How Thomas Aquinas refuted Muhammad and Islam

Islam
5 followers
There are many religions in this world, but out of all of them, Christianity and Islam
are the leading two. On the side of Christianity, the angelic doctor of the church,
Thomas Aquinas, has written profoundly in defense of Christendom, and in his work titled
Summa Contra Gentiles, Aquinas refutes the heresies which Islam's greatest prophet Muhammad taught.
Aquinas starts off and states,
On the other hand, those who introduced the errors of the sex proceeded in contrary fashion,
as is clear from Muhammad who enticed peoples with the promise of carnal pleasures,
to the desire of which the concupiscence of the flesh instigates. He also delivered commandments,
in keeping with his promises, by giving the reins to carnal pleasure, in which it is easy
for carnal men to obey. Aquinas argues that Muhammad developed followers quickly from carnal
and lustful pleasures that he espoused. For example, in Surah 4, Ayah 24 in the Quran,
we read that,
The woman your right hand possess, in Ayah 24, are those women which are prisoners of war,
or slaves that a Muslim may have. And according to the Quran, Allah decrees that Muslims can use
their slaves and prisoners of war for sexual intercourse. This is made more clear in Sunan
Abi Dawud 2155, which is an authentic sahih-graded hadith which records the context for the Quranic
verse above. Abu Sa'id al-Qudri said,
Some of the companions of the Apostle of Allah were reluctant to have relations with the female
captives because of their pagan husbands. So Allah, they exalted, sent down the Quranic verse,
This hadith speaks of a military expedition in which many Muslim men were wary to have intercourse
with the female captives and prisoners of war, but Allah sent down the Quranic verse in which,
as we read before, gives them the right and authority to use their female captives. Verses
and hadiths like these demonstrate that Muhammad misled men in the Arabian Peninsula with carnal
desires, as if a man had fifty slave women, he could use them all for intercourse.
Aquinas continues further and states,
An example of these fables that Muhammad taught, or which is known in the Quran,
comes from Surah 5, Ayah 110, in which we read,
This same exact story of Jesus molding a clay bird and giving life to it comes from the infancy
gospel of Thomas, which is a false and non-historical text about the early years of Jesus'
life. The Quran and or Muhammad completely rips this story off from this false text and claims
it to be real. I've covered this story in the Quran deeply in another video linked below.
Aquinas further adds more about Muhammad and states,
Aquinas argues that Muhammad did not do miracles or at least any that can be proven in order to
demonstrate the reliability of his claims as a prophet of Allah. One of the major miracles
of Islam is the splitting of the moon in Surah 54, to which there is no eyewitness testimony
around the world to see such a massive event such as the moon being split into two.
Aquinas states further,
This force of arms and military expeditions made up much of Muhammad's prophethood
and it granted him much power. In Sahih Muslim 1767a, Muhammad is quoted as saying,
will not leave any but Muslim. Furthermore, we read in Surah 2, Ayah 216 that,
This ayah demonstrates that fighting is part of the nature of Islam and is not a choice since
it's deemed as a moral obligation if someone is called to fight. Aquinas begins to finish up by
Lastly, no divine oracles of prophets in a previous age bore witness to him. Rather,
he corrupted almost all the teaching of the Old and New Testaments by a narrative replete with
fables, as one may see by a pursual of his law. Aquinas articulates that no prophets or scripture
speak of Muhammad either in the Old or New Testament. Furthermore, Islam teaches that
the Bible itself has been corrupted and is not to be trusted, yet interestingly,
many Muslims appeal to the Bible to argue that Muhammad is prophesied about,
when they at the same time believe the Bible is false, and so they pick and choose what
suits their theology when it works for them in their favor. Hence, by a cunning device,
he did not commit the reading of the Old and New Testament books to his followers,
lest he should thereby be convicted of falsehood. Thus, it is evident that those who believe his
words believe lightly. St. Thomas Aquinas makes it clear, and evident, that one must not hold to
the teachings of Islam if they desire the truth. Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed this video
and want to see more, please consider liking and subscribing. Also, if you want to support
my channel, consider becoming a member. As always, God bless.
