18 Incompatible Herbs and 19 Antagonisms | TCM Herbology Review

Medicinal leaves
30 followers
If you're studying for a big herbology test, like finals, year ends, clinic, entrance exams,
or boards, you'll probably want to be familiar with the 18 incompatible herbs and the 19
antagonisms. This is usually discussed under the heading of Herb Safety and Potential Adverse
Effects of Herbs. So, to give you some context, remember in the very beginning of herbs class,
we talked about techniques for combining herbs, and these had names like Mutual Accentuation,
Mutual Enhancement, Mutual Counteraction, Mutual Suppression, and blah blah blah. Well,
these first ones are all beneficial combinations, or combinations we would want to use in a
treatment. But the next two, Mutual Antagonism and Mutual Incompatibility, are combinations that
we want to avoid. These are also referred to as the 18 incompatible herbs and the 19 antagonisms.
So, when we talk about Mutual Incompatibility, this refers to a combination of two substances
that gives rise to side effects or toxicity that would not otherwise be present if either herb was
used alone. So, it's kind of like the whole is greater than the sum of its parts, but in a bad,
toxic way. And we call this the 18 incompatible herbs, but it really refers to three groups of
incompatibilities that add up to 18. So, Gonsal is incompatible with these four herbs. If we
combine Gonsal with any of these herbs, it would create side effects that wouldn't be there if we
used each herb separately. Aconite, either Jurfutsa or Wutou, is incompatible with these five herbs.
And Lilu is incompatible with these six. So, the total list adds up to 18.
So, what are some ways we can remember these? Well, if we look at the first one, Gonsal or
Licorice Root, notice that most of these herbs come from the Harsh Expellants category. The
exception, of course, is Haizao, which is a seaweed from the Transform Phlegm category.
But, if you get a question about which herbs are incompatible with Gonsal,
pick the one with Harsh Expellants in it. You can maybe remember that Gan and Gan go together.
Then we have herbs that are incompatible with the various forms of Aconite. So,
this includes Jurfutsa, Jertuanwu, and Jertsao. These are collectively known as Wutou. So,
here you may get a question about which herbs are incompatible with Futsa, or it may be worded
which herbs are incompatible with Wutou. I've seen it both ways. But, what I remember here is
most of these herbs are phlegm herbs. So, Beimu, both Jebeimu and Chuanbeimu, Guaolou,
and Jerbancha are all from the Transform Phlegm category. So, you can maybe think that the name
Futsa looks kind of like fuzzy. So, maybe you can think of fuzzy phlegm to remember this group.
And the last one is Lilu. Now, this is an herb that we don't learn and it's not typically used.
It turns out that Lilu is very toxic and it's used to induce vomiting in the treatment of
wind phlegm, which is just not a treatment strategy that we really use anymore. So,
because we don't use this herb, you may or may not get questions about it. But,
I might just remember that this is the group of Shen herbs. Ren Shen, Sha Shen, Dan Shen,
Ku Shen, even Xi Xin sounds kind of like Shen. So, for Lilu, think of Shen.
When it comes to mutual antagonisms, this is maybe not quite as bad because here we're not
creating side effects. It's just that this combination will minimize or neutralize the
positive effects of each herb. For example, Ren Shen is very good at tonifying Qi. But,
combine it with Wuling Zhe, it may neutralize those effects. So, when we say 19 antagonisms,
this just refers to 8 pairs and 1 triplet. The thing is, a lot of these are herbs that we don't
learn or aren't even in our Materia Medica. So, if we cross those out, that makes this list a
little bit shorter. Now, I'm not sure how common it is to get questions on these pairs. Like,
with every herb test I've ever taken, I've always gotten at least one question on the 18
incompatible herbs. But, with the 19 antagonisms, I could be wrong, but I feel like those questions
are less common. But, this is something that's good to look over and at least be able to recognize
it in case you do get a question about these pairs. And then, an additional one I'll throw in
is Ren Shen, Ginseng Radix, and Lai Futsa, Radish Seed. Now, as far as I know, this is not on the
traditional list of the 19 antagonisms. But, we do see this note that,
The Materia Medica of Combinations states that Lai Futsa is contraindicated when taking tonics.
And other sources will flat out say, Lai Futsa antagonizes the tonic effect of Ren Shen,
even though it's not on the initial list of antagonisms. So, even though this is not
officially one of the 19 antagonisms, I have seen people ask questions about this. That either,
Lai Futsa will cancel out the tonifying effects of Ren Shen specifically, or just that, if a
patient is taking a tonifying formula, they should avoid Lai Futsa or Radishes in general. So,
that's just something to be aware of. So, you definitely need to know this
for your big tests, but how useful is it in actual practice? Well, that's kind of an interesting
discussion. So, one example where the 18 incompatible herbs does come up might be in
the formula, Sher Tsao Tong, 10 Jujube decoction. This is a formula for fluid accumulation in the
chest, and you can see here that we use a bunch of harsh expellants to treat it,
then we add in 10 pieces of Da Tsao. Well, kind of the idea here is normally we would use Gan
Tsao in order to harmonize or moderate the harshness of these toxic herbs, but here we
can't do that because of the incompatibility between Gan Tsao and these herbs. Remember,
Gan and Gan don't go together. So, we use Da Tsao Jujube fruit instead. And so,
Da Tsao is taking care of this action of harmonizing those herbs. So, that's one
example of making a substitution based on the 18 incompatible herbs. But really,
many of these contraindications are not actually followed anymore, or classically, they never
really were. One example is the formula, Hai Tsao Yu Hu Tong, which is used to treat nodules like
Goiter. So, this formula was created in the 1600s, and you can see that it contains both
Hai Tsao and Gan Tsao, even though these are traditionally incompatible. We even find a note
in Bensky that says, Traditionally, both Hai Tsao and Kung Bu were thought to be incompatible with
Gan Tsao. Nevertheless, they were combined in several traditional formulas, and this prohibition
was removed from the official Chinese pharmacopoeia in 1977 because no real adverse
effects were reported. In another example, with Wu Ling Zhi, we see the note, Traditionally,
it was not to be combined with ginseng radix, Ren Shen. However, modern research has shown this
prohibition to be groundless. We even see combinations of Fu Tsa and Ban Tsa going as
far back as the Jing Wei Yao Li Wei in formulas that were created by Zhang Zhong Jing. So, on the
one hand, yes, you need to be familiar with the 18 incompatible herbs and the 19 antagonisms
in order to answer questions on your tests, but if you're in clinic and you see a formula where
Hai Tsao and Gan Tsao are being used together, don't freak out. It's probably okay. So, if you
want to review these groups of herbs, I have a handout you can download. It's actually several
handouts put together that will help you study various topics that tend to come up on herbology
tests, whether that's finals, year ends, clinic entrance exams, or boards. These are things like
herbs that are contraindicated during pregnancy, the 18 incompatible herbs and 19 antagonisms that
we talked about here, the basics of drug herb interaction, herbs with special cooking instructions,
and a few other topics. So, if you want a free download of these handouts, there's a link in the
description below. If you enter your email address, I'll send you these handouts as well as
links to other resources that will help you study for herbs. I have a whole bunch of videos, handouts,
and practice tests scattered throughout the YouTube channel and the website TCMstudy.net,
so I'll send you links to some of those resources as well. So, that's all for this one. If you want
to keep reviewing herbs, check out this next video on herbs that are contraindicated during pregnancy.
