Borderline Personality Disorder & Trauma, Do You Have It? Diving Deep with Dr. Shannon Sauer-Zavala 🌟 Join us on Yoga Plus for a 14-Day Trial absolutely FREE! Spark your wellness journey with us at: https://wellnessplus.tv/yogaplus 🌟
In this compelling episode of the Wellness Plus Podcast, Anesha Singh sits down with Dr. Shannon Sauer-Zavala, an esteemed clinical psychologist and an associate professor at the University of Kentucky. With over a decade and a half of experience, Dr. Sauer-Zavala discusses the limitations and challenges of current treatments for anxiety and depression. Discover the critical perspectives she offers on why some popular therapies do not work and what new methods she recommends based on her extensive research and clinical experience. Tune in as we dive deep into the controversial aspects of modern psychological practices that may be doing more harm than good. Don't miss out on these crucial insights that could redefine your approach to mental health.
are there any particular um research
findings or strategies that you've
developed regarding cognitive behavioral
treatments for anxiety depression or
borderline personality disorder yeah
yeah so um I I'm at the University of
Kentucky now but I used to work at
Boston University and when I was there I
helped develop a treatment called the
unified protocol which in my opinion is
not a very good name because it doesn't
you know it doesn't really sell but um
but the idea is like it's a unified
protocol it's one treatment that can
simultan L address
neuroticism and so that means anxiety
disorders depression Eating Disorders
BPD now at the University of Kentucky so
working with people with borderline
personality disorder is kind of my home
base I've done I've worked with those
folks like all through graduate school
um and so you know when I was applying
the unified protocol I wanted to test it
with people with borderline personality
disorder and I found that for BPD the
unified protocol worked really well for
some patients but for other people like
it really didn't seem to make a bit of
difference and like being the like
clinical scientist that I am I'm like
well why um and so one of the things
that's really interesting about BPD is
that you know in our the DSM like our
big book of um of like symptoms um you
need there's nine symptoms of BPD and
you need five of them to get the
diagnosis what that means is that there
are 256 different combinations of those
symptoms that can like lead to a BPD
diagnosis and so two people with that
same Di diagnosis can actually share
only one symptom in common so they can
look really different so there's like
emotional disregulation so being like
really up and down in mood it's kind of
like moodiness um and inappropriate
anger um so that's like the the emotion
side then there's what they call like
behavioral disregulation and so that
looks like um like self-injury and then
it also looks like any kind of impulsive
thing that you can think of that takes
my mind off of the distress I'm feeling
so it could be risky sex it could be
substance use it could be binge eating
um it could be like overspending like
things that most of us do to like some
degree like I know like oh I've had a
bad day I deserve to buy those shoes
I've been looking at right like most of
us do that to a degree it's just like
more extreme in folks with BPD and then
the other really key kind of symptom
area is interpersonal distress so um a
lot of conflict in relationships and
then the other really like key symptom
is fear of aband abandonment so like
really difficult
time tolerating separation from a loved
one or it can look the opposite where
it's like I just like don't engage with
relationships because I don't want to
get hurt so what we find is that these
symptoms can so part of the reason that
the unified protocol like the
neuroticism treatment worked really well
for some people is for some people these
symptoms come from experiencing really
intense negative emotions and like
wanting to avoid them and so a treatment
that targets avoidance of negative
emotions works really well but for some
people their behaviors and their
symptoms kind of come from other risk
factors so if people are kind of high in
that antagonism so like low
agreeableness have a lot of trouble with
trust a neuroticism treatment for
emotions isn't going to address that
like you need a module or you need
skills that are addressing like trust
and relationships and like um how people
kind of interact with other people and
then some people engage say like in
those some of those behavioral symptoms
not because they are trying to escape
negative emotions but because it feels
good and that's that disinhibition or
low conscientiousness so this is the
example of using substances some people
use substances because they had a bad
day and now I'm going to drink like
three glasses of wine so that I like get
that negative reinforcement so that I
don't have to feel that anymore some
people drink or use substances again
because it like feels good to be high
and if if you're using because you're
impulsive a treatment for dealing with
negative emotions isn't going to address
your substance use knowing that BPD is
really variable my my lab developed a
treatment we call BPD compass and
Compass like is a very loose acronym for
cognitive behavioral modules for
personality symptoms and so basically we
have a module for neuroticism a module
for antagonism or low agreeableness and
a module for disinhibition
and right now we've I mean we've I guess
we developed it in the summer of 2020
which in hindsight I'm like how did we
do that um because it was it was a time
but um we developed it in 2020 and now
we've tested it with over a hundred
people with borderline personality
disorder um and at this point we've
given like all three personality modules
to everybody so it's 18 sessions long um
and we see um large reductions in BPD
symptoms so people are getting relief
from their condition and we're
see big changes in neuroticism and kind
of like mediumsized changes in um
antagonism and small but significant
changes in um disinhibition that's
amazing yeah yeah I we're like so
excited about it um because most
treatments for BPD are over a year long
and that's like you know kind of rewind
to like there aren't enough providers
and you sit on a weit list and it's hard
to find people with the expertise that
you need we also wanted to develop a
shortterm treatment so we're thrilled
that we can that we can see that
important change so quickly um and we
just we're like waiting um for like
what's called a notice of award but
basically funding from the National
Institute of Mental Health to give us
like millions of dollars to test the
personalized version very cool amazing
congrats thank you what role does a
subconscious mind playing into all these
traits that's a great question and um
one that is like would be really
challenging for me to answer so you know
in my training like um so so the
subconscious mind is like more like um
would be like more like psychodynamic
psychology for better well definitely
For Worse probably like people that are
practicing cognitive behavioral therapy
and people that are doing more like
psychodynamic treatment like do not
really like go to the same conferences
read the same articles so like I feel
like if I describe the subconscious mind
I will mess up so I won't
but but I think that's like a failing
with our system because like ultimately
the goal is to like find the best
treatment for people not like be right
about your theoretical orientation we
take the beliefs that we have and we try
to like make it explicit like not
subconscious we try to like make it
overt right so like what like were their
messages that like you got from your
parents that sort of suggested that like
only like an A+ or a 100 was like
success that's like another so like
perfectionism is like you would ask like
what are so challenges right and so
people that are like anxious
perfectionists
um get a lot of like external reward for
being that way oh she responds to emails
so fast like oh like we can always count
on her and so it is extremely scary to
make those small changes it can be
because you're like afraid well if I
don't do it perfect will like people I
don't know will people say something to
me like will I get in trouble will I not
be respected in the same way and you
don't know um one of the things I always
tell my patients is that like again like
successful academic associate professor
I have tenure I failed math like and had
to repeat it in high school and while
that was like so embarrassing and like
terrible at the time I think that it
really helped me because if you've never
failed you never you don't get to learn
that like it sucks for like a little
while and then it's like fine right I
think that also goes in the role of
parenting as well it's like when you
want to protect your kid so much to the
point when they're adult on their own
they have no idea what to do yeah I mean
I think that we can
develop our sort of beliefs about the
way the world works we get those
messages from people around us and when
we're kids like that's a place that we
um our parents or our caregivers are the
people we're spending the most time with
and so you know we get messages about
performance right like that um that you
can of course contribute to sort of like
this perfectionistic um like high almost
to the point of like causing problems
for us conscientiousness right um where
I see so neuroticism the tendency to
experience negative emotions that one is
probably like more biological than maybe
some of the others but there's
definitely an
interaction with um with parenting and
what we find ISC like kids that are
pretty emotionally expressive like often
parents will be like it's not a big deal
it's okay and so they're not meaning to
do it but they might give like what are
like invalidating messages like oh
that's not a big deal it's not something
to be upset about which seems like I
mean I'm a psychologist and I still
sometimes say that stuff to my kid right
instead of being like I mean it sounds
pretty benign but instead of being being
like oh gosh I understand why you're
feeling that way like let's think this
through like more sort of validating
their emotional response and of course
like that like it's not a big deal can
be like don't be a baby don't cry about
it all the way to just like go to your
room I'm not gonna deal with this right
so so when when kids get messages that
like they should be able to turn their
emotions off really quickly or that
their reactions are not valid they
develop these beliefs that like it's bad
to feel
and um when people have the belief that
it's bad to feel they avoid and what we
know is that avoidance is a really big
symptom of anxiety depression psychology
just like any field is like so Niche but
basically like those attachment Styles
typically like or the way that they were
sort of like first studied was actually
in developmental psychology so people
that study kids and try to understand
and um the first I'm like having a blank
on on um the like researchers names but
the the first like kind of coining of
those like attachment Styles was
actually looking at kids um from London
who were like separated from their
parents during World War II and like
brought into the country so they
basically wouldn't get like bombed and
so that's like sort of where those
attachment Styles developed other
studies they'll do they they call it the
strange situation study um and so
basically like a mom it's always the
moms because like all these all these
studies were done in like I don't know
like the 70s so like who was taking
their toddlers to to experiment so it's
always the mom but the moms would like
bring their kid into the like research
room and like play with the kid and then
the mom would leave and a stranger would
come in and there were all these
different like iterations of it and
basically they would observe like what
the kid would do and the mom would leave
and they would categorize people into um
these different attachment Styles and um
I think that like the attachment style
piece right like I think it sort of fits
with um kind of neuroticism right
tendency to experience negative emotions
and then it also like kind of connects
with that antagonism or trust piece um
and we I mean so in our studies we
measure attachment like there are
questionnaires for it so we measure it
and see if like in in our treatment with
BPD like if people are get like
improving their attachment Styles but
all the research suggests that that's
not that's also not set in stone if
you're like anxious avoidant right now
you can have restorative relationships I
mean I think about like um
so like I grew up in a situation like
where I had a single parent my mom and
she was like always there she was like a
rock but my dad like kind of pieced out
when I was little and you know I think
it might have caused some trust issues
probably but um I think about like my
husband who is like just a person who is
like okay I'll be there at noon and is
like there at noon that's very
fascinating because I know there's this
trend of attachment Theory going around
so I was very interested in ing about
that hey guys I would like to take a
moment to introduce you to our app yoga
plus you will have access to an
incredible selection of videos led by
top instructors in yoga Fitness
Nutrition and so much more download our
yoga Plus app available on IOS and
Android today
[Music]
[Applause]
a
[Music]