The Great Pyramid’s Niche of Secrets

TopStrangerThings
9 followers
32 Video Views·May 28, 2024
Welcome to History for Granite.
Join me to explore ancient Egypt.
Together, we'll uncover secrets that only stones from antiquity can reveal.
Please subscribe to the channel to get notified when new videos are published,
and thank you so much for growing the channel.
The Great Pyramid of Giza has been a destination for travelers and explorers since antiquity.
Although the excessive attention this pyramid received
has contributed to its deterioration,
there is the benefit of having many written accounts of its condition throughout history.
One of my favorite kinds of research is studying the writings of travelers
visiting Giza from centuries ago.
It's wonderful to step into their shoes and experience the awe and wonder
of someone who could only see the pyramids first-hand because photography was not yet invented.
When studying the Great Pyramid,
it's only natural to want to begin with the physical evidence that remains today
because that's the most interesting part.
Also, physical evidence carries more weight than the testimonies of strangers.
But Khufu's pyramid has been subjected to so much
violent change over the millennia that one is easily misled into wrong assumptions.
You need a good idea of what transpired on the Giza Plateau in the past
in order to not misinterpret the evidence in front of your eyes.
It's at this point that the work becomes rather discouraging
because you are presented with a laundry list of exploratory missions from the past,
and many of these sources are quite difficult to track down.
Here's an example from Mark Lehner and Zahi Hawass's book,
Giza and the Pyramids, The Definitive History.
Part of me wonders why this list is included, as the information is so minimal
that it doesn't serve to help other researchers track down primary sources.
To me, it feels more like gatekeeping, simply a way of proving their own knowledge.
But if you're going to seriously investigate the Great Pyramid,
studying accounts from the past is essential.
In my opinion, this is the main hurdle that separates the amateurs
with those who have any chance of making a new discovery.
So it was with great delight that Matt from Ancient Architects
recently contacted me with a tip about some new sources from the early 19th century.
Independent researcher Stefan Bergdahl found two separate accounts
of visitors to the Great Pyramid in March and April of 1837.
Bergdahl has a new book on the Great Pyramid, and I've linked it in the description below.
He also has his research published on academia.edu, so I've linked that as well.
Priest Vecino and Prince Hermann von Puckler Musgau both toured inside the Great Pyramid
while Howard Weiss was excavating in the Queen's Chamber in spring of 1837.
Amazingly, both the prince and the priest claimed to have seen a sarcophagus there.
Now, having read many erroneous historical accounts about the Great Pyramid,
I am always prepared to dismiss testimony that widely differs from common knowledge.
Unlike today, the Great Pyramid in centuries past was a very inhospitable place.
It was extremely dank, dusty, full of obstacles, and infested with bats and snakes.
Furthermore, it would only be lit by whatever source of flame you brought with you.
Visitors were not able to scrutinize details of the pyramid's interior the way we can today.
The Great Pyramid in particular would have been a dangerous exploration,
because a fall down the steep Grand Gallery could cause serious injury or death.
But when Matt from Ancient Architects showed me there were two
entirely distinct accounts of a Queen's Chamber sarcophagus,
taken only weeks apart in 1837 when Howard Weiss was working inside,
well, it made the hair stand up on the back of my neck.
Let me say that unlike many other historians, I don't view Weiss in a negative light.
His documentation of his work at the Giza Plateau was unprecedented,
and 44 years ahead of Flinders Petrie, who is considered the father of Egyptology.
From my perspective, however you might view Howard Weiss's methods,
he did set a modern standard for documenting an excavation.
In the centuries since, there have been countless excavations that may have used a gentler touch,
but their documentation was poor, or even worse, never published.
For example, the chambers of Djedefre's pyramid will forever be a mystery,
because a modern excavation of them was never published,
and so now almost all of the evidence is lost.
Yes, Weiss did have some blunders.
Some notable ones are the enormous cavity blown out of the Great Pyramid's southern side,
and the destruction of the floor in the burial chamber of Khafre.
And in hindsight, taking the sarcophagus out of Menkaure's pyramid was not a good decision,
as it is now lost to sea.
But reading Weiss's words and understanding the scale of work that was being carried out,
I don't see a man with malicious intent,
just someone managing a huge project with hundreds of workers,
and doing the best he could with the conditions that were given.
So, an explanation that Stefan Bergdahl provided
about Weiss hiding a secret queen's chamber sarcophagus didn't ring true with me,
but that left the awkward scenario of explaining how two contemporaneous witnesses
both claimed there was one.
It was very gracious of Ancient Architects to share these new accounts with me,
and I felt it was important he get to make the first video with all of his thoughts and ideas.
If you're one of the few people who hasn't watched his video already,
do give it your attention.
Let me contextualize my analysis first,
by saying nobody wants there to have been a queen's chamber sarcophagus more than I.
Much of my research leans towards the queen's chamber being a tentative burial chamber,
and so finding evidence of a sarcophagus would validate many other ideas.
One historical account of a sarcophagus that was never easily dismissed
was that of Al-Idrizi in the 13th century.
But since hundreds of years passed between Al-Idrizi
and the next detailed report on the queen's chamber,
you could always explain its absence as destruction from visitors in the centuries between.
My next instinct when learning of the prince and the priest
claiming to see a sarcophagus in the queen's chamber
is that perhaps it could have been pulled out of the tunnel that is dug within the niche.
It obviously couldn't have been left in the chamber
because many visitors before Weiss did not see it.
Also, finding the sarcophagus under the floor in a pit dug by Weiss
seemed like an unlikely scenario.
Unlike the pit below the niche, Weiss didn't dig the tunnel in the center of it.
That excavation is older than written accounts of the pyramid.
This led me to explore Giovanni Caviglia,
who had been excavating in the Great Pyramid about 20 years before Howard Weiss arrived.
Caviglia was very much a treasure hunter,
and perhaps the first modern person recorded
as having been totally captivated by the monuments of ancient Egypt.
He spent every waking moment on digging campaigns
or soliciting benefactors to help him explore.
He subjected himself to extraordinary physical discomforts,
often just sleeping in whatever empty tomb that was available near a worksite.
These conditions caused him illness and eventually took his life.
Unlike Weiss, Caviglia wasn't interested in thorough documentation or publishing books.
When Weiss first came to Egypt in 1837,
Caviglia's enthusiasm for discovery captivated Weiss to hire him as part of his expedition.
But this partnership was not to last,
and Weiss ended up dismissing Caviglia because he wouldn't do his assigned work
and was always off, quote, digging in mummy pits.
It occurred to me that perhaps prior to Weiss's arrival,
Caviglia had excavated a sarcophagus from the Queen's Chamber tunnel,
and this could be a probable explanation for how one was found.
I couldn't yet explain its disappearance, but it felt like a start.
Even though Caviglia wasn't one to publish research,
he had previously worked with individuals who were interested in publishing.
A notable partner was Henry Salt, who became England's Consul General to Egypt around 1815.
So, in 1817, when Caviglia was digging around in the Great Pyramid,
we have Henry Salt to thank for providing documentation of his work.
An article was published in Antiquities of Egypt Quarterly Review,
Volume 19, which gives plentiful details about Caviglia's excavations.
This is a great example of the unexpected directions research can take you,
for I had not expected to find more information about Caviglia's work
and now I can even show a portrait of him as drawn by Henry Salt.
But alas, Henry Salt explicitly describes Caviglia clearing out the Queen's Chamber
niche tunnel and finding nothing except the graffiti of two European names at the end.
Caviglia also cleared out the rubble in the Queen's Chamber itself,
so a sarcophagus could not have been sitting there all along.
Having eliminated the only probable explanation, I was left in an uncomfortable position.
Pulling a sarcophagus from below the floor just didn't make sense to me,
and even less sense could be made of Weiss secretly disposing of it.
The question of a Queen's Chamber sarcophagus is interesting to modern researchers,
but in Weiss's time, a plain limestone sarcophagus would not have been a big find,
even in the Queen's Chamber of the Great Pyramid.
The Giza Plateau is littered with plain sarcophagi,
and without contextual information, it's just another stone box.
An undecorated limestone box wouldn't be worth stealing for Weiss, even from the Great Pyramid.
After a long weekend of poring over sources and cross-referencing everything,
it was beginning to drive me crazy.
I hadn't yet asked ancient architects for the new primary sources of Vecino and Puckler-Muscao,
because I didn't want to intrude on his project.
But after hitting a dead end with possible explanations,
I requested them, and Matt was gracious enough to share.
It was only after I read the testimony in Priest Vecino's own words that I could connect the dots.
To visitors of the Great Pyramid in 1837,
people who had no knowledge of Egyptian history or monuments,
the squared masonry in the Queen's Chamber niche excavation would appear to be a sarcophagus.
Imagine you're told there's a King's Chamber and a Queen's Chamber.
In the King's Chamber, you see the sarcophagus,
with a hole almost underneath it, and excavations underway.
You then visit the Queen's Chamber, and you're expecting a burial chamber for a queen.
But the only notable things in the room are the niche,
the squared cavity within, and Howard Weiss's men digging a hole underneath them.
You would just assume you were looking at a sarcophagus of a different style.
It was only because of how precise Vecino was with his description
that I could make this connection.
It's very hard to read someone's words from the past
and be able to decisively determine that they're describing something inaccurately.
His description of the sarcophagus is that it's inside the niche,
smaller, made of marble, open and simple, an excavation underneath, and a tunnel above.
Everything fits to the present visual evidence of the squared cavity in the niche.
I'd wager that if you knock against the walls of the cavity,
the long connecting tunnel will make an echo.
This could explain how Vecino describes it as making a hollow sound.
And if you're still skeptical that such a misidentification could be made,
there's enormous precedent for such mistakes in the Great Pyramid.
Even the foremost expert of his time, Flinders Petrie,
thought the granite leaf in the Portcullis Chamber was an unused portcullis slab itself.
When you look at the granite leaf closely, you can see that it's made of two separate blocks
and not seated in a manner that could be lowered without breaking the granite beneath it.
But in the dark gloom of the 19th century and earlier,
it just wasn't practical to scrutinize every last detail of the pyramid.
To err is human.
Another researcher's misidentification that vexed me
is from Charles Piazzi Smith in the 19th century.
He wrote numerous books on the Great Pyramid, and he is a very important reference.
Piazzi Smith repeatedly described the granite plugs in the ascending corridor as a portcullis.
When I was working on my video about the granite fragments from the destroyed portcullis
that were discarded beneath the granite plugs,
Smith's word choice made everything terribly confusing.
With the Queen's Chamber Sarcophagus connection made,
I could now see how other explorers would make the same mistake.
Even though Al Idrisi of the 13th century
says the King's Chamber Sarcophagus and Queen's Chamber Sarcophagus are similar,
that's not enough detail to contradict Vecino's mistake.
Similar could mean anything.
Squared off, or large enough to hold a body.
In all probability, it was the same misidentification.
Arriving at this conclusion was both exciting and disappointing,
for while I had solved this new mystery,
it also put to rest hope of a Queen's Chamber Sarcophagus.
Unless a new testimony can be discovered with enough description
to make it impossible to confuse a sarcophagus with the niche cavity,
I'm going to assume they are the same thing.
If you're honest with yourself about where the evidence takes you,
sometimes it leads to disappointing places.
But there's plenty of mystery remaining,
not the least of which is explaining why exactly there is an
evenly squared section of masonry in the Queen's Chamber niche
that extends for a few meters.
This is not how walls are normally built,
and so it's no wonder that it has been a focal point of explorers
since before written records.
Architect-researcher Gilles Dormian was so captivated by the squared niche excavation
that it led him to believe there must be tunnels or chambers underneath it.
This is the core thesis of his book The Chamber of Cheops.
But while Dormian's books are full of incisive observations and analysis
that you can't find elsewhere,
I do think he's going overboard.
All three of his books on pyramids suggest that hidden chambers of different pharaohs
remain undiscovered,
and surely most people would agree that such a thing is unlikely.
Just because there are anomalies that require explanation,
that doesn't mean the ultimate discovery is there waiting to be uncovered.
Priest Fazzino believed Weiss's pit in the Queen's Chamber floor
was a separate chamber itself,
so perhaps it had squared masonry similar to the niche cavity.
But squared masonry doesn't always mean a hidden chamber,
as earlier explorers who dug the tunnel 55 feet into the niche discovered.
In his book, Weiss mentions finding desert sand in his digs
both at the step near the Queen's Chamber and beneath the chamber niche.
This calls to mind Gilles Dormian's 1986 excavation
in the corridor leading to the Queen's Chamber.
Three drill cores were taken from the wall angling downwards,
and the deepest core sample found sand notably different than the local kind
from the Giza desert.
With the discovery of sand in three separate excavations near the Queen's Chamber,
we have a pattern.
I think it would be worth re-excavating Howard Weiss's dig in the Queen's Chamber floor
just to see if the same anomalous sand is present
that was discovered in the horizontal corridor.
As ancient architects point out,
you wouldn't be causing any damage to the original pyramid by doing so.
It's unlikely that the Egyptian Ministry of Antiquities would undertake such a project,
but they might take a proper scientific inquiry
more seriously than the search for a hidden tomb.
I have my own Queen's Chamber theory that can explain the sand,
the cavities, and numerous other anomalies that I'm saving for a special presentation.
Finally, I want to comment on these few photographs
taken from the Queen's Chamber over 100 years ago.
Probably the most famous one is this taken by the Edgar Brothers
for their 1910 book, The Great Pyramid Passages, Volume 1.
Prior to carefully scrutinizing details about Weiss and Kaviglia's work in the Queen's Chamber,
the appearance of the niche here was always a bit strange.
It looks as if the tunnel through the niche is completely filled up,
so full that loose debris is spilling out of it.
But how could that possibly be if the tunnel is 55 feet deep?
My new interpretation is that the niche cavity looks this way
because of how Howard Weiss finished his work in the Queen's Chamber.
After completing his exploratory digs and filling them in,
being a Victoria-era English gentleman, he had the floor tidally swept up.
The remaining loose debris was piled at the niche cavity entrance,
with the larger blocks left on the floor below.
It's not that the niche tunnel is completely filled,
simply the entrance is covered over, being the closest spot to dispose of rubble and sand.
This series of three photographs taken at the same location shows how the niche looks over time,
the first being taken in 1865 by Charles Piazzi Smith,
the next by the Edgar Brothers in 1910,
and then another probably from the early 20th century.
There's a little disturbance of the rubble,
but it looks as if nobody crawled into the niche tunnel
for most of the 19th and early 20th centuries.
To explore it would have been quite simple,
just shoving some loose fill out of the way, but for a long time it lay undisturbed.
This documentation is a good analogy for thinking
about how the Great Pyramid was probably treated throughout history.
Long periods of almost nothing going on,
interrupted by brief large-scale campaigns of exploration.
For most of history, the inside of the Great Pyramid was a fairly unpleasant space,
and so it took a lot of motivation to give it a proper examination.
We are very fortunate that explorers such as Weiss,
Paring, and Petrie did most of the recent work.
Their splendid job gives us a good understanding
of what evidence could be found within the pyramid in the past two centuries.
And don't worry, there's still plenty more things to be found within.
But don't jump straight to the hidden burial chamber of Khufu,
lest you end up with the same disappointment that has befallen explorers throughout history.
Thanks to everyone who watched this video to the end.
Please subscribe to the channel to see more of this content.
Give a like or comment as you see fit.
And above all, remember to ask your friends if they take their history for granted.
