2024 Baking Challenge Week 24 - Classic Key Lime Pie

Blackberry Hill House
143 followers
1 Video View·Jun 15, 2024
welcome to week 24 of the 2024 baking
challenge now tomorrow is Father's day
so in honor of that we are going to be
making Scott's favorite dessert classic
key lime pie so check your oven make
sure there's nothing in there set it to
325 grab your ingredients and let's go
[Music]
bake it's if you've ever made a pie
before you know the pie crust comes
first now this is a classic key lime pie
that means gram cracker crust you can
make it that's what I'm going to do I'm
also not going to tell anyone if you buy
a pre-made pie crust who cares if you
don't have the time you don't have the
time it's not that big a deal but for
this pie crust now this is a little
different I've only done um gram cracker
sugar like granulated sugar and a little
bit of salt this calls for powdered
sugar so this is a new one for me I
haven't done this one before um you're
going to need about
10 um graham crackers and you're going
to crush them I did these in my ninja uh
blender and then you going to need six
tablespoons of butter melted actually
I'm going to add that last you are going
to need a four of a cup of powdered
sugar get that all in there so it's
going to be a nice sweet crust which is
nice I I can understand it because the
the key lime is particularly
tart uh I believe an eighth of a
teaspoon of sugar yeah an eighth of a
teaspoon of sugar or salt just a little
teeny tiny
bit now I'm going to mix all that up and
then I'm going to add my 6 tablespoons
of melted
butter your pie plate needs to be a 9 in
round pie plate it has to be at least an
inch and A4 deep um I have this old
glass pie plate it is Pyrex it is
vintage I have two of them and I love
them and I was it was a tossup because I
also have this cobalt blue Pyrex um but
it's a little fancy and I thought the
green pie inside the blue was going to
be actually it's not really green is it
it's kind of a yellow color so you're
going to mix this up it's going to be
kind of gooey and
Ooey and then we're going to press it
into our pie
pan you are going to want to press it
all along the bottom evenly and then up
the sides as even as you can get it
because this is a graham cracker crust
you don't have to worry about crimping
so that's super nice if you find some
big Chun some big chunks in there don't
panic just grab a fork and crush them up
it's not that big a deal okay so dump it
in
um I think I'm only going to dump a
little bit of time here if I need some
more then um I'll add some more and then
you're going to start pressing once you
get this pressed on the bottom and the
sides it's going to go into your 325
degree oven for 15 minutes let me double
check
that um yeah 15 minutes so once the 15
minutes is up you're going to take it
out put it on a rack and forget about it
until we're ready to put the filling in
so get to
pressing start in the
middle work your way
around can turn your plate as you
go pressing pretty hard here you're
going to really need it to stick
together
try to keep it from coming up over the
edge and remember you can go back in if
you have some left in your bowl you can
go back in and fill in those those
spots okay let's talk about limes it
turns out there is a difference between
key limes and just your run-of-the-mill
limes for starters regular limes are
bigger this is the size of a key lime
these are Itty Bitty and my local store
did not not have them once I realized
that there was a dis difference in The
Taste um when we were in town uh like
populated town with a deer bgs and a
shnooks we went ahead and got some there
um so we are going to zest two limes now
it did not specify key limes so I'm
assuming it meant regular limes I'm
zesting four because honestly I feel
like two of these equals four maybe
that's excessive but Scott really likes
slime so I'm just going to take a chance
and go for it um now I am using my uh is
this Pampered Chef I feel like this is
yeah this is Pampered Chef um you know
I'm kind of snobby with Pampered Chef
stuff sometimes I don't own a ton of it
because it can be expensive but I love
this
thing um when we had the lemon tree I
was constantly doing lemon stuff and so
this neat little rtion has the bowl
underneath it has the microplane top and
then it has the juicing top so it does
ask for key lime juice or lime juice
freshly squeezed if at all possible
listen there is a difference between
freshly squeezed and in a bottle but
don't get crazy with it if you can't
find fresh limes don't worry about it
man don't worry about it just do the
best you can with what you have to work
with right I was lucky I found key limes
I don't even want to know how much they
cost um I did not go in and buy them
Scott did but yeah so you are going to
while your crust is in there
cooking here we go let me get all this
good stuff off of here that you
know zest is one of those things that
really makes my brain icky because I'm
like oh my gosh you're eating the
outside of the fruit Ro well yeah so we
are going to put this in
here um I wish wish this tilted or like
the bowl slid out that you could put
things in it easier but it doesn't so we
are going to use our whisk okay we're
going to use our whisk attachment on the
mixer oh and if you don't want to get
something like this micr plane it's from
Amazon it's super inexpensive and I use
that one a lot if I'm not going to juice
something something I'll usually just
break out the little teeny tiny
microplane okay we are going to use our
whisk attachment
here love the Whisk attachment never get
to use it all that much Bowl
up three egg yolks you are going to
where's my spatula how come I can never
find my spatula when I need
it boy I'm so well prepared
today uh green one I'll
do so three egg yolks and
your lemon lime zest I'm going to say
lemon zest probably eight different
times instead of lime but just know that
I mean lime not lemon although I would
imagine you could do this with lemon too
and it would probably be pretty neat all
right bowl is
up all right what are we doing here
high speed for about 4
minutes um basically you're going to
want this to get kind of thick it's
going to change color so it gets a
little bit lighter it's really it's
going to end up looking like an unset
custard okay since the mixer is not
getting it I'm just going to pull the
bowl out and I'm going to go after this
with my hand whisk you can use a hand
mixer doesn't matter we just got to get
the job done so about 4
minutes now the recipe did say that it's
going to look a lot like a Holland sauce
I don't know what that
is um obviously some kind of egg
mixture this is getting lighter and it's
definitely looking kind of custardy
smells good smells very tropical
fruity 4 minutes of this I thought I
could hack it but this is going to
be this is going to be the workout
man all right come back in 3
minutes okay um while that was whisking
and it is a very light yellow color now
and very thick um I've started juicing
my limes but we're going to add in your
can of sweet and condensed milk this is
a 14 o can which is two and a
half one and 1/4 cups of sweet and
condensed milk and that's going to go
right in
there
um I don't actually understand what
sweetened condensed milk is
um I just know that it looks like a
sugar
glaze
so I mean obviously it's
milk trying to get all of it in there
which is never ever going to happen Okay
and then you are going to beat that at a
high speed for 3 minutes while that's
speeding
um go ahead and get your limes Juiced or
get your juice ready I don't know how
many of these key limes it's going to
take to get to 2/3 of a cup all I know
is that juicing these teeny tiny limes
is really really tricky so let you know
how many I end up
needing okay now we're adding the 2/3
three 2/3 of a cup this is way too much
juice Bo I'm glad I noticed that
let me
just let me just work on this
here is that right all right 2/3 of a
cup of lime
juice and it
took one two three four five six seven
it took about eight limes to get
here um and we're just stirring this to
combine
just giving it a little stir here
nothing too
high you do want to make sure it's all
Incorporated um this is where you would
add the lime oil if you're using that
it's 1/8 to 1/4 teaspoon of lime lime
oil I'm not doing that uh I didn't see
the need to purchase lime oil when it's
not something that I'm going to use
more than once a year so this is
starting to thicken it's very pretty it
looks like
a looks like a pudding with lime zest
and it smells very good too
so all right that's done okay get your
hopefully your pie shell has cooled
enough we're going to get this put
in okay we are going to pour the mixture
into
the pie shell
here trying to make sure I get it all
out and if you notice I do have my pie
plate on a cookie sheet
um sometimes things overflow in the oven
anytime I make any kind of C Mustard Pie
they don't usually rise up um but when
I'm baking cakes they go on the cake
pans go on a cookie sheet um also pie
plates are hard for me to to grasp
sometimes if I'm having a a painful hand
day cookie sheets are just easier to get
in and out of the oven um I haven't
noticed that it really affects the
baking one way or the other so that's
what I do all right I'm just kind of
smoo smoothing the top out here making
it look all
pretty okay this is going to go into the
oven for 25 minutes all right the edges
are going to appear set it's still going
to be wobbly in the middle you're going
to need a thermometer for this the
middle of your pie should be
reading 145° that is when it is safe to
bring it out you're going to cool it on
rack completely okay you're going to
want this thing totally cool all right
into the oven good
luck when your timer goes off and your
pie is Reading 140° in the center you're
going to leave it on a rack to cool to
room temperature once it hits room
temperature which could take an hour
maybe a little longer you're going to
put it into the refrigerator now you're
going to need to refrigerate that for
several hours okay once it's been in the
refrigerator for a few hours you can
pull it out you can make it pretty with
whipped cream lime slices lime curls
things like that um you can make your
whipped cream you can use store-bought
whipped cream it doesn't matter it's
totally up to you you don't have to
dress it up at all you can just slice it
and serve it as is so you know figure
out kind of what you want to do you've
got a couple hours to make that decision
and I will see you back when it's time
to taste this
thing it's pie time p pie time it's high
time for pie time I don't know I'm not
making any sense um but this has been in
the fridge I've removed it from the
fridge I put little slices of lime and
some whipped cream on it and now it is
time to give this a try it smells really
good um and I will I will be the first
one to admit key lime is not exactly my
thing um so I'm not anticipating
falling in love with
this
but
hopefully Scott will think it tastes
good and that's all that
matters all right I am also terrible at
slicing and serving pie so I thought
about doing this in like a tart Pan
um it's holding together that's always a
good sign when you have a pie is that it
holds together
okay it looks really good on the
inside listen if you're it's essentially
a custard pie right with the eggs if
your if the inside of your pie is runny
it's not done and you should not eat it
it's not safe to eat remember that core
temperature needed to get up to
145° so
okay wo
it is wow that is very strong
um that
is really really strong but it's
good
[Music]
mhm the crust is really sweet and
crunchy I kind kind of wish I'd made my
crust a little bit thicker because I
think that sweetness would have uh
counteracted the tartness from the limes
a little bit better for me but I think
Scott's going to like this so um yeah
this is a good pie I did not expect to
like it this
much well that's it for week number 24
of the 2024 baking challenge this key
lime pie was definitely a winner
especially if you love tart citrusy type
of
desserts I can see that I will probably
be making this again and I hope that you
baked along uh if you did and you
enjoyed it leave me a comment tell me
what went good what went bad what you
liked what you didn't and hit the
Subscribe button because I'm going to
bring you a brand new to me recipe every
single Saturday morning between 7 and
9:00 a.m. you should also hop on over to
the Facebook page because I put out the
ingredient list for what we're going to
bake I do that on Wednesday morning
mornings that way you have plenty of
time to get your shopping done so I hope
that you tune in next week when we make
something a little sweeter than this and
something that I know I'm going to
absolutely love if I can do it correctly
uh so I will see you then
