The Different Types of Herbal Tonics

Medicinal leaves
30 followers
Hey there everybody, Sage of Popham here, founder of the School of Evolutionary Herbalism.
And what exactly does the word tonic mean? You know, this is a word that we see used a lot
in herbal medicine and in the alternative health world. You know, we hear about health tonics and
rejuvenative tonics and nutritive tonics and bitter tonics and chi tonics and the word tonic
gets used a lot. And I think this is one of those terms in Western herbalism or herbalism as a whole
really that can really use a little bit of clarification to make sure that we're all on
the same page when we use that word. So a question came up in a recent Q&A session with my students
and around, you know, what's the difference between, you know, a tonic from the perspective
of physiomedicalism versus, you know, the way the word tonic is used in, say, Ayurvedic medicine or
Chinese medicine. So that is what the topic for this video is and hopefully it provides some
clarity for you on what is oftentimes a little bit of a nebulous term. Question number one is coming
to us from Stephen Roberts in the Alchemical Herbalism program. And Stephen is asking,
are the physiomedicalist's use of the term tonic and the Ayurveda Rasayana for the most part
interchangeable in your view? If not, could you share some situations that might highlight where
they do not correlate that well? That's a really great question, Stephen. And it really brings me
to the kind of a conversation about the word tonic and what the word tonic means.
It's in Western herbalism a pretty loose nebulous term that I find being used in a wide variety of
contexts. And depending on those contexts, the word has a very different meaning. So I'd like
to define this term tonic a little bit and kind of elucidate a little bit of those different
contexts so we can understand what this word actually means. So oftentimes we'll see the
word tonic be used alongside something like a bitter tonic or a nutritive tonic or a rejuvenating
tonic or just a tonic herb. And oftentimes those really all mean very different things.
And so to me, when I think of the word tonic, I really like etymology. I really like thinking
about the roots of words and how those roots of words correlate to other words. And through
understanding other words that are related to one another, I think we can get a better sense for
what they actually mean. And so if we look at the word tonic, the root of that word is tone.
Right? Tone. And in the context of herbalism, when we're looking at tone, we're looking at the
tonal quality of a tissue, which really is looking at how tight is it or how relaxed is it.
And this is one of our kind of polarities that we see in terms of herbal energetics. Oftentimes
we just look at temperature and moisture of hot and cold and wet and dry, and it's very common to
overlook the tonal aspect. And that really is what makes up the six tissue states of the
physio-medicalist that you're mentioning here. So you have a heat excitation and cold depression
in terms of temperature. You have damp stagnation and dry atrophy in terms of moisture. And then you
have tension and relaxation in terms of tissue tone. And tension and relaxation are really,
really important to consider when we're looking at a tissue. It's not always pertinent, but when
it is, it's really pertinent, right? And you got to really address it because if the root cause
of an imbalance is due to the tone of a tissue, it's not going to be corrected just by attending
to hot, cold, wet, and dry, right? So this is a very good understanding to have about
the energetics of the tissues and conversely what remedies we want to apply.
So just a little background on the word tone, and now thinking of the word tonic,
right? What we see here is that it's going to increase the tone of the tissue, meaning it's
going to tighten up the tissue. It's going to provide firmness and stability, tensile strength
to the tissue. And this is really the opposite of a relaxant, right? Which is going to relax
constriction and tension or spasm. So our relaxants, more often than not, are things like
nervenes and antispasmodics. And then our tonics in this context are going to be our astringents,
and that's really the way I learned from Paul Bergner is that he kind of combines those words
together, that it's a tonic astringent. And it's helpful to combine those two words so we really
understand what we mean when we say the word tonic within that context. And I think that is
really the way that is best to understand that term tonic according to traditional western
herbalism. Now at the same time, in western herbalism, that word tonic is also used in the
context of a bitter. And the way that we see a lot of bitter remedies working through the mucosal
membranes, especially in the digestive system, but a lot of them are working on the mucosa in
general. And so kind of a mucosal membrane tonic action as a bitter, but also in the way that a
bitter remedy is going to increase digestion and increase absorption, it's going to bring more
nutrients into the body and kind of replenish the system in that way simply by bringing more
nourishment. And so this is where we get into some different ways of looking at the word tonic
and more of, I would say, kind of more of like a building up and strengthening of the person.
And so we see two sides of that. We see a bitter tonic through enhancing digestion
and absorption. And on the other side of that, we see it as a nutritive tonic, which would be
the remedies that kind of stand at the boundary between an herb and a food. And so these are
typically our very mineral-rich, nutrient-dense plants that we take oftentimes as strong infusions
to just fill in nutrient gaps and provide just bulk nutrition. And a lot of those remedies being
things like nettle leaf and red raspberry and oat straw and alfalfa, these are all very mineral-rich
plants that just are providing bulk nutrition to the body. But at the same time, most of those
plants are also astringent, right? Nettles, astringent. Alfalfa, astringent. Red raspberry,
absolutely astringent, right? So many of the, horsetail is another remedy in that category,
also astringent. So while they are providing mineral nutrition, they are also working as a
tonic astringent to tighten up those tissues. So that's kind of defining the word tonic in
more within the context of Western herbalism. And when you see a Western herbalist use the
word tonic, that's usually the way it's being referred to, right? So bitter tonic,
nutritive tonic, or tonic astringent. I'm not so sure I like how nebulous that is, right? And
it's like the same word being used to indicate very different things for the most part,
but that it is what it is. So now you're also, you know, kind of bringing in the comparison
of the Ayurvedic term rasayana, which essentially means rejuvenative, a rejuvenation herb.
You know, rasa has a lot of meanings in Ayurveda, but one of the definitions of rasa is like,
it's like the juice, right? Or it's the, it's like the sap of the plant, or it's the, you know,
in terms of the dhatus, or the seven tissues of the body, that rasa is like our plasma.
It's one of the first substances that is created from the absorption and digestion of physical
material. So the plasma, I kind of think of it as like the extracellular fluid. And so they say
rasayana, it's like the juice, it's a way of replenishing the essence, right? One teacher
defined it as rasayana, like therapy is like the way of the juice, right? It's like, it's that,
when people are very weak and very deficient and very fatigued, and they have, you know,
they're kind of wasting away and they don't have any vitality, we would traditionally use
rasayana type herbs to replenish and rebuild and restore that weak and deficient person.
In Chinese medicine, this would be, you know, the closest equivalent to that would be something like
what we would refer to as qi tonic herbs, right? So rasayana, qi tonic,
is a very different category from what in the West we refer to as a tonic herb, right? Which
again is oftentimes associated to like a bitter tonic or a nutritive tonic or a tonic astringent.
In the East, that term tonic or what is translated into the word tonic is very different. The best
term we have in Western herbalism that is most closely equivalent to rasayana or qi tonic herbs
is adaptogens, right? And I think it's really interesting that in the West, we didn't really
have a category for herbs to rejuvenate and replenish a weak, deficient, vital force.
And, you know, I think this raises some really interesting questions in terms of, well, you know,
in, you know, North America and Europe and where kind of Western herbalism
originated and has been developed over the years, it's like, do we just not have those kinds of
herbs? You know, we've got a few. We got our American ginseng and, you know, in the Northwest,
we've got devil's club and, you know, there's a couple other plants. But for the most part,
there's not a whole lot of plants that grow in the West or what we might consider the West
as having this kind of property. And so it's kind of raises some interesting questions, right?
Of, well, is that category not really present because there's no herbs that do that? Or do
they all grow in the East? Or is it more that it wasn't a very important area of focus in the
system of medicine? And this was, I remember one of my teachers at Bastyr talked about this and
they said, you know, in the East, they oftentimes were treating a lot of deficiency type diseases,
a lot of weakness, a lot of deficiency, a lot of emaciation and needing to
rebuild and rejuvenate people. And hence there's this whole kind of school of herbal medicine
focused on rejuvenation. Whereas in the West, we tend to be a little more excessive, right?
Eating too much rich foods and getting toxic and needing more to cleanse and purify the body,
right? And so we see the alternative blood purifiers is kind of an area of herbalism
that was a very large area of focus, right? I mean, Western herbalism for a really long time
was just purging, right? We're gonna make you vomit. We're gonna make you sweat. We're gonna
make you poop. We're gonna, you know, bloodlet you, right? It's like, it was like all this kind
of purging type therapies or like heroic medicine. And so I think it brings up some interesting
conversations in regards to, you know, why is it that we haven't developed that
orientation that much longer ago, right? I mean, we have it now in the adaptogen category.
And I think there's still a lot more for us to learn about adaptogens and how to properly use
them. I'm not gonna get too much on my soapbox on that topic, but, you know, adaptogens are very
popular plants these days. And a lot of times they're very misused and can actually be damaging
to people. They are not the cure-all panacea that everyone thinks they are. Someone's gonna
hate me for saying that, but it's true. And I'm saying this not from the perspective of
a supplement company, from the perspective of a medicine maker, from the perspective of someone
that is basically profiting by selling adaptogens, but I'm saying this from the perspective of a
clinician that has seen damage done to people by misuse and abuse of adaptogen type plants. So
the, we can't, adaptogen is a very new term in Western herbalism and a lot of it is very much
based on very reductionistic science on these plants or more specifically particular constituents
in the plants that have been isolated that work differently isolated than when in the whole plant.
And then in light of that science, we tend to overlook and neglect these thousands of year
old traditions that have used these plants and know these plants and understand how to properly
and effectively administer them. So that's just, okay, I guess I did jump up on my adaptogen
soapbox a little bit, but that's not the whole spiel. But I think it's just an important
consideration that we really want to not neglect the traditions that really understand how to use
those types of plants. So that is really my perspective here on the word tonic and some of
the different ways that we understand the word tonic in Western herbalism and really how to
differentiate that from the way in which some of these remedies or categories of remedies in the
East have that word in their rejuvenative tonic or chi tonic and just how to make sure that we're
really clear on what someone says. So I always ask when someone's like, oh yeah, this is a great
tonic. I'm like, well, what does that mean? Like, what do you mean when you say tonic? Are we just
kind of throwing that word around without really knowing what it means? Or are we really using that
word specifically in understanding what we mean when we say it? So I think it's really important
to clarify those things when we're communicating amongst one another as herbalists, right? So that
we're all on the same page and that we all have a good understanding of what we're all talking about.
So great question, Stephen, and hopefully that helped clarify for you a little bit of the
difference between our Western word tonic and some of the more Eastern definitions there of that word.
