Plunder, war, and the Horses of San Marco

Roman Stoneworks
4 followers
1 Video ViewยทMay 29, 2024
For thousands of years, during times of war,
art has been seized by the victor
and used as trophies of their victory.
The idea of, to the victor go the spoils,
this goes back thousands of years.
One of the most fascinating examples of this
are the four horses that have come to be known
as the Horses of San Marco.
And these horses served as war booty
at least twice, maybe even three times.
And this makes them a great case study
for talking about works of art seized during times of war.
Let's go see them.
We're in the Basilica of St. Mark in Venice.
The church is itself a jewel,
but it contains real treasures as well.
Up on the second floor now are four horses.
So these were in Constantinople,
and when they were brought here to Venice,
they were put outside this cathedral,
but today copies are there.
The detail on the horses is magnificent.
The understanding of the horses' movement.
You can see their veins, their muscles,
rippling under their skin.
And look at the way that their heads turn
in relationship to each other.
Originally, they would have been gilded.
They would have gleamed with gold.
And pulled a chariot.
And from the beginning,
they were associated with the idea of conquest,
of empire, of the emperor, of victory.
Let's just quickly review the story of the horses.
We think that the horses may go all the way back
to ancient Greece.
In fact, there's a tradition that states
that they were produced by the famous
Hellenistic sculptor, Lysippos.
Now, we don't know that for certain,
but it's a story that's long been attached
to these horses.
Well, and that's because of their incredible beauty
that one immediately associated them
with one of the greatest ancient Greek
Hellenistic sculptors.
They may also date from a slightly later period
from ancient Rome.
By the early 13th century, however,
we're on firmer footing.
We know that the horses were in Constantinople
until at least 1204.
This was a year that Western European crusaders
attacked the city of Constantinople.
The crusaders intended to liberate Jerusalem,
but instead they attacked Christians in Constantinople
in order to pay off a debt to the Venetians.
And brought the horses,
as well as a lot of other treasure,
back to Venice.
Now, the horses remained in Venice
for more than 500 years.
We're in Paris at the Musรฉe du Louvre
looking out at a triumphal arch
that was built by Napoleon Bonaparte.
And if we look closely at that triumphal arch,
we'll see copies of the horses of San Marco.
Now, we should say that the original horses
once stood here, and we'll get to that story.
In the late 18th century,
a young French general, Napoleon Bonaparte,
was leading brilliant military campaigns across Europe.
Now, this is shortly after the French Revolution
when France has overturned the monarchy,
and so we have a new period emerging.
The French Revolutionary Army
took unprecedented amounts of art and manuscripts
from across Europe.
Napoleon even brought experts with him
on his military campaigns
to help him identify works of art
that he could bring back to Paris.
And the idea was to make Paris the new Rome,
the cultural capital of Europe.
And the seizing of artwork
was actually written into the treaties
that the defeated rulers were forced to sign with Napoleon.
And so there was this veneer of legality,
but what Napoleon was doing
was what victorious generals had always done,
which is the idea of to the victor go the spoils.
As the conquering general,
you have a right traditionally to spoils,
to the artwork of the defeated country.
And while this was a common practice since ancient times,
there have been important voices against looting
or at least profligate looting,
for example, Cicero.
But what emerges during this period
is a new understanding of works of art
and their place as booty during wartime.
And one of the reasons for that
is that Napoleon seized the most important art in Europe
for one location.
For the museum we're standing in, the Louvre,
he sees, for example, the Lacoine, the Dying Gaul,
some of the most famous paintings,
Rubens' Descent from the Cross.
The Apollo Belvedere,
which was seen as perhaps
the greatest ancient sculpture of all time.
Keep in mind that what Napoleon intended to do
was to create an encyclopedic museum,
a museum where works of art
from all the nations of Europe could be seen.
But he was also intending that this museum
be a statement of his military brilliance
and a testament to the brilliance and power of France.
Having the most important works of art
from Europe in your capital
made you the leader of Europe.
We may not think of works of art
as having that kind of power anymore,
but they did in the 18th and 19th century.
Let's recapture for a moment
the tremendous excitement that existed in Paris
when the works of art
finally made their way up to the Louvre.
A grand procession into the city of Paris
was organized to celebrate this triumph.
Interestingly, the only works of art
to be uncreated and to be displayed in this procession
were the Horses of San Marco.
And to celebrate his military victories,
Napoleon commissioned the very arch
we're standing and looking at from the Louvre.
And he had the Horses from San Marco
placed on top of this arch,
the Arc de Triomphe du Carousel.
Of course, seizing works of art
created enormous despair throughout Europe.
But even in France, there were dissenting voices.
There was a petition from several dozen artists,
including the great painter Jacques-Louis David,
protesting Napoleon's seizure of works of art.
Now, of course, Napoleon is defeated in 1815,
and immediately the countries
that had works of art stolen from them
began to demand their return.
Now, it's not traditional
to send back works of art in this case.
The Duke of Wellington,
the general who was most responsible
for defeating Napoleon,
came from Great Britain,
which had had no works of art stolen by France.
But he looked on the great treasures
that had been amassed at the Louvre
and decided to do something extraordinary.
He decided to return the works
to their countries of origin.
He could have said
that those works now belong to Britain.
And in fact, there were members of the government
who considered at least selecting some of them
to bring back to England.
But in the end, about half of them
were returned to their country of origin.
And Wellington even took the extraordinary step
of paying for the cost of repatriating works
to the Vatican,
since the Pope didn't have the money on hand
to do it himself.
What's really fascinating is that
since not all of the works were returned,
some of them are here still in the Louvre today.
For example, works by artists like
Cimabue and Giotto.
So this is a really good reminder
that when we walk through museums,
there are really complicated
and often fascinating stories
behind the way that a work of art
came to a museum.
And it's interesting to think about
what a museum decides to display
on the plaque beside the painting
and what it decides to leave off.
Now we want to end with a quote
from an architectural theorist
who really began to think through
the legal and ethical issues
of removing works of art
from their place of origin.
He wrote,
The museum which is Rome
is also composed fully
as much of places, of sites,
of mountains, of quarries,
of ancient roads,
of the placing of ruined towers,
of geographical relationships,
of the inner connections
of all of these objects to each other,
of memories, of local traditions,
of still prevailing customs,
of parallels and comparisons
which can only be made
in the country itself.
That's such a lovely argument
for repatriating works of art
to their country of origin.
And the horses of San Marco
were repatriated,
but they were repatriated back to Venice
where they had been for hundreds of years,
even if it wasn't their original home.
Piano music
