SilverCrest Metals: Gold, Silver vs. Fiat — We Want "Real Money" on our Balance Sheet

Coin Crunch
8 followers
1 Video View·Jun 1, 2024
Finance
"Chris Ritchie of SilverCrest Metals shares his thoughts on how inflation continues to impact gold and silver miners, and explains why his company has chosen to hold precious metals on its balance sheet in this environment.
""The fact that we are sitting there digging up real money — money that's better than the fiat currency — we want to hold it. We want it on our balance sheet,"" he explained during the interview. ""Again, from a business perspective, any company that sells their product below the cost to produce it — not a great business.""
"
I'm Charlotte McLeod with investing news.com.
And here today with me is Chris Ritchie, president of Silvercrest metals.
Thank you so much for joining me.
Great to have you here.
Appreciate you having me as well.
Really good to be speaking with you.
I think it's going to be a fun conversation and where I thought we could begin since
it's our first time talking is by learning a little bit about you, how you got into
the mining industry, how you came to Silvercrest.
Yeah, thanks.
I've been at Silvercrest for about six and a half years now after spending 13
years on Bay street, wall street.
So, I mean, I have a background of helping resource companies raise capital.
And then, uh, this company was at a really interesting phase and I more or less came
in house to raise capital for, for that.
So here we are, you know, six and a half years later, we're producing sort of that
phase of the company is behind us, uh, now entering a new phase.
Okay.
And of course we're going to get into talking about what's going on at
Silvercrest right now.
But before we go there, I thought we could look at the precious metal sector overall.
So of course, gold and silver prices have really been moving in 2024.
And although some companies have also been moving as a group, the precious metal
stocks haven't been moving as much as some investors would like.
So we were talking by email before this conversation and you mentioned that this
disconnect kind of all goes back to inflation.
So I'm hoping that you can go into your thoughts there and outline
exactly what you're meaning.
Sure.
There are a million moving pieces to get a mine all the way from exploration
to development to production.
You know, there's labor, there's fuel, there's steel, there's consumables.
There's again, a million moving pieces.
And the cost of those moving pieces are going up more than the gold and silver.
So what we've seen in the last while is the margins of mining companies have not
expanded.
And in fact, many of them have actually contracted, you know, for example, our
labor costs have gone up approximately 50% in the last three years.
So again, you know, gold and silver is a proxy for inflation because of all the
inputs that go into getting it out of the ground.
All right.
And I think, you know, many people are looking at what's going on there and they
wonder what will it take to, to close that gap, right?
We just got our latest inflation data and I think it went down a little bit for the
month of April, but it remains pretty persistent and it sounds like it's, it's
set to remain quite sticky.
I think it will as well.
I mean, we've seen people exiting the workforce.
Um, not a lot of people are going into mining these days.
So even if there were new projects to get started, we're going to be fighting over
the same labor, the same talent and whatnot.
So, you know, a big part of, you know, our strategy is to sort of acknowledge
inflation and, and sort of build that into our base case and then figure out ways to
beat it.
Right.
And maybe we can talk a little bit about the company's strategy, because I think
that ties in quite well here.
So against this backdrop, Silvercrest has decided that it wants to hold precious
metals on its balance sheet.
So maybe you can talk a little bit about how you came to that decision and what it
actually looks like in, in practice.
Sure.
So about two years ago, a year and a half ago, we entered production.
Uh, we were fortunate enough to have an amazing high grade asset with high margins.
Uh, we paid back all of our debt in the first seven months and cash was coming in.
And the next obvious question for the team is, all right, what's next?
What are we going to do?
You know, and some of the knee-jerk responses are let's go build a new mine.
And collectively as a team, we said, okay, well, let's slow down.
Let's actually see how we performed on this one.
And what we did is we took every single penny we spent from day one, uh, all the
way through to the end of the mine.
And we assumed inflation in the future years of production.
And we divided it by the amount of gold and silver we have today.
And what we came up with was our total cost, our true cost.
And again, we calculate this differently because we include every penny, um, was
in the neighborhood of about $25 an ounce.
And at the time silver was 18, 19 bucks.
So instead of just sort of that default of sell your ounces, get your dollars,
start over again, we acknowledged that if we were to sell our ounces at that
moment in time, all we'd be doing is crystallizing a loss and the fact that
we are sitting there with, you know, we digging up real money and a money
that's better than the fiat currency.
We want to hold.
And, you know, so we, we wanted on our balance sheet, but again, from a, from
a business perspective, any company that sells their product below the cost to
Not a great business.
Right.
So that, that definitely makes a lot of sense.
And how, how long have you been following this strategy and what's
the long-term goal there?
I mean, the long-term goal is we want to give our investors
more exposure to gold and silver.
I mean, there's, there's a, we've got this default mentality in society that,
you know, the dollars that we use, um, do protect ourselves, but in fact, they're
just really, really convenient medium is experience exchange.
You're not using an ounce of silver to go buy a coffee.
Um, but at the same time, you know, these dollars, um, are subject to inflation.
So for us, we want to give our investors more exposure to the metal.
Uh, every ounce we hold on our balance sheet, um, has less risk because all
the risks will be behind us, which means if the price goes up, our investors
get all of that price increase.
And, you know, even further to that, we are subject to inflation.
So the gold we have on our balance sheet protects us, right.
It protects our business and it's not just mining, you know, every single
company that is subject to inflation has a responsibility to find ways to fight
back and we produce a product that does just that.
So we want to hold it.
All right.
And, you know, you mentioned this is for the benefit of investors.
And so I'm curious, you know, this is, it makes a lot of sense when you explain
it, but sometimes when something new is happening, happening, people
don't understand it right away.
So what is the reaction been from investors?
We've, we've had a range.
I mean, it's definitely new.
It's definitely different.
Um, we have an old guard in our industry that has done certain things in a long
time, so it's taken a bit of a, a challenge and I'll give our board a lot
of credit for being extremely open-minded, uh, on this front.
Uh, we've had some investors say, it's not your job.
It's not your job to hold ounces.
And my response is, you know, well, our job is to run a good business.
And if the price of the metal is below our cost to produce it, we don't want to,
you know, sell it at a loss or I can hold gold myself.
I don't need you to hold gold for me.
And my response is, well, you can hold dollars yourself.
You know, we've got, you know, over 90 million on our balance sheet.
No, we want to give investors more of the metal.
At the same time, I would say people outside of the traditional mining
world think this is extremely simple.
They think, of course, why would I walk gold and silver?
You're giving me more gold and silver.
You're fighting for a better price.
You know, they're, they're very, very open to it.
So it's been interesting.
I find non-mining people think this makes all the sense in the world.
Retail people make, think it makes all the sense in the world.
Some of the traditional investors have taken a little while to come around, but
when silver is at 29, 30 bucks and we started holding it about, you know,
eight, $10 ago they're a lot more open-minded today.
Okay.
Really interesting to see that range of reactions.
I can imagine there's been a lot of interesting conversations.
And so I'm not sure if you mentioned how much is on the balance sheet right now.
And I know this is, this is going to be a future question, but when
would you be looking to sell?
Obviously we've had, as we talked about, prices are running this year, but, but
clearly not enough, enough for you to consider that at this point.
Well, first of all, again, we have Canadian dollars on the balance
sheet, US dollars, Mexican pesos.
So we fundamentally believe gold and silver is just another currency
that we permanently want to have.
So there's always going to be some we have on there.
Again, we believe it's a better store of value.
We mentioned the cost to get it out of the ground.
That's one, that's one factor.
One of the other factors is there's significant functionality that gold
provides, and to give you an example of that, Charlotte, we took 400 assets over
the course of 31 years in the gold space and the price, our costs went
up approximately 8% per year.
And if you actually look at the gold price, the correlation of gold and our
costs went up on a 0.97 basis.
So almost a perfect correlation between our costs and gold.
So therefore we can use gold to protect our own business against inflation.
Right?
So for me, there's a functionality.
So to have as much gold on our balance sheet equivalent to our sustaining
capital, to me, it's just good, prudent risk management.
And then the final thought is great.
What if we do make a really good return today?
And we love the price.
We sell it.
Now what?
Right now we have to go back to square one and square one is only one out of
approximately 750 mines makes it to production.
And it usually takes somewhere between 15 to 20 years.
So we then have to say, what currency is better to protect our
value for the next 15 to 20 years?
Is it fiat currency or is it golden?
So for us, not only are we making a profit today, can we sell it and then
replace it way out in the future at a better cost and you know, the trends say,
no, we can't.
Okay.
Really important considerations.
And I can tell that this is a strategy that is evolving as you go.
So I'm curious, you know, we talked about how this is new.
People are having interesting reactions.
Is there anyone else in the mining industry who's doing a similar thing?
And do you think this is something that may be picked up among other companies?
Are you having that kind of conversation?
I'd love to.
I'm trying to have the conversation.
I think one of the very unique attributes of our mind is because we're so
profitable, because we have financial flexibility, it means we have choice.
And we believe we owe it to our investors to examine what all the
opportunities that this choice and flexibility gives us.
Unfortunately, you know, many of our peers just don't have that same flexibility.
They just don't have that balance sheet strength.
So again, it's, you know, we don't have to be a price taker when prices are really
weak and they're below the cost to produce it.
I mean, that's definitely the moment we want to hold more.
What we're hoping is more people have this conversation and put it on the
list of ways to allocate capital.
It doesn't have to be the only thing you're choosing.
There's great assets out there to develop.
There's times for a buyback.
There's times for a dividend.
All we're saying is this needs to be one of the choices that people consider.
And, you know, you mentioned, okay, so not, not all your peers have the
ability and flexibility to do this.
I think it's interesting to take a look at the sector because, you know, we, I
hear quite often during the last bull market, precious metals miners didn't
make the best decisions.
Now, this time around, they're being a little bit more prudent.
Do you find that's generally true or what are your thoughts on that note?
Again, we've been so ingrained to use fiat currency.
Our whole financial system is evaluated in dollars.
So we really don't know how to count in gold and silver.
So, you know, everyone's default option is to convert everything back to that dollar.
And once you've decided to hold a dollar, you have no choice but
to go out and try to spend it.
So I think, you know, that's one base challenge where we're trying to push
back on, you know, we're hoping now if costs do moderate and price of the metal
keeps going, that yeah, we will see margin expansion at some time, but we put our
hands up and we take responsibility because it's the industry that's
suppressing the price, you know, we, we can choose to sell it.
We can store gold and silver.
Can't really do that with coal or iron ore.
Once you produce it, it's, you got to move it.
We can choose to store it.
Um, so we don't, and when we don't, we're the ones selling the
metal and pushing down the price.
So, you know, I, I think again, it needs to be a choice to hold on.
And if we do hold on, especially when prices are weak or the environment's weak,
we can improve our return, which is hopefully improves our health and, and
hopefully snowballs in the right direction.
It's, it's definitely, it, it takes a mindset shift as you're talking about,
you know, just hearing you say it's the industry that is suppressing the price
in that way is quite, quite, quite a statement to make.
I wonder if you've had anything else to, to add there.
I mean, I feel like we've got this unique, uh, position where we have
exclusive access to go dig this money out of this ground and it's, it's a
product that we all use in our marketing that we believe in the metal.
Um, you know, but yet when it comes time to holding it, we choose not to, we
choose to sell it for a currency that we market against, we don't like the fiat
currency, but then we choose to hold our balance sheet in fiat currency.
You know, if the other side of the coin is central banks have exclusive
access to the printing press, now they're printing money left, right,
and center, and they're buying gold.
So we're in this weird position where they don't want what they're producing.
And our many people in our industry don't want what we're producing.
And we're just putting our hands up to say, we like our product.
We believe in the product and we want, we want more of the product.
Um, and yeah, we were hoping your investors think the same way.
All right.
And I think that that's maybe a good transition to talk about
Silvercrest's first quarter results.
We're talking a couple of days after those have come out.
So I wondered if you wanted to share a few top level highlights from that report.
Sure.
Uh, I mean, our guidance for the year, it was to produce approximately
10 million ounces of silver equivalent.
We're roughly 50, 50 silver and gold.
We're pretty unique in that we're a hundred percent precious
metals, um, which is great.
Um, the costs for us, we're going to be in the range of $15 to $15 and 90 cents.
Um, in Q1, our, our costs were $12 and 90 cents.
We benefited from some lower tax, which will normalize.
Eyes in future quarters.
Um, we didn't quite spend as much money in certain areas, which, which helped our
costs, but what that translates into is roughly 60% operating margins, right?
So for us, um, you know, we beat consensus estimates and, and I think
every category, um, but again, we're in this position now where that, that
sort of flexibility, the operational level gives us that choice.
So the market seemed to like what we were doing.
Um, you know, we paid a bunch of taxes in Q1.
We, we entered the world of tax paying, whereas last year we were still
working off of our, some of our tax losses.
Um, but we're looking forward with prices today being substantially
higher than in Q1, right?
I think, um, some people are starting to see, Hey, why am I selling today?
If I know that Q2 while we're halfway through Q2 is already looking much better.
And, and on that note, so on track for production guidance in 2024, what should
investors be, be looking for as the year continues?
Hopefully consistency.
Uh, one of the unique attributes for us is that we mine our material and then we
create a big stockpile on the ground.
And then our grade is quite high and we have medium and low grade.
We blend that together to put into the plant and that sort of consistency
allows us to have really high recovery.
So we're getting the most that we can out of that rock.
Um, and that has been giving us that those consistent results.
We've been in the range of 60% operating margins in the last six quarters or so.
Uh, so hopefully that's going to continue.
And one, one other unique attribute is, um, the term retained earnings.
That's kind of your scorecard.
Have you been running a good business or not?
Are you making money or not?
Uh, unfortunately the mining industry has struggled and it's, it's, it's not a
critique, it's, it's a really tough business.
Um, we had positive retained earnings of approximately 20, $21 million.
Uh, so to do that already, uh, after all the money going out the door to get
everything up and running is, uh, something we're really proud of.
So.
Uh, it's a unique attribute.
And again, I'll bring that all back to the asset quality, the margins and our choice.
Yeah.
Of course it all does end up relating back together.
So that's what 2024 is looking like for the company.
And I won't, I won't ask you to give me gold and silver price predictions, but I
think it's interesting, clearly you're, you're bullish on precious metals.
I think it's interesting to take a look at what you see coming broadly as the
year continues and perhaps into the future for, for the metals prices.
Yeah.
I mean, I think a common theme that people have been talking about is not many people
are out there trying to build new projects, right?
The costs are going higher, accessing capital is difficult.
And because it takes, you know, that 16 to 20 years supply of all things are
starting to get, uh, pretty squeezed.
And we've seen that with copper recently and uranium, everything else.
Um, the money is not coming back into the space to encourage new supply.
And again, the costs are going higher.
You know, we hear this word, oh, we need more copper.
Prices are going up.
We need higher prices.
We need higher margins.
The price going up on its own doesn't matter.
It's price relative to cost.
And right now, um, the incentives to bring on new supply still aren't that exciting.
So it just bodes well for someone who's already in production that the
existing supply is, uh, is, is worth a lot.
So we're thinking prices do go higher.
Uh, but we're also in a position if they do go lower, that we can be opportunistic
in terms of either holding onto more ounces at low prices or buying
back shares at lower prices.
Um, again, just using that, the choice that our flexibility gives us.
Right.
That, that really resonates.
I think I'm constantly hearing that the mining industry needs to attract
capital from, from outside the sector.
And we really need to see that.
So for you, do you think it's those higher margins versus the higher prices
that starts to bring that in and maybe get some discoveries or development going?
Again, I think it just needs like, if you were to make a list of, you know, all
the challenges over the next 20 years, I mean, grades are going down, you know, a
lot of people aren't comfortable going to some of the strange places in the world
where some of these commodities exist, taxes, permitting, ESG, you know, it's
not an easy forward looking trajectory for new supply.
Um, so I don't, I don't necessarily see visibility of a lot of new supply.
Uh, which is, which is why I do think again, companies already in production,
um, are in a bit of a, a bit of a benefit or in a better position today.
Right.
And as, as we're starting to get to the end here, I did want to ask for your
advice for investors who may be looking at precious metals companies, they want
to get involved, maybe they feel a little bit discouraged about some of the
performances that they've been seeing.
What advice might you have there?
Understand the risks.
I mean, I think there's, you know, we, we were one of those early stage companies
that went from a 5 million market cap to, you know, 1.8 or 9 billion Canadian today.
We did sort of run that gauntlet.
Uh, lots of risks on the way, but it's, you know, it's not easy.
Not every company makes it.
Um, costs do go higher.
So I think it is a challenge.
So for people who do want to invest, just know where on the spectrum you want to be.
I mean, if you're thinking very long-term to protect your purchasing power, it's
nothing wrong with buying the physical metal, you know, royalties and streaming
companies don't have as much operating risk.
Um, cash flowing companies are obviously healthier than the ones
you've yet to build.
So again, I think just for people to understand, if you're investing in a
mining company, sometimes you've got more exposure to the mining related
risks and less exposure to the metal.
And that's one thing we're trying to do.
We're trying to give people more exposure to the metal, uh, and
minimize the operating risk.
All right.
I think certainly you've given everybody a lot to think about today.
And just before I let you go, I'll put it back to you and ask if there's any final
thoughts that you would leave investors with.
Man, I think one key thing is I think a lot of people are talking
about rates going down, right?
Everyone's kind of hoping rates go down.
Uh, I think there's a scenario out here where rates can go up and, you know, I
think just making sure from a risk perspective that people have enough
flexibility, um, and safety and how they are managing their own portfolios to
make sure that they can withstand some of the volatility that, uh, that we're
probably going to be having here for a while.
All right.
I think that's, that's a good note to wrap up on.
So thank you so much for coming today to go over what's going on in gold and
silver and with silver crest.
This was really informative.
Thanks for having me, Charlotte.
Appreciate it.
Of course.
And once again, I'm Charlotte cloud with investing news.com.
And this is Chris Ritchie with silver crest metals.
Thank you for watching.
If you liked this video, make sure you subscribe to our channel.
We'd also love to hear your thoughts.
So leave us a comment below.
We'll see you next time.
