let's talk probiotics because they are
everywhere everybody seems to be on one
and as the gut doctor what's your
opinion about it my opinion on
probiotics is like
multivitamins do we have clar and
compelling evidence that a multivitamin
does anything for the average person we
don't what we know from some studies is
that people who take vitamins also have
healthy habits so vitamin takers tend to
be exercisers and clean eaters and
meditators Etc but we don't have
evidence outside of that that the
vitamin itself in a healthy person now
there are plenty of instances where
vitamin can be helpful for example the
patients I see who have Crohn's disease
many of them have low B12 because the
Crohn's can affect the small intestine
the ilium the dogs jump in dunum ilum
and so they don't absorb the B12 in the
ilum and they need to be supplemented or
they may have low iron because they're
not absorbing iron or because they're
bleeding or their vitamin D may be low
so in that setting those vitamins play a
really important role but the idea that
somebody who's healthy who doesn't have
Crohn's or some other reason to have a
specific vitamin deficiency needs stuff
and in fact when we look at Vitamin D A
lot of us are deficient and there are
two reasons for that one we don't get
enough sun
exposure but the second reason is that
they moved the level they changed the
level from what is normal they bumped it
up and so a third of the country became
vitamin D deficient now I don't know why
they chose to do that the government but
I suspect it had a lot to do with
lobbying from supplement manufacturers
I'm sure there was medical evidence also
that said the
previous lower limit of normal of 25
that got moved up to 32 so everybody who
was in the high 20s who decades ago had
normal vitamin D now was vitamin D
deficient but here's the thing we see a
lot of problems with vitamin D toxicity
from people just willy-nilly taking
massive amounts of vitamin D thinking
mistakenly that the higher the better
that's not how it works there's a range
there's a range and you don't want to
exceed that range now for some vitamins
and minerals and things if you have
extra you just pee it out it's not a big
deal but vitamin D isn't one of those so
you've you want to be careful about
vitamin D
toxicity and so when people take these
various supplements and things I think
they have a sense a lot of the time that
well it couldn't hurt right right so it
may help it can't
hurt even something like a probiotic if
you're taking multiple different species
those bacteria assuming that there are
actually live bacteria in the probiotic
because there's very little regulation a
lot of times the bacteria are dead but
let's say there are let's say the
product does contain what it says it
contains these live bacteria they are
potentially competing for
resources with other bacterial species
even the native ones in your gut that
are actually working and trying to do
their thing and now they're like oh wait
there's not enough of you know whatever
resource this is we need to eat and so
you can be altering your microbial
composition for the worse by taking a
probiotic oh God now now well I feel
like I'm in the camp of everything you
just said it can't hurt and so I'll just
keep like taking all these things and my
body will just pee out whatever I don't
need so that's one mistake I'm clearly
making second mistake that I'm making is
I I'm taking the probiotic and then I'm
taking a different probiotic and then
I'm also eating the yogurt and the
kimchi and I'm just making this gigantic
sort of bacteria salad but eat the
kimchi for sure I mean we have great
data on fermented foods and a lot of
this is from uh the sorn lab in at
Stanford so we know that kimchi and
sauerkraut are Powerhouse Foods they
contain a combination of prebiotics
which is a fiber so let's let's take
sauerkraut okay that's the fiber you
it's made from cabbage so you have the
fiber to feed the bacteria but in the
fermentation process you're also
producing lactobacillus so you have the
probiotic and then as part of that
fermentation process you're creating
metabolites like short chain fatty acids
those are postbiotics so kimchi and SAU
Kraut are this Powerhouse combination of
prepr and postbiotics and there's really
compelling data that eating even a
tablespoon of saut a day can provide
multiple different species in important
metabolite so this is ultimately sort of
medicinal food wow things like the S and
kimchi so by all means keep doing that
for sure so Dr Robin can you just give
us a short list of Probiotic foods that
we can eat instead of taking a probiotic
of Prebiotic Foods or probiotic I don't
like like I whichever ones I'm supposed
to eat what are the like what is the
list of free and Probiotic foods for
Prebiotic which are the foods to feed
the bacteria think high fiber and think
stringy fiber like asparagus and celery
and also things like oats dandelion
greens these are all great Foods fibrous
foods to feed your
bacteria for Probiotic foods think about
fermented they also contain Prebiotic
with the fiber but think about fermented
foods because those are producing
bacteria during the fermentation process
and I do want to say it's not that a
probiotic is a total waste of time in my
practice where I treat really sick
patients with crohn's and Al colitis
there are probiotics on the market that
have the FDA label as a medicinal food
this is a medical food for the treatment
of inflammatory B disease Etc they're
products that have over a 100 different
scientific studies behind them showing
that they work for these particular
conditions but that's different right
that's like the B12 for the Crohn's
patient that's not the average person
the data that the average person gets a
lot of health benefit or really any
health benefit
from taking a probiotic is a little
murkier and my concern is always that
people are going to say oh I don't need
to change my diet or really pay
attention to that because I'm taking the
probiotic I mean you're actually eating
the kimchi and doing all the other stuff
which is fantastic and I'm popping the
probiotic and you're I think you're
you're probably okay but but you don't
need it but I do I do want to caution
people if you're taking these high do
probiotics are you potentially using up
resources that your native bacteria that
need these resources and and remember
how would you know like would you be
bloated even though you're taking a
probiotic like how would you know that
it's backfiring you really don't you
really don't there's not a test we can
do for that but what I want people to
remember is that when you take a
probiotic product those bacteria may be
living half an hour I mean typically
under an hour in order to get meaningful
colonization and repopulation of the gut
you have to feed them and so the food is
ultimately more important because the
truth is it's not that you don't have
any healthy bacteria in your gut the
population is low how do you get well
population may be low say you've taken a
lot of antibiotics or you've had a
chommy diet how do you manipulate the
microbiome and get those healthy species
to grow by feeding them not by bringing
in more species that are basically going
to like hang around 20 minutes and then
you're going to poop them out so it's
really this whole idea of repopulation
and recolonization and we do that by
feeding what's already there and that
has been shown and that's the American
gut project study with the 30 different
plants when they ask a question what is
the most effective way what is the most
important thing to do to have a healthy
microbiome and this is a study done in
over 10,000 people 40 different
countries so really meaningful data and
the most effective thing was to get 30
different sources of plant-based Foods
in your diet once a week yes throughout
the week wow so it's it's still really
diet I mean if you look at uh an apple
that's grown organically and even better
biodynamically what's biodynamically
biodynamically is when you have the
animals fertilizing the soil so from a
local Farm a local Farm I love it yes
that is exactly local because it's going
to be more nutrient and micro BRD
because it's not travel 3,000 miles on a
plane and
barely to keep the thing so an apple an
apple you can
get millions of microbes from eating an
apple grown locally so Dr Robin I'm just
imagining that the person listening is
sitting here next to me and we have come
to you because we feel bloated or we're
struggling with IBS or constipation or
whatever and so it is just kind of a
classic gut issue what are the three
small habits that you would like us to
start implementing into our day-to-day
life that are the best things that we
could do that will build a healthy
beautiful kind of gut microbiome and get
our gut system working
correctly there are tons of things to do
but if I had to distill it down to three
I would say it's
hydration it's movement and it's fiber
and the movement remember that it's
smooth muscle it's not skeletal muscle
so it's not onto voluntary control but
we know that movement creates nitric
oxide and nitric oxide is part of why
keeps the heart healthy and keeps the
gut healthy and so the movement
stimulates Paralis if you don't have
things moving through in a timely
fashion not only do you have symptoms
like bloating and constipation but you
also have stasis of those intestinal
contents and you have bacterial
overgrowth because things aren't moving
through so the movement is really
important and I found that since
pandemic so much so many of us are so
sedentary I know that I'm not at the
hospital a few days a week anymore back
and forth where I'm probably walking
four or five miles every day I'm sitting
a lot more and um I think we've seen a
huge effect of that of the you know
effect of being sedentary on the gut so
we need to stimulate gut peristalsis the
people we see with the worst GI problems
are people in nursing homes and it's not
because they're elderly it's because
they're not moving wow so movement is
really key hydration I can't say it
enough times Plumbing we've got to
unclog those pipes and then the fiber
because the fiber feeds our gut microbes
so they can ferment that fiber create
all the healthy metabolites and it
doesn't have to be like some enormous
kale salad it can literally be grab a
carrot as you're walking out the door
and chump on it throw an apple in your
car eat some nuts something basic
ideally something on process I am so
curious about your poop oh what do you
want to know about I think I have a
feeling that you have wonderful poos you
really want to know yes I really want to
know