I use this wine key: Laguiole en Aubrac Wine Key Ebony I have used this glass in this Video: RIEDEL Veritas Champagne I have tasted the following wines in this Video:
The 100 Point Scoring System (from www.robertparker.com): 96-100: An extraordinary wine of profound and complex character displaying all the attributes expected of a classic wine of its variety. Wines of this caliber are worth a special effort to find, purchase and consume. 90 - 95: An outstanding wine of exceptional complexity and character. In short, these are terrific wines. 80 - 89: A barely above average to very good wine displaying various degrees of finesse and flavor as well as character with no noticeable flaws. 70 - 79: An average wine with little distinction except that it is soundly made. In essence, a straightforward, innocuous wine. 60 - 69: A below-average wine containing noticeable deficiencies, such as excessive acidity and/or tannin, an absence of flavor or possibly dirty aromas or flavors. 50 - 59: A wine deemed to be unacceptable.
Champagne is the king of bottle-fermented sparkling wine – there, I said it – but there are new contenders for the throne, and one has been making the rounds a lot in recent years. Compared to the centuries of tradition in Champagne English sparkling wine is a relatively new invention. The new wave – if you can call it that - of vineyard plantings in England started in the middle of the 20th century and today there are around 200 wineries covering 3,700 hectares of vineyards in England.
The region of Champagne alone covers 34,200 hectares 10 times all of the vineyards in England. More than half of the vineyard surface area in England was planted since 2010 and the hybrid and/or German workhorse varietals such as Bacchus, Seyval Blanc, and Solaris have been widely replaced by Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, and Pinot Meunier. The latter three varietals are of cause also the main varietals in champagne and the climate as well as some of the soils, such as Kimmeridgian limestone, are similar to Champagne. The cool and often wet conditions in the area are pretty good for the production of sparkling wine but they are also tough growing conditions if you are trying to make wine commercially.
Nevertheless more and more English producers have started making bottle-fermented sparkling wine in a similar style to Champagne and today we are going to find out, whether they can rival or even defeat the King of Sparkling wine in a blind tasting.
Hi, I'm Konstantin Baum, Master of Wine,
and it's time for another battle today.
They fought dozens of wars over the centuries,
but today it's time to settle the Anglo-French dispute
in a slightly unexpected way.
In these black bags are two English sparkling wines
and two champagnes, and after this blind tasting,
I'm going to decide who actually produces
the best sparkling wine.
Let's go.
♪♪♪
Champagne is the king of bottle-fermented sparkling wine.
There, I said it.
But there are new contenders to the throne,
and one has been making the rounds a lot in recent years.
Compared to the centuries of tradition in Champagne,
English sparkling wine is a fairly recent invention.
The new wave, if you want to call it that,
of vineyard planting started
in the middle of the 20th century,
and today there are around about 200 wineries
working on 3,700 hectares of vineyards in England.
Just for context, that's not a lot.
The region of Champagne alone covers 34,200 hectares,
so roughly 10 times of what you find
in the whole of England.
More than half of the vineyards in England
were planted over the last 12 years,
and the formerly widespread workhorse
or hybrid grape varieties,
Solaris, Bacchus, and Céval Blanc,
were widely replaced by Chardonnay, Pinot Noir,
and Pinot Meunier.
The latter three grape varieties are, of course,
also the most widely planted grape varieties in Champagne,
and also the climate and some of the soils,
such as Camerigian limestone, are similar to Champagne.
The cool and often wet climate in England
is pretty good for the production of sparkling wine,
but these conditions are also pretty tough
if you want to produce wine commercially.
You know, in 2012, I was actually living in London,
and I remember really well how the press
was describing the terrible growing conditions
in the vineyards and how some wineries
were not harvesting any grapes due to poor weather.
Nevertheless, more and more English producers
have started making their own sparkling wine,
and today we're going to find out
whether they can rival or even defeat
the king of sparkling wine.
So Leon ordered four sparkling wines for me,
and they are labeled one to five
because I couldn't find bag number four,
so if you have seen it, please comment down below.
I'm going to blind taste them side by side,
so let's see whether I can find out which one is which.
So let's pour and taste the wines.
There we go.
So right off the bat,
there's a huge difference in terms of colors.
So this is wine number one, two, three,
and five or four, whatever you want to call it,
but as you can see, this is like a salmon pink color.
This is bright yellow.
This is really dark reddish color,
and this is a little bit more golden in color.
Not that this necessarily tells me
all that much about the wines,
but there are big differences.
I would actually say that the color in wine number three
is a bit weird.
It stands out.
I mean, this is not the most typical sparkling wine color.
It's pretty dark for a sparkling champagne style wine.
Flavor-wise, they are actually pretty diverse,
very interesting.
This one, wine number one,
has quite a lot of complexity, intensity,
and there are flavors of brioche coming through,
a little bit of strawberry, a little bit of rhubarb,
so it's quite appealing.
Wine number two is much more fresh.
It feels like the youngest wine out of the bunch,
and the one that didn't have a lot of contact with the lees,
so it's more lemon zesty, quite fruit-driven.
There's also brioche character,
but it's not overpowering, that's for sure.
Wine number three is quite fruity as well,
but there's quite a lot of strawberry there,
quite a lot of cherry flavor.
There's also some brioche characters,
some dough character coming through,
and wine number four is, for me, the most classic in a way.
It smells of lemon zest,
it smells of those freshly baked brioches.
It also smells a little bit of ripe apple.
Again, nose-wise, I think they perform on a similar level.
I think the middle two wines are a bit,
well, a bit weird in a way,
so this one, due to its color and its dark fruit character,
the intense cherry fruit flavor
is not necessarily what I would think of
if I would think of sparkling rosé champagne-style wine,
and this is, well, a little bit more fruity,
little less serious, I guess.
In sparkling wines, in bottle-fermented sparkling wines,
you definitely want some brioche character,
and intense brioche flavor is often seen
as a sign of quality,
and here you don't really have intense brioche flavor.
I didn't say anything about the bubbles,
but they are fairly similar in all four wines,
so they are fine, they are delicate, they are intense,
there's quite a lot of bubbliness.
There's not much more I can say about the bubbles.
On the palate, there are also interesting differences.
The first two, wine number one and two,
are actually a bit lighter, a bit fresher,
quite a lot of acidity, quite a lot of liveliness,
while wine number three and wine number four
are a bit more round and concentrated,
there's more concentration there, a little bit more body.
So this would suggest to me that wine number three
and wine number four are actually from Champagne,
because, if I remember right,
then the wines from England tend to be a bit lighter,
a bit more of what people say wines from Champagne
used to be, like 30, 40, 50 years ago,
before climate change changed those dynamics.
But this is not necessarily always a given.
The fact that it's difficult to grow grapes in England
also means that the yields tend to be fairly low
compared to Champagne.
So sometimes the wines in England, due to lower yields,
actually have quite a bit of concentration,
while poor Champagne can be a little bit diluted
if it's really harvested at very high yields.
So, well, I'm not 100% sure
where I'm going to end up with those four wines.
So this is tricky, but I have to make a decision.
My favorite wines out of the tasting
are actually the first and the last.
I really like the complexity and, well,
the multitude of layers here in this wine,
and I quite like the concentration complexity on the nose,
but also on the palate that wine number four shows.
The middle two are also really good sparkling wines,
but I prefer those two.
So I'm going to give wine number one 91 points.
I'm going to give wine number four 92 points.
I think wine number two is, for me, an 89.1,
and wine number three is a 90.1.
But my task was to identify where which wine is from,
so let me start.
Wine number three is actually a very distinctive style.
It could be from England
because it's a little bit out of the box,
but I actually think I know which wine this is.
I think this is the Tétangé Rosé,
which is made by using quite a lot of red wine in the blend.
So they use Pinot Noir made as red wine
in order to give it this color, this concentration,
and so on and so forth.
So this is my first Champagne.
Now let's move on to the other Rosé.
I think Leon would not put two Rosé wines from Champagne
into this tasting,
but I actually think this could be from Champagne.
It's really well made.
It's a beautiful wine with lots of complexity,
but I'm going to say this is from England.
So this leaves me with those two wines,
and I'm going to start with wine number two.
I actually think, due to its lightness,
its crispness, its freshness,
and its absence of intense yeast flavors,
this is from England.
This is obviously a bit of a controversial argument
because you could say that in England
you can age wine for however long you want on the lease,
but due to its crisp and fresh acidity,
I actually think this is from the cooler climate region,
i.e. England.
And that leaves me with wine number four or five,
and I actually think this is from Champagne.
It's complex, it's multi-layered.
I believe this is a really beautiful sparkling wine
from the Champagne region.
I don't think it's like a top-notch wine
from any of the producers in Champagne.
I actually think it's like the Brut,
the standard wine of the house,
but it's really well made.
So let's start off with wine number three,
the one where I said this is not just Champagne,
Rosé Champagne, but it's Tétangé Rosé Champagne.
Let's see.
That's it, Tétangé.
To be honest, this is a bit of a party trick.
This wine is very distinctive in its style,
so it's not that difficult to identify it
if you have tasted it before.
So let's move on to wine number one,
which I said is an English sparkling wine, Rosé,
and it is an English sparkling wine, Rosé.
So this is the Coats and Sealy,
and I believe that Christian Sealy,
the person who is in charge of lots of famous estates
in the wine world, is involved in this product.
It's called méthode britannique,
whatever that actually means,
and it's a Rosé wine from Hampshire in England.
So the wine is a blend of Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier,
so there's no Chardonnay involved here,
and I think it's really well made.
It's beautifully complex and quite complete.
So a pretty nice wine.
So let's move on to wine number two,
the one where I said this is from England,
a sparkling wine from England,
a well-made sparkling wine,
but more of a fruit-driven style.
So this is Paul Rosé Champagne.
I actually thought this was from England.
I mean, I thought it was a good wine,
but not like an outstanding sparkling wine,
and this is actually
one of the more famous estates in Champagne.
In my defense,
this wine is actually the official supplier
to the queen or the king nowadays,
so there's a strong connection, you know,
between England and this wine,
but I was wrong.
So this means this wine is likely
the English sparkling wine,
and let's see what it is.
I'm really curious now.
English sparkling wine from Ney Timber.
I believe it's called Ney Timber,
and this is one of the most well-known producers in England.
They're really kind of famous
for producing beautiful sparkling wines,
and to be honest,
this wine was the one that impressed me
the most in this tasting.
So going back and forth between those wines,
I actually have to say I'm very impressed
by the English sparkling wines in this tasting.
This was a fascinating tasting.
If you think now that you can make a big bargain
by buying English sparkling wine as opposed to Champagne,
that's not necessarily the case.
The Ney Timber and the Paul Roger
are roughly at the same price,
so around 45, 50 US dollars,
while the Coats and Sealy cost around 50 US dollars,
and the Titanger Rosé around 70, 80 US dollars.
So they are all roughly in the same price category,
so not necessarily something you can make a big bargain on,
but it's definitely something worth discovering.
So the question in the beginning was,
can English sparkling wine dethrone Champagne?
And in this tasting, they definitely did.
Two beautiful wines that performed really well.
They were not worlds apart with the Champagnes,
but I think they showed better than the Champagnes,
and they were more to my palate.
This is an indication of where
English sparkling wine could be heading,
and I'm certainly going to try more of these wines
in order to kind of, yeah, stay in the loop.
But I'm not going to stop drinking Champagne.
That's for sure.
So thank you for watching.
If you enjoyed this video,
then please like it down here.
Subscribe to my channel if you haven't done so already.
My question of the day is,
have you tasted English sparkling wine?
Let me know what you think of those wines down below.
I hope I see you guys again soon.
Until then, stay thirsty.
♪♪♪