitations of this approach is that
fitting of this equivalent circuit Works
only when crystal is at a steady state
the crystal needs to be stabilized at
each frequency step interface and that's
why the data generation is extremely
timec consuming in this effort it takes
a hell amount of time to use impedence
analysis qcm Z process for data analysis
and that's why each one of this process
comes with a set of drawbacks and I told
you that there's a fourth method which
is most commonly or getting extremely
popularized nowadays is this one which
is quartz crystal microbalance with
energy dissipation a third approach that
is gaining increasing popularity qmd in
this method the quartz crystal is
excited to a resonant frequency for a
short period by applying a driving
voltage
so here you have the crystal you have
the electrod and you
basically it is excited with a resonance
frequency for a short period by applying
a voltage across it so you are applying
a voltage across it and it is resonating
the driving voltage is then turned off
and the voltage DEC over the crystal is
recorded as a function of
time the voltage over the crystal DEC as
exponentially dampened sinusoidally
given by this
particular expression where W here
a is the
amplitude here is the DK time constant f
is the frequency here is the phase angle
and the DK time constant is related to
the dissipated Factor
by this
relationship so this is currently the
most widely used qcmd method therefore
by numerically fitting the DK curve both
frequency and the dissipation of the
crystal can be obtained
simultaneously the DK time constant
depends on the rigidity or softness of
the mass absorbed on the crystal surface
for example rigid materials such as
metal films coupled with the oscillating
quarts when the driving voltage is turn
off the oscillation takes longer to
decay in other word the dek Curve will
be longer on the other hand if the
absorb mass is soft or Vis elastic such
as as protein lipids Etc it's coupling
with oscillating quarts is FL the
flexible Vis elastic mass dampens the
crystal oscillation causing DK faster
and the DK Curve will be shorter I'll
show you a schematics that will help you
to understand it here it is you look at
the DK
curve now they settle down you are about
to introduce this they haven't still
gone to the surface the DK curve but now
when we talk about things which are
vastic material material as I was
mentioning here look at it for example
rigid material like metal films couple
well on the oscillating quarts because
how we did it you as it is being
mentioned in the third approach gaining
increasing popularity of is qcmd in this
method the qu crystal is excited to a
resonant frequency fine it is so now if
you look at this picture so it is moving
at a resonance frequency it is already
there now
what you wanted to see the change of
this resonance frequency how it is
coming down right so let's see what it
says
right in this method the quartz crystal
is excited to resonant frequency for a
short period by applying a driving
voltage right once again I will go here
so you apply a driving voltage across
this and this is resonating now
okay the driving voltage is then turned
off then you switch off the
voltage so it is resonating like
this and then you switched off the
voltage so it will continue to resonate
for a
while right and the voltage Decay over
the crystal is recorded as a function of
time so you know after how much time it
is going to Decay and how it is going to
Decay the voltage over the crystal DC
has exponentially dampened the
sinusoidal wave given by then I talked
about the all the Expressions which are
present there now when we talk about
this
part numerically fitting the DK curve
both frequency and dissipation of the
crystals can be obtained simultaneously
the DK time constant remember this the
DK time constant depend on the rigidity
or softness of the mass absorbed on the
crystal
surface whether it is
rigid or it is soft
will determine the DK time for example
rigid material like metal films couple
well again there's a word couple well
with the oscillating
quarts and when the driving voltage is
turned off the oscillation takes longer
to DEC in other words the DK Curve will
be longer on the other hand if the
absorb mass is soft or visco elastic
such as proteins lipids Etc ET it's
coupling with the oscillating quarts is
is poor the flexible visco elastic
materials dampen on the C the crystal
oscillation causing it to Decay faster
now if you look at this structure it
will help you to understand it so this
is the first situation I told you before
adding once they add it dampens but here
look at it the point of contact they are
not properly contacted so the surface
contact of these things are very
less as versus here there's a better
surface contact when the surface contact
is more the dampening does not happen so
fast when the surface contact is less
they are they slipping on the surface
they're moving on the surface the
dampening happens
faster so this is a schematic
representation of the principle of qcmd
the oscillation frequency decreases as
the mass absorbed on the surface the
rigid Mass couple well with the crystal
leading to a long DK curve the VIS
elastic mass coupled poorly with the
crystal leading to a short Decay curve
now these are the most basic fundamental
of understanding how qcmd works thank
you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
