Should you Buy the Rental Car Insurance?

Auto Insurance
2 followers
6 Video ViewsยทAug 2, 2024
Car rental companies desperately want you to buy their insurance and will go to great lengths
and trouble to make you pay for even the smallest of damages if you don't. But should you buy their
insurance? And are the alternative forms of car rental insurance worth it? That's the topic of
today's video. If you're new here, my name is Ben. I'm the owner of Ben Tennant's Dream Vacations
Travel Agency. And on this channel, I provide weekly travel information and tips to help you
plan for your next vacation. So if you're new here, consider subscribing. So let's talk about
the insurance the rental car companies offer first. If you were to buy their collision damage
waiver or CDW for short, or you may even see it being called an LDW for lost damage waiver. But
in either case, if you're to buy the CDW from the rental car companies, the rental car company
surrenders their rights to charge you for damage to the vehicle with a few exceptions like gross
negligence. But otherwise, no matter how banged up the car is when you return it, you're off the
hook. Just return the car and be on your way. And no other approach, whether that be your own
insurance, your credit card, or a third party policy, which I'll cover here shortly, but no
other approach is as comprehensive or convenient. The problem with buying a CDW from a rental car
company is that it is ridiculously overpriced. A CDW can start at $30 per day and go higher and
even cost more than a daily rental car rate. That's why when you're renting a car, the agents
there push hard for you to purchase their insurance because it's clearly more profitable than the
rental car alone. Now you can cover your major damage responsibility by relying on your own
insurance, a credit card with insurance, or a third party policy. But in all those cases, you have to
pay a damage claim up front and hope to recover as much as you can, all of it you hope, by filing a
claim afterward. That might mean signing a credit card bill for hundreds or even thousands of dollars
when you return a damaged car, not knowing if you'll get all that money back. This is also why most
rental car companies won't accept debit cards or a credit card with a small limit. And remember
earlier when I said that if you buy the CDW from the car rental company, you're essentially off the
hook for any damage. Well if you don't buy the CDW, car rental companies can charge far more than
just fixing the damage. You can also charge for one, loss of use, meaning the potential revenue loss
while the car is out of service being fixed, even if the company had lots of other cars available.
And they generally figure that daily loss at the full retail rate. Two, towing charges, if you're
unable to drive the car back to the station. Three, diminished value, or the potential loss of the car's
because of your damage when the rental company disposes of it, usually within two years. And four,
administrative fees associated with the claims process. Most non-CDW car rental insurance will
cover these extras, but in some cases coverage depends on cooperation from the rental company.
So let's now talk about the alternatives to getting the CDW from the car rental companies.
The first alternative is using your existing car insurance. If your auto insurance covers
collision damage, in most cases it'll cover damage to a short-term rental. However, this coverage is
limited to you driving in the U.S. and maybe Canada, and it won't cover car rentals in any
other countries. So before you use your own insurance, check its coverage. If it does cover
rentals, you can place a claim on it. Still, you must typically pay your policies deductible, and
any claims may cause your rates to go up. And moving on to the second alternative is using credit card
benefits. These days, most credit cards offer free collision coverage for car rentals, provided you
use their credit card to pay for the rental. You might get a credit card with the description of
coverage, such as this one. Note that this card's benefits do not cover diminished value or
administrative cost. There are a few premium cards that actually offer primary collision insurance,
meaning they take on the full responsibility for the payment, but coverage on most cards is
secondary coverage, meaning the card picks up only what you can't cover from your own insurance.
And you still have to pay the rental company up front, then file for reimbursement from your card
issuer. Another gotcha in the fine print of this particular card is that this card pays for loss
of use only if verified by the rental company's log. Unfortunately, some rental companies don't
cooperate with credit card issues in providing this type of documentation in a timely manner.
And the last alternative is using a third-party rental car insurance. If you rent a car from one
like Expedia or Priceline, they'll offer you an option to buy collision damage for about $10 a
day. That coverage is provided by a third-party insurance company like Alliance. The cost is a
lot less than the rental car company's CDW, but as with credit card coverage, if you damage the car,
you'll have to pay all the costs up front and then claim later. And one last insurance item
I should mention is liability protection. But don't buy this from the rental car company.
Liability insurance comes with your homeowner's or renter's insurance and covers far more than
a rental car. If you're renting a car in another country, most countries are required by law to
include liability insurance. However, here in the U.S., required coverage is ridiculously small
because they typically only offer a set state minimum required. If you don't have substantial
liability coverage, then you might consider buying the rental company's offering. Still,
your best bet is to make sure you're covered 24-7 with your own insurance so you don't have
to pay for the rental company's overpriced insurance. So the takeaway from all this is
that if you've been using either your own insurance, a credit card, or a third-party policy
as your main source of collision damage coverage for your rental car, then those are probably still
good options for you to continue to use. As long as you're willing to pay all the costs up front
and even go into the process of filing a claim if you were to damage a rental car. However,
if you're unwilling to take any risk at all and just want the convenience of being able to just
drop off your rental car and going, even if it's damaged, then getting that overpriced CDW
from the rental car company is probably the better fit. Well, that will do it for this video. If you
found this video helpful, make sure to like the video and consider subscribing to get more travel
related videos just like this one. Thank you so much for watching and I hope to see you in a future
video.
