文藝復興時期建築是如何形成的?

宮廷建築探密
16粉絲
11 次觀看·2024年6月5日
在這次研討會的最後一段
我們結束在1453年在廣州遭遇崩塌
這是西方經濟學歷史的關鍵時刻
在接下來的意大利文化時代討論中
我們將看到
Etruvius的十本建築書的重新探討
啟發了新的作品和禮儀
並且解釋了羅馬作家所描繪的
伽羅姆納類型的理論
我們先看看15世紀建築師Alberti的作品和書籍
在中古時代
De Re Arquitectura
加入了許多其他
希臘和拉丁文字的書籍
並且偶爾被僧侶
為建築師園子的補償
Etruvius在瑞士的聖羔廟園的圖書館中
重新探討了
1416年 意大利學家Poggio Bracciolini的建築
並且開始被早期聖經詩人
Petrarch和Boccaccio
所描繪的
Etruvius的重新探討
引起了意大利建築師的關注
他們熱心探討
古老的建築物
隱藏在廢墟中
其中一位建築師是
佛羅倫丁·雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特
他獲得了
十本《建築物》
在1450年
他在1485年
以文字的方式
模擬了Etruvius的書籍
並且順利地出版了
這本建築物
是古老時期首件
作為一位佛羅倫丁
雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特
可能分享了
許多他的鄉村人
認為他的城市的
偉大的古老建築物
隱藏著
經典的特徵
是古老的
因此雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特的作品
似乎更像是一個嘗試
融合Etruvius的書籍
與古老建築物的
平面建築
如San Mignato al Monte
和著名的Octagonal Baptistry
顯示在左下角和中間
在15世紀
這些建築物
雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特
以古老建築物
為主題的作品
雖然他被慶祝成為
基督教建築師
但雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特的
深奧的古老思想
仍然在他的書中
他是一位學者
擁有極大的學習範圍
和無止盡的好奇心
他的個人象徵
是一隻翅膀
中文中的英文詞語
Quid tum
意思是
下一步要做什麼
雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特
雜誌是以
素心的方式使用
他將餘祥極地對
提案於餘祥的
一些例子
包括最細微的細節
在餘祥的介紹中
雜誌的類型
雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特的
興致寫作
顯然不是太多
的追求重組
他的羅馬前輩
而是要解釋
他覺得很混亂的
雖然雷恩·巴蒂斯特·艾伯特
不質問
餘祥的
FIRMITAS UTILITAS VENUSITAS
he chooses to lump the first two into a category he calls structure
and places beauty under the heading lineaments or ornament
As we can see in his treatise's table of contents
Alberti divides the contents in two halves
the first generally dealing with structure or function
and the second with lineaments or ornament
As Onayans has suggested, this subdivision of architecture
into two distinctive aspects
would lead over the next few centuries
to the separation of form and function
upsetting the Vitruvian balance
Before Alberti, explains Onayans
quote, there was no hint of the separation
between structure and ornament
For Vitruvius and other writers
a building had been an integrated whole
from the finest carving on its surface
to the unformed rubble of its core, end quote
Nevertheless, beauty still has a central role
in Alberti's treatise
as it did in Neoplatonic theory
which had been resuscitated by Renaissance humanists
The rootedness of his thinking in Greek aesthetics
is obvious in the following passage
from the De Re Edificatoria
Beauty is that reasoned harmony
of all the parts within a body
so that nothing may be added, taken away
or altered, but for the worse
This excerpt closely echoes definitions
offered by Plato, Xenophon, Plotinus
and other Greek scholars
Like Plato, Alberti even goes so far
as to warn against relativism
which sees beauty as dependent
on individual taste and perspective
Yet some, he says, would disagree
who maintain that beauty
and indeed every aspect of building
is judged by relative and variable criteria
and that the forms of buildings
should vary according to individual taste
and must not be bound by any rules of art
A common fault, this among the ignorant
Let me simply repeat what has been said
that the arts were born of chance and observation
fostered by use and experiment
and matured by knowledge and reason
The images in this slide show
three projects executed by Alberti
for his most important Florentine client
Giovanni Ruccellai
who is a well-known patron of the arts
In this 16th-century portrait of Ruccellai
by Francesco Salviati
those same commissioned works
are shown in the background
They are the façade of Santa Maria Novella
the Ruccellai Sepulchre
and the Loggia of the Palazzo Ruccellai
One of Alberti's first works for Ruccellai
was the façade of the unfinished
medieval church of Santa Maria Novella
in Florence
In his magnificent design
Alberti employs a square-based
proportioning system
which he derived from Vitruvius' treatise
The planar treatment of the façade
and the use of green and white marble
deliberately emulates Florentine medieval buildings
which Alberti was familiar with
and as noted earlier
may erroneously have been considered
as surviving late Roman edifice
Alberti's grounding in a medieval mural
understanding of architecture
is especially apparent in his design
for the Palazzo Ruccellai in Florence
which was the seat of the Ruccellai family
Here, pilasters and other details
appear almost to be inscribed
in the exterior wall
However, one can also appreciate
his familiarity with the Vitruvian text
and Roman influences like the stacked orders
which imitate ancient multi-story buildings
like the Colosseum and Theatre of Marcellus
Alberti's special interest in harmonic proportions
as described by Vitruvius
is clear in his elegant Ruccellai sepulchre
in the church of San Pancrazio in Florence
Here, he applies square and 2 to 3 ratios
in a design that reinterprets
the church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem
References to Florentine medieval architecture
are also clear
especially in the use of two types of marble
The fine proportions and delicacy
of the classical elements
reveal Alberti's intimate familiarity
with the Vitruvian text
and his belief that beauty in architecture
depends on the coordination or concordance
which he called concinitas
of number, outline and position
An important and now often overlooked
contribution to the conception of architecture
by Alberti
is the understanding of the individual building
as an integral and essential part of the city
which is conceived as a healthy
and nurturing polity
He thinks of the city as a sort of residence
in which streets are analogous to corridors
and public spaces and squares
analogous to living rooms
As he says in Book I
If, as the philosophers maintain,
the city is like some large house
and the house is in turn like some small city
cannot the various parts of the house
be considered miniature buildings?
END QUOTE
For Alberti, architecture
was essentially a political activity
His appreciation of the city
as the ultimate and desirablehabitat of humanity
would strongly influence
the new urban movement
of the late 20th century
which we will examine later in the course
The image on the right
shows the urban connection
between the Florentine baptistry
and the Duomo
and the room-like Piazza Annunziata
which was designed by Brunelleschi
Writing in Latin for an educated audience
and without illustrating his books
Alberti made an initial tentative attempt
to organize the columnar types
described by Vitruvius
from stockiest to most slender
However, he did not produce
a coherent system
The drawings on the screen
are all from later editions
of the De Re Edificatoria
In his treatise, Alberti made
a number of useful contributions
regarding the columnar types
and other elements
of the classical architectural repertoire
that took the study of architecture
beyond the Vitruvian treatise
We note, for instance,
his description of engaged columns
and pilasters
some having straight
and others articulated in tablatures
These illustrations
are from a posthumous edition
of the De Re Edificatoria
We will now examine
the writings of the four
principal Italian treatise authors
who followed Alberti
in the late 15th and 16th centuries
These authors were
Serlio, Vignola, Palladio, and Scamozzi
A native of the northern Italian city
of Bologna, the architect
Sebastiano Serlio
began to publish his five books
of architecture in 1540
almost a century after
Alberti wrote his treatise
The motivation was to provide
architects with more precise
descriptions of the orders
and the elements
of the classical vocabulary
than what Alberti had done
and to correct what he thought
were his predecessor's
mistakes of judgment
His treatise was the first
thoroughly illustrated one
and it was written
in modern Italian language
rather than in Latin
making it accessible to everyone
not just those
with a knowledge of Latin
It proved to be a huge success
across Europe
and its colonies in the New World
Serlio was the first
Renaissance author
to properly organize
and proportion the columnar types
from stocky to slender
beginning with the Tuscan
and continuing with the Doric
Ionic, Corinthian and Composite
In this drawing by Serlio
called a parallel
of the columnar types
he compares the different heights
associated with each type
when their diameters
are kept the same
In Serlio's way of thinking
the columnar types
were like a cast
of dramatic characters
One of Serlio's
most important contributions
was his comparison of architecture
with a dramatic play
To illustrate this point
he includes a drawing
in his treatise
of a tragic
by which he means
proper or decorous staged set
consisting of buildings
that are conceived
in the manner of the ancients
with columns and tablatures
pediments, etc.
Here we have placed
these five canonical column types
on stage
like actors in a fictive play
This image illustrates the concept
wherein different body types
and genders
roughly approximate
Serlio's parallel of types
Thus, from left to right
we have the Tuscan Farmer
the Doric Gentleman
the Ionic Maiden
the Corinthian Matron
and the Composite Vestal
What Serlio is saying
is that as in drama
there is a fictive aspect
to architecture as well
His lineup of columnar types
are presented as the main players
on an urban stage set
that allow us to engage
in dramatic play
The purpose of such play
is to elevate architectural discourse
and rescue meaning
out of the ordinary
Other contributions by Serlio
include his meticulous scale drawings
of exemplary Roman buildings
like the Pantheon and Colosseum
which he sometimes shows
simultaneously in profile
elevation and perspective
In his fourth book
Serlio details the five
now canonized columnar types
setting them in ascending order
at 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10
base diameters tall
from the Tuscan to the Doric
Ionic, Corinthian, and Composite
He also makes entasis
which is the upward diminution
and swelling of the column
begin a third of the way up the shaft
Serlio also provides a method
of achieving entasis in the shafts
He does this by dividing
in equal segments the column shaft
and the arc between the neck
and lower diameters of a column
as projected onto the base diameter
When the segment points
on the circumference
are projected upward
and made to meet
the horizontal elevational divisions
the points of intersection
describe a parabolic curve
This method was adopted
by subsequent Renaissance authors
Serlio also provided
proportional ratios for the pedestals
and illustrated the principle
of alignment of dados or wall surfaces
and the plinths of superimposed features
set above them
to create a gentle
stepping back effect
in the profiles of buildings
This effect is also grounded
in structural logic
as walls are more stable
if they are thicker at the bottom
Besides establishing
the Western classical canon
Serlio's five books
were filled with helpful illustrations
of such things as doorways, windows
and mannered building details
and motifs
One motif that still bears his name
is the Serliana
wherein an arch is flanked
by two trabeated columns
on either side
forming lower rectangular openings
The motif became so popular
in the Renaissance
that other architects
often incorporated it
as a distinguishing feature
Most notably Palladio
who employed it to such effect
that it is now alternatively called
a Palladian arch
Palladio's Basilica at Vicenza
with its stacked Serlianas
is shown on the right
next to a drawing by Serlio
which clearly served as inspiration
This brings us to the next generation
of Italian Renaissance architects
who were operating
in the late 16th century
Two of the most prominent practitioners
Vignola and Palladio
also authored treatises
which would prove to be
even more influential than Serlio's
Both Vignola and Palladio
further codified and rationalized
the columnar types
which, thanks to Vignola's treatise
began to be called orders
and employed modular systems of proportion
derived from Vitruvius
Vignola set his module
as half the column base diameter
and subdivided it into 12 parts
for the Tuscan and Doric types
and 18 parts for the Ionic
Corinthian and Composite
By contrast, Palladio set his module
as a full column base diameter
and subdivided it into 60 minutes
In their treatises, the numbers
shown next to profiles and moldings
refer to the dimensions in parts or minutes
Although they yield similar end results
the subdivisions are different
so it is important not to confuse drawings
by the two authors
Another difference between Vignola and Palladio
is in their treatment of column pedestals
Vignola makes the pedestals
of all five canonical orders
one third as tall as the columns
whereas Palladio varies them
and gives them particular proportions
as Serlio did before him
Palladio generally looked to Serlio
for many of his details
The architect Giacomo Barozzi
who came to be known
after his hometown of Vignola
near Bologna in northern Italy
published his canon of the five orders in 1567
His publication is perhaps
more accurately described
as an illustrated manual
for the setting out of the five columnar types
Where Serlio had established
the ascending sequence of orders
Vignola fixed their modular ratios as follows
Tuscan, 7 diameters tall
Doric, 8
Ionic, 9
Corinthian and composite, 10
These proportions are still widely accepted today
He retained Serlio's recommendation
that entasis should begin
a third of the height of the shaft
up from the base
and as noted in the previous slide
fixed the height of the pedestals
of all the orders
at a third the height of the columns
Vignola also set the height of the entablatures
as a fourth of the height of the columns
With regard to mouldings and profiles
he was generally faithful to Vitruvius
and ancient precedent
Thus, the Tuscan and Doric orders
have a single torus above the plinth
The Ionic has an attic base
with plinth, scotia, scotia, torus
The Corinthian has a plinth
torus, scotia, scotia, torus
as in the Pantheon
and the composite has an attic base
with plinth, torus, scotia, torus
Another example of Vignola's
deference to precedent
is his illustration of an alternate Doric order
which uses dentals instead of mutuals
beneath the cornice
Although dentals are an Ionic detail
and do not properly belong to the Doric type
Vignola sanctions the variant
because it is found on the ancient theatre
of Marcellus in Rome
One of Vignola's most helpful contributions
is his so-called Rule of Nineteen
according to which he divides each order
into nineteen equal parts
from the bottom to the top
assigning four parts to the pedestal
twelve to the column
and three to the entablature
The Rule of Nineteen
facilitates the design of elevations
as it provides a quick method
of setting the heights
of the eccentric components
In his treatise
Vignola shows two methods
of describing entasis
The first method, shown on the left
essentially replicates Sir Leo's drawing
His alternate technique, shown on the right
relies on retaining a constant base diameter
tilted at an increasingly steep angle
above and below the line of entasis
This method of describing a parabolic curve
is suggested especially
for making bellied column shafts
which today are sometimes called cigar-shaped
as they diminish both at the top and bottom
In the same illustration
Vignola describes a method
of delineating a twisted or Solomonic column
which was sometimes used
by Renaissance architects
Vignola's Tuscan order
is much like Sir Leo's
with simple, unarticulated profiles
Note the large bedboulding
the inverted S-shaped profile
of which is known as a sima reversa
beneath the projecting cornice
On the right is an example
of an 18th-century porch
detailed according to Vignola
We mention Vignola's faithfulness
to antique precedent
This sometimes took the form
of a gentle critique
of other architects and their works
In the images on the left
are a drawing of an attic base by Sir Leo
and a detail of the Tempietto
a celebrated round Doric building in Rome
by the architect Bramante
who was a contemporary and friend
of Sir Leo
Both Sir Leo and Bramante
employed the attic base on Doric columns
although strictly speaking
it is an ionic detail
As we discussed in an earlier segment
of this seminar
the attic base consists of stacked
convex, concave, and convex moldings
set on a square plinth
Vignola insisted on avoiding such license
and re-established the more proper
single torus base to the Roman Doric order
as shown in his illustration on the right
Another important contribution by Vignola
was his articulation of a system
of delineating the arches and columns
of the Fornix theme
He established a one-to-two proportion
for all Fornix arches
regardless of the order employed
and illustrated variants
with and without pedestals
Pedestals are especially useful
on upper stories
where parapets or balustrades
are needed across the openings
as in the arches of the Colosseum
shown on the left
In this slide on the left
is Vignola's plate
describing the mutualary Doric order
in other words
a proper Doric
with projecting mutuals
or stylized beam ends
beneath the cornice
He includes a reflected plan
of the soffit
or underside
of the projecting corona
and a reflected plan
of the capitol
The egg and dart motif
in the echinus
imitates the antique example
of Trajan's monumental column
in Rome
At top on the right
is a modern entablature
faithful to Vignola's treatise
As mentioned earlier
Vignola also described
an alternate denticulated Doric
based on his measurements
of the theater of Marcellus in Rome
You can see rows of dentals
extending just beneath the cornice
where normally in the Doric system
one finds mutuals
Although dentals are an ionic detail
the fact that an ancient Roman architect
should have employed them
in a Doric entablature
legitimized the variant
in Vignola's mind
In these two plates
Vignola describes
the ionic capitol and entablature
The drawing on the left
includes a helpful side elevation
showing the ionic baluster
with its balteus or middle strap
and a reflected plan
On the right
Vignola illustrates
his method of describing
the ionic volute
which was widely accepted
and still in use today
The method involves
inscribing a diamond
or rotated square
in the eye of the volute
which is set a third of a diameter
below the architrave
The diamond is 1 18th
the width of the column base diameter
and its center line
aligns with the outer face
of the shaft at the base
It is bisected diagonally
in two directions
so that a cross is established
through the center
Each arm of the cross
is divided equally into three
Each point now serving
as a center
for a succession
of 12 consecutive arcs
which together
describe the volute
In these plates by Vignola
he describes
the Corinthian and composite orders
Note the combination
of dentals and medallions
in the Corinthian cornice
The medallions are
the small scrawled brackets
set immediately beneath
the projecting corona
In the last plate of his treatise
Vignola shows a method
for proportioning the entablatures
of A-styler buildings
which do not employ
the orders
to organize
their exterior elevations
According to Vignola
A-styler entablatures
should be 1 11th
of the overall height
of the building
and proportioned
like his composite entablature
In his illustration
he embellishes
the composite A-styler cornice
with Corinthianizing medallions
and standing scrawled brackets
which are made
to resemble triglyphs
The building shown
at bottom left
faithfully employs
Vignola's cornice
Note too
how it articulates
the upper level
as the more important one
by surrounding the windows
with columns and pediments
and suppressing
the lower windows
The emphasized upper story
is called a piano nobile
meaning important floor in Italian
and it is commonly used
in the design
of classical buildings
In the same plate
Vignola also shows
how to properly proportion coins
These are the rectangular blocks
that are sometimes used
at the corners of A-styler buildings
to provide greater visual strength
Coins are derived
from practical uses
of interlocking stones
at the corners of
rustic masonry buildings
as shown in the top left image
Vignola's recommendation
is that the height of coins
be 12 of the 18 parts
associated with the module
of the composite order
which is used
in the A-styler entablature
In width, the coins
should be alternately
16 and 24 parts
We here come
to Vignola's contemporary
the Venetian architect Palladio
author of the four books
of architecture
which were published in 1570
A former stonemason
from Padova
in the Venetian territories
Andrea di Pietro della Gondola
as he was originally called
was given his classicizing name
by his patron
Count Gian Giorgio Tricino
who recognized
the young man's
exceptional talent
and interest in Roman antiquity
Palladio is known mostly
for his many beautiful
villas and townhouses
in and around the city of Vicenza
and a number of churches in Venice
The image in this slide
is of one of his
most celebrated buildings
the Villa Rotonda in Vicenza
Palladio based much of his thinking
on Alberti's ten books
beginning his treatise
with the assemblage
of the smaller parts
and their delineation
continuing with examples
of his own work
and concluding with
exemplary historic buildings
as a basis against
which to judge his work
Although his treatise
does not include
a parallel of the orders
as Vignola's had done
In this slide
we've arranged the columnar types
in such a way
in order to compare
their proportions
Unlike Vignola's
systematized ratios
of height to base diameter
and his rule of 19
Palladio's columnar proportions
are derived from
Alberti's individualized ratios
As we noted earlier
for his pedestals
Palladio uses different ratios
for the height and width
of the dados
or main vertical surfaces
Another difference
with Vignola
is that Palladio
varies the height
of the entablatures
so that the Tuscan and Doric
are one-fourth
the height of the column
as Vignola had specified
but the remaining Ionic
Corinthian and composite
entablatures
are one-fifth
the height of the column
His rationale
was that the more slender
and delicate three orders
are more appropriately crowned
with lighter entablatures
In his designs for villas
which were really
aristocratic farmhouses
Palladio treated the main volume
as a temple
complete with pediment and portico
Although this has been criticized
as inappropriate
for a residential type
Palladio's rationale
is that the ancient temple itself
was a house for the gods
In true humanist fashion
he places the temple
at the intersection
of a long landscaped approach
symbolizing nature
and a cross axis of rooms
housing the implements and fruits
of agricultural labor
This construct is especially evident
at the Villa Emo
shown on the right
Sometimes the cross axis
is configured to embrace
the axial approach
as at the Villa Tresino at Meledo
at top left
At the Villa Capra
in Vicenza
which is more popularly known
as the Villa Rotonda
Palladio separates the house
from the farm structures
and treats it
as a four-sided Roman temple
The building and its various rooms
are rigorously proportioned
according to Palladio's
seven ideal square-based ratios
which he derived
from Alberti and Serlio
These are the circle, the square
3 to 4, 1 to root 2
2 to 3, 3 to 5
and 1 to 2
These proportions can be extrapolated
in Palladio's drawings
of the Villa Rotonda
from the dimensions he indicates
in plan, section and elevation
Palladio also employed
mannerist themes
like the Colossal Order
which was used previously
by Michelangelo
In the Palazzo Valmarana
in Vicenza
he organizes the two lower stories
with a tall Corinthian order
threading a smaller order through
at the lower level
As a way of lowering
the apparent height of the building
he treats the upper story
as an attic level
A similar device is used by Palladio
in the elevations
of his churches in Venice
At San Francesco della Vigna
and San Giorgio Maggiore
he treats the taller nave
as an elevated temple front
symbolizing the divine realm
and the aisles and entrance
are expressed as a lower gable
symbolizing the earthly realm
Although his orders
are less systematized
and his treatise more nuanced
and therefore more difficult
to use than Vignola's
Palladio's exquisitely conceived
and detailed buildings
and the sheer volume of his output
gained him many devoted followers
and even caused an entire movement
to take root in 18th century Britain
In this slide we see
interior views of his church
of San Giorgio Maggiore in Venice
We'll here take a closer look
at those plates from Palladio's treatise
that deal with the orders
For the Tuscan order
which Palladio considered appropriate
for simple structures like farmhouses
he describes two variants
One shows a simple wooden entablature
as it might have been articulated
by the Etruscans
after whom the type was named
The other shows a stone entablature
similar to the one described by Vignola
but an appropriate degree of rusticity
is imparted by the treatment of the frieze
as a course of rusticated blocks
Like Vignola
in his description of every order
Palladio includes a plate
showing how it might be adapted
into a fornix motif
Perhaps deriving his proportions
from Vignola's slightly earlier treatise
he gives the arched openings
a one-to-two proportion
Here he describes the Doric order
and its associated fornix
Note that he shows
the trabeated ground-level Doric system
as baseless
and set on a crepice of steps
in the Greek manner
When placed on pedestals
the order is given an attic base
which Palladio also used
in the Ionic, Corinthian and Composite orders
In these plates
with details of the Doric order
we can see Palladio's notation of minutes
which are one-sixtieth the width
of the column base diameter
We also note the use
of alternating concave and convex moldings
which was a staple of his
and certain mannerist departures
like the merging of the column plinth
with the top of the pedestal
with a sweeping cavetto
In his plate
illustrating the Ionic Capitol
Palladio uses the same diamond method
put forward by Vignola
to describe the volute spiral
Some awkward conditions that occurred
due to the Capitol's frontal nature
he accepted as inevitable
as at the corner of his
Palazzo da Porto in Vicenza
Note that instead of dentals
which Palladio generally only employed
in connection with the Corinthian entablature
he uses broadly spaced blocks
similar to the ones he specifies
in his Composite order
Despite the differences
in their proportions
Palladio and Vignola's
Corinthian and Composite orders
are almost identically detailed
with some differences
mostly in the Composite cornice
This is because
they both derive their forms
directly from the Pantheon
and other antique examples
Note the use of blocks
instead of dentals
in the Composite order
and the optional pulvinated frieze
One last Italian Renaissance
treatise author needs to be mentioned
before concluding
this part of our study
A student of Palladio
and native of Vicenza
Vicenzo Scamozzi published his
idea of a universal architecture
in 1615
Among his contributions
was the formulation of a method
to proportion superimposed orders
A problem inevitably arises
if the same column base diameter
is used in successive levels
as the proper sequence
from bottom to top
is from stocky to slender
In other words
one begins at ground level
with the Tuscan or Doric
and continues up with Ionic
Corinthian and Composite
Being increasingly more slender
the fixed diameter of the orders
will yield successively taller stories
making the elevation top heavy
Scamozzi's solution
was to make the base diameter
of each successive order
the same as the neck
of the previous one
The drawing in the middle
of the slide by William Ware
shows how Scamozzi's system
balances the floor levels
Another contribution by Scamozzi
was his invention
of an Ionic capital
with angled volutes
Apparently inspired
by the composite order
from which he removed
the rows of acanthus leaves
this Ionic variant
eliminated the problem
of the type's uncompromising frontality
Allowing it to be used
more elegantly in corner conditions
ground buildings, etc.
The variant
which is now known
as the Scamozzi Ionic
became a favorite
especially of Baroque architects
in the 17th and early 18th centuries
In this next section
we will examine the architecture
of the 16th century
or late Renaissance in Italy
which is today
sometimes referred to as Mannerism
This approach is characterized
by expressionistic departures
from the canons
established by the treatise writers
The Italian Renaissance
had ushered in an age of rationalism
defined by a renewed interest
in the Greek and Roman arts and letters
Architects like Brunelleschi and Bramante
and the authors of the first treatises
Alberti, Serlio, Vignola and Palladio
took great pains
to acquaint themselves intimately
with the surviving buildings from antiquity
which they emulated
in an effort to capture
what they believed to be
the science of good form
Among these architects
Bramante was thought to have come closest
in capturing the classical spirit
and his Tempietto in Rome
seen on the left side of the screen
was considered to be
of such a level of perfection
as to merit inclusion
in discussions
of the great buildings of antiquity
A younger generation of architects
would soon be building
upon the foundations
laid by the first Renaissance masters
exploring the full expressive range
and potential
of the classical language
The artist and architect
Raffaele Sanzio
popularly known to us as Raphael
was perhaps the first
of this emerging generation to do so
First, by introducing decorative schemes
and later architectural patterns
that did not strictly comply
with tectonic principles
His early work, however,
shows a strong grounding
in canonical principles and approaches
of the sort espoused by Bramante
who is thought to have been his uncle
and mentor
This is evident
when one compares, for example,
the polygonal temple
and his painting
Marriage of the Virgin
with the Tempietto
Raphael's move away
from Bramante's canonical classicism
which strictly upheld
the tectonic principles
of antique Roman architecture
and towards a more playful bending
of the classical rules
is perhaps first apparent
in his design for the Chigi Chapel
in the church of Santa Maria del Popolo
in Rome
Here he takes a straightforward
serliana and bends it
to conform to the round plan
of the chapel
The effect is simultaneously
one of unity and complexity
Note, however,
that in this departure from norm
Raphael does not seek to overturn
the tectonic nature of classical forms
Another building designed by Raphael
showing a departure from principle
is his façade
for the Palazzo Branconio dell'Aquila
in Rome
Although this building
no longer stands
its elevation survives
in architectural drawings
In this elevation
one can see that the building
was richly decorated
and employs the familiar device
of a repeating fornix motif
at the ground level
where shop fronts are incorporated
The second floor, or piano nobile,
features a series of pedimented aedicules
framing large windows
another familiar device
known since antiquity
Note, however,
Raphael's incorporation
of arched niches
between the aedicules
In this sketch
by an unknown artist
we see a close-up
of the building's left corner
Again, note the location
of the voided niches
between the aediculated windows
of the piano nobile
These voids
are deliberately placed on axis
with the columns below
an alignment that goes against
what would be considered
proper tectonic principle
where one normally expects
structural members
in an elevation
Raphael indicates voids
The vaguely unsettling effect
is more pronounced
at the corner of the façade
which a Renaissance architect
would ordinarily make
both visually and structurally robust
The popularity
of the Palazzo Branconio
is evident in the many
surviving drawings
by other architects and artists
and in its replication
by the architect
Bartolomeo Baronino
20 years later
at the Palazzo Spada in Rome
Although there are obvious differences
this view of the Spada courtyard
shows an identical alignment
of niches and columns
While Raphael nudged
the classical language
toward greater expressionism
the younger Giulio Romano
a pupil of his
can be more properly credited
with the introduction
of the approach or attitude
toward architectural design
that modern historians
have termed mannerism
Romano's most celebrated work
is the Palazzo del Te in Mantua
which he built
in 1526
for Marquess Federico II Gonzaga
This building was used
as a weekend retreat
and stable for the Marquess
who was an avid equestrian
As the aerial view
on the left shows
the building appears to be
a straightforward
Renaissance composition
with an aligned courtyard and garden
However, it is filled
with deliberate anomalies
and architectural departures
that challenge the visitor
At first glance
the entrance façade
appears to be
an ordinary composition
with rows of pilasters
which are coupled at the ends
for visual reinforcement
of the corners
a familiar Renaissance device
Yet on closer inspection
the rhythm of pilasters
and the bays which they frame
is deliberately varied
so that there is no regularity
The three entrance arches
sit in a bay
that is much too wide
from a tectonic point of view
The façade is only redeemed
by the use of rustication
for the plain wall surfaces
which can be interpreted visually
as supporting the long stretches
of entablature above
Upon entering the courtyard
the visitor is greeted
by still more surprises
In what appears to be
a normative enclosing wall
of engaged columns and rustication
familiar architectural elements
are made to appear
structurally challenged
and sometimes defy
or contradict each other
Note for example
the slipped triglyphs
that look as if they are about
to fall off the entablature
Or the pedimented cornices
over the flat niches
which are broken by keystones
which are made to look
as if they are thrusting upward
In the image on the right
a rusticated keystone
slices through a horizontal cornice
and stops just short
of the pediment's apex
The slipped triglyph
shown below left
pushes into a small window
A third architect
who is considered
to have been a mannerist
was Michelangelo Bonarotti
who like Raphael
is usually referred to
by his first name
on account of his fame
as an artist
A native of Florence
Michelangelo began his career
as a sculptor
gaining wide recognition
for statuary works
like the David
shown on the left
This work was commissioned
to stand as a symbol
of the city of Florence
Michelangelo's Pietà
or Mourning Mary and Dead Christ
is shown on the right
Like many artists of his day
Michelangelo was also
sometimes commissioned
to design buildings
His two most important works
in Florence
are found in the church
of San Lorenzo
which had been built
in the early 15th century
by the first great
Renaissance architect
Filippo Brunelleschi
In the plan at top left
the two interventions
by Michelangelo
are indicated in yellow
These are the New Sacristy
on the right
and the Laurentian Library
overlooking the cloister
Note that the large
domed octagonal chapel
behind the church
is a later 17th century edition
and is not shown in this plan
of the 16th century sacred complex
Michelangelo's New Sacristy design
was commissioned
to balance the Old Sacristy
which had been designed
and built by Brunelleschi
100 years earlier
Using the Old Master's
square and dome
with pendentives
as a starting point
Michelangelo's New Sacristy
is, however, filled
with poetical departures
from normative
architectural expressions
So, for instance,
he paints the frieze
over the ground level
palasters white
like the walls
to suggest that the Sacristy's
domed roof
is lifting up off the base
The flanks of the chapel
are filled with
sculptural compositions
in white marble
Where Brunelleschi
celebrated entrance
to the Old Sacristy
with pedimented doorways
Michelangelo suppresses
the entrance
by placing it
in an unstressed zone
beneath an empty
pedimented niche
The New Sacristy's
flanking sculptural groups
are designed as tombs
for Giuliano de' Medici
Duke of Nemours
shown on the left
and Lorenzo de' Medici
Duke of Urbino
on the right
In what are arguably
Michelangelo's most
accomplished works
he shows the two dead men
who died young
at 37 and 26 years of age
respectively
as having risen
from their sarcophagi
into shallow
unstressed niches
as if to suggest
lives that were cut short
Their unfulfilled careers
are further suggested
by the stressed
pedimented empty niches
flanking the statues
Michelangelo treats Giuliano
as a personification
of the active life
and Lorenzo as
the contemplative life
Note how the sarcophagi
are shown with split lids
on which flanking
allegorical figures recline
On Giuliano's tomb
figures of night and day
complete the composition
and on Lorenzo's tomb
are the representations
of dawn and dusk
appropriate for a
contemplative state of mind
In the architecture
of the upper tier
Michelangelo challenges norms
by crowding the pediments
between pilasters
and by inverting
familiar pot-bellied balusters
above the pilasters
In Michelangelo's design
for the library at San Lorenzo
also known as the Lorenziana
or Lorentian library
the otherwise normatively treated
great hall or reading room
is entered by way of a staircase
set in a lofty square vestibule
The cascading gradients
fill the room
presenting an irresistible invitation
to the visitor
to ascend and enter
the reading room
The walls surrounding
the vestibule
are at first appearance normative
with series of coupled columns
forming regular bays
On inspection, though,
they contradict the walls
by being entirely embedded
within them
Here Michelangelo sets columns
and walls in competition
for structural primacy
so that one is left
with a vague feeling
of uncertainty or contradiction
of the sort one often encounters
in the pursuit of knowledge
in books and manuscripts
Other contradictory features
are the brackets beneath the columns
These are normally used
as supports for cornices
but here they almost appear
as liquefied stone
oozing out of the walls
under the weight of the columns
One cannot fail to notice, too,
that the pediment of the library entrance
is greater in width
than the space between
the flanking paired columns
The device of crowding pediments
in between columns or piers
appears to have been invented
by Michelangelo
and was knowingly adopted
by Giulio Romano
and other architects who followed
Michelangelo's last architectural works
with the Dome of St. Peter's Basilica
in Rome
and the city's seat of government
on the Capitoline Hill
the Piazza del Campidoglio
both designed in the 1540s
At the Campidoglio
Michelangelo arranged
three public buildings
around a trapezoidal piazza
or square
In the center of the square
set in an oval pavement
he placed a bronze equestrian statue
of the Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius
which in Michelangelo's
day was thought to represent
Rome's first Christian Emperor
Constantine
A great stair
leads axially up into the piazza
the far end of which
is fronted by the Palazzo Senatorio
an important government building
that served as city hall
The flanking buildings
incorporate ground-level colonnades
that both frame
the Palazzo Senatorio
and lead to the wings
of its great symmetrical stair
The significance of this project
by Michelangelo
is not just architectural and urbanistic
but also political
The Capitoline Hill
overlooks the ruins
of the ancient seat
of the city's government
the Roman Forum
seen in the aerial view on the left
extending beyond
the Palazzo Senatorio to the east
In his three-sided urban design
Michelangelo reorients
the seat of government
to the Vatican
and the Dome of St. Peter's
seen on the horizon
in the image at bottom right
Fortuitously
that dome was also built
to Michelangelo's designs
This reorientation
was a statement
of the modern city's
Christian outlook
and grounding in its pagan past
One of Michelangelo's
most important contributions
to Renaissance architecture
was the introduction
of the Colossal Order
This device
which was picked up by Palladio
some 20 years later
in his elevation
of the Palazzo Marmarana in Vicenza
organizes multiple levels
within a larger ordered framework
which establishes a scale
for the large elevational composition
In his flanking buildings
at the Campidoglio
Michelangelo laces a minor order
between the colossal pilasters
to create a lower scale
relevant to the colonnade
In the diagram at top left
the Colossal Order is shown in blue
and the Minor Order in tan color
Although the nuanced works
of Raphael, Romano, and Michelangelo
would have an enormous impact
on Western architecture
Mannerism was short-lived
and it evolved
into the more vivacious
or flamboyant expressionism
of the Baroque period
Although his output
was much more limited
one architect and sculptor
whose works presage this shift
is Bernardo Buontalenti
On the left is his
Porta delle Suppliche
in the Uffizi Palace
which shows strong influences
from Michelangelo
Note the split pediment
with its reversed segments
as if thrust apart
by the sculpted bust
above the cornice
Note as well
the overlaid door frame
set against an otherwise
normative pilastered opening
Buontalenti's increasingly
Baroque manner
is evident in his design
for the Fontana dello Sprone
shown below right
which deliberately obscures
the distinction
between building and art
and treats architectural form
as organic matter
As we have seen
in this presentation
mannerist architects
pushed the boundaries
of established and accepted
architectural language
by challenging but
and this is essential
in understanding
the mannerist spirit
never truly overturning
the classical canon
Even as canonical
or normative expressions
are manipulated and reconfigured
mannerism was careful
not to challenge
or obscure tectonic logic
For all the playfulness
of the buildings
by Raphael, Romano
and Michelangelo
one can still always
trace the logical
constructional underpinnings
of the designs
As we will see
in the next section
at the start of the 17th century
the earnest playfulness
of mannerism
transformed into
the full-fledged
illusionistic drama
of the Baroque
