The French Paradox: How rich food and wine could help you stay healthy | 60 Minutes Australia

History Of Food
342 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 23, 2024
How's this for a diet? Fat? Okay. Red meat? Not a problem. Cheese and cakes? You can eat them to your heart's content.
And it gets even better. Fancy a glass or two of wine to wash it down? Go ahead. It's good for you.
It's fun and it works. It's why French women don't get fat.
Of course, this dream diet has been around for centuries. It's known as the French paradox and it defies all logic.
How come they thrive on all that rich food and wine and have lower rates of obesity and heart disease than we do?
Well, being French, you can bet style has something to do with it.
Take a deep breath and relax. Pause and enjoy the view. For this is a diet story with a difference.
We're in a small village in France. It's market day and lunch is on our mind.
In Australia, we're always told don't eat the skin of the chicken and look at all the butter this man's putting on.
It's the best part. It's the best part.
My gastronomic guide is William Page. Originally from Adelaide, this chef has lived in France for the last 13 years.
He's been awarded a prestigious Michelin hat, the ultimate symbol of acceptance here.
You wouldn't eat it like that, would you? You better would. Oh yeah, for sure. Lots of mashed potatoes with it.
Just take up the butter. For that crunchy bit.
As we all know, the French love to thumb their nose at convention. Here they've made political incorrectness an art form.
So, for instance, if the common wisdom is butter is bad, then the French will eat more butter.
They feel absolutely no guilt eating, drinking, whatever they want.
It's an incredibly liberating way to live and infuriatingly for the rest of us who spend most of our lives concerned by what we consume,
it seems to be healthy.
There's hardly a fatty to be found in France, despite their high-fat diet.
And this is the French paradox. Their incidence of heart disease is one of the lowest in the world.
They have half our rate of obesity, yet they have one of the richest diets on the planet.
We don't like low fat, low this, sugarless this, because it doesn't taste good.
I mean, butter is not something that's bad for you. Chocolate is not something that's bad for you.
Eating duck fat is not bad for you, but not if you have it, of course, three times a day and the way many countries eat mega portions.
As president of the champagne house Verve Clicquot, Mireille Giuliano knows a thing or two about indulgence.
So you see the reason you don't gulp down champagne, because all the drama is in the glass.
The elegant Madame Giuliano is also the author of the extremely successful book French Women Don't Get Fat.
So why don't French women get fat?
Because they eat for pleasure and they eat with their five senses.
So no counting calories.
That's boring.
All too often, like in America, we judge the quality of our food by quantity and by how quickly we get it and how fast we can eat it.
But in France it's all about quality.
They even have food police patrolling cheese shops and delicatessens.
Anywhere there's food, there are fines and loss of license for poor quality products.
Cooking for us is very sensual.
So we take pride in what we prepare.
Cooking is an act of love, as opposed to many countries where cooking is a chore.
It's going to be a ravioli truffle with wild mushroom cream.
That's what I'm going to do here.
Cream again.
Yes and no.
You just so happen to fall upon this particular dish.
In the kitchen of William Page's restaurant, lunch is on the menu.
It's like this every day.
In France, the midday meal is rarely a grab-and-run affair.
Much more, it's an affair to remember.
France closes down between midday and two o'clock every day.
All the businesses, all the commerce, everything's closed.
So they generally go home to eat or they eat in a restaurant or whatever.
But yeah, everybody eats lunch, like a real sit-down lunch.
So not like a sandwich that we might have.
Not at all.
According to the French, a long lunch could well mean a long life.
Taking your time is good for you.
More courses mean more variety.
And a satisfied stomach means no snacking.
I think how they eat is very healthy.
I know, I lost weight when I came to France.
We eat slowly, we take the time, we put our fork and knife down between bites.
Actually what it does is that if you eat slowly and not in a stressful situation,
your taste buds will be satisfied after a few bites.
So you don't need to eat much.
This oyster, and of course in France, with butter.
It's a wonderful only-in-France moment,
where a restaurant is this doctor's laboratory and lunch his experiment.
They put butter and they put cream on everything they eat.
Cardiologist Michel Delogereau is one of two men who discovered the French paradox.
And are snails good for you?
Yes, they're very good.
His explanation is that the bad things in the diet,
the saturated fats, red meat, butter and cream,
are cancelled out by the good things, the variety and the freshness of the food.
But the key is drinking. Wine is the real lifesaver.
And so every lunchtime you have some wine?
Yes, that is typically French. We have all the time a bottle of wine open.
The way of drinking of the French is chronic drinking every day,
every day, and moderate drinking.
This is rare medical advice, but science has confirmed what's long been suspected.
People who drink a couple of glasses of wine every day
live longer than those who don't drink at all.
Alcohol also protects those who've had heart attacks.
In our studies, in patients with established chronic heart disease,
two to four drinks were associated with a 50% reduction of the risk of recurrence.
So drink moderately and you halve the risk of having a second heart attack.
Yes, exactly. This is scientifically demonstrated.
One or two glasses of alcohol per day, probably in most people,
protects your heart, may protect against stroke,
and there's evidence that it may protect against dementia.
So I want to tell the good news.
I think it's important to tell the good news about alcohol or wine,
wine particularly, and a glass of beer occasionally,
and not be afraid to tell the truth. That's the truth.
Brisbane cardiologist David Cahoon says Australians should pay close attention
to the French way of living and eating.
A lot of the food that you hear about is food that is on the surface not very healthy,
but there's other things they add to the food.
So it's the total blend, you see.
So when they have their fatty meal, a lot of the time they have cheese.
Cheese modified or fermented milk is actually not dangerous.
Grape juice, which is fermented wine, not dangerous, positively healthy.
At this place, the menu changes every day.
Today there are two starters, tomato salad, fresh vegetables,
and then poached fish followed by San Polana, special soft cheese,
and then fruit for dessert.
But to book a table here, you have to be a toddler.
At this crèche, like most in France, lunch is four courses.
But this being France, it's much more than just about the eating.
It's also about educating the palate.
Certainly it's the lifestyle, it's not the genes, it's not genetics.
And we've seen that in one study after another,
that culture is very important and a big part of culture is what you eat.
While the French thrive on ignoring dietary convention,
our fixation with it grows.
The zone diet, the Callaway diet, this orgasmic diet,
the healing diet, the Hawaiian diet, don't diet, Eskimo,
it goes on and on and on.
And what's the craziest diet you've heard of?
The craziest diet is the Hallelujah diet, actually.
The Australian paradox is the greater our obsession with losing weight,
the more we pile on.
Portion sizes are getting bigger.
And we're all tuned to eat what's on our plate, you know?
You've got to eat what's on your plate.
As portions get bigger, people eat more.
And we're just over-consuming.
That's it.
The key thing about eating is to enjoy what you're eating,
but when you've eaten enough, don't eat any more.
Be satisfied.
That's a key thing.
And don't snack.
OK, I won't.
Do you ever snack?
Rarely, because, again, when you have your three meals,
you really don't have reasons to snack.
Do you ever drink soft drink?
No.
Never?
No.
Not good, all this sugar, and it's not appealing for me.
Basically, I have coffee or tea or water and wine.
I would have the chocolate marquise,
because it's a mousse with a vanilla brûlée centre.
That sounds good to me.
While something sweet is always on Marie's menu,
it never makes it to her hips.
I love espresso ice cream.
Not only do French women not get fat,
they don't even break into a sweat.
French women don't jog.
This is very bad for your joint.
We'd rather do things that give us pleasure,
and walking gives us great pleasure.
Is there a French word for guilt? Does it exist?
No, actually, I mention in the book that, you know,
sometimes I go to a restaurant in New York or in America
and I order a dessert, and the waiter would come and say,
ooh, this is sinfully delicious.
And to me, why is it sinfully?
I mean, you know, it's a dessert and I don't have it every day,
and why should it be sinfully?
It's just very delicious.
Back in Australia, David Cahoon is doing a long-term study
on the effects of diet on heart patients.
He prefers a variation to the French paradox,
the Mediterranean diet.
Replace the butter and red meats with olive oil and fish,
but keep the daily wine.
His patients are losing up to eight kilos a year.
And is it protecting them from further heart attacks?
Well, the evidence from two big trials
is that heart attacks may be reduced by more than 50%,
simply by modifying the diet.
Very simple.
The French are considered the most pleasure-driven people on earth,
so even if we don't like their rich food,
perhaps we can learn from their attitude.
C'est la vie.
Stop the diet obsession, concentrate on common sense,
and quite literally, eat to your heart's content.
Is obsession the reason why so much of the world
is now battling the bulge?
Oh, I think so, yes.
And the result is that your body takes revenge
and then people binge.
I mean, it's that simple.
Whereas if you have it a few times a week
or you choose your moment to have it
and you eat slowly and you have less,
well, you can have your cake and eat it too.
Hello, I'm Tom Steinfeld.
Thanks for watching 60 Minutes Australia.
Subscribe to our channel now for brand new stories
and exclusive clips every week.
And don't miss out on our Extra Minutes segment
and full episodes of 60 Minutes on
Ninenow.com.au
as well as the Ninenow app.
