Underappreciated Historical Weapons: the Bec De Corbin / Crow's beak / Raven's beak

Ancient Swords
6 followers
2 Video Views·May 31, 2024
In this episode of Underappreciated historical weapons we look at the bec de corbin or crow's beak / Raven's beak.
This episode of Shatterversity is brought to you by one of my all-time favorite sponsors,
Audible, where if you go to www.audible.com forward slash Shatterversity, or if you're in
the U.S. you can text Shatterversity to 500 500, you'll get your first audiobook for free
if you give them a try for 30 days. Why is Audible one of my favorite sponsors? Well,
I've been signed up to Audible separate to being sponsored by them for years. Have a look at my
Audible library. There is an unmatched selection of audiobooks including Audible exclusives that
you cannot find anywhere else, narrated by some of the most talented people in the world.
You know, it's still the beginning of the year and if you're looking at trying something new
going into the future, try Audible. Listening to audiobooks is the best way you can read a
book because it's read to you. I love listening to them when I'm driving in my car or working
at the computer and Audible, their app is just phenomenal where I can listen to it on my phone
and when I jump to my computer it syncs up automatically and picks up right where I left off.
If you want to learn about cooking or fitness or just escape into a new world with a wonderful
fantasy, Audible is just excellent and might I suggest you check out one of the greatest
fantasy epics of all time, The Wheel of Time, beginning with The Eye of the World,
narrated by the flawless Michael Kramer and Kate Redding. They are just wonderful. In fact,
if you want to get the first book in The Wheel of Time, The Eye of the World, for free,
go to www.audible.com forward slash Shadiversity or if you are in the U.S. you can just text
Shadiversity to 500 500 to get that book for free with a 30-day trial and indeed a membership.
By the way, if you sign up for a membership, you get a book for free each month at such a
good price. It's insane and you just get all your audiobooks that you want. I've done it for years.
It's awesome. So please do go check it out. Thank you, Audible, for sponsoring this video
and now let's get to the subject of this video.
Greetings, I'm Shad and welcome to Underappreciated Historical Weapons and in
this episode we're looking at a kind of interesting weapon because it is both
underappreciated and, in this kind of state, it is overappreciated and it is indeed the scythe.
The scythe is a kind of complex, sophisticated subject when you really dive into it and there's
a bit to cover so let's go right into it. First of all, the scythe, as depicted in many pop
cultures, the grim reaper scythe. This is actually a grim reaper's, you know, fantasy design.
Okay, so the classic grim reaper's scythe, no, no, that's not really a weapon. Though,
there's a weapon that's quite similar to it that I'm going to mention later because
it's not really a scythe. What is a scythe? Well, a real scythe is actually an agricultural
implement that wasn't just used in the medieval period but all the way through to the 1800s
and it, of course, looks very much like what you see here but with some very key,
important differences. One of the differences is that there's actually two handles right about
here on a real scythe and I'll move back so we can see it. So it wasn't actually meant to be
held like this but, in fact, on the handles that protruded out of the main shaft. And the other
key difference is that the blade that was on the scythe was actually not lined up, as you see this
one being lined up, to the shaft itself. It was actually kind of tilted to an angle and the reason
for this was for cutting grass and grain. And so when you held the scythe on an angle downwards
like this, the blade was actually in line with the ground. And so you would hold it at the handles
and you'd do these big swashes and sweeps and stuff and you would thresh and cut grass in a
very effective way. It was a very effective farming implement. It, you know, was used for a very long
time because it was effective and it wasn't actually a weapon. Yet, farming implements have
been adapted into weapons all throughout history. It was done in Japan. A lot of the martial arts
weapons that we see were actually originally farming type implements like the kama and even
the nunchucks, right? So they were actually farming implements and the scythe was one of those as well.
And in Europe, another example, the flail in its original form was actually a type of farming
implement for threshing grain, knocking grain and stuff like that. It was on a big pole and everything.
But this is the thing. Some farming implements can actually be quite effective weapons even if they
weren't originally designed as such. And so if you had nothing to use except this, you know, you're a
farmer, right? And you have this scythe with a pretty vicious sharp blade on the end and you
needed a weapon. Well, it's better than nothing, isn't it? So you can actually use the agricultural
scythe without changing anything on it as a weapon. In fact, there's even a treatise describing
certain techniques that you can try, you know, use the scythe in that full-on combat. There is debate
if this is actually meant to be taken seriously, trying to establish it as a legitimate weapon, or
it was just a novelty, something kind of interesting. In all honesty, it's a very awkward weapon, especially
with the blade being, you know, off-centered to the line of the shaft. It's like tilted on a different
angle. That makes it kind of awkward. And so using it, you have to use different kind of techniques
and stuff. But of course, it's like I said, it's better than nothing. But still, being competent
with a weapon like that versus someone who's also using the same weapon or even a better weapon
that's designed for real combat, you're at a bit of a disadvantage. And if you can win, that shows
the level of competence and skill, doesn't it? Yet in reality, it's actually a very inefficient weapon
design as it is. And so there is an adaptation on the scythe that people have their speculation
onto exactly how this war scythe really came about. And people say it's because people started
using scythes as weapons and realized, you know, these aren't actually fully effective as a weapon.
In fact, there's a couple of distinct changes we'd want to make to an agricultural scythe to make
them effective weapons. And one of the things is the angle in which the blade is protruding from
the shaft. You can stab people really well with it, but there's this big vicious blade on the underside
that's actually really hard to strike people with. I mean, the only way you would do it is if you
overshoot your opponent, then try and pull it in and try and slash that way. But when you do a big
swing like that, you're just stabbing them. You're not actually using the blade. And people seem to
notice this and realize, well, if we want to get the utility out of this blade, we're going to need
to change the angle. And so there is such a weapon known as a war scythe. And this is the
underappreciated weapon that I'm kind of talking about because the actual classic kind of cliche
death scythe is not really effective, okay? Yes, there was a novelty, and if you had nothing,
it's better than nothing. But if you actually wanted to adapt this to combat, well, there is
such a thing as a war scythe, and it's not this. What it actually is, it's like a polearm with a
scythe-looking blade. Sometimes they were repurposed agricultural scythes, but
people say that agricultural scythes, their blades are too thin to handle the rigors of
full-on combat, and they get damaged too easily. And so a proper war scythe has a purposefully
built blade on the end. It's still shaped like a scythe blade, but it's thicker and more robust,
curving forward on the end. And because it's now, instead of angled like 90 degrees from the shaft,
it's actually sticking up forward with a forward-curving striking end. Well, you can actually
strike with the blade, and it's a far more efficient weapon. That is what is called and
known as the war scythe. And it's pretty darn vicious, but we don't see it depicted very often
in pop culture, video games, movies, role-playing games, stuff like that. It's very unknown. But
having said that, the variety and versatility of polearms, medieval polearms, there's so many
that, honestly, people seem to default to some of the classics. And that is like the halberd,
the poleaxe, and if they're a bit aware of one of the more common types of polearms that were
used by the more common soldier, the billhook, or simply known as the bill. But there are so
many other types of polearms that there's too many to list. But if you just look them up,
there's heaps there, and the war scythe is one of them. The thing is, though, there's actually
another historical weapon that, in terms of shape and proportions, it matches quite closely
what this thing is here, the cliché scythe, the death scythe. That's not a real agricultural scythe
because it's just made for blades and stuff like that. So what weapon is this? Well, it's called
the bec de corbin, or the war pick. And it's pretty... the name explains itself quite adequately.
It's a polearm weapon, long shaft, with a pick on the end. Except, again, this was made for combat.
It wasn't made to mirror a real scythe. It has no blade on the bottom or top end. It's a pick.
And because it's a pick, you don't need something so long, which will add unnecessary weight.
And it doesn't really increase its functionality at all. It's as long as it needs to be to be
effective, but no longer. And so the bec de corbin, or war pick, the actual spike only
comes out to about this far, sometimes even shorter. But my goodness, with the leverage that
you can get from a big pole weapon with a pick on the end, right? Wow! The penetrative power and
just the deadliness of this weapon is crazy. And we see spikes like this put on many other
polearm weapons, kind of combining the uses. So, for instance, the halberd has an axe head on one
end, and on the other side, we see a big old spike. Well, the bec de corbin is actually kind
of... takes one thing from the classic halberd and one thing from the classic poleaxe. Because
with a poleaxe, you have an axe head and a hammer head on the other side. Well, generally, with a
bec de corbin, you'll have a spike on one end and a hammer on the other. And so there is a danger
with... even if you were to, say, use a classic kind of spike scythe kind of thing like this, and it
wasn't a true war pick where it was longer and stuff, you'd be using it in almost the exact
same fashion as one another. They're about the same. And there is a potential weakness that you
can get with either one. And it's the weakness of, you know, picks and spikes like this, is that it
gets stuck in the opponent, especially if they're wearing metal armour. This is the thing. People say
that weapons like the bec de corbin, or even the spike on halberds and everything, were universally
used to get through metal armour. Yes and no. You see, there are high chances that it can pierce
metal armour, but generally, it'll only puncture the metal depending on how strong the metal is.
Because sometimes the metal is much lower quality, so it'll be able to penetrate much deeper. But if
it's a good quality metal armour breastplate and stuff, it only penetrates about this much. And
then they have padding underneath, and it actually doesn't really injure the wearer. And even if it
does, it's only a tiny little puncture wound. It's not big. They'll bleed a little bit, but
definitely not fatal, right? And then there's a big problem that usually results out of trying to
strike the metal plates of armour with a weapon like the bec de corbin, or the spikes on halberds,
and even poleaxes and stuff, is that they get stuck in the metal. It gets jammed. The metal, you know,
doesn't want to push aside. So there's a lot of friction when it gets jammed in from a big swing.
And more often than not, you can't pull it out. You've almost disarmed yourself. You're trying to
pull it out. The person will be standing there fine, and they can attack you, and you don't have a weapon.
And so, to save yourself from that, that is why, in my opinion, they have a hammer on the other end.
Because a hammer can do devastating strikes against metal armour, and you don't have to worry
about it getting stuck in the armour. Does that mean you would never use the pic, or not at all?
Because there are other types of armour that have far less, you know, chances of you, the weapon,
the pic part, getting stuck in, like gambeson. And when it comes to a weapon like a bec de corbin,
that would be able to do some pretty good damage to a gambeson, especially with a good swing.
Mail, as well. Piercing strikes have a much higher chance of penetrating mail. And so a weapon like
a war pic, which is really what the classic scythe is, kind of, it really, that's what the classic
scythe is, except it's much longer. It has a useless blade on the bottom, and you can't really use.
It's essentially a war pic. It's actually not a scythe. It's more, it's got more in common with a
war pic, or a bec de corbin, than the actual war scythe from history. That's kind of interesting.
But there are some armour types, even metal plated armour types, that even if you get a small amount
of penetration on, you could still kill someone. And it's not like on the breastplate. It's on
helmets, okay? Even if you penetrate a helmet by that much, and you're able to strike the skull
and fracture the skull, that can be game over right then. That's a full-on debilitating attack.
And so one of the main targets for a war pic like this would be helmets. Absolutely. And they would
have much greater chance at penetrating and subverting the whole protective purpose of a
helmet in and of itself. And the head is one of the most vulnerable parts. That's one of the main
areas you don't want to get hit, especially by a weapon that has chances of penetrating it. And so
that's what you rely on. This is basically a headshot, insta-kill weapon. And it's not guaranteed
that you're going to penetrate the helmet in all circumstances. But even if you don't penetrate it,
all that force is concentrated on such a, you know, small area. So much force is getting transferred
onto the helmet. And then even if it doesn't penetrate, all that blunt force is knocking.
And if you get knocked on the head so much that your brain then sloshes around and hits the inside
of your skull, concussion, you're down. And if you're incapacitated in a battle, you're dead.
Yep. So there we go. There's kind of three sides of this discussion of a scythe used in combat.
One, it was an agricultural scythe. And yes, they were used in combat. There's even a treatise
depicting it. Two, the real proper war scythes were actually quite different to what the standard
classic scythe that you see depicted. And the weapon that has most in common with this classic
scythe isn't a scythe at all, but a war pick, or the Bectacorbin. So there we go. Very interesting
subject cover. I hope you have enjoyed. And of course, I hope to see you again. So until that
time, farewell.
