The United States is steadily being divided as social movement after social movement sweeps across the country, from Black Lives Matter to the protests over the Israel–Hamas war. According to Mike Gonzalez, co-author of “NextGen Marxism,” these protests are actually being fueled by Marxist organizations, which foment ideas that seek to introduce the next iteration of Marxism. One that’s not solely determined by economics and class, but instead by race, ethnicity, sexual identity, and any point of difference that can be exploited.
We speak to Mike Gonzalez about the evolution of Marxism, how it has infiltrated student protests in the United States, and how the end goal of Marxism still remains the same—to destabilize society.
Hey, welcome to Crossroads. You know, several years ago, if someone told you that Marxism was
the biggest story in the country, what would you have said to them? A lot of people thought
Marxism was dead in the national discussion, but lo and behold, here we are, and with
social movement after social movement, let's call it, advocating Marxism and openly declaring
themselves as Marxist, I think it's become an undeniable topic for our country. And so to learn
more about this and what's happening with the new Marxists, as we watch, for example, groups like
BLM declare that they're trained Marxists, as we watch the same financial channels behind them,
now funding the pro-Hamas and pro-Gaza protests, it's worthwhile considering what do these
individuals actually want? Is it really about the surface narrative or is it about something else
entirely? Well, here to speak to us about this is co-author of Next Gen Marxism, Mike Gonzalez.
Hey, Mike Gonzalez, thanks for being on Crossroads. Thank you, Josh, for having me. It's a great
opportunity. You know, Mike, you have a new book out talking about the new Marxists and what they're
really about. And I think you couldn't have timed this more perfectly because, you know, I think
we're watching now the new protests taking place, the protests of the year. It seems they've chosen
to focus this time on the, you know, Israel-Hamas war. And now you have these pro-Palestine protests
at American campuses. I recently did an episode looking into the finance channels behind it,
and it's all these Marxist organizations. And interestingly, some of the same Marxist
organizations that were funding or backing BLM and funding or backing a lot of the other big
social movements we've been watching. And, you know, this has me wondering, are these people
trying to start some kind of like weird Marxist revolution because their own materials talk about
this? But it doesn't totally make sense, I think, for the average person when they're watching this.
How do you make sense of this? Well, I mean, it's exactly, when Katherine Gorka and I,
Katherine Cornell Gorka, my co-author, when we first sat down in December 2022 to start
writing this book, we couldn't have dreamed that it was going to come out at a more propitious
time. Propitious badly, in a bad way, right? This is bad for the country. These are bad
demonstrations, you know, that seek to tear the country apart. But that is what Marxists want to
do. So it doesn't really matter whether the cause is Gaza or climate or police brutality,
or the two evergreens, race or sex, or anything. I mean, an example, somebody's calling it the
Omnicause. I read a piece on her, a writer called it the Omnicause. And that's because
she noticed that Greta Thunberg, that Swedish teenager who's usually haranguing us about the
planet, now she's wearing a Palestinian keffiyeh. And she recently, just last month, just about
four months ago, she announced that she was a socialist, she was an anti-capitalist.
So that's really all these forces are. They pick, this is what David Horowitz used to say,
the issue is never the issue. The issue is always the revolution. And so what we do in the book,
Next Gen Marxism, is we work how we explain and we expose how Marxism has evolved from the
Manifesto written by Marx and Engels in 1848 to what we have today, to the Next Gen Marxism that
we have today. Well, I want to dig into that because, I mean, I want to go into what these
groups are really about, what they're doing, and also kind of how they choose their issues. Because
as you mentioned, or what they're really about, because as you mentioned, the issue is never the
issue. It's actually about something else. But let's start by, as David Horowitz notes, as you
said, but let's go first into the idea of Marxism and New Marxism. Because, I mean, when you talk
to a lot of people who believe in Marxism, they talk about it purely based on economics. As myself,
having studied the origins of it, I'd say it's kind of more religious, actually. But in terms
of actual practice, you know, Marx is going on about class warfare, the bourgeoisie and the
proletariat. The New Marxists are talking about race and gender and so on. How is that Marxism?
So there's been three iterations by our counting of Marxism. One is the first one,
the Manifest of 1848 by Marx and Engels, Friedrich Engels, his sugar daddy. And the second one,
the cultural Marxism of the 20s in Europe, in Germany, in Italy, especially in the 20s and 30s.
And then what we call the next-gen Marxism of America, which is the race-oriented
Marxism that begins in the 60s, when all these ideas begin to flourish.
Let's just put two boxes together. One is the things that Marxism has changed,
the things that have changed, and the things that have been kept. In the first box,
the things that have changed, the old Marxism, the Marxism of Marx and the Manifesto, was, as you
said, economically deterministic. Everything was about economics, about the forces of production,
the revolutionary would be the worker, social classes were determined by people's relationship
to the means of production. If you worked with the lathe, if you were the lathe operator,
you were a proletariat. If you owned the lathe at the factory floor, you were a capitalist.
And revolutions would happen inevitably, where the worker, the proletariat, would overthrow the
bourgeois in bloody, sudden, and abrupt revolutions, kill the bourgeois, rape his wife,
get rid of the whole class, and emerge victorious. All of that has changed.
The things that have been kept, the second box, is the idea that all of interaction,
all of human interaction, is to be seen through a paradigm, a prism, of the oppressor versus
the oppressed. That is in the first page of the Manifesto, in English, in the English
translation, but also in the original German, I have read in the original German,
and that continues to today. That survived the cultural Marxism iteration and the American
next-gen Marxism. The other things that have changed are the Marxist desire to abolish the
family, to abolish the nation-state, to abolish God, religion, and to abolish private property.
That also, that survives, and that is very much a feature of today's Marxism.
And so what was the big shift where they went from, okay, briefly, kind of a funny anecdote.
I was talking to a friend who researches these groups, he actually goes to some of their meetings,
and he was telling me, this is Alex Newman, by the way, those of you who watch my shows,
he was telling me that there's a conflict taking place within these meetings where
the Stalinists and the Trotskyites are criticizing the new communists because they say they've lost
their way, they've forgotten about class struggle, and these newfangled kids, forgetting tradition,
apparently, they're focused now on these other issues. And so what is the line that connects
the old Marxists and the new Marxists? You mentioned that it's, of course, focused more on
destroying religion, destroying family, and these things, but for example, BLM or the
pro-Gaza protests, how do we make sense of that as it relates to Marxism?
Well, maybe I'll let me explain it, how it evolves. Marx was wrong, and the worker had
no interest in overthrowing the system. The worker liked his family, the worker worshiped
God, the worker was patriotic, and the worker actually liked private property, he just wanted
more of it. And capitalism supplied the worker with creature comforts that he liked.
So the worker, when German, after the Russian Revolution, when German and Italian communists
tried to overthrow their states and establish German and Italian Soviets, they failed because
German and Italian workers were no part of that, because of all the things that I just said.
So these Marxist ideologues said, we need to reconstruct Marxism. We need to take account
of the fact that the worker has bought into the cultural narrative of the rich and powerful.
They believe in God, they like their family. We need to destroy all that, we need to undermine
all that through critical theory, through struggle sessions, through infiltrating the institutions
and indoctrinating people. We need to get rid of the old narrative and replace it with a new one.
These ideas come to America because the people who enunciated these ideas,
the German ones, came to America. In Italy, Gramsci died shortly after he was released from
prison in 1937. But the German ones from the Frankfurt School came to the US, and these ideas
flower here in the 60s. And then one of the Frankfurt School, one of the German philosophers,
very old at the time, in the 60s, he sees the riots, the race riots, and he says,
he says it's, I'm quoting verbatim, the people of other colors and other races
will lead the revolution. The revolution will come from the ghetto population.
So then the worker will no longer be the revolutionary worker, the revolutionary
agent will no longer be the instrument of revolution. It will be the members of the
marginalized groups expressed in race or sex, and what have you. But they have to grow the groups.
They have to, because Black Americans are only 12% of the population, so they have to invent
other groups, like the Hispanics, which is a group that had not existed. The Asian Americans,
which is another crazy group that brings together people from the subcontinent, East Asia,
Malaysians, Indonesians, Japanese, Indians, Pakistanis, they're all members of one group,
and it's supposed to be oppressed. And then they invent 57 genders, they invent
ever more, and then all of these groups are then organized through community organizing,
as idealized by Saul Alinsky, who takes Lenin's ideas about organization and refines them for
the American context. And that is really, these ideologues recruit and train the women who will
found Black Lives Matter. You know, these children of the 60s, and they use the word
recruit. Eric Mann, who recruits Patrisse Cullors, the BLM founder, he said, he wrote a book in 2011,
well before the founding of Black Lives Matter, he said his organization had recruited Patrisse
Cullors at the tender age of 17 to initiate her in the life of Marxist-Leninism. So if you read
the things they say, you listen to them, they speak in the language of this next-gen Marxism,
the language of critical race theory. America lives, is systemically racist, lives under an
oppressive superstructure and all these things. And of course, ergo, if it's America systemically
racist and lives in an oppressive structure, all the structures and all the systems have
to be getting rid of. We have to unlearn everything. Back to the old Marxism,
in which a dialectic, in which the new replaces the old.