Some American veterans fought for their lives along the beaches of Normandy. Some were among the first to witness the horrors as they liberated emaciated prisoners from concentration camps. And some even helped Holocaust survivors as they began to reclaim their lives. Now, 80 years after the D-Day invasion, their stories live on. Join us in collaboration with Arlington National Cemetery for a special digital program honoring the resilience, commitment, and courage of American veterans. Learn how their sacrifices inspired some Holocaust survivors to serve their new country.
Speakers Rebecca Erbelding, Historian, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
Allison S. Finkelstein, Senior Historian, Arlington National Cemetery
Remarks by Albert Willner, son of Holocaust survivor and US Army veteran Eddie Willner
Moderator Lindsay MacNeill, Historian, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
my 13th birthday was June 6
1944 and the Machine shop where I worked
had a clandestine radio and we heard
radio free free Europe BBC uh announcing
that the Normandy invasion had started
my birthday present was to hear the
Tatam of the call of the uh Radio free
Europe and then the announcement our
grandfather told us about the landing in
Normandy he would lay out a checker
cloth on his table red Checkers for the
allies and black checkers for the German
positions and he would outline the
Normandy Landing whenever we ended he
would always say well don't tell any of
your friends all of a sudden there's a
lot of people in the streets hugging
kissing dancing jumping of Joy it it was
Unreal it was uh incredible and that's
when I found out the fantastic news the
Americans had just landed in Normandy it
was the end of a nightmare I'll never
forget this as long as
I tomorrow marks 80 years since D-Day a
pivotal moment in the Allies victory
over Nazi Germany which ultimately led
to the end of the Holocaust you've just
heard from Holocaust Survivors who VI
vividly recall learning of the Allies
Landing in France the news of the Allied
invasion brought them A Renewed sense of
hope amidst the horrors and threats that
they endured thank you for joining us as
we honor this important anniversary I'm
Dr Lindsay mcneel a historian at the
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
tonight we will discuss the significance
of this Invasion and the role it played
in The Liberation of millions of
innocent people persecuted by the Nazi
regime we're going to introduce you to a
D-Day veteran and a holoc C Survivor and
discuss how their lives were shaped by
this
history joining me tonight are two
special guests my colleague at the US
Holocaust Memorial Museum and a curator
of our special exhibition Americans in
the Holocaust historian Dr Becky Air
Belding hi Becky hi Lindsay Becky could
you tell us a little bit about the
museum for our viewers who might not be
familiar with our work absolutely so the
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
is located in Washington DC and it is
Museum dedicated to documenting studying
and ensuring the relevance of Holocaust
history we use the power of personal
stories and artifacts to educate people
around the world about the history of
the Holocaust and that is a history that
raises questions about choice about
human behavior and about our roles in
society
today thanks Becky I'd also like to
welcome the senior historian at
Arlington National cemitary Dr Allison
finklestein hi
Allison hi Lindsay thank you so much for
having me tonight I'm really honored to
be able to join the museum to
commemorate the 80th anniversary of the
D-Day invasion I work at Arlington
National Cemetery or ANC for short we
were founded in 1864 during the American
Civil War as a place to bury soldiers
who died in nearby Washington DC area
hospitals though forged in the horrors
of the Civil War over the past 160 years
ANC has evolved into a unique
multi-layered site of memory known
worldwide our Rolling Hills are now
filled with the graves of service
members and their families members from
every time period in American history
from the American Revolution through
today memorials and monuments honor many
aspects of our nation's military past
and the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier
stands is a sacred site of pilgrimage
honoring America's missing and
unidentified War dead this year we are
actually commemorating the 160th
anniversary of the cemetery's creation
and tonight's program is an important
part of that
commemoration and I I just have to add
that this program is really very
personally meaningful to me as well my
own grandfather Lewis finlin was wounded
on June 6th during the D-Day invasion
and I'm really grateful to have the
chance to speak a little bit about him
later
tonight thanks so much Allison tonight's
program is really special because that
brings together our two institutions and
their missions both of the men we will
honor tonight have a connection to
Holocaust history and both are laid to
rest at Arlington National
Cemetery before we get started just a
quick note to viewers we'd love to hear
where you're tuning in from feel free to
message Us in the chat and you can also
ask any questions related to the program
there as well we'll get to as many as we
can by the end of our
conversation okay Becky I want to start
with you before we get to D-Day and the
United States role in the 194 4 Invasion
we need to understand the context for
Americans at the time let's go back to
1933 before World War II when the Nazis
Rose to power in Germany what was life
like for
Americans well as the Nazis are coming
to power in Germany and 1933 Americans
are really grappling with a lot of their
own problems 1933 is the fourth year of
the Great Depression um an estimated 25%
of the American Workforce is unemployed
you can see a line here of people
waiting for food and there's seemingly
no end in sight so Americans are really
optimistic about the new Roosevelt
administration Franklin Roosevelt
becomes president in March 1933 only six
weeks after Hitler is appointed
Chancellor but things are really bad in
the United States um this is also a
society in which racism and
anti-Semitism is really common there are
a lot of colleges and Social Clubs that
forbid Jews from becoming members many
states are racially segregated either by
law or in other areas they're segregated
through redlining and through quieter
methods um even the US military at the
time is racially segregated and the US
is also very anti-immigrant at this time
in the 1920s Congress on a bipartisan
basis had passed new immigration laws
and these laws were based in these ideas
of racism and anti-Semitism and
Prejudice and they were meant to keep
the country white and Protestant for the
future by purging immigration from
countries which had large white
Protestant populations and providing
fewer immigration opportunities for
countries with large Catholic and Jewish
and non-white populations and so all of
these factors led the United States to
be really quite isolationist from the
rest of the world not wanting to get
involved the country is very very far
from becoming a superpower and is really
grappling with a lot of
things so it's a complicated time in
American history and what's going on in
German in the early 1930s and what did
Americans know about what was happening
there I mean obviously it's it's a
difficult time in Germany too but the
Nazi party is promising a lot of hope so
Germany had also been struggling with
its own crisis they lost the first world
war and then were in a severe economic
depression after that war and then they
got caught up in the global Great
Depression that began in the late
1920s after Germany's defeat in World
War I and the punitive Treaty of
Versailles the many Germans were looking
for someone to blame for their seeming
loss in stature and the Nazi party was
very quick to point its finger always at
Jews scapegoating them as the source of
many of the country's woes so after
Adolf Hitler the head of the Nazi party
was appointed Chancellor in January 1933
the Nazis quickly in the spring of 1933
began to enact anti-semitic measures
targeting German Jews including a
nationwide boycott of all Jewish owned
businesses throughout the country
this was followed in the spring of 1933
by a series of discriminatory laws that
attempted to drive Jews virtually out of
all aspects of life in Germany and the
Nazis hoped that all of these laws would
eventually Drive Jews out of the country
itself this was not a secret in the
United States you can see in this photo
that the
caption in the boycott photo is in
English there are newspaper articles
this is not something secret I think we
look back and we think that Americans
only learned about the Nazi hatred of
Jews at Liberation in 1945 and that is
not true these new laws and the boycott
and book burning are front page news in
the United States right next to news of
the new deal and about the end of
Prohibition in fact there are enough
American reporters on the ground in Nazi
Germany that often some of these events
like the boycott and like book burning
are actually reported in American
newspapers in advance of them actually
happening and As Americans are
protesting the Nazi treatment of Jews in
Germany you know they're reading these
articles and Americans are showing up at
rallies at marches they're sending
petitions to the US government to ask
them to do something to get the Nazis to
stop all of that is happening in the
spring of
1933 but like many protest movements
it's hard to sustain and by the summer
of 1933 those protests start to die
out five years later in November 1938
Nazi leaders unleash a nationwide wave
of violence against Jews that will
become known as
chrisal the news of chrisal KN like the
early laws made the front page of
newspapers throughout the United States
it was front page news for about three
weeks here and these attacks exacerbated
an ongoing Refugee crisis Jews who were
still in Germany which now included
parts of Czechoslovakia and Austria
which the Nazis had annexed are
desperately trying to flee and Americans
are looking at this crisis and they're
concerned about the violence they
consider it a terror attack against the
Jews of Germany but they're also saying
that we as Americans do not want any
more Jewish refugees those strict
immigration laws that I mentioned were
still in place they were not revised and
the US had no Refugee or Asylum policy
at all most Americans are still
isolationists they are unwilling to get
involved in any sort of international
Affairs and that is a bipartisan
position I think a lot of our viewers
are probably going to be quite surprised
to learn just how much Americans knew
about what was going on in Nazi Germany
and Now Alison I want to turn to you to
tell us a little bit more about a
specific person's experience as Becky
just told us christon was a turning
point for many German Jews could you
introduce us to someone who experienced
it firsthand tell us about Eddie
Wilner I am really honored to be able to
tell the story of Eddie Wilner his son
Al and his daughter nah are family
friends of mine and it's really
meaningful to share the story of what
Eddie went through during World War II
and also how he eventually built his
life here in the United States Eddie was
born with the name helmet Wilner in 1926
in Germany when the Nazis came to power
his father sigfreed initially believed
that his family would be safe like many
other Jews in Germany he had served
honorably in the first world war in the
German Army and he thought that his
service would help Safeguard his family
but Sig freed soon realized that despite
his service in the Great War Germany was
truly becoming unsafe for Jews Christal
knocked was the Tipping Point for Eddie
and his family as it was for so many
other Jews they knew at that point that
they needed to get out of Germany
through the help of a Jewish Refugee
organization Eddie's father sigfried was
able to send Eddie out of Germany to
Brussels Belgium where he hoped that
Eddie would be safer Eddie was placed
with the Jewish Family living in Belgium
there was a lot of anti-german sentiment
there at the time and even though Eddie
was a German Jewish Refugee escaping
Nazi persecution helmet is a very German
name so he was given the nickname Eddie
instead that nickname stuck and he went
by Eddie since the time that he was
about 12 years old and it's actually the
name that is inscribed on his headstone
at Arlington National
Cemetery months later Eddie's parents
also arrived in Belgium they had to
leave everything behind in Germany and
they lived in one small room in Brussels
it wasn't big enough for Eddie to live
with them so Eddie stayed with the host
family and he visited his parents on the
weekends despite these circumstances it
was still a meaningful reunion for the
family what they did not know at the
time was that their time together in
Belgium would be the last Almost
peaceful moments they would ever spend
together as a family
because of course what they couldn't
know is that in September
1939 nearly a year after Christal
knocked and after the wiers have made it
to Belgium World War II began when Nazi
Germany invaded Poland and initially
Eddie and his family are fine right
they're far away but we know that this
changes several months later in May 1940
when Nazi Germany invaded Belgium France
and other neighboring countries what
happens to the
wilers the story of the Wilner family is
quite incredible and rather complex at
times after the German invasion of
Belgium the Belgian government rounded
up and intered German men as enemy
aliens that even included Jewish
refugees like sigfried Eddie's father he
was sent to an internment camp in
southern France Eddie and his mother
went searching for his father all they
knew was that Sig freed was somewhere in
southern France but Eddie and his mother
were arrested crossing the border and
they were also imprisoned as enemy
aliens they were later released and they
continued to try to locate Eddie's
Father eventually they found him and the
family was briefly uni reunited in 1942
they heard rumors about Jews being sent
Away by the Nazis to unknown
destinations maybe concentration camps
the family found shelter with a priest
who housed Jewish refugees all of whom
were trying to avoid both the Nazis as
well as their French collaborators
France really was not a safe place for
Jews at that time eventually it was the
French police who discovered and
arrested Edy and his family they sent
them to dony a Transit Camp outside of
Paris thanks so much Alison I can only
imagine how terrifying it must have been
to have fled Nazi Germany and then to
find yourself once again back in danger
from the Nazis uh before we keep going
with the program I want to stop to
welcome viewers watching from around the
country and North America hell hello to
viewers in Martha's Vineyard
Massachusetts Minneapolis Minnesota
Miami Beach Florida Phoenix Arizona San
Francisco California and Toronto Canada
thanks so much for watching
tonight and I know Alison that will'll
come back to the rest of Ed's story a
little bit later but I want to add some
context here Nazi Germany was not only
Waging War across Europe it was also
intensifying its persecution of Jews
eventually this escalated to a policy of
mass murder beginning in the summer of
1941 the Nazis and their all I and
collaborators began systematically
killing Jewish men women and children in
mass shooting operations which you can
see a photograph of here later the Nazis
created killing centers specifically to
murder Jews using poison gas and was
really important to remember here is
that this is happening under the cover
of War we talked earlier about how much
news there was in the 1930s about what
was going on in Nazi Germany but once
the Nazis begin to commit mass murder
they're trying to cover up what they're
doing they don't want everyone to know
about their crimes and people including
Americans don't have a full picture of
what's
happening and for more than two years of
the war from September 1939 to December
1941 the US was officially neutral then
on December 7th 1941 the Japanese
attacked Pearl Harbor in response
America declared war on Japan and then
Japan's allies Germany and Italy
declared war on the United
States Becky what are the early stages
of America's involvement in World War II
look like well in the First full year of
the war so
1942 um the American Military and the
American people are mostly focused on
the Pacific front and on the fight
against Japan young men are being
drafted and sent to training camps and
women are volunteering for women's units
and going to work in factories to
produce for the Allied militaries
rationing begins and the home front is
completely changed by the war 1942 isra
spent building up Manpower and supplies
in advance of what they know will be a
really difficult ground and air fight
against Germany and against its access
Partners in Europe and in November 1942
those ground troops fa their first real
challenge in what was called the
European theater the US participates in
Operation Torch which was the Allied
invasion of North Africa this was
America's first major ground operation
against Nazi Germany and at this point
they are hundreds of miles away from the
Nazi killing centers where most people
were being murdered only a few weeks
after that invasion of North Africa
began so still in 1942 in November
Americans and the American public
learned for the first time that the
Nazis have a plan to kill all European
Jews so as you said while Mass killing
had been going on for more than a year
there weren't American journalists on
the ground reporting back um all of this
information firsthand and so there had
been Rumors in American newspapers of
mass shootings or of certain towns being
wiped out in in Eastern Europe but
Americans particularly before Pearl
Harbor when the US was still officially
neutral Americans had been really quick
to dismiss that as just a rumor as
anti-nazi propaganda as just a way to
pressure the American people and the
United States to get involved in the war
but by November 1942 and from then on
the idea that the Nazis are rounding up
and deporting European Jews and trying
to kill them all was something that was
treated as fact by American newspapers
so November 1942 for many reasons is a
real turning Point
here so in the first year of the US
entering the war the US has really
focused on getting the Manpower and
building the material it needs to fight
um I'd like to hear more about one
American soldier in particular Alison
could you tell us about James Milner
Roberts Jr how did he find himself
joining the
Army James Milner Roberts Jr was born in
Pittsburgh after World War I and he went
by his middle name Milner so that's how
I'm going to refer to him throughout our
program his father had served in the US
Army during World War I which inspired
Milner to follow in his footsteps Milner
commissioned as a second lieutenant in
the US Army Reserve in May of 1940 and
remember that was even before the United
States had entered World War II but a
week after the Pearl Harbor attack he
received orders that he would be serving
as a weapons instructor by June of 1943
he applied to the Airborne and was
accepted for service after training he
was deployed Ed to England just 3 months
before the D-Day invasion Milner was air
marched to be part of the 101st airborn
division when he arrived he helped with
preparations for the upcoming Invasion
at the time the invasion was known by
the codame Operation Overlord it would
be key to the Allies strategy to win the
war and attempt to reach Berlin military
leaders felt strongly that another front
in Europe was a necessity for combating
Germany after the Nazi invasion of
France so da of course is quite well
known right it's the largest amphibious
invasion in US military history it was
key to the Western allies victory over
Nazi Germany and many of us have seen
powerful depictions of the battle from
Saving Private Ryan to Band of Brothers
but Miler was there what exactly did he
experience leading up to D-Day Milner
was slated to fly a glider plane during
the oper ation glider planes were a
truly terrifying and nerve-wracking
piece of equipment they were essentially
an engineless airplane made out of wood
and fabric that were meant to transport
troops and Equipment they really weren't
so different from little wooden toy
airplanes Milner actually recalled how
he was not looking forward to flying
over the English Channel in a glider but
just 5 days before The Invasion he was
reassigned to be the Tactical Aid to the
commander of the the Omaha Beach Landing
General Leonard jro who is also buried
at Arlington National Cemetery jerro
needed Milner's ability to read photo
Maps which he had gained through his
glider training now for those who don't
know during the Allied invasion of
Normandy the five beaches that the
Allies landed on were each given code
names Omaha gold Juno sword and Utah
each of the Allied invasion forces
landed on different beaches the United
States landed on Omaha Beach and Utah
Beach Milner talked about his experience
on D-Day in an interview recorded with
the Holocaust Museum in 1992 let's take
a listen I landed on
dday uh with elements of the 16th
infantry of the first division right in
the middle of Omaha Beach it was called
the easy red
section well in a way it was a Miss
nowhere from the point of being easy but
from the point of view of being red it
had something along that
line the easy red sector was part of the
main Battleground area on Omaha Beach
and it was where the Germans focused
most of their efforts and resources
Omaha was the most heavily defended of
the five beaches the Allies landed on
Milner's recollection of how the water
seemed to turn red during The Invasion
it's emblematic of the heavy casualty
sustained that day if anybody has ever
had the opportunity to visit the
Normandy American cemetery in France it
is located on the high Bluffs
overlooking Omaha Beach looking out from
the cemetery it is clear how difficult
the fighting must have been that day but
despite the obstacles they faced the US
and its allies were able to push the
German forces back and claim the beaches
but by the end of the day Allied troops
suffered more than 10 ,000 casualties
with
4,400 confirmed dead more than 2500 of
those deaths were Americans many
unidentified Omaha Beach saw the highest
number of casualties but Milner was one
of the lucky ones who survived and in
the days after the landing he and his
fellow soldiers were stuck in what he
described as a stalemate in an area of
hedr these were thick shrubs that served
as a natural barrier that the Germans
used to their ADV vage to try to shut
out the Allied Forces every day Milner
and a group of soldiers would go out on
a patrol of the hedg r areas and report
back on what they saw so they could
strategize about how to break the German
line Allied troops were not trained in
hedro combat so these patrols were
particularly dangerous and deadly yet
they were eventually successful in
breaking through in July of
1944 um I'd like to remind our viewers
please send your questions for Becky and
Allison and on that note Allison I have
a bit of a more personal question for
you right now you mentioned at the top
of the show that your grandfather served
on D-Day could you tell us a little bit
about what he
experienced yes thank you Lindsay so
much for bringing that up my grandfather
Lewis finlin was also on Omaha Beach on
June 6th 1944 and there's a picture of
him outside of a quanset Hut in Scotland
doing his pre-invasion training I was
really close to my grandpa and I had the
opportunity to record an oral history of
his service which is now at the Library
of Congress veterans history project my
dad also did an oral history of him in
the 1990s which was donated to what is
now called the national World War II
Museum in New Orleans and it was
actually used by Stephen Ambrose in his
book about
D-Day in these oral histories my dad and
I learned harrowing details about my
grandpa's D-Day experience
he served in the Navy as a seaman Gunner
on an
lcvp that stands for landing craft
vehicle Personnel these were also known
as Higgins boats they were the small
landing craft that transported troll
soldiers onto the beaches the fronts of
them opened up to create a ramp for
departure onto the beach or into the
waves my grandpa was one of the sailors
Manning an lcvp as it transported
soldiers to the shore or as close as
they could get he was assigned to Omaha
Beach actually most likely the easy red
sector like Milnor although it's hard to
be certain where he actually landed
because of how much the landing craft
may have drifted that day my grandpa Lou
recalled that he was taking in elements
of the 29th Infantry Division they
encountered heavy fire as they neared
the beaches as well as obstacles in the
water itself they did successfully make
one Landing dropping off the soldiers
before turning around to attempt a
second Landing but on the way back they
hit a mine as far as my grandpa knew and
he was wounded he passed out he was
picked up by a hospital ship and he was
taken to a hospital in Southampton
England to recover and after he
recovered he returned to duty he served
for the remainder of the war even
helping to capture a ship in bremerhaven
Germany as well as staying on for
occupation Duty my grandpa lived with
the phys iCal effects of that wound for
the rest of his life he endured frequent
pain in his leg he would tell us as
children he could feel the piece of
shrapnel going up and down his leg the
war and especially the invasion had
haunted him he did not talk about it a
lot with my grandma and he really only
started to open up more about it to my
dad in the 1990s and later to me after I
graduated from college and here's a
picture of my grandpa and grandma with
my sister and I at William and Mary
toward the end of his life my grandpa
joined a support group at his local VA
where he started to process some of the
PTSD he had dealt with his entire life
some pretty upsetting stories came out
about what he saw that day about the
fellow sailor he lost when they were hit
how he was trying to grab his hand to
bring him back onto the boat and lived
with that for the rest of his life
but like so many other World War II
veterans he had struggled for a long
long time in silence
and despite being proud of his service
my grandpa was also humble but what he
always talked about was how he was proud
to serve as a Jewish American sailor
that he was out there he understood what
this war was about he was fighting for
his Nation he was fighting for his
people and he was not afraid to tell
that to the German PS that he
encountered when he finally did get back
into the
war Alison I think I speak for many of
our viewers when I say how
extraordinarily special it is to hear
you share not only your extensive
knowledge of dday but also your personal
connection and your grandfather's story
thank you I'd like to also share a
comment from a viewer named Larry Larry
writes my tremendous gratitude to all
those who served in World War II and
sacrificed their lives for the benefit
of others if not for these Brave and
passionate soldiers I would not be here
today and of course we know that for
many of these soldiers D-Day was kind of
a beginning point right not the end they
still had to fight their way into the
German front line and across Europe and
dday also did not immediately end the
suffering of Jews and other victims of
the Nazis by June 6th 1944 the Nazis and
their allies and collaborators had
already murdered more than 5 million
European Jews and Nazi authorities would
continue to murder Jews until the final
days of World War II but the Allied
invasion of France and the subsequent
victories likely saved hundreds of
thousands of Jews in Western and Central
Europe from being murdered in the
Holocaust I think that really ties back
to what you said about your grandfather
that he was proud to tell these PS right
that he was Jewish that he knew what he
was fighting for and
against Becky can you zoom out for a
minute and give us a sense of the
landscape of the war after D-Day of
course so as you said the Allied troops
still have a really long way to go in
terms of geography and fighting before
Jews and other victims of the Nazis are
liberated and there are really a few key
points and events to note here in the
European theater there are multiple
fronts being fought right there's the
front that opens up thanks to D-Day
which is thousands of miles from the
Nazi killing centers by June 1944 the
Allied Forces had pushed the Germans and
Italians out of North Africa and they
had invaded it first Italy in September
1943 or for I'm sorry first Sicily in
September 1943 and then they moved on to
the mainland of Italy and in fact Allied
troops took Rome liberated Rome the day
before D-Day which was an important
Victory and something that Americans
were celebrating when they started to
get news that the D-Day invasion had
begun and you also have the Eastern
front where you have the Soviet Red Army
slowly beating the Germans back West
towards Germany many of the killing
centers and concentration camps are Nazi
OCC Ed Poland and Germany and so Soviet
troops are closer to reaching them at
this point than the American and British
troops are and these fronts are all
trying to defeat the Nazi forces they're
all trying to liberate territory and
they're all trying to make it to
Germany's capital of Berlin and as the
fronts push that German line back the
Nazis are still actively persecuting and
killing Jews and other groups so as the
Nazis are being pushed back into Germany
they are likewise moving their prisoners
Jewish and other forc laborers back from
from the front lines of the war and
further Inland towards the center of
Germany to continue their brutality
against them and eek out the last bits
of Labor from these poor people in the
hopes of turning the tide of the
war thanks Becky it's so important that
even as we commemorate D-Day we keep the
bigger picture of the war and the
Holocaust in mind can you now take us
through the next year of the war for
Milner and other Americans who survived
D-Day well in August 1944 so we're now a
little more than two months after the
invasion at Normandy the Allies liberate
Paris and James Milner Roberts is there
he's part of that effort and he
Witnesses all of the joy and the
celebrations in the city and I think he
probably and many Americans thought at
that point that the war would be over by
the end of the year and that German
defeat was imminent from then on but
there is a Las ditch effort by Germany
and German forces in the middle of
December 1944 that becomes known as the
battle of the B
this was a counter offensive located in
the dense Arden Forest between Belgium
and Luxembourg and you can see in this
picture how snowy and cold it was the
Germans were trying to create a bulge
they were trying to push through the
Allies front lines and divide the Army
in two as a way of pushing the Allies
backwards towards the coast they were
desperately trying to secure some kind
of Victory any kind of Victory against
all of the losses that Germany had been
mounting it takes more than a month of
heavy fighting in the brutal cold but
finally the German troops failed and It
ultimately became a really decisive
Allied Victory it was a massive battle
there were more than 600,000 American
troops involved including James Milner
Roberts this Victory is really crucial
in the western allies Advance towards
Germany in the spring of
1945 so Becky we also know that 10
months after landing in Normandy and
almost three months after their
important victory in the Battle of the
Bulge US service members liberated the
binal concentration camp in April
1945 we also know that American troops
were deeply Disturbed and in disbelief
in what they witnessed and among those
Witnesses was Milner what was his exact
experience well as you said Lindsay this
was absolutely unbelievable to most of
the American troops when they witnessed
B inval in the other camps that they
liberated it was unbelievable and it was
really upsetting and in fact it was so
unbelievable that many soldiers took it
upon themselves to try to document these
crimes they took photos they wrote
letters home describing in great detail
what they saw and general Eisenhower as
our viewers may know encouraged this he
feared that Nazi atrocities might
otherwise be someday chocked up to
propaganda and so we know that these
young soldiers um directed by Eisenhower
created important evidence of the
horrors of the Nazi regime evidence that
you and I use in our work all the time
when American troops liberated buen bald
Milner was miles away but he heard about
it and he heard rumors of the camp and
he decided he had to go see it for
himself so two days after Liberation he
went on his own accord because he too
wanted to document what was happening
decades later he still remembered it he
remembered seeing piles of bodies as he
wandered around the grounds he saw the
crematoria and he realized there must
have been thousands of bodies that were
burned there and he was struck by the
sheer number of corpses in comparison to
the number of survivors which he
described as living
skeletons a few days later when he was
back with his unit they actually
participated in a Liberation um he
liberated a camp himself a subcamp of
buen bald called leig techla and what he
saw there also affected him for the rest
of his life this was a particularly
horrific Liberation because the Nazis
had had realized that the American
troops were closing in and so they
separated the prisoners into two groups
one group they sent on a forced March
and the other they gathered into a
barracks and they burned the barracks
they burned the prisoners alive and
those who tried to escape were killed
Milner and his unit arrived just too
late he said that he could still see the
building smoldering when they got there
decades later he said he could not
understand what had happened that day
and we have him talking about that in
the oral history the Museum recorded
let's listen I couldn't believe what I
was looking at
uh I should have by that time but it's
still hard to believe that Humanity will
do something like
this particularly people who are
disadvantaged you put in and burn them
alive for what reason it was obvious the
war was virtually
over uh these people weren't going to do
any damage to anybody
it has to take a a a very Twisted mind
to uh authorize and carry out something
like
this that is really one of the more
horrific accounts of Liberation that
I've heard and it it just reminds you
that the Nazis were dedicated to
continuing this reign of brutality even
when it was clear that they had lost the
war and that when we're thinking about
this from the perspective of Allied
troops every second counts in terms of
saving people's lives as they're moving
through Europe I also always reflect
when I when I hear liberators give their
testimony with how young they were at
the time I mean they were 18 19 20 21
years old witnessing this and then
grappling with it for the rest of their
lives inevitably with the traumatic
stress disorder that Allison mentioned
earlier um Milner and his fellow
liberators really felt strongly that
that this needed to be documented
um and they were angry about what they
saw they decided that other people
needed to witness the horror and so they
brought local towns people Germans over
to look at the evidence of what they had
found at leig tea and Milner said that
some of them fainted when they saw the
scene but these were German people who
lived right near the camp and claimed to
the American soldiers that they had no
idea what was happening there and Milner
of course did not believe them he and
the other soldiers buried the bodies um
all the bodies that they could find in a
cemetery in leig and they held a service
for um out of respect for the victims
and Milner says that he when he was
organizing the service it wasn't part of
their official military duty but he and
his fellow soldiers felt a real moral
responsibility to do
this Alison I want to come back to Eddie
Wilner who we talked about earlier in
our
conversation we've heard about the shock
that so many these troops like Milner
exper experienced when they discovered
the camps Eddie personally survived
these Horrors what was he going through
during the
war we last left Eddie in
1942 when he and his family were
imprisoned in the johy transit Camp
outside Paris but they did not remain
there for long in September 1942 German
authorities deported them on freight
cars to awsb now a killing Center these
Freight cars were packed with people
there was no food little water just a
bucket to relieve oneself along the way
the train stopped in a town and the
German guards ordered those men capable
of working to disembark the train now
was the point when sigf freed and Eddie
had to make a quick and consequential
decision they chose to disembark and
Eddie never saw his mother again it's
very likely that she was gassed upon
arrival at owitz but her ultimate fate
is still not known
like so many other victims of the
Holocaust the details of her final
moments and her fate are lost leaving
little trace of her death in the
historical
record Edd and his father were sent to
forced labor camps nearby where they did
hard labor building Rail lines digging
up unexploded bombs and constructing
underground bunkers they were given
little food and clothing many prisoners
died of exhaustion starvation and
disease in these inhumane conditions
in the fall of 199
1944 Eddie's Father grew very weak Eddie
returned from work one day and saw his
father through the barbed wire he prayed
that his father wasn't being sent to the
gas chamber at awsb now but after that
day he never saw his father again
another life Lost Without a Trace
through this painful moment though Eddie
had a friend with him at one of the
camps he had Beed befriended Mike swab
another boy his Agee who was Dutch years
later Eddie reflected on how important
that friendship was for their Mutual
Survival Let's listen to Eddie in his
own words we made a pack that we're
going to stick it out together we talked
about it and they said we just have to
help each other the best way we can if
you find some food you share with me I
find some extra food I share with you
and has to be complete honesty and we're
going to get out never to leave that
idea behind that we're not going to make
it we are going to make it and uh there
was a single biggest thing in my life
and I'm sure his life that uh that made
me survive plus a lot of luck plus a lot
of faith plus a lot of other things but
I think that I think the idea that uh
we're going to make it by escaping or
some other way uh made us stay
alive this friendship between Mike and
Eddie it saved both of their lives
they're packed it helped them survive it
gave them something and someone to live
for they stayed friends for the rest of
their lives and Al Wilner Eddie's son
grew up calling Mike his Uncle
Mike it's a sentiment we really hear a
lot from Holocaust survivors in this
shows up in a lot of testimony that they
credit luck they credit circumstance but
they really credit friendship and and
relationships you hear it from service
members too who are going through all of
these horrific things the importance of
their comrades of of people who can pull
them through um it's a really powerful
piece of
testimony really is so in January of
1945 the Soviet Army was approaching
aitz and the Germans decide to evacuate
the camp Eddie and Mike are sent on a
Death March and then on to several more
camps by April 1945 an exhausted Eddie
and Mike are sent on another death March
but this time something rather
remarkable happens Allison would you
tell us about
it yes well on this Death March Eddie
and Mike overheard from the SS forces
that the Americans were nearby Eddie
Mike and four other men decided to try
to escape in a group after three nights
of marching there was an airplane
overhead which they used as a
distraction to escape the six mon men
decided to run in different directions
Eddie and Mike of course escapes
together
and they were unsure of the fate of the
other four men Eddie and Mike's
appearance it made it obvious that they
had escaped from some type of Camp they
were tattooed their heads were shaved
and they were covered with lights and
after several days on the Run they saw
tanks and heard the German language
being spoken they put their hands up and
discovered not a Nazi but a German
American Soldier and interpreter they
had encountered an American Tank Company
D company 30 second Regiment of the
third Armored Division this was a moment
that changed the course of Eddie's life
the leader of the company Lieutenant
Elmer havland decided to take Eddie and
Mike in he helped them get cleaned up
gave them uniforms and fed them when D
company found Eddie and Mike they were
about 18 years old and they each only
weighed around 75 PBS the tankers helped
them regain their health and they gained
about 50 pounds in 3 months the war
ended a few weeks later and Eddie and
Mike ended up spending six months with
The Tank Company you can see them here
these American soldiers had taken in
these former prisoners informally
adopted them really they gave the boys
the opportunity to survive and they
formed relationships with them that
lasted the rest of their lives it is
this remarkable connection between
people you wouldn't necessarily think
would have this type of bond in the
midst of this horrific War these
American soldiers they went above and
beyond the Call of Duty to show kindness
and empathy to two young boys who had
suffered unspeakable
tragedies and of course while Eddie and
Mike survived most victims of the
Holocaust did not Mike was not able to
find any family after the war Eddie lost
both of his parents during the Holocaust
and at age 18 he had to try to rebuild
his life he imig ated to the United
States in December of
1947 and Eddie was so inspired by the
group of men who took him in from D
company that he volunteered for military
service and served in the Army for 20
years I mentioned earlier that Eddie's
son Al Wilner is a family friend of mine
we had the opportunity to speak with Al
about his father's experiences for this
webinar which Al actually worked on with
us let's hear from Al now the fact that
uh um these
officers um and uh you know men took
them under the wing to bring them back
to health I think had a tremendous
impact I'm not sure he would have come
to the United States had he not linked
up with company D he was really grateful
for the opportunity to have U served I
think grateful for the opportunity to
become a citizen of his adopted country
just the fact that he was able to kind
of start a new life you know with my
mother and then I have five brothers and
sisters I think that obviously he was
eternally grateful to the country for
giving him that opportunity and the and
the people that made it
happen inspiring story it really is and
it's so nice to get to hear him talk
about his father and his service in the
military and I'm sure Alison even more
for you since you know him personally oh
it absolutely is Al has done a lot of
research on his family history as has
his sister nah who's a writer and a few
years ago Al actually did a pilgrimage
entirely on foot during which he
retraced his father's Death March and
other aspects of his Survival Story
right now he is back in Europe with his
children his nieces and his nephews he
is taking them to these sites on a
pilgrimage to places that are so
important to their family's very
existence and survival and that's why Al
couldn't join us tonight but the impact
of those tankers Lifeline to Eddie and
Mike it created several new generations
of Americans in the Wilner family who
has served the United States in the
military the government and other
capacities and it's just incredible how
Eddie's experiences continue to live on
through his children and his
grandchildren what a
legacy absolutely and it's it's not just
this history that unites Eddie and
Milner uh we know that both J Milner
Roberts and Eddie Winer are buried at
Arlington National Cemetery Alon what
does it mean to honor these veterans in
one of our country's most sacred
grounds it means so much many people
they think of ANC as primarily a burial
ground for those killed in action or for
the graves of President John F Kennedy
famous generals Admirals and Medal of
Honor recipients and while important
these graves are just one aspect of
Arlington's history Arlington is also
the final resting place for thousands of
lesser known American Service members
and their families all of whom have
fascinating stories waiting to be told
at Arlington our history team likes to
say that we can tell the entire history
of our nation within our boundary walls
we have many stories that people may not
expect to find here we have the graves
of at least 11 Holocaust Survivors both
those who served in the military and
those who did not we have the graves of
dozens of service members and civilians
who liberated or were involved in the
liberation of the concentration camps
people who witnessed the evidence of the
Holocaust firsthand we also have the
graves of formerly enslaved Americans of
freed people who tried to build a new
life during and just after the Civil War
of leaders in the women's suffrage
movement the civil rights movement and
the efforts for American Indians to gain
citizenship rights I could go on and on
at Arlington we can truly touch upon
stories that are relevant to every
American no better their background or
their interests and today's program is
really evidence of that we have this
opportunity to collaborate with folks
like you guys at the Holocaust Museum to
share these stories and tell everybody
that they are all welcome at Arlington
National Cemetery and this is
particularly important for educators we
have an education program and in our
World War II module we have an entire
lesson plan about Eddie Wilner so the
opportunity to amplify his story share
those materials and collaborate with you
all at the Holocaust Museum during the
80th anniversary of dday and the 160th
anniversary of the cemetery it's such a
privilege and we're just so grateful
thank
you I have been so fascinated to learn
more about Arlington National Cemetery
from you and about these connections
between Holocaust history and the
cemetery it's been really wonderful
getting to learn more about it um Becky
the museum has preserved stories eddes
milers along with those of many other
survivors and victims and liberators how
does the museum serve as a place to
remember those who may not have their
own resting place it's as you said it's
been really meaningful for the museum to
work with Arlington National Cemetery as
well and as Allison showed Eddie Wilner
and J Milner Roberts have gravestones
they have a place in Arlington where you
can visit and you can lay flowers and
you can honor their memory but if you
listen to the story you know that people
like Eddie and Mike's parents they don't
have a resting place Eddie and Mike
never learned what happened to their
families and so the museum collects
these stories and artifacts and
testimonies and works to memorialize the
experiences of millions of people many
of whom do not have a gravestone that is
one of the missions of the museum to try
to act as that place of a memorial of
memory and as a way to collect and learn
so that we can continue to honor the
victims and survivors of the Holocaust
and to help our visitors learn more
about how and why something like the
Holocaust Could
Happen thank you both I think it's time
for us to turn to some questions from
our audience and Becky this first one I
think is for you Chantel asked about the
force marches or the death marches that
we talked about earlier uh they'd like
to know what ends up being the fate of
the prisoners who are LED on these
different death marches in general so we
heard about Eddie and Mike but what
generally happens yeah I mean it really
depends a lot on when we're talking
about and where we're talking about so
some of the forced marches for example
from aitz in January 1945 when the aitz
killing Center is evacuated those
prisoners are being sent to Germany and
often to other camps or work sites where
they are subjected to even more forc
labor but in the spring of 1945 in April
many people are just sent walking you
know the Germans don't want them to be
liberated and so they just set out um
sometimes by train and sometimes by foot
um some are killed in this with the
story that you heard about leig techla
um but many are liberated by American
troops or by Red Cross Personnel on the
roads um in columns often very weak and
not in any place where they've had food
or rest for a very long
time and uh I have another question for
you which is did any Holocaust Survivors
serve on D-Day yes they did um the
museum defines Holocaust Survivors as
people who were persecuted by Nazi
Germany and its allies and collaborators
which includes people who were in
Germany in the 1930s but did manage to
find a permanent Safe Haven who were
able to immigrate to the United States
before the outbreak of war and some of
these soldiers many of them young men um
many of these uh new immigrants were
able to become soldiers they joined the
American Military some of them took
advantage of their fluency in the German
language and knowledge of German culture
to become interrogators or to become
intelligence personnel and so some of
them landed on D-Day or dropped as
paratroopers um mainly to help the
Allied Forces to help the forces of
their new country um and to liberate
their homelands and and for some of them
they were trying to find their own
families
thanks Becky Alison a question for you
what do you think the greatest
misconception is when it comes to the
intertwining of the history of World War
II and the
Holocaust I think the misconception is
that they are not intertwined to often
especially here in the United States we
sometimes get caught up in the drama of
World War II this was a war that was
documented so well through photos
through Motion Pictures we seen footage
of the actual service members we have
watched the films that we talked about
earlier Band of Brothers the miniseries
um Saving Private Ryan even more
recently I found myself getting caught
up in the new series um masters of the
air it's easy to be swept away in this
epic story about good versus evil about
the so-called greatest Generation but we
have to remember that when we're talking
about D-Day or the battle of the bolds
or the invasion of Sicily it's not just
about troop movements and airplanes it's
not just Sherman tanks it is about what
this war was being fought over
particularly in the European theater of
operations this was a war against a
regime that was anti-semitic and racist
and we cannot treat the Holocaust and
World War II those combat operations and
support activities as separate if we're
going to talk about World War II we need
to talk about the
Holocaust absolutely and Alison I want
to share a comment we got from Mark he
writes my uncle John jop landed at
Normandy plus three fought in Battle of
the Bulge liberated dcau and won the
bronze star for bravery in World War II
Korea and Vietnam he is buried at
Arlington National
Cemetery thanks so much for sharing that
with us mark thank you for sharing that
and if you have any information about
him you can go on our website um contact
uh us and share anything you may have
about his story thank you and you know
in our comments during the show we have
seen so many of you sharing your ties to
D-Day and Liberation and the Holocaust
and one really stood out to us uh a
woman Debbie shared that her father was
with the 104th infantry which liberated
Dora mbal a concentration camp also
called Nord Howen and another commenter
also named Debbie shared that he was
part of the unit that that liberated her
father the Timberwolves the 104th thank
you so much I think we're really excited
after this program to go into the
comments and read all of the things
you're sharing please keep sharing these
stories yeah and that's a really amazing
connection to see in the comments right
that one of your uh relatives was a
liberator and the other liberated that's
really amazing to
hear Larry also writes as tears fall
down my face my dad Al with Survivor
every day blessed America for the
opportunity and the opportunity
opportunity they provided him and those
he brought here after the
war feel like you can hear and that's
some of the echos of the ways that Eddie
and Al talk about uh their experiences
as
well uh thank you so much Becky and
Allison for joining us tonight it's been
a real pleasure talking with you to our
audience it's been wonderful to see
these comments coming in um as we
mentioned earlier you can visit
Arlington National Cemetery and pay your
respects to these men as well as many
other service members from World War II
and numerous other Holocaust Survivors
for those outside the DC area Arlington
hosts many virtual educational programs
like this one where you can learn more
about the stories of individuals laid to
rest there we will share links in the
chat where you can learn more to learn
more about the history of the Holocaust
from an American perspective we invite
you to visit our special exhibition of
Americans in the Holocaust it's on
display right now at the Museum in DC
we'll also share a link in the live chat
where you can view the online
exhibition I'd like to take to take a
moment and thank Eddie wilner's son Al
Al is also a veteran and was inspired by
his father to
serve I'd like to end tonight's program
with some words from
Al as this program is being conducted on
the eve of the 80th anniversary of D-Day
um really our profound gratitude to
soldiers uh who served and their
families uh and the sacrifices that were
made uh really uh
those that service and that sacrifice is
reason I'm here to give this talk today
thank you