Nadler statement on Overreach: An Examination of Federal Statutory and Regulatory Crimes

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
May 2, 2024
Hearing: Overreach: An Examination of Federal Statutory and Regulatory Crimes
Subcommittee on Crime and Federal Government Surveillance
Roughly a decade ago, we learned through this committee's bipartisan
over criminalization task force of which I was a member that there
are simply too many federal criminal laws on the books that they
reach is often too broad and there are too many individuals are jailed
for far too long because of them. For too long. Congress under both
parties has created new offenses or expand the existing laws in response
to a national crisis, daily headlines or highly publicized tragedies
often federalizing crimes traditionally prosecuted by the states
without inquiry into whether the federal government should be involved
at all. Instead of playing politics and trying to prove who is toughest
on crime. We should be doing more to prevent crime before it even
happens. For instance, we could address substance abuse and mental
health disorders and the school to prison pipeline cut off the iron
pipeline that funnels guns into major cities like New York and Philadelphia
or provide real solutions for the unhoused. Nonetheless, I am pleased
that we have the opportunity to tackle the important subject of over
criminalization today. Which has long been recognized as a major
contributing factor to both mass incarceration and over policing
in America. But let's be clear This hearing should not be about Donald
Trump or about the January 6th rioters. The courts will decide whether
they were properly charged, nor should it serve as a platform to
undermine the federal regulations that keep us our constituents and
our communities safe. While over criminalization and the regulatory
context is certainly cause for concern. We should remember that regulations
ensure that we breathe clean air, drink clean water, consume safe
food and medicines that our loved ones worked work in safe environments.
The hearing should be about the countless individuals. Mostly black,
brown and poor, who for decades have borne the brunt of the overuse
and abuse of criminal law in the federal system. As the number of
federal criminal statutes has ballooned over criminalization is at
wide ranging negative impacts on individuals who are in a social
or economic disadvantage, whether by exploiting already existing
disparities in access to legal resources by leading to the increased
surveillance and targeting of minority communities by law enforcement
or by driving mass incarceration. The Department of Justice in particularly
the Bureau of Prisons continues to grapple with the cost of over
criminalization and mass incarceration, both fiscally and with respect
to other resources, such as manpower. That is why Congress should
be working together to craft legislation that ensures that the resources
of federal agencies law enforce federal law enforcement and federal
courts are used most effectively and not wasted on the enforcement
of crimes that are better handled by the states. If we are to have
a real discussion about the problems associated with over criminalization
and solutions, we must first recognize the many forms that over criminalization
takes in the federal criminal justice system. It occurs most frequently
through federalizing crimes traditionally reserved for the states.
Adopting duplicative and overlapping stats, enacting vague or broad
criminal statutes and enacting criminal statutes that fail to set
meaningful mens rea standards. Whether Republican or Democrat, we
should all agree that the resulting broad expansion of federal criminal
law undermines any effort to provide just and proportionate punishment
for criminal conduct and lessens the legitimacy of the criminal justice
system overall. It is vitally important that we rein in the growth
of the federal Criminal Code. And that's where all of the laws on
the books are truly necessary and whether they are accomplishing
what should be their ultimate goal. The protection of the public
safety I look forward to hearing from our witnesses, and before I
yield back the balance of my time I ask you an animous consent to
enter into the record. A written statement from Michael P High School
President of the National Association of Criminal Defense, an organization
that has worked for more than a decade on the issue of over criminalization
without objection, and now I yield back the balance of my time. The
gentleman
