Where does this tidal water come from? Where does the seawater go after ebbing? Why does it occur so regularly? These questions have puzzled scientists, including great minds like Newton. However, the fundamental causes and mechanisms of tides continue to elude complete explanation and remain a subject of diverse theories and ongoing research.
#gjwpluswatchparty Good news! Gan Jing World recently launched GJW+ streaming, a platform dedicated to presenting a wide array of clean, uplifting, traditional, and educational film and television works. Subscribe to GJW+ now for only $6.99 per month, the price of just two cups of coffee, and enjoy a top-notch viewing experience with your family. Click the link below and by using the exclusive discount code SARA, you can enjoy a 15% discount.
Unveiling the Forgotten, the Forbidden, and the Divine — a journey through China’s lost wisdom and a return to timeless tradition.
Follow me, and rediscover the China that time tried to forget. And consider supporting my research through a donation to help keep these forgotten voices alive. (Donation link: https://paypal.me/KSJBG)
Hello everyone, I'm Sarah. Today we'll talk about the tides.
A line of tidal waves rushes from the sea, in front of the pavilion, snow-like waves pile up.
Seusser's poem vividly portrays the majestic and spectacular number one tide in the world,
the Qingtong tide. Standing atop the pavilion to watch the sea,
he sees the tidal wave on the sea resembling a white line,
Soon, the white line turns into a long white ribbon,
and the tide head grows higher and higher, sweeping in mightily.
In an instant, waves pile up in front of the building like lofty white snow.
The Qingtong tide is grand and unparalleled in its momentum.
According to folk tales, the Qingtong tide is said to be caused by Wu Zixu,
who transformed into a sea god. Back then, he feared that King Fu Chai of Wu would fall
into a trap devised by King Gojian of Yue called the Revenge of the Wounded Snake.
Wu Zixu strongly advised King Fu Chai against it, which angered the king.
In response, King Fu Chai ordered Wu Zixu to take his own life.
Before dying, Wu Zixu left a letter asking for his head to be hung on the city gate
facing the kingdom of Yue, so he could witness Yue's invasion of Wu.
Upon reading this letter, King Fu Chai became furious and threw Wu Zixu's body into the river.
The people of Wu believed that Wu Zixu's body drifted into the East China Sea
and transformed into a sea god in Hangzhou Bay.
Legend says that the calm entrance of the Qingtong River, once peaceful with blue waters,
turned into powerful tides and waves due to Wu Zixu's lingering spirit.
Guohong of the Eastern Jin Dynasty, in his work Baopuzi, refuted the popular belief,
stating it was unfounded as tides existed before his death with the formation of the earth.
In reality, the Qingtong tide is a tidal phenomenon.
It's just that the unique geography of the Qingtong River's estuary
creates the spectacular Qingtong tide.
So, what exactly are tides?
The periodic rise and fall of sea water on earth are collectively known as tides.
Tides include high tides when the sea level reaches its peak
and low tides when it reaches its lowest point.
The process from low tide to high tide is called flood tide,
while from high tide to low tide is called ebb tide or ebb.
Tides can occur as semi-diurnal tides, with two high and two low tides per day,
or as diurnal tides with one cycle per day.
But where does this tidal water come from?
Where does the seawater go after ebbing?
Why does it occur so regularly?
These questions have puzzled scientists, including great minds like Newton.
From historical records, humans have studied tides for over a thousand years,
accumulating rich knowledge about their periodicity and regularity.
Accurate predictions of tidal movements have been made,
and significant progress has been achieved in utilizing tides.
However, the fundamental causes and mechanisms of tides continue to elude complete explanation
and remain a subject of diverse theories and ongoing research.
Today, we explore the origins and mechanisms of tides from a fresh perspective.
Over 2,000 years ago, ancient Chinese scholars had already recognized the
connection between tidal phenomena and the movement of the moon.
Wang Chong of the Eastern Han Dynasty proposed in his work
Luan Heng that waves rise and fall with the waxing and waning of the moon.
Guohong of the Eastern Jin Dynasty, also discussed in Baopuzi,
helped see waves roar and recede in harmony with the moon's phases.
Both explicitly pointed out the correlation between tides and the moon's movements.
By the mid to late 8th century AD, during the Tang Dynasty,
the geographer Dou Xiuming further developed on Wang Chong's ideas,
proposing the synchronous principle that tidal waves correspond with the phases of the moon.
He authored the earliest comprehensive treatise on tides,
titled Haitao Xi, Records of Sea Waves, marking the beginning of tidal predictions.
In his work, Dou Xiuming asserted theories such as moon and sea mutual influence,
sea and moon mutual expectancy, describing characteristics of synchronous lunar tidal
patterns, their cyclic regularity of ebb and flow, and methods for calculating high and low tides.
Through his calculations, Dou Xiuming determined that the tidal cycle,
based on a 24-hour day, was approximately 12 hours, 25 minutes, and 14.02 seconds,
a figure closely resembling the modern concept of semidiurnal tides.
Remarkably, this calculation was made over 1,200 years ago.
Moreover, Dou Xiuming created the Dou Xiuming Tidal Time Chart, facilitating the observation
of daily high tide timings, predating by over 400 years Europe's earliest known London Bridge tide
tables. In 1687, Newton proposed his theory of universal gravitation concerning celestial motions,
defining numerous hypothetical forces or fictitious forces such as inertial force,
centrifugal force, and tidal force to maintain force equilibrium in mathematical calculations.
His seminal work, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy,
remains his most significant scientific contribution.
The introduction in its Chinese translation notes,
When discussing Newton's achievements today, we first mention his Law of Universal Gravitation
and then his Three Laws of Motion. But while readers of the Principia can easily find his
Three Laws of Motion in the book, they won't find the Law of Universal Gravitation highlighted as it
is today because Newton believed that the principles governing the magnitude and direction of
universal gravitation should be deduced results, not introduced as empirical universal principles,
despite his belief in its universal applicability.
Before Newton, Descartes presented a cosmic system emphasizing a certain type of special
material, ether, what Newton called hidden matter, that facilitates interactions among objects,
ensuring the continuity of their movements. The ether was an imagined substance presenting
the first dynamical model of the universe devoid of divine forces.
When Newton's theory of universal gravitation failed to explain the well-known perihelion
advance of Mercury, Einstein's theory of relativity emerged.
In 1905, Einstein proposed special relativity, ruling out the possibility of any effect
propagating faster than light, implying the fundamental assumptions of relativity
and contradictions in Newtonian celestial mechanics.
Laplace had previously proven in his studies that if gravitational interaction were not
instantaneous, that is, if propagation were at the speed of light, the motion of planets would
no longer strictly comply with the law of conservation of momentum, and he deduced that
the solar system would be unstable, only able to exist for a short time. This contradiction
highlighted the need to establish a new theory to replace Newton's theory of gravity.
This new theory, to unify the law of universal gravitation and the basic assumptions of special
relativity, required abandoning the classical mechanical assumption of space, the space-time
we occupy is an idealized, completely unqualified, flat space.
Einstein used Riemannian geometry to describe a curved space-time.
After eight years of research, he successfully proposed general relativity.
General relativity required space-time to be curved, this curvature of space-time is also a
physical reality, fundamentally different from the imaginary fictitious forces of inertia.
General relativity first successfully explained the perihelion advance error of Mercury and
predicted the deflection of light in the gravitational field of the Sun. On May 29,
1919, during a total solar eclipse, photographs of starlight behind the Sun confirmed the bending
of light, validating the experiment. Exploration and interpretation of cosmic space continue to
develop, and subsequent scientists have proposed theories of gravitational waves and dark matter.
True scientific exploration is based on open thinking and the pursuit of understanding the
true nature and knowledge of the universe, rather than being immersed in certain hypotheses
and closed-minded. Newton used tidal forces to explain tidal movements, considering lunar and
solar tidal forces as the primary drivers of tidal ebb and flow. In 1740, D. Bernoulli,
from the perspective of static equilibrium, assumed that the Earth's surface was covered
entirely by the ocean, and the sea level could maintain perpendicularity everywhere with the
combined forces of gravity and tidal forces. This idealized ocean tide is called equilibrium tide.
A tidal theory based on this is called the equilibrium tide theory. This is the first
tidal theory proposed after Newton. It assumes that the entire surface of the Earth is surrounded by
uniformly deep ocean water, without inertia or viscosity. Under the influence of gravity and
tidal forces, the ocean surface remains in equilibrium, forming an ellipsoidal shape called
the tidal bulge. Due to the Earth's rotation, there is periodic rising and falling of the ocean surface
at fixed points on the Earth's surface, resulting in tides. According to this understanding, the side
of the Earth facing away from the Moon should not experience high tides. However, it has long been
observed that even this side experiences high tides. To explain the seemingly strange tidal
phenomenon on the opposite side of the Earth from the Moon, some have proposed that both the Earth
and the Moon orbit a common center of gravity. The centrifugal force predominates on the side of
the Earth farthest from the Moon, while gravity predominates on the side facing the Moon. This
explanation accounts for the bulge of the tidal ellipse and goes beyond the assumptions of the
equilibrium tide theory. In summary, all these explanations are fundamentally based on gravity
and the fictitious centrifugal force, which exerts a pulling force on the ocean surface,
causing it to rise. Let's consider an example. Guam is an island at the southern end of the
Mariana Islands in the Pacific Ocean, closer to the equator, located in the central area where
the Moon directly affects the sea surface. It is far from continental plate coasts and bays,
with wide open seas around, experiencing minimal influence from additional factors such as
topography, making it quite typical. This is the recent tidal table forecast data for Guam,
with May 1 as the third quarter moon, May 8 as the new moon, May 15 as the first quarter moon,
and May 23 as the full moon. According to the tidal data shown in the chart,
select typical daily data for a month and plot a schematic diagram of the tidal bulge distribution
to observe the counterclockwise rotation and changes of the tidal bulge throughout the month.
With the Moon's phases changing, the tidal bulge slowly rotates synchronously with the Moon's orbit
around the Earth. The tidal bulge distribution on any typical lunar phase day in the schematic
diagram corresponds to the tidal level distribution at different times of the Earth's
rotation on that day. From the changes in the tidal bulge distribution during this month,
the following phenomena and regularities can be observed. Firstly, regardless of whether it is
the new moon or the full moon, the first quarter moon or the third quarter moon, the waxing crescent
or waning crescent moon, the waxing gibbous or waning gibbous moon, although the phase difference
between the moon's positions is approximately 180 degrees, the tidal bulge exhibits similar
distribution characteristics. The difference lies in the varying tidal levels at Guam when
the moon is at its zenith. After the new moon, the tide is lower, and after the full moon,
the tide is higher. Secondly, from the waxing crescent moon through the full moon to the
waning crescent moon, with the changes in lunar phases and Earth's rotation,
the tidal bulge completes a shift in its center of mass distribution towards the direction opposite
to the sun. The distribution of higher tide water shifts from initially being opposite to the sun,
undergoes the combined effects of the sun and the moon over half a month, and then returns
to its initial low tide characteristic state. In the two tidal bulge shifts within a month,
the waxing crescent and waning crescent moons serve as starting or ending points.
When the moon is at its zenith, the tide at Guam rises from initially above minus 0.2 meters to
above plus 0.5 meters, whereas during the shift from the waning gibbous moon through the new moon
to the waxing crescent moon, the tidal bulge undergoes a similar periodic shift, but in
reverse, lowering the tide levels at Guam. Thirdly, the tidal bulge distribution on the days of the
waxing gibbous and waning gibbous moons is relatively balanced, being in an intermediate
state of the tidal ellipsoids migration. This is characterized by the tidal range being close to
its minimum. During this time, the high high tide gradually decreases, and the low low tide
gradually increases, often crossing over each other. Following this period, the new high high
tide gradually increases, and the new low low tide gradually decreases, with their difference
approaching the maximum. Moreover, the tidal range reaches its maximum three days after the new moon
and full moon, just as described in the poems of Sudongpo. On the 18th day of the eighth month,
the tides are the most spectacular in the world. However, the problems arise. Firstly,
during the new moon, when the sun and moon are in conjunction, at noon the tide is at low tide,
and the tidal bulge shows that the distribution of seawater tends towards the distant direction
away from the sun and moon. The tidal forces combined during the new moon phase should
theoretically reach their maximum, but the distribution of seawater in the tidal bulge
does not converge towards the direction of the sun and moon. Instead, it moves away from them.
Also, during the first quarter and last quarter moons, the tidal bulge distribution does not
consistently converge towards the direction of the moon. Why is this? Are the forces applied
by the sun and moon on the tidal bulge primarily gravitational or pressure-based? Secondly,
in the diagram from the first quarter moon to the new moon, the moon moves approximately 90
degrees counterclockwise over eight days, corresponding to eight rotations of the Earth.
However, the phase angle of the peak high tide of the tidal bulge only advances by about 63 degrees.
In other words, during the Earth's rotation, the high tide bulge does not synchronize its
rotation with the Earth, moving forward through the moon's direct alignment.
Are the sun and moon pulling the tidal bulge forward through gravitational attraction,
or are they pushing against it, hindering its forward movement?
Thirdly, on the day of the full moon, the distribution of seawater in the tidal bulge
tends to favor the side of the moon opposite to the direction of the sun.
If the force is gravitational, it seems to conform to the theory that the moon's tidal
force is 2.17 times stronger than that of the sun, but this contradicts the earlier analysis
during the new moon phase. If the force is pressure-based,
then evidently the pressure from the sun must be greater than that from the moon.
Moreover, the characteristics of the tidal bulge distribution during the first quarter
and last quarter moons are similar, despite the moon being 180 degrees apart in phase.
How does the tidal force based on universal gravitation actually function?
The tidal data from Guam exhibit typical and representative characteristics.
Similar features are observed in tidal tables from other islands near the Pacific equator,
albeit with much stronger tidal ranges near zero latitude. Along continental coastlines,
bays, and higher latitudes, various factors can alter these characteristics,
resulting in either an inverted or diurnal tidal distribution.
Originally, if unaffected by factors such as the sun, moon, and other influences,
ocean waters on Earth's surface would naturally rotate synchronously with the Earth's rotation.
According to equilibrium tide theory, the combined tidal forces during new and full moons,
coupled with the Earth's forward rotation, should theoretically cause the tidal bulge
to move beyond the moon's position. Why, then, does the tidal bulge not move synchronously with
Earth's rotation? Here, we propose a contemplative approach, starting from phenomena, conducting
intuitive and image-based analyses from one phenomenon to another, without relying on laws,
theorems, axioms, or propositions, to avoid being misled by hypothetical concepts,
theories, or boundary conditions. Water is a fluid, and a fluid's characteristic is
incompressibility, capable of transmitting pressure. Hydraulic servo systems in engineering
machinery utilize this property. Water naturally flows downhill. To move it uphill requires positive
pressure to push it up. From the tidal table data of Guam and the evolutionary regularity of the
tidal bulge in a month, we can see such phenomena. The Earth's rotation naturally moves the sea water
around the Earth every day, influenced by the sun and moon. It appears that there is pressure
exerted on the water surface ahead, causing the slowly moving tidal bulge to form a high tide
that is not synchronized with the Earth's rotation. The moon's rotation around the Earth, on the other
hand, exerts pressure on the sea surface like a moving barrier, causing the tidal bulge to follow
slowly behind. Could this be the case? The pressure exerted by the sun on the sea level and the Earth's
forward motion cause the tidal bulge's sea water distribution to lean more towards the moon's side
around the full moon. Twice a month, around the new and full moons, the tidal bulge moves towards
the far end from the sun, creating the cause of tidal high and low tides and the invisible force
behind the switch between high and low tides. As for whether this pressure is due to spacetime
distortion, dark matter, or other reasons? It can only be said that the true vacuum of space,
the non-material emptiness, and the forms of microscopic matter and microscopic spacetime,
although current technological means have not yet detected them, may not necessarily mean they do
not exist. Did the ancients' rich imagination point out the essence of the interaction between
the tidal bulge and the moon with the moon pushes the sea, and the sea meets the moon?
What is left to us is a broader and boundless space, waiting for us to explore and break through.
There is a saying, the great Tao, is exceedingly simple and easy. The essence of the objective
world is originally simple. When we abandon all imposed non-objective, unreal concepts,
and free ourselves from old constraints, true knowledge will naturally emerge.
Alright, we'll stop here for today. I'll see you next time.