Of Mîm & the Dwarf’s Curse | Of The Children of Húrin: Tolkien's First Age Explained - Part 4 of 13

Basically Dwarves
3 followers
2 Video Views·May 29, 2024
Once upon a time, there lived in Middle-earth a very different type of dwarves.
A darker type. Relics of an older world that are, by the time of this story, almost entirely
extinct. Almost gone from Middle-earth forever. But not cool.
Maja Govanen Melanin and welcome to another instalment in this series explaining and
breaking down Tolkien's epic first age tale of the Children of Túrin. In the last video,
we explored Túrin's time among the outlaws of the wilderness, the Wolfmen, the Gaurwaith,
whom Túrin has now become the captain of. It is Túrin's hope that he might redeem these Gaurwaith
and reforge the gang of outlaws into a fighting force of his own. A group of warriors in the wild
to resist the rising tide of Morgoth's dominion.
So in this video, I will continue the tale of Túrin and the Wolfmen and I'll check back in
with Túrin's epic elven buddy Beleg Cuthalion, who returned to Doriath alone after Túrin pridefully
refused to accept the pardon of his foster father, High King Eluthingol. However, just before I get
back to our main characters, there is a new character that I want to take a moment to
introduce. Because not only is this guy a fascinating and unique individual, he represents
one of the final vestiges of an older world. He is a living relic, a persistent piece of the past
belonging to a long forgotten people. And by the end of his life, he will be the very last of his
kind. So this guy's name is Mim. But in order to understand who Mim is and where he came from,
we first need to take a look at a particularly peculiar group of ancient beings whom Tolkien
called the Petty Dwarves. Now, the Petty Dwarves, or the Nibin Nogrim as they are known in the
Sindarin tongue, are quite a bit different from the other dwarves of Beleriand and the rest of
Middle-earth. They are not of Túrin's folk, but they are also not accounted among the Firebeards,
or the Broadbeams, or any other clan of dwarves in Middle-earth. Instead, they are very much their
own thing. But that wasn't always the case. A great deal of the specifics surrounding the Petty
Dwarves are steeped in mystery, and Tolkien even wrote,
Long out of mind, little was known of them even in days of old.
But we are given just enough information to draw some pretty interesting conclusions.
So, first question, where exactly did these Petty Dwarves come from? Well, they came, some said,
of dwarves that had been banished from the Dwarf Cities of the East in ancient days.
But, although it might seem that these Dwarf Cities in the East are a reference to the great
First Age Dwarf Cities of Belegost and Nogrod in the Blue Mountains to the east of Beleriand,
I don't actually think this is the case. We know that the Petty Dwarves were in Beleriand
before either Nogrod or Belegost were delved, and so I would speculate that the Dwarf City
from which the ancestors of the Petty Dwarves were banished was, potentially, Khazad-dûm.
Anyway, regardless of where exactly they came from, it's actually even more difficult to say
what exactly it was that these Petty Dwarves were banished for. In the relatively newly published
Nature of Middle-earth, Tolkien tells us about dwarves of the strange and sinister kind known
as the Petty Dwarves, in origin, as was later known, descended from dwarves banished for evil
deeds from the great mansions of their kind. There are no details on the specifics of these evil
deeds, but in the Children of Hurin, we are told, the Petty Dwarves loved none but themselves.
If they hated and feared the Orcs, they hated also the Eldar, and the Exiles most of all,
for the Noldor, they said, had stolen their lands and their homes.
So, I think it's fair to say these Petty Dwarves represent a kind of third party in Valeriand.
They are no friends to the bad guys, they are enemies of Mordegoth, but they are also enemies
of the Elves, and they seem to hate what we would call the good guys no less than they hate the
Orcs. So, second question, how are these Petty Dwarves different from the other more famous
dwarves of the First Age, the dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost? Well, after their banishment from
the great dwarf cities of the East, these exiled wicked dwarves wandered westward before the return
of Mordegoth. Being masterless and few in number, they found it hard to come by ore of metals,
and their smithcraft and store of weapons dwindled, and they took to lives of stealth,
and became somewhat smaller in stature than their eastern kin, walking with bent shoulder and quick
furtive steps. Nonetheless, as all the dwarf kind, they were far stronger than their stature promised,
and they could cling to life in great hardship. Furthermore, in the War of the Jewels,
we are told the great dwarves, the dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost, despised the Petty Dwarves,
who were, it is said, the descendants of dwarves who had left, or been driven out from the
communities, being deformed or undersized, or slothful and rebellious. However, what I find
really interesting about these Petty Dwarves is that Tolkien basically leaves it up to us,
the readers, to decide whether they are, like, malicious villains, or simply misunderstood
victims. There is plenty of evidence to support both of these seemingly contradictory
interpretations. As I've mentioned in earlier videos, when the Sindar Elves first encountered
these Petty Dwarves in the wild, they did not know that they were incarnate beings,
and the Elves actually hunted and killed these Petty Dwarves, believing them to be animals.
Now, in that earlier video, when I first mentioned this, a few people asked the very good but also
kinda grizzly question, does that mean the Elves ate the Petty Dwarves after they'd been hunted?
Well, we aren't given an absolute answer, but from what we are told, I would say no. Tolkien
wrote that the Sindar only became aware of the existence of the Petty Dwarves,
indeed when they attacked the Eldar by stealth at night. The Eldar therefore thought that they
were a kind of cunning two-legged animals. But after the Eldar had made the acquaintance of the
Naugreen, that's like regular dwarves, the two-legged animals were recognised as a variety
of dwarves and were left alone. And eventually, the other dwarves, those great dwarves,
made peace with the Sindar and they acknowledged that the Petty Dwarves had never declared
themselves to the Eldar, but had at once attacked the newcomers in darkness and ambush.
So, my interpretation of this isn't that the Elves hunted the Petty Dwarves for meat,
or for sport, as a hunter might hunt deer, but rather they hunted them for protection,
as a shepherd might hunt wolves. Either way though, by the time the Sindar realised their
mistake and stopped hunting these little dwarflets, the Petty Dwarves were pretty close to extinct.
And at the time of this story, now at last they had dwindled and died out of Middle-earth,
all save Meem and his two sons. And Meem was old, even in the reckoning of dwarves, old
and forgotten. But the third question to answer before we move on is, what did these Petty Dwarves
contribute to Beleriand before the return of Mordegoth and the coming of the Noldor?
Well, the answer to that is, quite a lot. Scattered all around Beleriand, there are a
number of long-abandoned ruins that were originally delved by these ancient Petty Dwarves.
Within the hill of Amon Ruth, there are caves known in the language of the Petty Dwarves
as Shabhund, which I will talk a lot more about just a little later in this video,
but the most iconic of all the Petty Dwarves' former dwellings are the caves above the river
Narog that were once called Nullukisdin. Long before the coming of the Noldor,
the dwarves of these halls had dwindled and mostly died out. But when the super awesome,
amazingly wonderful Noldorin prince Finrod Felagund came to this part of the world and
found these long-forgotten caves, he repurposed them into a secret Elvish stronghold that he
called Nargothrond. But it is worth pointing out that this incredibly important secret Elvish
kingdom of Nargothrond was built within the ruins of a far older delving that was founded by these
Petty Dwarves. And in the nature of Middle-earth, we are actually told that Finrod Felagund
established Nargothrond with the aid of the very few Petty Dwarves that remained there.
We are told that super wonderful Finrod Felagund rewarded the Petty Dwarves very generously,
but it turns out their friendship was feigned. And in the end, the leader of the Petty Dwarves
tried to murder Finrod in his sleep. And the reason that I mention this is because it just so happens
that this treacherous Dwarven chief who tried to murder the loveliest elf ever to live,
at least in my opinion, was none other than Mim, the guy I'm going to spend a lot of time talking
about in this video. In fact, it was for the attempted murder of Finrod Felagund that Mim
and his sons were driven out into the wild. Now, if, like me, you consider Finrod Felagund to be
one of the most delightful characters that Tolkien ever wrote, then surely the fact that this Mim
guy tried to murder him in his sleep cements Mim pretty clearly as a villain. And yet, bizarrely,
it's just not that simple. Mim the Petty Dwarf is a character who existed in Tolkien's imagination
for an incredibly long time. As I've already explained, the tale of Turin is the germ from
which the entire legendarium grew, and it was a story that Tolkien worked on for pretty much his
entire adult life. The first draft was penned around 1917, and he was still working on this
story at the time of his death in 1973. And so, this character changed a lot in Tolkien's mind
over the course of his life. In some of the earliest versions of the legendarium, dwarves
were wicked, and in many instances, straight up villainous creatures. But, as we of course know,
dwarves ended up changing dramatically as the legendarium evolved, and Mim's characterization
is, I think, a good example of how dwarves eventually grew from sinister villains into
a proud and heroic branch of the free peoples. As subsequent drafts of Turin's tale were written
and rewritten, Mim the Petty Dwarf evolved into a much more nuanced and a much more morally complex
character. There is a 26 line poem of Tolkien's that's never actually been officially published
in English, and it's not super easy to find, but the English translation of the title is
The Complaint of Mim the Dwarf. And although the poem is pretty impossible to accurately date,
and it's only officially available to read in German, although I will put a link to an unofficial
English translation in the description below, it does massively humanize the character of Mim.
We see the extent to which this guy is old and lonely, and we see how he struggles so hard with
forgiveness. If he could forgive, he would feel young again, and he would be able to craft all
the wonderful things that he made in his youth. But Mim cannot forgive. The embers still smoulder
in his heart. However, it is definitely worth pointing out that a great deal of what we know
about Mim comes from writings that Tolkien never intended to be published. It is an absolute
privilege to get to read these writings, but for that reason I think we ought to tread a little bit
more carefully around this character. He is not like Frodo or Gandalf or Bilbo, he is a fascinating
facet of Tolkien's lifelong process. But I don't think we can say that yes, this given version of
Mim's character is the true canon version. Such things are just too simplistic for the complexities
of Tolkien's creative process, and there's nothing we can do except make peace with that.
That being said though, I do think there are some similarities between the moral arc of Mim's
character and the moral arc of Gollum. In many ways they are totally different, but both Mim and
Gollum do absolutely awful things, neither of them really do achieve redemption in the end,
and yet both are incredibly pitiable. Despite their actions, we want to like them. We want to
see Frodo metaphorically save Gollum's soul, and we want to see Turin do the same for Mim.
Anyway, that was a pretty lengthy introduction, but it was necessary because we've now arrived at
the point where Mim, the petty dwarf, enters into the tale of the children of Turin.
So, it's now been two years since Turin left his home in Doriath and became an outlaw of the wild,
and by now he is 22 years old. He is the captain of the Gaurwaith, but he is known to them
only as Nathan the Rond. And after the departure of Beleg Cuthalion, which I talked about in the
last video, Turin's band of outlaws are once again falling under hard times. Rains lash the land
out of season, and orcs come down from the north in ever greater numbers. More often than not,
the Gaurwaith were hunted rather than hunters, and as the weather turned colder and summer faded
away, Turin realised that his outlaws desperately needed to find a secure refuge of their own
before the coming cruelty of winter. Anyway, one grey and rainy day, the Gaurwaith's lookout
spots three small shadows moving stealthily among the stones. Turin orders the three shapes to halt,
but as he cries out, they bolt into the darkness. Androg the Archer, Turin's second-in-command and
his sort-of-friend, looses an arrow at one of the shapes, but two of the three vanish into the dusk.
However, the third one, the oldest, the slowest, the one who lagged behind, he is seized by the
outlaws, thrown down and held by many hard hands. The captive struggles, and he bites the outlaws
like a beast and he draws blood from Androg's hand, and Androg declares to his fellow Gaurwaith
that this creature is either an orc or of orc kin. Either way, they ought to kill it. But their
captain Turin tells them no. He alone recognises that this captive they've taken is in fact a dwarf,
old and poor, but not an orc, and undeserving of death. The outlaws wish to rob the dwarf and steal
whatever he may be carrying in his sack, but Turin stops them from doing this too. He addresses the
old dwarf and he gives him an opportunity to speak on his own behalf. And thus, Mim, the petty dwarf,
comes face to face with Turin, son of Hurin. Mim kneels at Turin's feet and he begs for his life.
He says, I am old and poor. Do not let them slay me, master, for no cause as orcs would.
And at this we once again see Turin's immense capacity for compassion. Pity stirs in his heart
and he shows Mim mercy. However, he also knows that his Gaurwaith are facing hard times,
and this strange dwarf may be able to offer them some sort of respite. Turin says,
Poor you seem, Mim, though that would be strange in a dwarf, but we are poorer, I think,
houseless and friendless men. If I said that we do not spare for pity's sake only,
being in great need, what would you offer for ransom? Now, Mim has no belongings of any great
value and he says to Turin, I do not know what you desire, lord. But Turin looks around at the
bitter wind and rain-swept land and he replies, At this time, little enough. A safe place to
sleep in, out of the damp woods, doubtless you have such for yourself. Mim confirms that yes,
indeed he does, but he cannot give it to the outlaws in ransom for his life, for he is too old
to go back to sleeping under the cold and unfeeling sky. At this, Turin's second-in-command
Androg draws a knife with his uninjured hand and threatens Mim by saying, You need grow no older.
I can spare you that. When Mim sees Androg's blade, he clings to Turin's knees in great fear
and says, Lord, if I lose my life, you lose the dwelling, for you will not find it without Mim.
I cannot give it, but I will share it. To which Turin replies, Your life is spared,
Mim, till we come to his lair, at least, Androg adds. But Turin turns around and rebukes his
second-in-command. He says, If Mim brings us to his home without trickery, and it is good,
then his life is ransomed, and he shall not be slain by any man who follows me. So I swear.
Then Mim kisses Turin's knees and says, Mim will be your friend, Lord. At first he thought you were
an elf by your speech and your voice, but if you are a man, that is better. Mim does not love elves.
Now, I don't want to over-make this point, the comparison only goes so far,
but I do think there is a significant likeness between Turin's relationship with Mim in this
moment and Frodo's relationship with Gollum when they meet in the Emyn wheel. In both cases,
the protagonist displays pity whilst being told to do the opposite. The grovelling creature makes
a promise of friendship and, without wanting to spoil what's about to happen, in both cases,
the meeting turns out to be astoundingly important in the grand scheme of things,
but not necessarily in the most positive way imaginable.
Anyway, the deal is made. Turin and the outlaws will spare the petty dwarf if he leads them to
his home. But, a little bit like Sam Gamgee, Androg the Archer absolutely does not trust
this new companion and is thoroughly eager to be rid of him. And, as we will see in a few minutes,
that feeling is entirely mutual. So, Mim leads Turin and the Gaurwaith to his home within the
hill of Amon Ruth, which is a Sindarin name meaning Bald Hill. But, a Sindarin name is not
the original name for this place. As I've already mentioned, in ancient days this hill belonged to
the petty dwarves and in their language it was known as Shabhund. The peak of this hill is
entirely bare save for a great growth of the Saragon plant, which is known for its red flowers.
In fact, what Saragon means in Sindarin is blood of stone. And when the outlaws see the hill from
afar and they see the vast numbers of red flowers atop its peak, Androg comments,
see, there is blood on the hilltop. To which Turin replies with the most foreboding words
imaginable, not yet. As Mim leads the outlaws up the thorny slopes of the hill, he takes them on
secret paths that they themselves could not ever have found on their own. Until, eventually,
the dwarf brings the outlaws to his cave. Although, cave is a bit of an understatement
for what this is. Among the elves, Mim's house was called Bar En Nibin Noeg, which only ancient
tales in Doriath and Nargothrond remembered, and no man had seen. From the outside, it looked like
a cave opening behind trees and near fresh water. But as the outlaws enter and they walk towards
the back of the cave, they find that it has been deepened and bored far under the hill by the slow
hands of the petty dwarves in the long years that they had dwelt there. When Mim enters his
underground home, he claps his hands and immediately another dwarf appears holding a torch.
Mim addresses this other dwarf in their own language and Androg, obviously, considers this
to be an act of war. He charges forward shouting, attack first, there may be a hive of them.
But once again, Torin tells him no, that's crazy, and instead he renames the house of Mim Bar En
Danwed, which means the house of ransom. It is Torin's intent that he and his outlaws will live
alongside Mim and the other petty dwarf at least until the end of winter. But ideally,
if his outlaws can behave themselves for once, these near forgotten dwarven halls inside the
could become their new permanent home, their stronghold against the enemy.
However, when Torin follows Mim through the dark tunnels towards the light of that other
dwarf's torch, he eventually finds himself in a small but lofty hall, and there Mim kneels on the
ground. Beside him stands the dwarf with the torch, and against the far wall lies a third
dwarf, Kym, son of Mim. This is the dwarf that Androg shot in the dark.
When Mim sees what's become of his son Kym, he wails and he tears at his beard. Torin offers to
lend his skill at healing, in the hopes that perhaps the elvish arts he learned in Doriath
might save Kym's life, but it's too late. When he asks Mim, may I help you, the old dwarf turns
his head and Torin sees a red light in his eyes. Not unless you can turn back time and cut off
the cruel hands of your men. This is my son. An arrow was in his breast. Now he is beyond speech.
He died at sunset. In this moment of sorrow, pity, long hardened once again wells up in Torin's heart
like water from a rock. He says he would recall the arrow if he could, and he tells Mim Baran
Danweth, House of Ransom. This shall be called in truth, for whether you dwell here or no,
I shall hold myself in your debt. And if ever I come to any wealth, I will pay you a Danweth
of heavy gold for your son, in token of sorrow. Within Dwarven culture and through the moral
lens of their people, this is an incredibly honourable and venerable thing for Torin to say.
Mim even acknowledges it. He tells Torin, you speak like a dwarf lord of old, and at that I
marvel. My own ransom I will pay therefore. You may dwell here if you will. However,
although Mim does seem to have a highly decent amount of respect for Torin, he does not feel
the same way about the rest of the Gaur wife, and Androg in particular, you know, the guy who shot
and killed his son, he Mim cannot ever forgive. In fact, after making peace with Torin, Mim lays
a curse upon Androg, a Dwarvish curse, something that we don't see very much of throughout Tolkien's
writings, but it plays an important part in this story. Mim says, for all to hear,
he that loosed the shaft shall break his bow and his arrows, and leave them at my son's feet.
And he shall never take an arrow, nor bear a bow again. If he does, he shall die by it,
that curse I lay on him. And so, with great fear of this curse, Androg the Archer does indeed
break his bow and his arrows, and with great grudge, he lays them at Keen's feet. However,
this does nothing to mend the rift between him and Mim. In fact, if anything, the bad blood between
them is now worsened, and Androg takes every opportunity to remind the outlaws just how
untrustworthy Mim is, just how dangerous it is to keep him around, and he even utters a curse
of his own. May the Dwarf die with a dart in his throat. I cannot stress this enough, Androg hates
Mim. Mim hates Androg. And the fact that they both kind of like Taurine is the only reason
that they haven't yet tried to kill each other. Anyway, this video's been going for over half an
hour now, and I have yet to even mention the absolute legend that is Beleg Cuthalion, which
I think demonstrates an immense degree of self-control on my part, but the time has finally
come to remedy that. Last time we saw wonderful Beleg Cuthalion, he returned to the woodland
kingdom of Doriath alone, after Taurine refused to join him in the battles on the North Marches,
where Mordegoth's orcs are ever-multiplying and ever-growing in daring. So, Beleg does what
Beleg does best. He fights the bad guys, and he saves the day. But when winter begins to bite
again, and the orcs retreat from the guarded realm, Beleg leaves Dimbar too. And with the
threat of Mordegoth stayed, at least for a while, Beleg returns into the South, back into the wild,
towards the hill of Amon Ruth, where Taurine told him to seek him out. However, before doing that,
Beleg returns to Doriath's capital, Menegroth, where he has one last interaction with the High
King Elu-Thingol and his Divine Queen, Melian the Maia. And in so doing, Beleg is given an
incredibly awesome gift by Queen Melian herself. When Beleg explains his last meeting with Taurine
and his intent to continue his quest by finding him again, Melian gifts to Beleg a store of
lembas, the waybread of the elves. Now, on the one hand, bread might not seem like the most
amazing gift of all time, but this is a huge deal. In all of Middle-earth's history, we only know of
three people who are able to make this bread, and all three of those people are exceptional women.
The first ever lembas was baked back during the Age of Starlight, during the Great Migration of
the Elves from the Uttermost East towards the Uttermost West, and it was baked by Yavanna herself,
one of the mightiest of the Valar, kind of like a goddess of nature and plants and animals and all
growing things. And Yavanna made the first lembas from magical corn that only grew in the blessed
realm of Valinor. By the way, in this context, corn does not mean maize, it's just a general term for
various wheats and oats and barley. Anyway, at this time, the only known person in Middle-earth
who can bake lembas is Yavanna's star pupil, Melian the Maia. According to the customs of the elves,
the keeping and the giving of lembas can only be done by a queen, and in nothing did Melian show
greater favour than in this gift. And I imagine that this information concerning an immensely
powerful woodland queen of an elvish realm giving a gift of lembas to someone before they set out
on a dangerous quest is certainly going to sound familiar. Because, of course, the third and final
confirmed baker of lembas in Middle-earth's history is Galadriel. Now, Galadriel is not a part
of this story, I don't want to derail what's going on right now with an unnecessary tangent.
Also, in the words of Christopher Tolkien, there is no part of the history of Middle-earth more
full of problems than the story of Galadriel and Celeborn. But, if you're curious to know what
these two were getting up to during this part of the first age, the most consistent answer
is that they are hanging out in Doriath, falling in love and building their relationship.
Celeborn is the great nephew of King Elu-Fingol, and Galadriel is the great niece of Elu-Fingol
through a different brother. After arriving in Middle-earth, Galadriel seems to bow out of the
drama that the rest of her family become so embroiled in, and instead she remains behind
the scenes in Doriath, watching and learning from her queen and her teacher, Melian the Meyer.
Galadriel is taking her first steps on the road towards becoming the next all-powerful,
lembas-giving lady of a guarded elvish wood. This is the beginning of Galadriel's transition
into the new Melian, into the Galadriel we all know and love from the Lord of the Rings.
And although this is nowhere stated, I think it's certainly reasonable to speculate that
Galadriel may very well have been present when Melian gifted this lembas to Beleg.
Melian says to Beleg,
This waybred shall be your help in the wild and the winter, and the help also of those whom you
choose. For I commit this now to you, to apportion as you will in my stead.
In other words, what Melian's saying is, here's some lembas Beleg, you can share it with Turin
if you want to, or not, totally up to you. Which is a huge deal, because at this point,
no mortal has ever tasted lembas before. What Melian's giving here is an utterly unique gift.
Anyway, that's probably enough of a tangent about bread. Beleg takes this gift, and he also
takes the dragon helm of Dor-Lomin, the helmet of Turin's ancestors. And he brings them both
with him on his quest into the south. A quest to once again find Turin in the wilderness,
and hopefully, this time, to stay with him.
So, getting back to Turin and Mim and the Gaurwaith in Amon Ruth, now that the outlaws have
a semi-permanent abode, things are finally starting to go quite well.
Over the span of a spring, and a summer, and an autumn, Turin's friendship with Mim grows deeper.
They seem to truly respect and appreciate each other. Turin spends a great deal of time atop
the peak of Amon Ruth looking out at the lands before him, and to the east he sees the woodlands
of Doria, to the west the guarded realm of Nargothrond, to the north the forest of Brethil,
and far, far away, on the distant horizon, he can just make out the mountains of shadow
that lie between the wild and his childhood home of Dor-Lomin, where his mother and his sister
still dwell beneath the boot heels of tyrant Easterlings. For a long while, the life of
the outlaws went well to their liking, and although under normal circumstances food would
be incredibly difficult to find in abundance atop a hill of stone, Mim the dwarf shares with the
Gaurwaith some of his food. Because unknown to men and elves, there is a type of fleshy root
that grows in these lands, which are good to eat when boiled. Mim refers to this food as
earth bread, and because of his knowledge, the outlaws now have plenty of food,
plenty of shelter, and more space than they know what to do with, for the endless caves of Barr
and Danwed could house a hundred or more at need. Before long, the Gaurwaith had entirely given up
on their previous way of life. They went on no more raids against mortal men, and although they
did not particularly enjoy sharing their home with its original owners, Mim and his surviving son,
who's called Ibun, that's the only other petty dwarf left in the world, but it is better than the
alternative. Of all the outlaws, only Androg is truly ill-contented. His mutual hatred for Mim
has only grown over the span of these two years, and he just can't shake his certainty that the
petty dwarf is up to something sinister. One dip. Androg is wandering through the many tunnels and
caves of Barr and Danwed, and he stumbles upon a secret hidden stair leading from Mim's house
up to the flat summit of Amon Lu. But he keeps this information to himself, for while Androg's
distrust of the dwarf continues to grow, so too does Turin's trust of him.
As months and eventually seasons pass, Turin becomes ever more friendly with Mim, and the
two of them frequently sit together and take counsel for long hours at a time. However,
when another autumn passes into another winter, the good times begin to take a turn.
In these days of Morgoth's dominion, as the strength of Angband grows, each winter comes
colder and crueler than the last. By midwinter, Amon Ruth is covered in snow. Hunger haunts the
If you're keeping track, it has now been four years since Turin left Doriath. He was 21 years
old when he killed that Fordweck guy and became captain of the Gaurwaith, he was 22 at the
beginning of this video when he met Mim, and by this midwinter that I'm talking about now, he is
24, turning 25 in the coming March. It's been three and a half years since Turin last laid
eyes upon his beloved Beleg Cuthalion. But it is during these darkest days of winter,
when the fortune of the outlaws is at its lowest ebb, that a stranger suddenly appears upon the
slopes of Amon Ruth. He is tall and strong and cloaked in white, and by the time the watchmen
of the Gaurwaith are aware of him, he's already arrived at their camp. Thus it was, that Beleg
Cuthalion's wisdom yielded to his love. And potentially, against his better judgement,
he returned to his best friend Turin. And Beleg brought with him gifts. Lembas for the outlaws,
but he also brings another gift that is meant for Turin alone. The dragon helm of Dor-Lomin,
the dwarf-forged helmet that once belonged to Hador himself, and now rightfully belongs to
the current chieftain of the House of Hador, Turin, son of Hurin. When Turin looks again upon
his beloved Beleg, he is conflicted. On the one hand, he is delighted to see him, for he had
often regretted his stubbornness. But there is still a part of him that's reluctant to accept
any kind of pardon or aid or charity out of Doriath. He gladly accepts the dragon helm,
for that is his by right, but when Beleg offers him some of Melian's lembas, Turin says,
The helm of my fathers I will take, with good will, for your keeping, but I will not receive
gifts out of Doriath. But to this, Beleg gives Turin an absolutely epic and entirely necessary
piece of tough love. He says to Turin, Then send back your sword, and your arms. Send back also
the teaching and fostering of your youth, and let your men, who you say have been faithful,
die in the desert to please your moon. Nonetheless, this waybread was a gift not to you,
but to me, and I may do with it as I will. Eat it not, if it sticks in your throat,
but others may be more hungry and less proud. Now, if Turin were a different type of anti-hero,
I reckon he'd probably get angry and double down and try to defend himself,
but he doesn't. What he does instead is, I think, really quite endearing.
After Beleg calls him out for his ridiculous attitude towards bread, Turin's eyes glinted,
but as he looked in Beleg's face, the fire in them died. I wonder, friend, he says,
that you deign to come back to such a churl. From you, I will take whatever you give, even
rebuke. Now, churl is a relatively archaic word that pertains to a rude or mean-spirited person,
and deign means to do something that one considers beneath one's dignity. So what Turin's basically
saying here is, yeah, okay, I am being a bit of a jerk, but you Beleg are just too good for me.
And as I'm sure by now you will not be surprised to hear, Beleg's response to Turin's sort of
apology and his self-reflection is simply to be the loveliest, kindest, and most wonderful
friend in the world. He finally agrees to stay with Turin and the Outlaws, and in the days that
followed, Beleg laboured much for the good of the company. Those that were hurt or sick he tended,
and they were quickly healed, for in those days the Grey Elves were wise in the ways of life
and all living things, and they had many arts beyond the reach of men. Moreover, Beleg the
was great among the people of Doriath, he was strong and enduring and farsighted in mind as
well as eye, and at need he was valiant in battle, relying not only upon the swift arrows of his long
bow, but also upon his great sword. Basically, just by spending time among the Gaurwaith,
Beleg has pretty single-handedly doubled the bad-assery of the Gaurwaith. For the first time
since Turin was a teenager, he and Beleg are finally reunited for the foreseeable future.
Once again, they are fighting together, they are living side by side, and they are united in
common cause. As we will see in the next video, Beleg and Turin are growing into one of the
ultimate sets of friends in the entire First Age. The dragon helm and the strong bow.
Unbelievably awesome. However, as great as this may sound, not everyone in Amon Ruth is
happy about it. Androg the archer has never been a friend of Beleg's, and now that the elf is
taking secret counsel with Androg's best friend Turin, jealousy is beginning to stir in Androg's
heart. But Androg is not the only one who is less than enthusiastic about Beleg joining the Outlaws,
and as it goes, the only thing that Androg has in common with his nemesis Meme the Petty Dwarf
is that they both want to be rid of the elf. However, whereas Androg is motivated by a
relatively trivial type of jealousy, Meme is motivated by a much more profound
hatred. Meme hates all elves, and just like Androg, he is deeply jealous of Beleg's friendship
with Turin. And so, the hatred that Meme bore to Beleg led him now, in his darkened heart,
to an evil resolve. If Meme can't have Turin all to himself, perhaps it's time to be rid of Beleg
and the rest of the Gaurwai. The wrath of Angband is coming for the Outlaws,
and Meme sees a way that this could work to his benefit now.
That is what I'm going to talk about in the next video, and I will also explore the staggering
badassery that is Beleg and Turin united. Two captains. Two astoundingly uncomfortable thorns
in Morgoth's side. The two warriors who will take command in the battle for the fate of the wild.
So, to make sure you don't miss one of the coolest parts of this entire story,
hit subscribe if you haven't already, and be sure to click like and leave a comment on this video
if you enjoyed it. However, until next time, as always, my dear friends,
much love, stay groovy, and nevaer, melanie.
