The U.S. Congress Joint Economic Committee will hold a hearing on "Made in America: The Boom in U.S. Manufacturing Investment." This event will begin at 3:00 p.m. ET on June 12.
Witnesses:
Mr. Kevin Hostetler, CEO
Array Technologies, Albuquerque, New Mexico
Mr. Skanda Amarnath, executive director
Employ America, Washington, DC
Dr. Adam Michel, director of Tax Policy
Cato Institute, Washington, DC
Mr. Scott Lincicome, vice president of General Economics and Stiefel Trade Policy Center
Committee hearing titled, Made in America, the Boom in U.S. Manufacturing Investment.
Today's hearing will begin with five-minute opening statements from myself and Vice Chairman
Schweikert and each of our four witnesses, and then we'll proceed to questions alternating
between parties in the order of member arrival.
I was going to remind members to keep their questions to no more than five minutes, but
I think you and I can handle that.
Now on to opening statements.
Over the past few years, we have seen a truly remarkable comeback story for American manufacturing,
impacting communities both in my home state of New Mexico, but across the country.
The economy has added hundreds of thousands of new jobs in manufacturing and construction,
as private investment has flowed into the clean energy sector, semiconductor production,
and advanced technology manufacturing throughout the U.S.
This was not an accident.
We fought hard to bring real solutions to the table and move forward with the Inflation
Reduction Act, the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, and the Chips and Science Act.
These policies have driven the comeback story that we are seeing.
And this graph shows how factory investments surged after the passage of those laws, a
trend that we hadn't seen under any prior administration's policies.
With these historic builds, we've spurred a manufacturing renaissance across America.
And not only is this benefiting our economy, but it will also bolster our national security
and protect our children and grandchildren from the impacts of climate change for years
to come.
The build-out of these key industries will pay dividends by creating middle-class jobs
that people can build a family around in their home communities.
They will create thousands of careers in New Mexico and across the U.S. in the skilled
trades and in advanced manufacturing.
And it is critical in this moment that we work with unions, with industry, with training
centers and local leaders to make sure that implementation of these policies is done right.
To ensure our workforce can capitalize on these opportunities, we need to focus on training
and upskilling.
Apprenticeships and vocational training, as well as partnerships with community colleges
and universities, will give more Americans the chance to meet rising demand for these
careers that will help move our communities, our country, and our economy forward.
That's why our legislation made sure to invest in these efforts and in companies that commit
to building up America's workforce.
Array Technologies is a perfect example of a company that is leading the way by expanding
its manufacturing facilities here in the U.S.
I was happy to be at Array's groundbreaking ceremony in April of this year with Secretary
of Energy Granholm, and I'm glad that their CEO could join us here today.
For decades now, Array has been a world leader in manufacturing solar trackers, the hardware
that rotates solar panels towards the sun throughout the day.
This year, Array is investing more than $50 million to construct a new 216,000-square-foot
campus in Albuquerque, New Mexico, that will support 300 new jobs in the near term.
And they're expanding largely because of the production tax credits that we worked so hard
to include in the Inflation Reduction Act.
Just as they did for Array, these incentives sent a powerful signal to companies that we
are ready to build big things in this country once again.
In the last few years, we've seen hundreds of manufacturing announcements representing
billions of dollars in private investment.
And along with the Inflation Reduction Act, we're seeing booming private investment in
semiconductor manufacturing from the Chips and Science Act.
This law is already boosting employment and wages in New Mexico, with Intel announcing
a $3.5 billion investment in its Rio Rancho campus and fab.
This facility is expected to create at least 700 permanent manufacturing jobs, but thousands
of construction jobs in the meantime.
And we're not stopping there.
Just yesterday, the Department of Commerce announced new CHIPS Act funding for Solero,
a homegrown New Mexico company that can now expand production and hire 100 new manufacturing
workers.
With support from these policies, companies are opening new factories in American communities
to build everything from semiconductors to wind turbines and heat pumps to solar panels
and energy storage.
That's what good policy does.
But I want to make sure that it's clear that due to these policies, business isn't only
growing in urban centers.
We are driving investment in rural America.
And I've seen this firsthand back in New Mexico, where ARCOSA recently opened a new wind tower
manufacturing facility in Valencia County.
Back in April, I got to meet the workers there and see the first wind towers coming off the
line at that facility.
And this is just one example of how these laws that we've passed here invest in the
economy of the future.
These bills are also driving investment in rural energy and infrastructure that can reduce
operating costs, lay the groundwork for future economic growth.
And with this approach, we're making sure that the benefits of this manufacturing boom
reach the entire country.
I'm looking forward to hearing from our witnesses on how these federal investments have guided
business and manufacturing decisions in the U.S. and how we can continue to support this
expansion and make sure it benefits as many Americans as possible.
With that, now I'll turn to our Vice Chairman, Chairman Schweiker.
Thank you, Chairman Heinrich.
And would you believe I see parts of this differently?
Being a big fan of something that's often referred to as allocation theory, when it's
done through a government grant, will that government always be granting to the latest,
best, fastest, most nimble, most cutting-edge, most disruptive technology?
Or do we often fund incumbency?
I think the record shows that much of the capital expenditure, which every dime has
been borrowed, once again, this cash flow that's going out, every dime is borrowed money.
So you actually now think of the rate of return of we're paying interest on that.
We also have some charts, and we are happy to put them into the record without an objection,
that also will demonstrate that manufacturing employment functionally is the same as it
was in 2022.
Once again, demonstrating that, yes, you may get spikes in trades as a plant is being built,
but are we back into the cycle, once again, of a planned economy, industrial policy, where
we actually, a fraction of that money could have gone into the research and development
of the next generation that disrupts and makes America truly leap ahead the rest of the world.
Instead, this policy has set off a cascade of subsidized chip manufacturing.
You see China now organizing what was the last fund, $30 billion.
The EU is now setting aside a massive subsidy to have theirs.
We've actually now created a race to the bottom.
At the very same time, we're doing tax policy, saying we need a global minimum.
But over here, we've functionally financed something that's dramatically more expensive
in a global race to the bottom of subsidy policy.
It's math, you can't avoid the reality.
The other thing I will also give is the basic belief of, if you're going to have industrial
policy, the concept of having government handing out grants and the political danger
that comes around when I must go knock on the door of the administration or the politicians
to get my cash, the distorting effects that has on society, on competitive markets, and
the allocation theory comes back into play.
If we're going to borrow money from your retirement and my kids' future, are we actually getting
the long-run economic growth, or as so often was quoted around here, are we just seeing
the sugar high for a short time without long-term extended growth and sustainable employment?
And with that, I yield back.
Now I'd like to introduce our distinguished witnesses today.
Mr. Kevin Hostetler is the Chief Executive Officer of Array Technologies, a global company
specializing in utility-scale solar trackers and renewable energy, headquartered in Albuquerque,
New Mexico.
Array has been a leader in the solar industry for over three decades and has helped build
out the U.S. supply chain for solar components.
Prior to joining Array, Mr. Hostetler served as CEO at RoadTorque, where he led the company's
growth acceleration program, and as CEO of FDH Infrastructure Services, an engineering
consulting company focused on critical infrastructure like bridges, dams, and transmission towers.
Mr. Skanda Amarnath is the Executive Director at Employ America, a research and advocacy
organization committed to the macroeconomic policies that can sustain full employment
outcomes.
Employ America has written at length about the interconnections between manufacturing
investment, productivity growth, and employment gains for workers, among other pressing economic
policy topics.
Now, prior to joining Employ America in April of 2019, as Research Director, Mr. Amarnath
worked as a market economist and strategist and as an analyst at the Federal Reserve Bank
of New York.
Dr. Adam Michel is the Director of Tax Policy Studies at the Cato Institute, where he focuses
on analyzing the economic and budgetary effects of taxation in the United States.
Prior to joining Cato, Mr. Michel served as the Deputy Director at the Joint Economic
Committee under Senator Mike Lee.
Mr. Scott Lincecum is the Vice President of General Economics at Cato's Herbert A. Stifel
Center for Trade Policy Studies.
Mr. Lincecum is also a senior visiting lecturer at Duke University Law School, where he has
taught a course on international trade policy and previously taught international trade
policy.
Mr. Hostetler, let's begin with your testimony, and then we'll just continue in the order
of the introductions.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Vice Chairman, and all members of this committee.
It's an honor to be here today.
My name is Kevin Hostetler, and I am the CEO of Array Technologies.
Our U.S. footprint includes Albuquerque, New Mexico, where we have our manufacturing facility,
and our research and development hub in Chandler, Arizona.
Array is a leading American manufacturer and global provider of tracker solutions for utility-scale
solar energy projects.
Our solar trackers are an integral part of solar farms, rotating panels to follow the
sun, which increases energy production by up to 25 percent.
Founded in 1989 in Albuquerque as one of the first U.S. solar manufacturers, Array is a
true American manufacturing success story.
We're proud to be an American company sourcing low-carbon domestic steel, supporting local
jobs, and using a traceable U.S. supply chain with trusted partners.
I'm grateful to be leading Array during this nation's manufacturing renaissance.
In April, Array broke ground on a new manufacturing campus in Albuquerque, where we will make
our clamps, center structures, drive system components, and electrical controllers.
The IRA and 45X credits are helping us to onshore critical components and realize this
$50-plus million expansion.
To start, our new facility will employ more than 300 local residents in the near term.
This growth will enable us to further develop more onshore capacity and make more solar
technology here at home.
Over the next decade, we anticipate significant growth in industry employment, with solar
manufacturing jobs expected to more than triple.
In the meantime, we need to create a skilled, renewable energy workforce.
That's why we partner with schools like Central New Mexico Community College.
In 2022, we donated a 1.3-megawatt solar site that generates power for the campus and serves
as a training facility for Array to provide hands-on learning to students.
Collaborations like these are building a pipeline of talent, ensuring that students and job
seekers have the necessary skills and knowledge to thrive as the industry creates jobs.
The IRA and other federal investments have helped grow our domestic production.
As an example, the 45X tax credits are allowing us to onshore clamp manufacturing, where we
are importing, and this will double our manufacturing capacity in Albuquerque.
We have also invested in new capital equipment to support the current and future growth of
our facility.
Since the passage of the IRA, there has been a notable uptick in announcements for new
solar manufacturing facilities across the supply chain, driven by the law's provisions
and the anticipated rise in solar demand.
This has caused a ripple effect as our business growth has also spurred growth for our partners.
Copper State Bolts and Nuts Company has added an additional 30,000 square feet in their
Goodyear, Arizona facility to support their solar business.
Our partner, Prefert Steel in Mount Pleasant, Texas, has invested $25 million in solar in
the last 24 months, employing over 200 people.
Lock Joint Tube in Temple, Texas, invested $16 million in a dedicated tube line to support
solar tracker manufacturing.
And finally, our partner, Nucor, is investing $70 million in capital for a new steel plant
in Kentucky to support the growth in solar demand.
The IRA has set the stage for long-term growth and stability for our business and the U.S.
solar industry.
The law is expected to facilitate nearly triple the current solar capacity by 2028, fostering
a strong, sustainable future for renewable energy in America.
IRA's presence in New Mexico not only boosts the local economy, but also positions the
region as a hub for renewable energy innovation and manufacturing.
We're proud to work with companies like Enchanted Machine Works, Knockout Metalworks, and Precision
Sharpening.
This growth contributes to a more resilient and diverse economic landscape, benefiting
the broader community and promoting long-term prosperity.
The IRA has spurred a true manufacturing resurgence, and IRA is just one example of how this legislation
is paying dividends.
With policies that supercharge solar manufacturing and create new jobs, together we are paving
the way for a brighter, more sustainable future.
Thank you for the time, and I look forward to answering your questions.
Mr. Emert.
Chairman Heinrich, Vice Chairman Schweikert, thank you for the invitation to testify today.
My name is Skanda Emernath.
I am the Executive Director of Employee America, a nonpartisan macroeconomic policy research
organization.
Before discussing what the available macroeconomic data tells us about the nature of manufacturing
investment and public policy, I'd like to first lay out some reasons why manufacturing
and industrial investment may be of unique relevance.
Economic development and manufacturing advancement have long been tied together.
No major advanced economy has sidestepped the industrialization process on its path
to becoming wealthy.
If you compare what each country exports, it becomes clear which countries are richer
and which countries are poorer.
Richer countries tend to produce a broader diversity and higher complexity of traded
products.
That's because richer societies have accumulated superior know-how for producing highly complex
leading-edge products and can do so across a broader range of goods.
The reasons to encourage investment in manufacturing are thus twofold, ensuring that workers and
enterprises in the U.S. capture the knowledge spillovers associated with producing technologically
advanced goods and encouraging broader industrial diversification at the national, state, and
local levels.
A more diversified economy also goes hand in hand with a wider range of opportunities
for workers and businesses.
But where other sectors have thrived over the past few decades, manufacturing has seen a
general decline.
Some reasons for the decline were inevitable, but it's worth noting that this trend also
grew more visible in high-tech advanced manufacturing sectors.
With this in mind, the surge in construction of manufacturing facilities is worth studying.
The level of spending that the private sector has engaged in to construct manufacturing
facilities has increased from approximately $80 billion in 2019 to roughly $220 billion
today.
Even after adjusting for specific cost increases, the level of real investment has more than
doubled since 2019.
While public policy is surely supporting much of this increase, it's worth clarifying that
these expenditures are directly deployed by private firms, not by governmental actors.
Not all manufacturing subsectors have seen a surge in investment, but the ones most closely
adjacent to recently enacted legislation have.
The manufacturing supersector encompassing computer and electronic products and electrical
equipment, appliances, and components has seen a tenfold increase in real manufacturing
structures' investment since 2019.
This supersector includes not only the primary subject matter of chips, but also photovoltaic
cells for solar panels, batteries for motor vehicles, and transformers for the utility
sector, all potentially facilitated by chips and IRA.
The timing of the surge in investment in manufacturing construction is the most compelling evidence
that chips and IRA are having a sizable impact on the willingness of manufacturers to build
and improve their facilities.
The effects of policy enactment are especially clear-cut across census regions in the Midwest
and the Sun Belt, where manufacturing investment surged noticeably following the enactment
of legislation.
To fully evaluate the success of policy, it will require translating capacity gains, which
recent construction spending should represent, into gains in manufacturing output and productivity.
But importantly, it is still far too soon to expect relevant manufacturing facilities
to reach productive maturity and achieve the anticipated level of output.
It will take time to fully build up capacity, and more time still to reach productive maturity.
The relevant manufacturing investments, given their capital intensity, are also unlikely
to show their full labor market impact through factory floor jobs alone.
Instead, what we see is how manufacturing investments can drive growth in construction-related
or product research and development jobs.
While targeted sectors are likely to see further gains in employment only as production scales
up, the bigger gains in employment are materializing right now for electricians, engineers, architects,
lab testers, and a range of other fields I describe in more depth in my written testimony.
As we look to the future, it's important to remember that leading-edge manufacturing production,
whether tied to semiconductors or the vast array of new energy technologies, often requires
available and affordable financing, a proximate supply chain and industrial base, and a skilled
workforce.
These necessary conditions for investment often depend on the presence of industry in
the first place, thereby giving rise to what most might understand as a chicken-or-the-egg
dilemma.
It often takes a critical mass of policy support to ensure investment decisions can overcome
hurdle rates that otherwise deter the sorts of investments that we're seeing right now.
We've had decades of declining interest rates and a falling cost of capital, but only in
recent years has a flurry of investment in capital-intensive manufacturing sectors emerged.
This flurry has even defied the Fed's recent campaign to tighten financial conditions thus
far.
But even with this progress, old and new constraints, whether they stem from financial constraints,
regulatory burdens, or something entirely different, are likely to bind.
In ensuring that enacted legislation yields maximum benefit for the public, my hope is
that lawmakers and policymakers stay attentive, open-minded, and pragmatic.
Dr. Michel.
Chairman Hynek, Vice Chairman Schweikert, and members of the committee, thank you for
inviting me to testify today.
It's a particular honor to participate in a hearing for a committee I once worked for
and which I have many fond memories.
To understand the state of our current economy, it's important to begin with the tax reforms
passed in 2017.
By cutting the corporate tax rate and allowing full deductions for new investments called
full expensing, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act empowered businesses to expand their U.S.
operations.
These changes were particularly helpful for investment-intensive sectors like manufacturing.
The tax cuts led to faster growth and higher wages.
Today, those same tax cuts continue to support a strong labor market, additional investment,
and a larger economy.
Instead of building on the successes of the tax cuts by making the 2017 reforms permanent,
Congress has more recently done the opposite.
Instead of letting individual Americans, investors, consumers, entrepreneurs, determine the quantity,
quality, and location of new projects, Congress and the President have repeatedly inserted
themselves into the private economic decision-making, allocating scarce resources according to their
own design and for Washington's benefit.
These types of centrally planned industrial policies have a multi-decade track record
of spectacular failures.
Such policies inevitably require more than just incentives.
For example, generous subsidies support electric vehicles and their infrastructure, but the
billions of dollars of support isn't enough.
The subsidies come with heavy-handed regulations that all but ban the competitors, and the
administration now tells us that tariffs are also necessary to protect the industry from
foreign competition.
Market manipulation on one margin always leads to a cascade of new state interventions that
aren't just windfall profits to corporate industry, but costs to American consumers.
Industrial policy also breeds corruption and fraud.
Past tax credits have resulted in schemes designed to drain the U.S. Treasury of hundreds
of billions of dollars.
These fiscal costs, these fiscal resources lost to the programs also represent multi-trillion
dollar opportunity costs, such as foregone opportunities to make more effective tax cuts
permanent.
For example, Congress chose to spend trillions of dollars on dubious energy subsidies in
the Inflation Reduction Act instead of pursuing broad-based policies like making expensing
for research spending permanent, a policy that would have benefited millions of businesses
and their employees all across America.
As a result of Congress's failure, business R&D plummeted when expensing expired.
I'll end with the most worrying trend.
The Biden administration is actively exporting these industrial policies around the world,
and they're doing this over the explicit objections of Congress.
Working through the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, the administration
has designed the building blocks for an international tax cartel that targets America's most successful
employers with higher taxes in more than 100 new countries.
The minimum tax they've designed not only raises tax rates, but explicitly encourages
competition with state subsidies.
Paired with domestic U.S. corporate subsidies, the OECD minimum tax has prompted new industrial
policies in countries around the world, including the European Union, South Korea, Japan, Israel,
Germany, Vietnam, Bermuda, Singapore, Ireland, Taiwan, India, and China, just to name a few.
These offsetting subsidies create no new productive economic activity.
They simply pad the profits of big, politically connected firms.
Congress might as well have lit a trillion dollars of taxpayer money on fire.
At least a bonfire wouldn't have fueled multiple years of high inflation.
Which leads me to my concluding recommendations.
Congress should reject the Biden administration-led OECD tax cartel by cutting its funding and
withdrawing from the OECD membership.
Congress should also reject industrial policies here at home by repealing the more than $3
trillion of tax subsidies, including those in the CHIPS Act and the Inflation Reduction Act.
Pursuing neutral, pro-growth tax policies that support American employers by keeping
taxes low for everyone will provide the biggest benefits to workers, to manufacturers, to
service providers, and to families across the country.
Thank you.
I look forward to your questions.
Mr. Whitsakam.
Chairman Heinrich, Vice Chairman Schweiker, members of the committee, thank you for having
me here today.
Industrial policy is indeed back in Washington, and supporters are already taking credit for
an American manufacturing boom.
Today, I'll offer two notes of caution detailed in my written testimony.
First, the recent increase in U.S. manufacturing investment must be put into context.
Before the CHIPS Act and IRA were enacted, market factors had pushed companies to reconsider
semiconductor supply chains.
Private demand for, and investment in, green energy was soaring, and several major U.S.
projects had been announced.
It's thus unclear how much manufacturing spending today has been caused by, instead of just
coincident with, new U.S. industrial policies.
Furthermore, increases in industrial spending are still a relatively small share of total
output and investment.
That spending might still be important someday, but it's not currently an economic game-changer.
Indeed, actual U.S. manufacturing performance has been flat since 2022.
Private surveys have been pessimistic, and 2024 projections are now softening.
Maybe a boom eventually arrives, but it's just as likely we're again seeing what critics
of targeted tax credits, subsidies, tariffs, and other industrial policy measures have
long cautioned, that they don't generate sustainable, long-term growth, but instead just redistribute
existing resources to favored companies at a net loss to the U.S. economy.
Second, we must also consider the actual return on all these investments.
When the government showers preferred industries with trade restrictions and trillions of taxpayer
dollars, the policies will inevitably produce something in the real economy.
The real question is what, exactly, all that government support is getting us.
Is it generating dozens of innovative and globally competitive American factories and
a strong U.S. economy?
Or will it produce a few narrow successes and many other failures, not just unfinished
projects, but entire industries dependent on government support, plus unintended and
unseen costs elsewhere in the economy?
Today it is too early to say, but there are already warning signs here and abroad, ones
we have seen before.
Here at home, the cost of building, staffing, and starting production at subsidized facilities
has skyrocketed, thanks in large part to supply-side barriers like the National Environmental Policy
Act, tariffs, and Buy American restrictions.
High costs and other unforeseen issues have now delayed or canceled many semiconductor,
EV, and solar projects, even some where construction had already begun.
And there are already worrying signs that factories eventually completed here won't
produce cutting-edge technologies that compete globally without open-ended government help.
Solar panels, for example, still cost more to make here than abroad, even with all the
subsidies and tariffs.
The industry's solution?
Even more tariffs.
Finally, politics is again distorting industrial policy's implementation.
Social policy a tap to CHIPS Act subsidies, IRA dollars funneled to swing states, slow
and complicated bureaucracy, election-related investment uncertainty, and, of course, a
lobbying boom there on K Street.
These and other issues remind us that there's a huge chasm between celebrated investment
announcements and actual productive factories.
They also show that the risk of today's industrial policies is that they produce small and discreet
benefits at a massive cost, including not just a budgetary hit, but by diverting finite
taxpayer and private resources away from better targets.
There are also concerns abroad because subsidies here have prodded the EU, Japan, South Korea,
Taiwan, India, China, and others to offer subsidies of their own.
Thousands of new industrial policy measures in the last year alone likely worth trillions
of dollars.
If history is any guide, this uncoordinated and predictable global subsidies race could
generate gluts and trade wars that would undermine the very domestic investments our industrial
policies are trying to encourage.
In the end, almost everyone would be worse off, especially developing countries that
can't afford big subsidies and, in the case of green goods, the environment.
In closing, American industrial policy has long faced challenges that limit its effectiveness
and inflict unintended economic and geopolitical damage.
It's too soon to conclude that we're following the same path today, but signs do point in
that direction.
Now, this doesn't mean that Congress should just sit back and watch things unfold, simply
hoping our trillion-dollar gamble pays off.
As I and Adam and others have written, there's a long list of proven tax, trade, regulatory,
immigration, and other reforms that Washington can and should pursue to boost strategic industries
and address strategic challenges.
But subsidies and protectionism still aren't on that list.
Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
Thank you.
Mr. Hostetler, I want to ask you a question.
I was really pleased to visit Array in April with Secretary Granholm to break ground on
your new manufacturing facility.
But one of the things that really struck me was the stories that individual folks who
work for Array were telling about their jobs and their impact on their families.
Can you talk a little bit about the kind of benefits a working family can access through
a career in advanced manufacturing, what that means for the wider community?
Absolutely, Mr. Chairman.
As you were able to witness in our groundbreaking in April, the stories of our employees coming
into this industry and those that have been in for some time are enjoying very strong
wages, great benefits, and great additional education opportunities through our local
resources with our local community colleges.
They're able to build a solid foundation for their family and, again, contribute a
great deal to the local economy.
One of the challenges we have in New Mexico right now is that there are so many simultaneous
construction projects going on between the transmission that's being built, the manufacturing
that's being stood up.
Workforce is a real challenge.
Can you talk a little bit about the relationship between the Inflation Reduction Act and your
efforts to invest in local workforce to build that capacity?
Absolutely.
As I said in my prepared remarks, Mr. Chairman, we've been working with the local community
college.
We've provided them some additional systems to which they could train employees early
on in how to build, install, maintain, and control solar systems.
We're also employing local engineers, local maintenance, a very wide degree of different
employees in customer service.
All of that is geared at, once again, providing a very stable, very strong foundation for
their lives and their community.
Mr. Aberneth, talk a little bit, expand on how this focus on energy tech, on semiconductor
production and infrastructure, how do those relate to the overall groundwork for U.S.
job growth?
What does that mean for the future of the American middle class?
Sure.
I would start with, obviously, the gains have come through construction investments so far.
Especially if you look at the labor market data, while we've seen, let's say, manufacturing
employment has recovered from the COVID recession, and it's probably been pretty stable overall,
the real gains have probably been more visible in other sectors, especially in terms of,
first, the trades, construction.
But also, if we look through the repair and maintenance, and into particular sectors of,
especially engineering services, engineering and drafting, and lab testing, and there are
at least a few key sectors, again, where manufacturing and services actually go hand in hand, where
there's a tendency to say, manufacturing and just focus on particularly that subsector.
But I would actually encourage people to think a little bit more holistically about how manufacturing
and services are pretty complementary in these contexts.
And especially when you think about where the good jobs are, those are jobs that are
typically attached to where you're higher in the value chain, where you actually are
at the leading edge.
And that's, to my mind, the merits of focusing on semiconductor manufacturing, on particularly
newer energy tech.
And these are jobs that will be good jobs also on the factory floor, but also elsewhere.
That's typically also good for, in terms of commercial opportunity for American businesses
as well.
Yeah, many of the people in the skilled trades that I talk to would point out that, you know,
when you're building these things, they're inherently temporary jobs.
But those are the good jobs that support their middle class families.
They are temporary.
When they're standing up an Intel factory, and then they move on to building transmission,
and then they move on to building a research facility at our national labs, we think of
those as temporary.
But they're really permanent jobs for those individuals.
I want to ask you as well, you know, we've seen some of the supply chain that we hemorrhaged
for decades, particularly to China, but more broadly to Southeast Asia, for things like
for solar panels, for modules, for electric motor components, for battery storage.
Some of that supply chain is beginning to move back onto U.S. shores.
How important is that?
And how critical is the structure of a production tax credit to have incentivized that reshoring
of critical supply chains?
It definitely seems like this flurry of manufacturing investment that we've seen is pretty concentrated
in terms of the timing of it.
And so while it's very possible there are layers of policy supports that have been helpful,
it definitely was unleashed all at once, I would say, in terms of it being over a very
concentrated time period.
And that suggests that it does require critical mass to get over these hurdles.
And these things are to get to actually, well, I think there are actually a lot of merits
to what some of the other people have testified as far as having broad-based policies that
are supportive of all industries.
There's also a certain quantum of investment that is needed in a lot of cases, especially
where you get into capital-intensive sectors.
And so these are things that have clearly been helpful as far as seeing the surge, especially
in 2022 and 2023.
Again, this is the first phase of manufacturing investment in terms of structures.
You obviously want to see it show up in equipment and production later on.
And these are obviously open questions that need to be tackled in real time.
But there is clearly something that's valuable about having onshore supply chains that we've
probably learned over the last few years.
In certain contexts where we've had a knockout of auto production for two years, there's
definitely certain things that can build in more resilience.
And then there are things that are especially valuable in terms of leading-edge technologies,
where, again, I think there's a lot of national security and economic security relevance to
just being at the leading edge there.
And I'd say at least in the context of, call it, batteries and semiconductors, there's
been evidence that the U.S. has fallen behind.
Vice Chairman.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Doctor, first off, a couple of things from your testimony, your written testimony.
And I'm chasing a couple of things.
So in my opening statement, I tried to touch on, shall we say, allocation costs, because
I remember the rage from our brothers and sisters on the left when we did tax reform
being a trillion and a half dollars, which, as you know, joint tax missed the number by
$900 billion.
It's actually on top of receipts that came in.
But this is direct subsidies that's over $2 trillion.
And the distortion factors of allocation.
So my couple of questions are, when I look at the distortion of a planned economy, industrial
policy, which the left embraced, wages, wage growth, the cost to society of the inflation
it helped fuel.
Is society functioning poorer today?
Will I see that a couple trillion dollars of planned economy spending in workers' wages,
will the wages long run be healthier and stronger?
Or did we actually create a short-term sugar high in a limited number of politically connected
organizations?
Thank you for the question.
It's, I think, the second one.
The chart that you're holding up there shows the cost of the direct subsidies compared
to making policies that were expiring at the same time, namely business expensing for
research and spending in physical investments like manufacturing facilities.
Those policies were expiring.
And so, and the cost, the $2 trillion cost of the direct subsidies is significantly larger
than setting neutral policy that gets out of the way of investment for all businesses
rather than targeted businesses that receive specific checks from Washington.
And so that's why we should first get the government out of the way of investment before
the government starts getting in the business of picking who's investing and where.
This borrowing and spending and its contribution to inflation, ultimately, is society poor?
Yes, undoubtedly.
When the government is taxing the money out of the economy to then redistribute or borrowing
all of these things make us poor.
There's dead weight loss on the tax side.
There's inefficiencies on the spending side.
Inflation is making people poorer.
For those of us in the Phoenix, Scottsdale area, unless you make 26% more today than
when this all began, you're poor.
Mr. Lincoln?
I don't know why I always screw.
Look, you actually have a great chart in here.
Because remember, part of this hearing was titled the manufacturing boom.
But if you actually look at the dot plot and say, hey, here's where the industrial policy,
the spending began, and the number of plans that were happening under existing tax code,
and considering if you actually put in the hiccup, as we'll call it, during COVID-19,
how do you think you call this a boom?
It might be a tighter concentration.
But the fact of the matter is, under a allocation theory of tax policy, we were doing actually
quite well, and it was a wider distribution.
Right.
Thank you.
If you look at the headlines around that time, whether it's in 2019, 2020, 2021, you saw
there was a lot of interest for various market-related reasons, the pandemic, geopolitics, and the
rest.
There was interest in changing supply chains, changing sourcing, on-shoring certain production
of defense-related technologies or other critical industries.
And, you know, I think it's undeniably true we're going to see some sort of sugar high,
some sort of investment, because of all of these subsidies.
I mean, again, we're talking trillions of dollars, potentially, in government and taxpayer
money, going to favored industries.
But the question is not only about whether that's inducing that sugar high, it's what
Because in the pre-IRA, pre-CHIPS era, where we were seeing some of those announcements
and some of those investments, those weren't coming because somebody was dangling cash
at a company, or they weren't coming because there was some sort of tax credit expiring
or whatever.
They were coming because the investors saw a legitimate long-term investment that they
wanted to make.
And those are the types of investments we want here in the United States.
All right.
Doctor, I want you to confirm something I believe I understand.
When we do it through sort of tax regulatory allocation theory or policy, the vast majority
of that that goes to corporate America actually goes to workers' wages.
When the tax code is treating investment neutrally through something like expensing or a lower
corporate tax rate, most of that is shared by workers through higher wages.
The additional investment leads to higher productivity, which then leads to higher wages.
The opposite is not true.
A tax credit does not have that same pass-through to higher wages.
It primarily goes to pad the profits of the corporation doing the favored activity.
Which I've always found an amazing irony in where the two parties are and what we say
about each other, and yet we can demonstrate mathematically this policy over here is actually
what helps workers.
And with that, I yield back, Mr. Chairman.
Senator Welch.
Thank you.
I want to thank all the witnesses.
It's interesting listening because really there are two economic philosophies at work
here.
There's the industrial policy that obviously underlies a lot of the acts that have been
recently passed.
And there's the very strong free market approach with government not being involved at all.
I voted for those pieces of legislation and support them and think that government does
have a role.
But I think that's really the debate as I listen to you.
But I want to ask you, Mr. Hostetler, right?
That's correct, yes.
You have to deal with this guy in New Mexico?
I do.
Well, Mike, it's tough.
It's tough.
You know, it's really interesting what you're saying because the legislation, there's some
funds available for you to help folks learn how to do solar installations and then move
towards providing more clean energy, correct?
Yes.
The CHIPS Act also provided some funds that got invested in Vermont at global foundries.
And folks there see that as jobs.
They don't see it as the government involved or not involved.
I mean, the bottom line for them is that it's going to give them a new lease on life on
these advanced CHIPS.
But tell me how it makes a difference for young people whose jobs prospects in many
of our rural communities are really pretty limited until they get an opportunity to do
something that has a sustainable future.
Yes, absolutely.
First, I mean, I like to think of this as a great example where you separate the theory
from practice and the reality, right?
So these specific provisions passed within the IRA has led to definitive practice of
on-shoring, and that is bringing jobs back to the U.S. that were previously done in Southeast
Asia.
That, as we discussed, that new factory will generate 50 additional jobs that we are, again,
on-shoring back from Southeast Asia into the U.S.
This coupled with the fact that some of the provisions that were outlined in the IRA provides
prevailing wages and apprenticeship programs for all construction projects, which not only
ensures good-paying jobs and an opportunity to learn a new career in what will be a sustainable
future for the U.S., that is in the renewable energy.
So we feel really strong about those specific provisions and what they're doing in terms
of assuring good wages and wages that will be able to be sustained over a long period
of time.
Thank you.
And, you know, to be fair to the pre-market argument, as a result of some of these so-called
industrial policies and really putting a limitation on imports with tariffs, American consumers
are going to pay a little more, right?
But what I've seen is that if the whole goal is to just get the lowest price, then capital
will go to the cheapest labor, and pretty soon you have hollowed-out communities like
we had in Vermont when we lost our machine tool industry.
In coming from a rural state, I've seen that manufacturing is a critical part in these
rural communities that depended on agriculture but had the benefit of manufacturing.
So I guess I'll ask you, Mr. Amroth, do you see some benefit in these policies that are
being disputed about their economic efficacy with having as a goal trying to bring some
of these manufacturing jobs back to our communities?
Thanks.
So I would say especially where it deals with you're trying to rationalize particular policies
for a particular industry, right?
There's obviously places where it could be in excess, but it's also we're thinking about
what types of capacities are being built up in the process, right?
In the case of machine tooling, for example, is a pretty specialized industry, and where
there's also a lot of evidence of where competition isn't exactly fair on the global scale, and
where there needs to be some thought given to what capacities are we losing in the process?
These are people who obviously are working and earning a paycheck, but they also are
developing a certain set of skills, a certain type of know-how.
That's pretty valuable and very costly to lose.
Thank you.
My time is up, and I didn't have a chance to address you, but I want to acknowledge
that when you do have industrial policy, you do have tax policy, there's going to be winners
and losers.
And if you're on the side, as I was, to support the Inflation Reduction Act, it really does
demand of those of us who supported those policies that there be a hard-headed, hard-nosed
assessment of what's been the cost and what's been the benefit.
So, your point in that respect, I agree with.
I'll yield back, and I guess Mr. Smucker, you would?
Yeah, go ahead.
Thank you, Senator Welch.
And just a follow-up to some of the comments that Senator Welch just made, and I think
he aptly described, perfectly described the debate that we're having now and the debate
that we'll be having next year as we look at extending certain provisions of our tax
code and other changes that could be made.
How do we design the best system to achieve what I think are shared goals?
We want all Americans to prosper.
We want the economy to grow.
We want to encourage innovation.
We want to promote job growth and opportunity.
And so, I think it's a very valuable discussion to have.
And Mr. Hostetler, I understand or I hear the impact on your business, and I think your
employees have benefited from that.
You have benefited from that.
But I worry about the broader impact on all Americans.
And I think if you look at what has happened after the IRA was passed, I think it's called
the Inflation Resurgence Act, it should be, because we saw inflation grow, and our folks
on our side had warned that that is exactly what would happen when you expand supply that
much.
And while it's benefiting some people, I think on a much broader basis, I talk to people
in my community who haven't seen the benefits of some of the companies that have benefited,
and they're hurting.
It's difficult for them sometimes to put food on the table, gas in the car.
Prices have gone up 20%, at least, some items much, much more since we've implemented some
of these industrial policy items, as Senator Welch was talking about.
It's painful for people.
And you compare that back, and I'll get maybe Mr. Lindsell, I'll ask you to respond to this,
but compare that back to the impact of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.
Now, that bill wasn't perfect, but it attempted to broaden the, you know, it attempted to
implement good tax policy that provided a broad benefit, that grew the economy, that
encouraged innovation.
And it's pretty difficult to look at that and say it didn't work.
Middle income, real household income had increased about 5,000 per household.
The economy was growing at a much faster clip than it had been before, which, by the way,
helps to address, I think, what is one of the biggest existential problems, and that is the
growing debt and the fiscal trajectory that we're on.
And so, and more people were employed.
Typically disadvantaged populations had the lowest employment rate ever.
And one of the numbers I'm most proud of is we had the lowest poverty rate ever in
the history of the country after just several years of implementation of the Tax Cuts and
Jobs Act.
So, Mr. Lindsell, am I looking at this correctly?
Would you want to, do you want to expand on what I said or react to what I said?
It seems to me there are two very clear examples of economic policy that was put in place.
We have a pretty good record of the impact after a few years in each case.
So, am I, do you want to respond to that?
No, I mean, I think you're directionally correct.
I think the reality you have, and I think it's correct, that we all share the same objectives.
We want good jobs, a strong labor market, a strong economy.
The question is what's going to actually generate that in a sustainable way while minimizing
the distortions, not just the economic distortions, but the political distortions as well.
The more free market approach not only avoids taxing certain jobs, so we tax solar panels
that hurt solar installation jobs, we tax, you know, half of all imports are manufacturing
inputs, so those are inputs used by American manufacturers to support American jobs.
You not only are taking from consumers and raising the cost and shrinking their budgets,
but you also put Washington in charge of making decisions about what factory gets money,
what factory doesn't, what place gets those dollars as well.
And that over the long term creates enormous problems.
And I think it also creates a risk for even more subsidies and protectionism in the future.
We had solar panels in 2012 that have then, tariffs in 2012, that have just steamrolled,
and now we have another solar panel tariff case now pending.
The Intel CEO is now talking about a chip sack 2.0 just weeks after the first subsidies
were implemented.
These things have a way of simply sticking around forever, if not being expanded, because
the industries that we're supporting are not actually globally competitive.
I have more questions, but thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Mr. Tucker.
And I apologize to the panel and everyone in the room, because we'd love to dive down
into this.
We have votes on in the House, so it's the tyranny of the calendar.
Please understand, I think actually there may be, I think even the chairman may also
have some other questions.
Three days, we have to sort of submit some additional questions to you.
I know I have a couple of allocation ones I want to send to the good doctor.
And with that, the hearing is adjourned.
And now we go race to vote.
Goodbye all.