Did Seattle's Stefan Frei Deserve a Red Card for DOGSO.

MLS SOCCER 360
264 followers
Welcome to Insider Replay for MLS Matchday 11.
I'm your host, Andrew Wiebe.
And as always, we're taking a closer look at the most controversial
refereeing decisions in Major League Soccer.
We start in Minnesota with a razor-thin offside call
that had Peter Vermees bringing an iPad to his press conference.
25th minute, Minnesota driving down the left side.
Tani Oluseyi lurking in the middle.
Now, the original ball. Freeze it here, Producer Phil.
You can see, this is clearly onside.
So the play continues.
The ball runs, and here's the pass that leads to the goal
that's given on the field for Minnesota United.
Your first thought is, what should I be looking for in terms of offside?
Because the ball is passed the second-to-last defender,
the defender's positioning doesn't matter.
The question is, is Tani Oluseyi even or behind the ball when the pass is made?
Watching it live, my brain just flashed. Offside.
But we've been doing this for a long time on Instant Replay,
and the parallax effect is not going to fool us.
So, though you have that first reaction,
you have to consider the angle of the camera on the field
and the offside line we're attempting to look down.
Just for reference, look at the six-yard box in this situation.
We all know that's a straight line. Does it look it? Of course not.
So for me, the only person on the field that has the view
is the AR who kept the flag down.
And second, there's no way this is clear and obviously offside,
in my opinion, for the VAR to intervene.
So for me, this is a good goal. No offside.
And if you're looking for a little bit of math,
of course, Soccer Photonometry, our good friend on Twitter,
he has this at about one inch onside.
With the offside law, find your truth wherever you can, folks.
All right, let's head to Washington, D.C.
D.C. United hosting the Seattle Sounders.
20th minute, Jared Stroud bearing down on goal.
Here comes Steph Fry. Down goes Jared Stroud.
And yes, you can see the contact.
That is a clear foul and penalty.
Rosendo Mendoza, the referee, points to the spot.
Now there's one more decision for Mendoza and his crew.
Is this a yellow card or is it a red card?
To boil it down, did Stephen Fry play the man or did he play the ball?
Mendoza says man. The red card comes out.
No review is initiated, and off goes Fry.
Now, this is one of those calls that's going to split opinion.
And thus, here I am still wrestling with it three days later.
Let's start with my take on MLS Wrap-Up Saturday night.
For me, Fry went down to win the ball with his right hand,
but Stroud's low touch past him beat him.
To my eye, it looked like Fry reacted by moving his arm up,
toward, and through the right knee of Stroud, taking him down.
The angle from inside the goal was particularly compelling.
My opinion was penalty and red card.
Though Fry originally played the ball, ultimately he played the man.
If you sensed just a little bit of second guessing there, yeah, you'd be right.
That decision was the harshest possible interpretation of the law
and with days to reflect on it, I'm not so sure present me completely agrees with past me.
Was Fry really playing the man and not the ball?
After all, Stroud's final touch isn't exactly a predictable one,
and Fry's original movement is into the space,
clearly with an intent to poke the ball away or make a save.
In a kinder view, the play happens fast, Fry doesn't have time to react,
and double jeopardy, penalty, and a red card for denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity
ought to be reserved for truly intentional takedowns.
So yes, for me today, I'd prefer a yellow card and a penalty.
I'd love to hear where you stand.
Refereeing is hard.
Shout out to all of you who have to make these decisions in the real world.
One more play from this one, 42nd minute, Jared Stroud again.
Is this a red card tackle on Stroud?
For me, no, I agree with Mendoza, yellow.
Watch how Stroud pulls out of the challenge, pulls his feet back.
For me, it's reckless and not excessive force.
And excessive force is the question for Ali Badawi in the 97th minute
of Philly's home loss to RSL.
Watch this play from the beginning.
It is physical in every single moment.
Crash, bang, wham, here comes Badawi at the end right into Chicho Arango.
The first challenge is probably yellow card worthy,
and then Badawi kicks the ball into Arango.
So yeah, that's a yellow card from Malik Badawi,
but you've got to ask a couple of questions here
because this reeks of potential red for violent conduct.
One, was that kick of the ball excessive force?
Two, did the kick hit Chicho in the face?
If it does, I think that's a red card.
The foul is called, the play is dead,
and Badawi ultimately knows where he's kicking this ball.
Where do I come down on this one?
Ultimately, I think more often than not,
that's probably a red card on Ali Badawi.
He's fortunate here to see yellow from Badawi.
The one thing I will say, if I was the VAR,
I cannot tell you for sure that this ball hits Arango in the face.
My last consideration here comes down to game management.
Watch RSL, watch Arango.
He just sort of pops up after some initial complaints.
It doesn't feel like the players are saying,
hey, this is injustice on the field.
You're probably thinking, Weeby, you're waffling right now.
And you're right, this is a difficult judgment call.
If red card was the call on the field, I would not disagree.
As it stands, I'm okay with yellow in this situation.
All right, let's rapid fire through some more
and get through match day 11.
Cincinnati, Colorado, 49th minute.
All right, Georgie Mihaljevic in the box.
Yeah, you see it. That's a pull, everyone.
The question is how much of a pull,
and does it clearly and obviously affect Georgie Mihaljevic's ability
to control the ball?
I think it does, and I think it's a foul.
No penalty is the call on the field,
and it all comes down to the degree of the pull, folks.
Let us know what you think.
Great spot here by the VAR, Chris Pinto,
in the same match in the 68th minute.
Yuyukubo scores.
The ball's in the back of the net for Cincinnati,
but watch closely here.
Yep, Yuyukubo controls the ball with his hand
before the ball goes in.
That's a great spot and a good no-go call.
Good offside call in New York City, Charlotte.
Moonsef Bekrar is cursed.
He finally puts the ball in the back of the net,
but as you can see from this view from behind,
his foot is behind the second-to-last defender,
and he's leaning.
I've got that as clearly offside.
Well done to the AR, Catherine Nesbitt.
Another great offside call from this match by the other AR,
Oscar Mitchell Caballo.
Ernan scores the goal for Charlotte, but watch.
His left leg appears to be the closest thing to the goal,
in my opinion.
Either way, you're trying to count two defenders.
He needs to be even with the second-to-last.
Ultimately, because he's the closest to the goal line,
for me, this is offside,
and that it was called live is extremely impressive.
Well done.
Easy call from Mark Alleton, the referee in Red Bulls Vancouver.
Noah Ayla is running back.
Noah Ayla is reaching up,
and Noah Ayla is denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity
for Ryan Gauld with his hand.
That is a red card, folks.
And this, in the 11th minute from Orlando, Toronto,
is not a red card for me,
and that was a call from Armando Villarreal,
the referee on the field.
Why not?
For considerations,
the distance between the offense and the goal,
as you can see, still pretty far out in the angle.
The general direction of the play is not toward goal,
but toward the end line.
Yes, the attacking player is going to keep the ball,
but there is a recovering defender.
So, great call from the crew on this one, in my opinion.
And we end with an O...
