Si Ni San | Review of TCM Formulas

Medicinal leaves
30 followers
Hey this is Nicholas. We're continuing to talk about formulas and in this video we're talking
about sunnisan, frigid extremities powder. So the first thing we should mention is that we
have two formulas with very similar sounding names. Sunnitang, frigid extremities decoction,
and sunnisan, frigid extremities powder. Both of these formulas treat cold limbs,
but the underlying mechanism is very different. Sunnitang treats cold extremities due to yang
collapse or devastated yang. So the idea here is there's just not enough yang to warm the body.
So we'll see cold extremities, an aversion to cold, curling up when lying down, a pale tongue,
and a faint pulse. Sunnisan on the other hand treats cold extremities due to liver chi stagnation.
The idea here is because the chi is stagnant the extremities aren't being properly warmed because
the chi is just not circulating there. So here you'll see coldness in the fingers and toes but
the head and body will still feel warm. And because we're dealing with liver chi stagnation we'll see
additional signs and symptoms like irritability, fullness in the chest, a red tongue with a yellow
coat, and a wiry pulse. So maybe a way you can remember the difference between these two formulas
Ti is for tonify. So sunnitang tonifies yang to warm the entire body. But S is for stagnation.
So sunnisan treats cold fingers and toes due to liver chi stagnation. Or if we wanted to be
more Chinese about it we could mention that the character san not only means powder it also means
to scatter or to disperse. So sunnisan disperses stagnation so that the chi can reach the
extremities. And we actually have another formula called dangwei sunnitang which treats cold
extremities due to blood deficiency. Again the Ti means tonify but because this one has dangwei
in the name that means we're tonifying blood to warm the extremities. So with sunnisan even though
our chief complaint is cold extremities we're actually not treating it with warming herbs.
Instead we're using acrid moving herbs to spread the chi and release constraint. And we do this
using a very interesting dueyao pair chai hu plus bai shao. This combination is discussed in more
detail in the dueyao video. I'll link that below. But the basic idea is we have the saying that
the liver is yin in form and yang in function. We say that the liver is yin in form we mean that
liver stores blood and likes to be soft and relaxed. We said that liver is yang in function
we're referring to its function of moving chi and governing free coursing. So the pair chai hu plus
bai shao addresses both of these aspects. Bai shao is a nourishing herb that softens and relaxes the
liver. Chai hu is an acrid herb that moves liver chi and relieves constraint. And then we add in
which is another chi regulating herb especially for fullness in the chest and epigastrium.
And then zhe gong cao is there to harmonize and also to strengthen the spleen. So notice the
temperature of these herbs. Even though we're treating a condition of cold extremities all of
these herbs except for zhe gong cao are actually cool in temperature. So we could say that the cold
fingers and toes are a sign of false cold. We're actually likely to see heat in the center because
We can also point out the direction of these herbs. Chai hu has more of an upward and outward
direction. It's very light and ascending. But zhe shi is more bitter and descending. It has a strong
downward direction. So with this formula we're moving chi in all the directions. And then we
can also say that this formula can also be used for disharmony of the liver and spleen. Because
chai hu and bai shao are working more on the liver whereas zhe shi and zhe gong cao are working more
on the spleen and stomach. So I don't know how often you'll see this formula prescribed in
clinic but it's still a good one to know because it's one of those small formulas that you'll see
pop up inside of other formulas. For example chai hu shu gong cao is a modification of
si ni cao. So we start with the original four herbs and then we just add in additional moving
herbs like chen pi, xiang fu, and chuan xiong. Shui fu jiu yu tang is a formula that moves both
chi and blood. And we can see that it's basically tao hong si wu tang plus si ni san. So we're
combining our basic blood moving formula with a basic chi moving formula. Even chao ya san some
people say is based on si ni san. This one might be a little bit of a stretch but we could at least
And then this can even show up as a modification for other formulas. So for some formulas you might
see something like for liver chi stagnation and ribside pain combine the original formula with
si ni san. So this is a good formula to know and that's si ni san. So this was a video about
formulas but if you're interested in reviewing individual herbs I have an online review course
It's $40 and it reviews all of the single herbs. So if you're starting to study formulas going back
and reviewing your single herbs can give you a good foundation for understanding the formulas,
formula composition, and formula modifications. But that's all for today. Thanks and see you next time!
