Ranking Member Scott Opening Statement at CFPB Hearing - June 12, 2024

U.S. Senate Banking Committee GOP
29 followers
Jun 13, 2024
thank you Mr chairman director choa
thank you for being here with us today I
will say that listening to Chairman
Brown's comments it sounds like we're
talking about two completely different
agencies and frankly I'm sure our view
is completely different the cfbb has not
been Idol in its Pursuits based on the
pace and scope of announcements I see
coming out of your agency it looks like
full steam ahead I think the celebratory
cheers from 17th Street echoed all the
way over here after the Supreme Court
ruling however I want to be clear that
their decision on cfpb's funding
structure only increases my concerns
about the agency's lack of
accountability Time After Time your
agency brushes aside Congressional
concerns forges ahead with political
agendas and pushes well past the
boundaries of its Authority this ruling
is not a green light for your
Progressive wish list and when we look
at the reaction to your regulations is a
Litany of lawsuits all of which take
time attention and resources away from
the laws you should be implementing and
enforcing as well as the American
consumers you should be protecting so
frankly it makes me wonder what
consumers are you protecting the cfbb is
supposed to be an independent agency but
under your leadership it seems a bureau
Works hand inand with the White House
and appears more interested in scoring
headlines for the Biden Administration
than doing its job whether it's standing
with President Biden as he unveiled the
junk Feast campaign or as we saw
yesterday with the vice president
announcing your new proposal to ban
medical debt from credit reports the
political coordination is crystal clear
you're not protecting consumers or
saving people money instead you're
pedaling a false narrative that the
Biden Administration is doing something
to reduce the actual cost
but then reality hits and we realize
this administration's actions simply
shift who saves and who
pays It is Well pasted time we end this
junk fees narrative and focus on the
junk philosophy behind them with every
action taken there are tradeoffs and
those trade-offs have
consequences in this case the
administration is trading a Punchy head
line proclaiming they are saving familes
money today while actually building
higher costs down the road take for
example your credit card late fees rule
while the rule May save some folks
around $20 each time they make a late
payment how much will it cost these same
consumers when they no longer qualify
for a credit card because they haven't
paid their balances on time how much
will it cost them when their credit
score drops as a result of these late
payments how much will it cost them when
the rate for their car loans and their
mortgages go up not down you can't just
keep erasing the bad facts to fit your
political narrative the bill always and
unfortunately always comes
due you've made a choice to try to Curry
political favor with little regard to
the harm it will cause Americans down
the road you have done this to America's
small businesses as well small
businesses tell me the same story over
and over again and that story is simply
a Washington Shakedown designed to be
little more than a gotcha exercise just
like the cfpb's Civil investigative
demands or CID
process under your C process the bureau
May issue without any court order a
subpoena to a business when they are
when you are looking into potential
violations of the law and once that
subpoena has been issued the cfbb can
demand nearly anything they want from
reams of documents to Executive
testimony so what does that mean for a
company that draws the IRA of your
agency it means years of costly
investigation with little hope of relief
or in other words a bureaucratic Witch
Hunt one small business recently
described the the process to me and I
thought this was
really incredible to see what the
government can do to you as opposed to
for you for three years the cfpb audited
this company but this audit resulted in
no fines no reprimands and no additional
cfbb action then in
2022 four years later the cfpb issued
the first CID which resulted in 12,000
pages of document production and
testimony under oath for the CEO but
again he took no action then in
2023 the cfpb issued another CID
broadening the scope further and
requesting millions of pages of
documents this time the firm attempted
to fight back and appeal but
unfortunately for this small business
the only option for appeal is through
the cfpb
itself not surprisingly the agency
rejected the appeal to date after
countless hours of employee time and
hundreds of thousands of dollars of
outside legal fees the cfbb has taken no
action and this is just one example of a
story which is playing out across the
country every day for far too many small
businesses American consumers and
businesses deserve better they deserve
protection by their government from Bad
actors and to be left alone when they
are simply trying to make a living
